In order to make it easier for everyone to see clearly, Liu Zhiyuan operated it, and soon several large segmented inscription plates appeared on the screen, which made it more convenient for the people below to see clearly.

Liu Zhiyuan's question came out, and everyone began to discuss again, since they are engaged in art, like these famous artists, of course the people below will not be strangers, but it is precisely because they are not strangers that a group of people have not only seen the authentic works of these people, but perhaps it is also because Liu Zhiyuan planted the seeds of doubt in their hearts first, in short, at this moment, a group of people, no matter how they look at this question, there are problems, but they feel that they are suspicious.

There was an endless debate below, but in the end, there were a few voices that said: "I always feel that this question is a little lax in writing!"

"Yes, font spacing also seems to be a bit of a problem!"

"Are these really the famous inscriptions? I always feel that the power of these fonts seems to be lacking!"

"That's it, that's how I feel!" "And so do I, anyway, I don't look like those famous artists made inscriptions!" ......

A group of people kept shouting, Liu Zhiyuan had a serious face, and a pair of eyes glanced around like torches and said, "You guys shouldn't all be blind, right?"

As soon as these words came out, there was silence for a while, and Liu Zhiyuan couldn't cry or laugh for a while, and said to people, "It's so easy to blow up? You must be too honest, aren't you?

"I'll go to Mr. Liu, you looked really scary when you pretended to be serious just now!"

"That's right, it's not the sudden change of the hippie smile's face, we thought you were angry!" "Okay, bluff a quasi?" Liu Zhiyuan really smiled when he looked at the students below patting his chest, "Actually, I'm praising you, because you really guessed wrong!"

Many people want to say that in fact, when they watched Liu Zhiyuan change his face just now, they all planned to change the words that came to their mouths directly, and then they heard Liu Zhiyuan say this, at that time, a group of people were about to vomit three liters of blood, and they really deserved to be the former host star, this Nima's acting skills are also good, right?

"Okay, let me tell you about the name of the person before the inscription, "Bu Yuan Tu" inscription "Li Dao (誌)" may be "Li Daoming" or "Li Zao" and other issues for research, this picture is actually to this you should already know that he is fake, in fact, I am not the only one who has made a final conclusion about this picture, there are people who have begun to study it a long time ago, they think that this picture is a copy of the Northern Song Dynasty, and when the Northern Song Dynasty copied the "Bu Yuan Tu" in the middle of the Northern Song Dynasty, due to the "making" and "Dao" The two characters in cursive are not easy to distinguish and distinguish, so Zhang Boyi mistook the cursive word "made" as "dao", and then copied it with a small seal, resulting in the phenomenon of miswriting. ”

Of course, even if you glance at the name and don't say, the most obvious point of this inscription, this is said to be Zhang Boyi's seal script is not reliable at all, this seal is very lame, the line spacing and word spacing are deviated, not only skewed, the word spacing is uneven, the size of the word is uneven, and the proportion of many words on the left and right sides is out of balance. This can be seen in the words "Li Daozhi" in the first line of the seal script and Li Deyu in the second line, which is written by people who have no level, and a mature calligrapher will not make such a mistake......"

Liu Zhiyuan opened his mouth like this, and everyone knew why Liu Zhiyuan was glaring at them just now, because they were really right, but it was a pity that they didn't insist on it.

"In addition, everyone must have seen that this obvious can not be in the obvious three words 'step diagram', right? These three words are certainly not Song Gaozong's words, the forger actually wants to learn Song Huizong's inscription, but the pseudo-author did not learn Song Huizong's thin gold body, so there are many famous painters who have objections to this doubtful words, and some people even say that it is just like what I said before, this painting is just a fake painting made by descendants according to the Song Dynasty Mi Fu's "painting history", it is a fake work of outright poor painting level. Of course, this "step diagram" is when it really exists, in fact, he really should have, at least and Mi Fu, Tang Yuan, etc. in the Song and Yuan dynasties have seen Tang Yan Liben's original work......"

I'm Cao, this Nima is really unraveling a link and another link, which makes people more and more excited, I originally thought that this thing might not exist from beginning to end, but now Liu Zhiyuan actually said such a thing again!

"What about Mr. Liu's painting, where is it now? Everything in our museum is fake...... the people below have completely believed Liu Zhiyuan's words.

Liu Zhiyuan smiled: "Don't worry, there is one last doubt, I will solve it for you, and then I will continue to tell you other digressions, and finally what we want to talk about is seals, the habits of the ancients, whether it is words or paintings, are to be printed, everyone knows it, right?"

Because of Liu Zhiyuan's words, everyone once again suppressed their doubts and nodded at people.

"Yes, almost every piece of work has it. ”

"There are problems with the seal method and the method of the seal of this "Bu Yuan Tu", the three parties are the three seals of the 'Seven Seals' of Zhangzong, but compared with the real 'Seven Seals of Mingchang', the seal on the "Bu Yuan Tu" is weak and weak, and the seal is not played by Jin Zhangzong, and the seal part of the seal is not consistent with the specifications of the real seal. ”

To sum up, the above analysis and research of Tang Yan Liben and the volume of "Bu Yuan Tu" show that although most of them are valued by scholars and many research results have been published, no unified understanding of the authorship has been formed so far. It can be summarized into three opinions: the first view is that the Bu Yuan Tu is an authentic work of the early Tang painter Yan Liben and is a representative work of Tang Dynasty figure painting; the second view is that it should be a copy of the Northern Song Dynasty painting by Yan Liben of the Tang Dynasty (or the Tang painting related to it), which is an important work reflecting the painting style of the Tang Dynasty; and the third view denies that this work is an authentic work of Yan Liben or a copy of the Song people, but does not deny or partially agree with the elements of Tang Dynasty painting......"

"Although there are differences in the above three views, they all affirm or basically agree that the Bu Yuan Diagram is an important image material for the study of early Tang Dynasty paintings, and it is related to Tang Yan Liben, and now the paste in your mind is clear?"

Liu Zhiyuan smiled and watched everyone speak like this, the students below listened to Liu Zhiyuan's explanation, and finally came to include, in an instant, three simple and clear words clarified a plate of loose sand in their minds, with the clarification of this loose sand, the following suddenly remembered a thunderous applause, accompanied by sharp cheers and howls.

I can see that the people below are going crazy with excitement, and they are really going crazy.