342. Historical data should be trusted!
At this moment, the professors sitting in the back row couldn't stand it anymore, and stood up, their actions immediately attracted everyone's attention, and after the professors got the microphone, they said very seriously:
"Does historiography look at who there are?"
"The more history books you record, the more you can be trusted?"
"We solemnly declare here that no matter how many historical books there are after the Tang and Song dynasties, they can't shake the "Datang Entrepreneurship and Living Note", and we can't use these historical materials to deny the "Datang Entrepreneurship and Living Note"!"
"It can only be used as evidence to fill the loopholes in "Datang Entrepreneurship and Living Note". ”
"I can only use "Datang Entrepreneurship and Living Note" to deny other historical books. ”
The professor's words immediately caused a roar.
Li Shimin's fans laughed at the time, and their eyes were full of disdain and ridicule:
"Why?
"If you say you can't deny it, you can't deny it?"
"Is what you say is what you say?"
"Sure enough, it's an expert!"
They coaxed you, and immediately attracted a collective slap of Li Shimin's fans, and they all felt that the professors were too domineering.
In the live broadcast room, the crowd is also excited.
"Is this the professor? Why are they what they say?"
"Are you the authorities?"
"Why can't we ordinary people disagree?"
"Is this bullying us?"
It's good that the professors didn't speak, but as soon as they spoke, they were immediately chased and intercepted, and they wanted to prove it to Chen Tong, but it turned out to make things worse and worse, and it made others even more distrustful of Chen Tong.
The professor's face turned black at the moment, and sure enough, it was still necessary to be professional in raising the bar, but they still patiently explained:
"I am not oppressing anyone on the basis of my own academic prestige, I am simply expounding a basic rule of historiography. ”
That is, historical materials such as history books and epitaphs collected by historical research institutes must be graded for credibility. ”
"We can only use historical materials with high credibility to deny historical materials with low credibility. ”
"You can't use historical materials with low credibility to deny historical materials with high credibility!"
"Otherwise, there are so many conflicts in the historical materials, how to choose?"
In the credibility rating, "Datang Entrepreneurship and Living Note" belongs to the highest level of credibility for studying the history of the founding of the Tang Dynasty by Li Yuan. ”
"No historical record can shake it. ”
What the?!
The professor's words immediately caused an uproar below, and many people were stunned at that time.
"Do historical materials still need to be graded for credibility?"
"We've never heard of that!"
"What does this mean? It means that you can't just take out a history book and you can refute it?"
The professor's words directly made many people confused at that time, and they had a kind of surprise and confusion like a layman looking at an insider.
Before, they questioned other professors, but now when they hear other professors say this, many people nod their heads again, it turns out that it is not that professors want to use academic authority to suppress them, but that there are basic rules in historical research.
People are just doing things according to the rules of the industry.
Everyone has their own industry and understands that the industry has its own system and standards.
In an instant, public opinion fell to Chen Tong's side again.
The beautiful hostess was also stunned, and said with a wry smile: "Sure enough, interlacing is like separating mountains, as a layman, sometimes I make common-sense mistakes." ”
The beautiful host, as soon as she finished speaking, she was directly sprayed by Li Shimin's fans.
Zhenguan Weitian directly reprimanded:
"What common-sense mistake?"
"This is simply nonsense, this is the industry barrier that has been formulated!"
"Where are the criteria for credibility grading?"
Li Shimin's fans directly questioned these professors, feeling that the professors blocked the entry of these laymen and prevented others from having devastating doubts about their academic research.
The professors' faces were ugly, but they still explained carefully, although some historical materials were wrong when Li Shimin's fans gave examples, he didn't want to dwell on this, but wanted to clarify more important things.
"The so-called credibility grading is to rank historical materials as trustworthy. ”
"There are certainly standards. ”
"The first biggest criterion is: the time criterion!"
"The more original the historical material, the closer it is to the time when the historical event occurred, the more credible it is. ”
"Take the historical data you gave as an example. ”
"Datang Entrepreneurship Note, it is not only the emperor's record, but also the notes of the army, writing the history of the founding of the country during the Li Yuan period, and from the original historical materials to the finished book, it is basically a real-time record. ”
"The credibility of this kind of historical data is of the highest level. ”
"And the epitaph of Pei Lin that you are talking about below, that is a historical material that appeared in the Zhenguan period, and its credibility will be reduced. ”
"The old and new Tang books, the general knowledge of governance, are all historical materials hundreds of years later, and the credibility is even lower. ”
As soon as the professor explained this, everyone suddenly realized.
"No wonder, when those professors talk about the history of the Sui and Tang dynasties, they basically don't use the old and new Tang books, but mainly talk about the "Tang Dynasty Entrepreneurship and Living Note", which turns out to look at more primitive historical materials. ”
"In this way, the professors are also justified and act in accordance with the regulations, there is nothing wrong with it!"
The professors did not distort the rules of the industry to set up obstacles for others, and some people agreed with this explanation.
But Li Shimin's fans are even more unconvinced, because the professor's words directly negate the part about Li Yuan in the old and new Tang books, and even more negates the part of Li Shimin.
How can you brag to others in the future?
Zhenguan Weitian, directly slapped the table and roared:
"What industry standards do you need to stipulate?"
"I don't think that's reasonable!"
"Why do you say that you should divide the credibility of historical materials according to time?"
The professors were choked to death, they didn't expect that there were such nonsense people, industry regulations are industry regulations, you first question people, and then question industry regulations.
Is it just that as long as it is different from your statement, you have to question it!
If their own students dared to ask them that, the professors would just slap the table angrily.
At this moment, their faces were ugly, and they felt that these people were too unreasonable.
The professor didn't want to raise the bar with them, so he snorted coldly:
"Industry regulations, that is definitely the evaluation standard within the industry, that is recognized by everyone in the industry, has become a practice, can you say that it can be refuted?"
"For example, if you want to shovel out the gunpowder residue in the rocket, you have to shovel it manually, so why don't you use a machine to shovel it?"
"For example, if you are piling a well in a construction site, and the drill bit falls into the hole, you have to manually dive into the mud to find the drill bit, why not use a machine to find it?"
"Are we going to explain to you the process and historical background of the industry? Or will we explain to you the various complex practical factors in it?"
The professors finally know why Li Shimin's fans are so annoying.
Is it that the math teacher will teach you an arithmetic problem, and he will have to explain to you first, why does one plus one equal two? Are you sure you can understand it?
Li Shimin's fans rolled their eyes, they felt that this was the professors' weak hearts, Zhenguan Weitian, said,
"Then you should tell me, why, you say that you should judge credibility in chronological order?"
"Why can't we use whether it is widespread or not as a criterion for grading credibility?"
"We don't think that's reasonable!"
The professors are really going to be by these people at this moment, isn't this a pole?
Because when it comes to academic research, everyone is still relatively rational, and for this kind of-for-tat, I have to question every word you say, and they are too difficult to accept.
One by one, they were so angry that they blew their beards and stared, and many people's blood pressure continued to soar, they felt that they were hasty, and they had to find a professional to raise the bar.
If you continue like this, you have to be angry and go to the hospital.
Li Shimin's fans were even more proud when they saw the professors like this, and the shouting was louder:
"Say, what do you say?"
"If you can't say it, it means that it's unreasonable! ”
The fans of the other phalanx are full of disgust, who doesn't have their own industry, everyone, their own industry doesn't have some special standard system?
A rule is a rule, you have to ask why it is so stipulated, isn't this a matter of raising the bar with others?
Seeing that the situation was about to get out of control, these professors were angry and slapped their hearts, Chen Tong slapped the table with force, and roared angrily:
"Shut up!"
"Since you are questioning, why is the credibility of historiography so graded?"
"Then I'll give you a reasonable explanation!"