If he argues again, maybe he will also sit on the fourth throne of decay. Shang Luoyu ignored the lawsuit between the two of them, and only took out a soft cushion from his bag.

The chair in the arena was a solid wood chair, Huang Yixi sat uncomfortably in the first game, his back was so sore that he didn't get up for a long time after going home.

He was so distressed that he immediately rushed out and walked a few streets before he could buy a mat that was soft and hard and of the right height.

He put down the cushion, helped Huang Yixi sit down, and took out a thermos flask from his bag.

Xiao Lizi waited for Lafayette, and he was so diligent, Zhou Liufang complained wildly in his heart.

Huang Yixi sat down and began to observe today's judges.

The judges of this debate competition are still the same as the first one, and Professor Shi Congmin, a law professor who has only watched it on TV before, is also present.

When she saw him in the first scene, she felt familiar, but she couldn't remember where she had seen it for a while, and she suddenly remembered it when she went home, and she discussed it with Shang Luoyu.

He is a professor of law at Kyoto University, a doctoral supervisor, and the director of the Center for Legal Studies at Kyoto University.

However, I heard that his work has not been going well recently, and he has left the research center of Kyoto University, and the new position that he had negotiated has not been able to take up his post for a long time.

Leaders in the professional field, when they are brilliant, the road is smooth, and the flowers are blooming, but when the times are not smooth, there is often no way out.

Shi Congmin is also in such a dilemma now, after the new position is not followed, no one throws an olive branch, which is undoubtedly a big blow to Professor Shi.

However, it seems that he is in a very calm mood, and he is talking and laughing with the judges next to him, and his mood should not be affected much.

A legal celebrity is a legal celebrity, and with a character like this, Huang Yixi believes that he will not fall like this.

It's really not good, writing books to help people fight lawsuits is also a way out.

Huang Yixi thought so, she didn't realize that her heart was quite wide, and now at this time, she was still worried about the big guys.

Fortunately, she heard the host's order---- debate began.

The pace and intensity of this debate match are not the same as the previous one.

Like the first scene, Shang Luoyu still argued: "Substantive justice is the destination pursued by law, and procedural justice is to serve substantive justice...... Substantive justice, that is our purest belief in justice, no matter how many things are packaged, what the people want to see most is justice......"

After Shang Luoyu started his argument, Guo Feng stood up as soon as the other party argued: "...... The skin does not exist, the hair is attached, and substantive justice is ultimately idealized, and I think it is difficult to achieve. Cases are constantly changing in the course of their trial and occurrence. It is very difficult to determine the difference between fairness and justice and right and wrong....... as the saying goes, if procedural justice is not maintained, then the judicial order will gradually be chaotic, and people will gradually lose confidence in the law if they cannot see the realization of justice......."

After Wei Qiaoyin finished speaking, it was Huang Yixi's second defense, she only said a few words of defense this time, but cited a world-famous case, the famous Simpson case in the United States: "The prosecution presented 723 pieces of evidence; the defense refuted the "insufficient evidence" with 392 pieces of evidence; the prosecution and defense argued for 460 days; a large number of witnesses were dispatched; the plaintiff also launched a strong team of prosecutors; it took more than a month to screen the jury members, and then the jury members were isolated... How much will society pay for such a lengthy procedure, and how can defendants with poor financial means bear the heavy costs of litigation?

No wonder Goldman, one of the victims, said with tears in his eyes after hearing the jury's verdict of "not guilty," "I am convinced that today is a failure for our country, because justice has not been done." ”

This murder case, which was dubbed the "trial of the century" by the American news media, may be clear to everyone about the truth, but the law has failed to allow the murderer to be punished as he deserves. Will such a "procedural justice" undermine a greater degree of social justice?"

Xu Tingting debated this debate topic when she participated in the debate competition in college, and they also said this stalk that Huang Yixi said, and she was also mentally prepared, and she stood up as soon as Huang Yixi's words fell: "We can't say that with procedural justice, substantive justice will definitely be realized; without procedural justice, there must be no substantive justice or substantive justice." Because the derivation of substantive justice has to go through a series of litigation processes, which are dominated by litigation procedures. If procedural justice is violated, then the result is based on improper means, and even if the facts are found correct and the punishment is appropriate, it cannot be said that substantive justice ......"

Huang Yixi finally felt a lot of pressure.

Xu Tingting really has two brushes, and she and Guo Feng are full of oppression from the momentum.

At the same time, there were also people in the audience talking.

"Xiao Fang, which side do you think will win?" The one who asked this was a middle-aged man, he was a doctoral supervisor of Qingyuan University, named Lu Wenqiang, and he was asked about his proud disciple.

The thin young man known as Xiao Fang glanced at his mentor, "No, boss, you actually asked this question, do you still need to ask? It must have been won by the Lingxi Provincial team." ”

He always remembered that his mentor was from Lingxi Province, and he said early that he would come to cheer for the Lingxi Provincial team.

Otherwise, two busy people would not have sat here early in the morning.

"Maybe there, you see the fat woman in the Minyue Provincial Team, she looks clumsy, but her thinking is quite sensitive. ”

When the two of them came in, the contestants were already seated, covered by a table, and Lu Wenqiang had a high degree of myopia, so he didn't realize that he was talking about a pregnant woman.

"That's right, I heard that she was the best debater in the first game, but it is difficult to make a forest alone, unlike the Lingxi team, the four of them performed very well. ”

Xiao Fang still continued to take the route of compliments, as a senior and excellent student, he had long realized that whatever the tutor liked, he must be right, if he was wrong, he must be blind.

"What a single tree, the overall quality of the team in Minyue Province is good, the beginning of the debate is also very good, and the fat woman also knows how to connect the upper and lower levels, which is very good. Lu Wenqiang continued to analyze.

"Boss, you are really discerning, but their tactics are not good, the role of the first debate is very weak, and the one named Shang Luoyu is wasted in the first debate. Xiao Fang refuted it quietly, although the boss could not be refuted, but he didn't like the echo worm very much.

The beginning of the debate and the good is half the difference, the topic of the debate was originally set by the positive and negative sides, and the debate will start according to the position of their own side, as long as the players who can stand here, they can be competent, I don't know why they will arrange him in a debate, overkill, it seems that the background and means of the lawyer named Zhou Liufang in the fourth debate are incredible, and the captain can be squeezed to this point.