Chapter 137: Lawyers' Debate Competition (2)
"You may wonder why we have such a rule. Professor Li Jun waited for everyone's voices to drop down slightly, and then explained with a smile: "In the previous debate competitions, not only could the contestants prepare the topics in advance, but also agree on the debate ideas, so that no water leaked. In this way, there will be no problems, but it will also lose the essence of the debate competition, and it will not be able to really consider the lawyer's skills, eagerness, and ability to cooperate with each other on the spot. All lawyers will encounter all kinds of problems during the trial, and they can't always say to the opposing lawyer and the judge, you can't say this, you haven't said this before, I can't answer you, if so, then the trial is meaningless. ”
Professor Li Jun's tone was humorous, and the applause rang out at the scene, and some people said that he was right, and today's debate competition is interesting. Some of the so-called 'best debaters' are actually just 'memory emperors'.
Some players also wailed, "Although this rule is new, it is unfair to the players who participated for the first time this year, because the team cooperation of the competition has 10 points, and the rhythm of the old players is easy to grasp, and the new players must grasp the rhythm and cooperate with each other, and the difficulty has increased more than a little." ”
The players in Linting City laughed again, because on the stage, they didn't dare to be too presumptuous, laughed and paused, "quack", like ducks, among the four of them, two of them were contestants who participated in the debate last year and cooperated with each other, and the four people in Baishui Prefecture on the opposite side were all unfamiliar faces, and looking at the information, none of the two people were the same, not to mention the tacit understanding, but I was afraid that I didn't even understand what cooperation was.
I don't know how exciting they will lose.
As soon as the debate questions of the first group were announced, even Shang Luoyu and Huang Yixi were a little stunned at this time, and the debate questions were:
Defendant Zhang San, male, 35 years old, is the director of the housing management department of a municipal state-owned enterprise.
In December 2011, a municipal state-owned enterprise planned to repair and renovate the heating project in the family area in May 2012, which was specifically responsible for and undertaken by Zhang San, director of the housing management department, and Li Si, a clerk of the housing management office.
On January 10, 2012, Wang Wulai, the manager of an engineering company, gave New Year's greetings to Zhang San and Li Si (Wang Wu was a classmate of Li Si and was familiar with Zhang San). After Wang Wu entered the office, he took out a large envelope and put it on the coffee table, saying, "The Spring Festival is coming, this is a small matter, buy some New Year's goods for the two of you." ”
Li Si said: "Director, do you see this?" Zhang San said: "Since it is a piece of manager Wang Wu's heart, you can take it first." Then Zhang San went to report the work, Li Si talked with Wang Wu, Wang Wu proposed to Li Si to contract the heating renovation project, Li Si said that he could help, but it must be agreed by Director Zhang San and decided by the leaders of the enterprise.
Soon after Wang Wu left, Zhang San returned to the office, and Li Si told Zhang San about Wang Wu's request to contract the project, and opened the envelope, found that it was 30,000 yuan, and asked Zhang San what to do.
Zhang San said: "Your lover is in the hospital for surgery, you can keep the money." I don't want it yet, and I'll talk about it when I'm short of money. Manager Wang Wu's contracting project, you draft a report for instructions, and I will talk to the enterprise leaders. ”
On 21 January, Li Si drafted a request for Wang Wu's engineering company to contract the renovation of the heating project, which was signed by Zhang San and reported to the enterprise leaders, who told the enterprise leaders in person that the project should be contracted by Wang Wu's engineering company.
On February 25, the leaders of the state-owned enterprise decided not to agree to contract the project to Zhang San's engineering company, but to the city's municipal engineering company. Later, the case was reported by the masses.
Positive: Zhang San's behavior constitutes the crime of accepting bribes (accepting bribes of 30,000 yuan, Li Si will be handled in a separate case).
Opposite: Zhang San's actions do not constitute a crime.
Huang Yixi couldn't help frowning, sure enough, it's a criminal question! That's it, the problem is that this topic is obviously unfavorable to the opposing party, I really don't know which one of the great powers came out? Huang Yixi looked at the host, and always felt that he was the most suspicious, and he had to say that Huang Yixi was the truth.
"Both sides are invited to start drawing lots to decide the identity of the pros and cons. The host laughed.
The four debaters glared at each other, and Huang Yixi hurriedly raised his hands, "Don't tell me to go, I've been very weak since I was a child, and I haven't even been hit by another bottle." ”
Shang Luoyu also shook his head, his luck was not very good, the only good luck was to meet Huang Yixi. Song Lili lowered her head to look at the new shoes, fortunately, Kang Mingyang was a little eager to try, Shang Luoyu asked him to hurry up, and he could only hope that Kang Mingyang's luck would be able to draw the square.
After the two sides finished the debate and drew lots, the host Li Jun looked at the Baishui State team narrowly and announced: "The positive side of this debate competition is the Linting City Lawyers Team, and the opposite side is the Baishui State Lawyers Team." Let us encourage with applause, and look forward to all the debaters who can bring us a wonderful and fierce debate!"
"Well, God is your own father. ”
Huang Yixi glared at the four ugly ducks sitting opposite and laughing "quack", feeling a little indignant, in vain she had just returned to her hometown to worship her ancestors and move the tomb, why was she so unhelpful.
To be able to sit in this auditorium, except for a few reporters, almost everyone is related to legal work, all the lawyers and law-related workers are laughing, such a topic, if the positive side can't win, then it's really a hell, the lawyers in the Linting City area are even more vigorously applauded, although some people in the Baishui Prefecture area are now sparsely seated, but everyone turned their heads sideways, with a look of "don't look at me, I'm not a cheerleader in Baishui Prefecture, I'm here to fill up".
"It's three minutes. The competition has officially begun, so please have a debate first!"
He is also the captain of the Linting City lawyer team, he has been a lawyer for more than ten years, and he is also a player who participated in the lawyer debate competition in the last period, so he must have some skills.
Just now, he was not good at the players in Baishui State, and it was also one of the strategies they agreed upon, which was to give Baishui State a dismount at the beginning and kill their sharpness.
In their opinion, Baishui Prefecture is a novice, and there is no fame in the legal community of Minyue Province, and the only one who is a little wary of it is the little white-faced Shang Luoyu, but he is just a scary name, and there are many turtles that have come back over the years, but most of them are not adapted to the soil after going ashore.
He will put himself in the position of a debate, he must think that he is the most suitable, and sure enough, when it comes to putting his views and strengthening his own momentum, he is definitely the most suitable person.
In a short period of three minutes, the positive side talked eloquently, focusing on the basic fact that Zhang San, as a state functionary, used his position to seek benefits for others, from law to morality.
Finally, he also made a summary with great momentum: "Leaders, judges, teachers, and peers, the report of the 19th National Congress of the Communist Party of China pointed out that the situation in the fight against corruption is still grim and complex, and the determination to consolidate the overwhelming situation and win an overwhelming victory must be as firm as a rock. It is necessary to adhere to no forbidden areas, full coverage, and zero tolerance, adhere to heavy containment, strong pressure, and long-term deterrence, persist in investigating bribery and bribery together, and resolutely prevent the formation of interest groups within the party. As a lawyer, we should adhere to the basic principle of the legality of crimes, and we should not tolerate criminals. ”
Shang Luoyu and Huang Yixi glanced at each other and were happy. I have to say that this positive debate not only has legal knowledge, but also has a political height, and it has to be said that it is very powerful (no harm) (shame) to raise the legal debate to this height.
.com。 Wonderful Book House .com