Countless fans have sighed that if they don't study "Water Margin" a few times, they really haven't understood "Water Margin".

So, is the real murderer who shot Chao Gai Song Jiang or not? This question may remain controversial forever.

Although Shen Cong's reasoning and analysis are very convincing, after all, it is only reasoning and analysis, even if the probability reaches more than 90%, there will still be some controversy.

And Song Jiang can undoubtedly be regarded as the most successful character portrayed in "Water Margin".

The story of "Water Margin" continues.

After Chao Gai's death, after some twists and turns, Song Jiang sat on the first position in Liangshan.

Then, after several twists and turns, the jade unicorn Lu Junyi finally went to Liangshan.

Lu Junyi's confidant and servant Yan Qing, the prodigal son, also followed Lu Junyi to Liangshan together.

After that, several stories with Yan Qing and Li Kui as the protagonists, "Black Whirlwind Qiao Ghost Hunting", "Liang Shanbo Double Offering His Head", "Yan Qing Fighting", etc., are extremely enjoyable for book fans.

Liangshan's momentum is getting stronger and stronger, and characters with distinctive characters such as Shi Qian, Qin Ming, Hu Yanzhuo, Chai Jin, Hua Rong, Zhu Tong, Dai Zong, and Shi Xiu have also joined Liangshan.

In the end, the number of heroes and leaders of Liangshan reached one hundred and eight, and Liangshan's momentum reached its peak.

After that, the main hall of Liangshan was changed from "Juyi Hall" to "Zhongyi Hall", and the banner of "doing the right thing for heaven" was played.

One hundred and eight heroes are arranged, "thirty-six Tiangang, seventy-two earthly evil" seats.

Song Jiang corresponds to Tiankuixing and sits in the first place.

Lu Junyi corresponds to Tiangangxing and sits in the second position.

Wu used the corresponding Tianji Star to sit in the third position.

After that, the main characters familiar to fans are:

Gongsun Sheng corresponds to the Tianxian Star and sits in the fourth place.

Lin Chong corresponds to Tianxiongxing and sits in sixth place.

Lu Zhishen corresponds to the sky lone star and sits in the thirteenth position.

Wu Song corresponds to the Heavenly Wound Star and sits in the fourteenth place.

Yang Zhi corresponds to the dark star and sits in the seventeenth position.

Li Kui corresponds to the Heavenly Killing Star and sits in the twenty-second position.

Shi Jin corresponds to the sky MSI and sits in the twenty-third position.

Yan Qing corresponds to Tianqiaoxing and sits on the thirty-sixth chair.

......

The serialization continues, the rebels led by Liang Sheng's heroes are becoming more and more courageous, their morale is getting higher and higher, and the wonderful plot is always continuous, which makes fans dizzy.

However, when the story reaches the end, it becomes more and more embarrassing and regretful.

Faced with the situation that the Liangshan rebels became more and more courageous, the imperial court changed its strategy and sent people to appease them.

So, under the guidance of the compromise ideas of Song Jiang and others, Liangshan accepted Zhao'an and reorganized into the army of the Song Dynasty.

The Great Song Dynasty court adopted the strategy of "borrowing a knife to kill", and ordered the heroes of Liangshan to go to conquer Liao and Fangla, and the heroes of Liangshan continued to fall.

After years of war, there were only twenty or thirty people left in the end of one hundred and eight heroes.

However, even these survivors have not escaped the fate that followed.

The Great Song Dynasty court saw that the heroes of Liangshan were alone, so they poisoned Song Jiang and others shortly after they were awarded the title of official.

Song Jiang and Lu Junyi were poisoned with imperial wine and mercury respectively.

Song Jiang drank the imperial wine and knew that he had been poisoned, because he was afraid that Li Kui would gather in the mountains and forests again in order to take revenge, so he invited Li Kui to his place, so that Li Kui also drank the poisonous wine without knowing it.

After Li Kui drank the poisonous wine, Song Jiang told Li Kui the truth, Li Kui did not blame Song Jiang, only said, "I served my brother when I was alive, and when I died, I was just a little ghost under my brother." ”

After that, Song Jiang and Li Kui died of poison.

Wu Yong and Hua Rong also hanged themselves in Tate'erwa.

One hundred and eight heroes, only a few people were able to die well, Wu Song, Lu Zhishen, Gongsun Sheng, An Daoquan, Yan Qing, Li Jun, Chai Jin and so on.

The great cause of the vigorous Liangshan Uprising ended like this.

And the vigorous "Water Margin" is also over.

"Water Margin" is over, but the mood of all book fans has not been calm for a long time.

Since Song Jiang accepted the invitation of the imperial court, the mood of book fans watching "Water Margin" has been very different from before.

Looking at the heroes of Liangshan, falling one after another, book fans always feel that there is a depression in their hearts that is difficult to release.

Who buried the great foundation of Liangshan? Who made the heroes of Liangshan fall one after another?

Is it Song Jiang?

Yes and no.

Judging from the story itself, Song Jiang's acceptance of the imperial court's recruitment was the beginning of the destruction of Liangshan's good foundation.

But among the heroes of Liangshan, it is not only Song Jiang who supports Zhao'an, but also Lu Junyi, Guan Sheng, Shi Jin, Qin Ming and others, all of whom support Zhao'an.

The decision to accept Zhao'an was not made by Song Jiang alone.

Therefore, the blame cannot be put on Song Jiang alone.

Also, look at the essence through the story.

The reason why Song Jiang accepted Zhao'an was mainly related to the social atmosphere at that time.

At that time, the society preached the "three outlines", that is, "the king is the minister", "the father is the son", and "the husband is the wife", and Song Jiang is the product of this thinking.

Song Jiang went to Liangshan, it was really a last resort, if it was not forced by the form, Song Jiang would definitely not go to Liangshan, but would be a good official and get ahead, so as to glorify the ancestors.

He has always called the emperor of the Great Song Dynasty "Shengshang", which shows that in his concept, the "Son of Heaven" is sacred and inviolable.

He had always believed that cooperation with the rulers was the "right way".

Therefore, Song Jiang is so enthusiastic and eager to accept Zhao'an, which is the limitation of Song Jiang's thought, and it is also the internal historical reason for the failure of the uprising revealed in the whole work.

Song Jiang is not the only one who has this kind of ideological limitations, but the other main leaders of Liangshan, Lu Junyi, Wu Yong and others, also have this kind of ideological limitations.

Therefore, the limitations of the leader's thinking were the main reason for the failure of the Liangshan uprising.

For the ending of "Water Margin", countless fans regret it very much, emotionally speaking, they are unacceptable.

They couldn't accept the continuous decline of one Liang Sheng's heroes one after another, and they couldn't accept the Liangshan leaders represented by Song Jiang, who were eager to be recruited, buried the vigorous uprising, and caused the heroes to die one by one.

But they also knew that the failure of the Liangshan Uprising was a historical inevitability, and it was not something that could be caused by the decision of a single person.

It's just that what fans can't accept is not the failure of the uprising, but the fact that the heroes keep dying in battle, and there are few people who can die well.

So, is it possible to fail in another way?

The heroes gathered and dispersed, and finally were forced to leave Liangshan for various reasons.

In this way, the uprising also failed, and the heroes did not have to die in battle.

Many book lovers are thinking about this question in their hearts.

However, they also know that since Li Fan wrote such an ending, there must be a reason to write like this.

It's just that they can't see through it for the time being.

But no matter what, the vigorous "Water Margin" is over, and the ending is not good in the eyes of book fans.

......