346. Comparison of the two versions (ask for subscription!)

In the auditorium, everyone urged Chen Tong to continue.

Chen Tong continued to analyze and said:

"Second, crying and chasing the teacher, completely ignoring the geographical environment at that time!"

"Do you know where Huo Yi is? That's basically in front of Taiyuan. ”

"And the Tujue people are far away from the Great Wall, even Liu Wuzhou is also far away in Mayi, that is to say, Li Yuan can quickly rush to the aid of Taiyuan, this is the second place he attacked after leaving Taiyuan. ”

"It didn't go very far. ”

What's more, Li Yuan only heard rumors that the Tujue and Liu Wuzhou were going to attack Taiyuan, and there was no battle report from Taiyuan, which means that this was an uncertain event. ”

"Taking a step back, even if the Tujue and Liu Wuzhou are definitely going to fight Taiyuan, what is Taiyuan? It is a war fortress of the Sui Dynasty to defend against the attack of the Tujue, easy to defend and difficult to attack!"

"Everyone knows that the siege of a city in ancient times was protracted, and the Tujue people were not good at attacking cities at all. ”

That is to say, in terms of the geographical environment at that time, Li Yuan could have waited until Taiyuan to send an exact military report, knowing the large-scale army movement of the other party, he was rushing to help, and he could also come in time. ”

"That's it, I have to stage a thrilling scene of crying and chasing the teacher, is it necessary?"

"Are these all drama spirits?"

"Third, changing military orders on the spot and treating war as a child's play! This was a taboo for soldiers and was completely out of line with the specific conditions at that time. ”

"You must know that the most important thing in ancient times was the morale of the army, and you first issued the order to retreat, that is, you confirmed that the Tujue and Liu Wuzhou were going to attack Taiyuan. ”

And Li Yuan's soldiers are all soldiers of Taiyuan, their parents, wives and daughters are all in Taiyuan City, if Taiyuan City is broken, then they will be ruined. ”

"Wait for these people to go back to Taiyuan, and then you change the general order on the battlefield, and let these soldiers risk the destruction of their families, and under huge psychological pressure, they will continue to attack Huoyi in front of you. ”

"At this moment, the combat power of the military heart is definitely falling down. ”

"Is this child's play-like way of commanding troops to show that Li Shimin is smart? Or is it to show that Li Shimin doesn't know anything about military affairs at all?"

"The most important thing is that they are going to rebel!"

"The soldiers rebelled just to have something to eat and shelter their families. ”

"When the army retreats, all the soldiers are like arrows, and they want to protect their families, this is the wood has been completed! ”

"If you want to go against the trend and let them come back to fight, this is equivalent to giving up Taiyuan, it is equivalent to letting them abandon their families, and the soldiers can still listen to you?"

"Do you really think that these soldiers are die-hard fans of Li Shimin? Tell you, if you do this, the soldiers will immediately mutiny! Because this will go against their original intention of following the Li clan in Longxi. ”

"The soldiers of the Sui and Tang dynasties rebelled so fast, they teach you how to be a man in minutes!"

"Li Yuan just beat more and more people, just by relying on the other party's surrendered army. ”

"Do you think Li Shimin's advice is smart or stupid?"

"This is a loophole, so in the military dimension, there is a big suspicion about Li Shimin's crying and chasing the division!"

"Next, it is to enter the stage of finding historical materials to verify whether there are other historical materials that can verify its authenticity. ”

Chen Tong said with a smile.

In an instant, there was a discussion in the auditorium.

"This is the process of verifying historical data, let us see the charm of logical thinking!"

"Although we are not familiar with the ancient military system, at least we still have IQ, and when you say that, we feel suspicious. ”

"It's like a sieve. ”

The fans of the other phalanxes were all excited, at least today, in this high-profile place, Li Shimin's fans didn't dare to mess around.

In this way, they felt the joy of fairness on the line.

At this time, the live broadcast experience directly brushed up the rocket fish, and the reward amount exceeded 200,000.

Message from the local tyrant:

"Go on!"

"Let me see, how to verify the authenticity of this historical material next?"

Li Shimin's fans had extremely ugly faces, and they wanted to reprimand Chen Tong, but Chen Tong did not say that this historical material was fake, but only that there were doubts.

Is he going to show people the lower limit of their IQ?

They could only clench their fists and stare at Chen Tong with hateful eyes, wanting to kill him with their eyes!

Chen Tong took a sip of water, and then continued to analyze:

The record of this historical material is recorded in detail in the Datang Entrepreneurship Notes. ”

"Let's take a look at "Datang Entrepreneurship Notes", how to record this period of history. ”

When Li Yuan heard the rumor that the Tujue and Liu Wuzhou were preparing to attack Taiyuan, Li Yuan was also very worried at that time, after all, Taiyuan was his base camp, and he really wanted to withdraw at that time. ”

But Li Yuan is not an impulsive person, he is notoriously steady, he did not act rashly, but directly convened a military meeting. ”

"He wants to ask everyone for their opinions. ”

At that time, the military meeting was divided into two factions, with Pei Lin as the main person, insisting on returning to Taiyuan first, and when Liu Wenjing came with the news of the exact alliance with Tujue, they attacked Huoyi again. ”

But at this time, Li Jiancheng and Li Shimin both opposed this opinion, and they thought that now was the best time to attack Huo Yi. ”

"After fighting Huoyi, if the Tujue and Liu Wuzhou really attack Taiyuan, then they can catch up with them if they return to help. ”

"And if they capture Huoyi, they will harvest more grain, grass, soldiers and horses, and their strength will increase greatly, and they are fully capable of being more positive with the Tujue. ”

"After stating the powerful relationship, Li Shimin and Li Jiancheng have absolute confidence in attacking Huoyi, and they are willing to make a military order!"

Just when Li Yuan was hesitating, his son-in-law Chai Shao also brought good news, Chai Shao led the troops to reconnoiter Song Laosheng in Huoyi and find out the details of Song Laosheng. ”

"I found that Song Laosheng was more than brave, lacking in resourcefulness, and he was irritable by nature and not good at the art of war. ”

At this time, Li Yuan knew himself and the enemy, measured the gap between the enemy and me, and felt that he was sure of victory, so he arranged his troops and decided to stay and attack Huoyi. ”

"Let's not talk about the question of who is more primitive in historical materials. ”

"Let's just take a look at these two historical sources, the description of the same thing, which one do you think is the real history?"

"Datang Entrepreneurship Note, has this record been dead to blow Li Yuan?"

"Nope!"

"Li Yuan is still a steady player as always, he can be cowardly, but a steady player will not act impulsively, and he pays attention to planning before acting. ”

"Did it erase Li Shimin's credit?"

"Nope!"

"Clearly and clearly, it is Li Shimin and Li Jiancheng who are the main attackers of Huoyi, and Li Yuan, as the coach, finally felt that what these two sons said was very reasonable and adopted it. ”

Moreover, in the follow-up battles, Li Jiancheng and Li Shimin had important strategic deployments. ”

In this battle against Huoyi, everyone's contributions are clearly described, and it is not similar to the kind of online article, just to pave the protagonist, the image of the supporting role is constantly weakened. ”

And the record of this period of history is completely in line with everyone's personality, the blood and courage of the Li Shimin brothers, Pei Lin and Li Yuan's old scheming, prudence and seriousness, are all vividly reflected. ”

And all kinds of details are in line with the historical environment and military system at that time. ”

Therefore, from the logical dimension, it can be judged that there are no loopholes in this historical material and it is worthy of acceptance, and then it is a question of mutual corroboration with other historical materials. ”

........................

After Chen Tong finished speaking, he looked at everyone, and at this moment, everyone nodded again and again.