Chapter 175: A Thesis That Provoked Li Yiru

Fudan University Campus Network, a small school website, with a maximum of 50,000 daily views, exceeded 2 million visits in just 8 hours!

Especially since the morning, the number of real-time visits has been soaring, and at 7 o'clock, the huge traffic destroys the website in a short time, and it cannot be accessed normally for a long time.

At this time, it was the end of the semester, and many students at Fudan University needed to take courses for the next semester on the intranet, or check the exam results, etc., and as a result, they collapsed......

The initiator, Li Yiru, is also a victim, he still wants to see how many downloads his article has, but as a result, he was not given this opportunity.

The article "My Opinion" on the official website of Fudan University, "My Opinion", has already been downloaded by many netizens, and then it was widely forwarded.

The madness and speed of this retweet far surpassed Li Yiru's previous papers. Moreover, the breadth of the in-depth strata is also very unexpected by everyone.

At noon, Li Yiru went to the bookstore at the school gate to buy magazines, and the boss's white-haired old man was also holding his mobile phone to read his article, and he read it with relish.

After all, the story of the Three Kingdoms period is too deeply rooted in the hearts of the people, Zhuge Liang and others know it to women and children, and this article is easy to understand, so there is no threshold for the public to read, and everyone may not know whether what Li Yiru said is right, but they can understand the logic in the text.

Few people have read "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", and even many people still think that Zhuge Liang is really as awesome as in "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", and many people's perception of the Three Kingdoms is wrong, but it does not prevent everyone from reading Li Yiru's article with relish.

This is why Li Yiru used the most plain language to tell a shocking truth!

The old man raised his head and glanced at Li Yiru, and asked curiously, "Child, is this true or false?"

Li Yiru smiled: "There is no absolute truth or falsehood in history, I can only say that it should be the case in high probability." ”

"Child, how do you forward this, you help me forward it to the circle of friends. ”

Look, even the old man is interested in this, although the old man has no big culture, but he doesn't listen to the storytelling.

In the evening, "My Opinion on the Fake Work of the Later Teacher" is already overwhelming on the Internet.

Li Yiru didn't have evening class that night, and when he came home for dinner, he found that even Giessen TV's "News Network" reported on it.

The hostess sat upright: "Just today, an article called "My Opinion on the Fake Work of the Later Teacher's Table" suddenly exploded the circle of friends and the Internet. ”

Male host: "Because this article is from Li Yiru, who is known as an idol of Chinese culture, and it is also an on-the-spot essay in the "Boya Cup" exam, it has attracted widespread attention from the whole people. Below, we conducted a visit to investigate this article. ”

In the TV, everything in the picture is the reporter's outdoor interview:

"Hello, beauty, may I ask, have you read the article "My Opinion on the Fake Work of the Later Teacher"?"

"I'm really shocked! I'm still a little surprised, isn't this article really written by Zhuge Liang?"

"We don't know, do you think, did Zhuge Liang write it?"

"That's not it, Li Yiru said no, that's not it. Li Yiru is my idol!"

……

The reporter continued the interview:

"Hello, sir, may I ask "My Opinion on the Forgery of the Later Teacher's Table", have you read it? Do you think it is Zhuge Liang's work!"

"I haven't read it! But you don't have to think about it to know that it must be Zhuge Liang's work! Otherwise, can the textbook allow it to rely on Zhuge Liang's name for so long?"

……

"Hello, may I ask, what do you think of the article "My Opinion on the Fake Work of the Later Teacher"?"

"It's pure nonsense, it's nonsense!"

"What's your reason?"

"If the "Later Teacher's Table" was not written by Zhuge Liang, then a scholar would have corrected it a long time ago, how could it be disclosed by a high school student first?

"Uh...... Is there any specific reason for this?"

"Isn't that specific enough?"

……

"Girl, "Later Teacher's Table-"

Before the reporter finished asking, the little girl was directly excited: "My idol is simply too powerful, too powerful!"

Reporter: "......"

……

Li Yiru watched the TV screen while eating, I have to say, it's really the public watching the excitement, even if they watch the excitement, everyone is standing in line with their own cognition.

In TV interviews, in fact, most people are not convinced by their own views, and only a few people support them.

And the same is true on the Internet.

After all, Zhuge Liang and the list of teachers before and after are really too deeply rooted in the hearts of the people.

The appearance of Li Yiru's article seems to be trying to change the public's self-perception, and he does not have this strong appeal, so that the public accepts everything he says unconditionally.

After all, he is still too young, just a fledgling, and only two articles have been exposed.

In the TV screen, the style of painting changed, and the reporter appeared in the office of Professor Wang of the Department of History of the University of Keyson.

Reporter: "Hello Professor Wang, today's article "My Opinion on the Forgery of the Later Teacher's Table" is being reprinted wildly on the Internet, may I ask, after you read this article, what is your evaluation?"

Professor Wang said: "This article has clear logic and sufficient arguments, and it can be justified to a certain extent, but we can also refute it in many places.

As for the real author of "The Later Teacher's Table", the academic community has always agreed with Zhuge Liang undoubtedly, and Li Yiru's point of view is very novel, very exciting, and at first glance, it is very convincing. I think that's why he became the winner of the Boya Cup. ”

The reporter asked again: "Can Li Yiru's conclusion stand?"

Professor Wang sighed slightly: "I think his point of view has a certain degree of reasonableness, but whether it can stand on its own, I don't think I can just give a conclusion, if I have to come up with an attitude now, I am more inclined to traditional cognition, but Li Yiru has such careful thinking at a young age, and can have his own bold questioning, it is still very rare!"

At the same time, the independent enrollment of Keyson University is also about to start, and Li Yiru is welcome to actively apply!"

Li's mother looked at the TV: "This professor is denying you, it seems that there is really something wrong with your article!"

Li Yiru shook his head: "It's not necessarily that there is a problem with my article, there are many academic problems, and it is normal for there to be disagreements in the industry." This professor denies me, and there may be other professors who support me, right?"

"Hehe, the famous University of Giessen, and a professor of history, people are wrong, are you right?

Li's mother pouted, on this issue, she still chose to believe the professor, after all, the professor eats more salt than her son eats rice!

The son is indeed awesome, but the awesome is in the brain, and the brain power and academic discrimination are two concepts!

It is true that the son is a genius, but growing from a genius to a national warrior is a process of gradual accumulation.

Li Yiru didn't talk back, today is "the world doesn't brag day", Li Yiru went back to the room to read in accordance with international practice.

But this night, it was really restless. Regarding whether the article "Later Teacher's Table" was written by Zhuge Liang, the entire Internet has debated and turned over. But the arguments of netizens are often superficial and can't get to the real core.

When the video of Professor Wang's interview was circulated on Douyin, netizens who had previously chosen to believe Li Yiru turned against him.

After all, Li Yiru wrote this essay in a hurry in a short period of time, and his opponent was a professor of history at a famous university.

When Li Yiru and Professor Wang have diametrically opposed views, everyone will naturally be more willing to believe Professor Wang.

In particular, Zhuge Liang's "Later Teacher's Table" is itself closely related to the public's deep-rooted cognition!

Li Yiru has always been reluctant to participate in online disputes, and if he reads the comments, he is estimated to be angry to death eight times a day.

He still wants to spend his time on things that are really useful, such as reading books, such as flirting with girls, such as flirting with girls, such as flirting with girls......

Today is December 26th, and tomorrow, he will arrange a live broadcast, and then broadcast live again, which is New Year's Day in 2020!

Starting from January 1, 2020, he will start the live broadcast career of Li Yiru's Sinology series, which is his only job before the college entrance examination, and it is also the most realistic and feasible job.

Many variety shows basically contact him every day, but he is not interested, and he does not have such a large chunk of time.

Before the college entrance examination, everything else gave way, and he had to work hard to be admitted to Fudan University.

The Chinese culture series will not take up too much of his time, and it can continue to maintain the popularity for him and continuously increase his income, which is the most suitable platform for his development in the next 6 months.

Tomorrow, he will go to the company to shoot promotional materials, and in the evening live broadcast, he will officially announce that Li Yiru's series of live broadcasts will officially start on New Year's Day!

After reading the book for a while, Li Yiru took out his mobile phone and posted a Weibo: At 9 o'clock tomorrow night, Doule video, we will see you or leave!

Li Yiru is on the heat, as a result, as soon as this Weibo was released, the comments broke 1,000 in an instant, 200,000 in half an hour, and 400,000 in 1 hour!

Li Yiru used powerful data to prove how popular he is at the moment!

Among the miscellaneous comments, there was a challenge "manifesto" called a hot post.

A big V with the real name "Sun Zheng" left a message under Li Yiru's Weibo: The article "My Opinion on the Fake Work of the Later Teacher" is worthless except for a little gimmick. This is just an ordinary exam essay, but I didn't expect it to be widely discussed. I will connect with Li Yiru in the live broadcast room tomorrow night to refute Li Yiru's views one by one, and the bet is the entire income of the night.

Li Yiru soon saw this hot comment, because now this comment is the first hot comment.

Li Yiru doesn't know who this Sun Zheng is, but netizens helped him answer his questions, and his resume is as follows.

Sun Zheng: Male, a graduate student of the Department of History of Renmin University, and the anchor of the Sinology Channel of the Funny Fish Platform.

Li Yiru didn't expect that the other party was really a little unexpected. If you really come to PK with yourself when you broadcast live tomorrow night, then do you agree?

Agree, he is not qualified enough, Li Yiru is too lazy to waste time and fight with others.

If you don't agree, it makes us feel like we're cowardly. Last night, Xia Yuqing still called us Li Xiaoyi, how many chains were dropped?

Moreover, tens of millions of netizens are staring at it, and if they don't answer other people's connection PK, it will become hot search news in the blink of an eye.

Now in this Internet era, even those who cooperate to fight fake boxing can make a wave of news, so they don't dare to take the "professional" connection PK, which will definitely become a hot news for everyone to complain!

Moreover, in addition to Sun Zheng, will anyone else also jump out to PK with him,, so do you have to deal with them one by one?

Li Yiru thought of this and decided to set up rules in his live broadcast room.

He replied to Sun Zheng: @ε­™ζ­£, may I ask, how much money can you make after a live broadcast?

Sun Zheng: Under normal circumstances, the net income of about 10,000 yuan, what are you doing?

Li Yiru @ Sun Zheng: You earn about 10,000 yuan in a live broadcast, and I earn about 5 million yuan in a live broadcast, why should I bet with you?

All netizens burst into laughter:

"Haha, I wanted to say it a long time ago!

"This naked gap! I blush for Sun Zheng!"

"The current anchor is really speechless for the sake of popularity!"

"Renmin University also cultivates this kind of goods!"

"Don't talk about the National People's Congress, it's Beijing University, didn't it also make a celebrity education scandal!"

……

After a while, Sun Zheng @ Li Yiru: Then don't gamble, do you dare to connect with me tomorrow night PK?

Li Yiru smiled and replied: I dare, but you have to connect with me on time to PK, my live broadcast time is from 9 pm to 11 pm, I must wait for you quietly, but you won't release my pigeon, right?

"How is that possible?"

"That's good, don't release my pigeons under any excuse!"

Li Yiru really responded to the battle, and after the battle, Li Yiru posted on Weibo again: Tomorrow night, I will have a video connection with Mr. Sun Zheng to discuss Zhuge Liang and the article "Later Teacher". I solemnly declare that, in principle, in my future live broadcast career, I will no longer accept anyone's online PK, after all, my live broadcast is not an entertainment attribute, and I don't want my Chinese culture sharing lectures to be interrupted constantly.

Li Yiru's announcement can be regarded as a way out for others to provoke.

After the Weibo was posted, Li Yiru glanced at the time, it was only more than 8 o'clock in the evening, so he turned off his mobile phone to prevent external interference, and he was about to start working.

This night, a new focus of discussion will appear, Li Yiru PK Sun Zheng!

One represents the Chinese Studies Channel of the Doule Platform, the other represents the Chinese Studies Channel of the Funny Fish Platform, one is a 17-year-old genius of Chinese Studies, and the other is a graduate student of the History Department of the National People's University.

This night, the focus of public opinion was basically focused on this.

Sun Zheng's Weibo fans are growing in a straight line, and he has successfully gained a wave of popularity.

Some netizens left a message on his Weibo: "Sun Zheng, I can't wait, you can just broadcast PK live tonight." ”

Sun Zheng replied: Don't worry, I'm sorting out the information, preparing in detail, and I'll face Li Yiru tomorrow night.

Netizen: Li Yiru wrote "My Opinion on the Fake Work of the Later Teacher", and they wrote it in three hours, and they didn't have a chance to check the information. You still have to sort it out, Mr. Graduate Student of the History Department of Renmin University?

Sun Zheng was directly stunned and couldn't answer a word.

There was a lot of uproar on the Internet, and some people analyzed Li Yiru's article, but there was no very powerful article to refute Li Yiru's views, and many netizens who firmly believed that Li Yiru was wrong were waiting for Sun Zheng's strength.

It was late at night, and the lights of the buildings were falling one after another.

Just when many netizens were about to rest, an article suddenly appeared in the forum of 19 Middle School, which was titled "Some Analysis of Refuting the Fake Work of the Later Teacher", which was quickly forwarded by the students of 19 Middle School, and in a short period of time, it popped up on the Internet.

Professor Wang of the University of Giessen also saw this article very quickly.

Professor Wang has some regrets about accepting the interview with "Giessen News Network" tonight.

He still believes that "The Later Teacher's Table" is Zhuge Liang's work, although Li Yiru's analysis is reasonable and well-founded, but he feels that more than 8% of "The Later Teacher's Table" is Zhuge Liang's work.

The reason why he regrets it is because he shouldn't have waded into this troubled water, and his remarks have become a sword in the hands of many netizens.

In fact, he also knew that when the pseudo-theory of "Later Teacher's Table" was thrown out by Li Yiru, there must be people in the academic community who supported Li Yiru, and it was normal for him to have differences in academic opinions, but he didn't want to be the person in the whirlpool of the Internet.

Because the Internet is a double-edged sword!

He paced in the living room, holding his iPad and began to read "Some Analyses to Refute the Falsification of the Later Teacher's Table."

[Abstract: The Later Teacher's Table is an important material for the study of Zhuge Liang, and for a long time, there has never been any doubt about the authenticity of the Later Teacher's Table. Now there is a middle school student Li Yiru's "My Opinion on the Fake Work of the Later Teacher" exam essay, which has aroused national discussion, which is simply a big joke in the world!

。 In response to this ridiculous point of view. Based on the historical basis, I put forward my own views on the provenance, emotional tone and terminology of the "Later Teacher's Table", and the historical figures involved, and comprehensively refuted Li Yiru's article "My Opinion on the Falsification of the Later Teacher's Table", proving that the "Later Teacher's Table" was indeed written by Zhuge Liang. ]

Seeing this, Professor Wang glanced at the word count of this article, and it turned out to be more than 9,000 words, which was actually a paper of more than 9,000 words.

But Li Yiru's exam paper has only been exposed for less than a day, and someone wrote a 9,000-word paper to fight back, which shows that the author of this little steamed bun called Wangzi is also a talented talent!

Professor Wang continued to read:

[How much bitterness and sighs are contained in the sentence "Bow and do your best, and then die", this sentence has become synonymous with Zhuge Liang's spirit and has been passed down to this day.

However, for the article "Later Teacher's Table" from which this sentence originated, Li Yiru deduced from its details that it was not made by Zhuge Liang, and put forward a lot of seemingly strong evidence. In the author's opinion, these inferences and "evidence" are inherently unconvincing. The controversy over the authenticity of the "Later Teacher's Table" mainly focuses on the following aspects.

1. The source of the original text of the "Later Teacher Table".

"The Later Teacher's Table" was not included by Chen Shou in "Zhuge Liang Collection", nor did it appear in "Three Kingdoms", but appeared in Wu Guoda's "Silent Notes" by Zhang Yan.

Pei Songzhi in "Three Kingdoms, Shu Shu, Zhuge Liang Biography" notes Xi Chisel tooth "Han Jin Spring and Autumn Period": "This table, Liang Ji does not have, out of Zhang Yan's "Silent Notes". This is one of the sources of Li Yiru's false views.

The author believes that it is too far-fetched to conclude that it is a forgery just because "The Later Teacher's Table" is not included in "Zhuge Liangji" and "Three Kingdoms".

Does the fact that historians do not record the table to show that it does not exist? There may be a complex reason behind it, but it is not so simple.

Why didn't Chen Shou record the "Later Table"? Chen Shou's "Chronicles of the Three Kingdoms" and "Zhuge Collection" were compiled in the early years of the Western Jin Dynasty, and the political and public opinion tone of the Western Jin Dynasty was orthodox with Wei.

……

Second, the style of "Later Teacher's Table".

(1) Li Yiru said that the full text of "Later Teacher's Table" is extremely negative and pessimistic, in fact, Zhuge Liang once said in "Street Pavilion Self-depreciation Book" that 'the subordinates are weak and talented, and they are not based on evidence,...... The minister does not know the person, and the matter is dark'.

Therefore, it is said here that 'the talent is weak and the enemy is strong', which contains the same meaning of review and self-blame for the failure of the First Northern Expedition.

……

Therefore, the negative pessimism of "The Later Teacher" does not violate common sense.

……

Fourth, the question of Zhao Yun's year of death.

The year of Zhao Yun's death is Li Yiru's "ironclad evidence" to prove that "The Later Teacher's Table" is a forgery.

"Shu Shu - The Biography of Zhao Yun" records the year of Zhao Yun's death: "In the first year of Jianxing, he was the general of the Zhonghu Army and Zhengnan, the Marquis of Yongchang Pavilion, and the general of Qianzhendong...... The army retired and was demoted to the general of the town army. 'Died in seven years, chasing Shun Pinghou.

Judging from the above text, the year of Zhao Yun's death was the seventh year of Jianxing.

And the record of "Later Teacher Table": "From the minister to Hanzhong, in the middle of the year, Zhao Yun, Yang Qun, Ma Yu, Yan Zhi ......"

At first glance, there is a contradiction between the record of the "Later Teacher Table" and the record of "The Biography of Zhao Yun" that Zhao Yun died in the "seventh year of Jianxing". Li Yiru took this opportunity to determine that the "Later Teacher's Table" must be a forgery.

On this point, I think, if the ambition and the expression do not match, you can doubt the table or doubt the will, is it necessarily the wrong "Later Teacher Table"? Could it be that the "Biography of Zhao Yun" incorrectly recorded the year of Zhao Yun's death?

Therefore, Li Yiru's point of view is not ironclad evidence!

……

To sum up, the author believes that "The Later Teacher's Table" is indeed from Zhuge Liang and not a forgery.

References:

……]

Professor Wang put down his iPad and said in a daze: "Talent!"

In a short period of time, maybe just a few hours, this "Wangzi Little Steamed Bun" wrote a-for-tat paper on Li Yiru's "My Opinion on the Fake Work of the Later Teacher", and there was no negligence in the arguments, Professor Wang could think of to refute Li Yiru's arguments, this paper was all summarized, and even some of the arguments Professor Wang ignored.

This paper, if his doctor writes it, it is estimated that it will take a week to write this level, and the argument may not be as sufficient as "Wangzi Little Steamed Bun".

In particular, in the paper, "Wangzi Little Steamed Bun" mentions an argument that Professor Wang could not have dreamed of - the explanation of the word "mourning".

Wang Tsai Xiao Mantou believes that there are two interpretations of the word "mourning" as a verb, one is "loss, loss", and the other is "death, death".

Because the word "mourning" is used as "death", and the object cannot be added directly after speaking. Therefore, the "mourning" of "mourning Zhao Yun" can only be interpreted in the first way, that is, "loss, loss".

However, the loss of Zhao Yun and other generals does not mean that they are all dead.

That is to say, "mourning Zhao Yun" in the "Later Teacher Table" means that Zhao Yun is lost, and losing it does not mean that he must be dead, and it can also be interpreted as "not in his place".

Therefore, with such an analysis, there is no difference between "The Later Teacher's Table" and "The Biography of Zhao Yun" in the year of death.

Professor Wang admired it, and said in his heart which colleague is this Wangzi little steamed bun, it's too awesome, and the comprehensiveness of the refutation of Li Yiru's article and the tricky angle make people admire!

Li Yiru can write "My Opinion on the Fake Work of the Later Teacher's Table" in a few hours, and he can even write "Some Analysis of Refuting the Fake Work of the Later Teacher's Table" in a few hours, and it is also reasonable and well-founded, this talent is also amazing!

Professor Wang was excited, awesome, this year's Chinese academic circles are full of talents!

At this time, Sun Zheng was also excited.

He was urgently searching for information to refute Li Yiru, and was preparing to defeat Li Yiru tomorrow night, so that the majority of fans could take a look at his talent that he couldn't hold back.

However, when he saw the article "Some Analyses of Refuting the False Work of the Later Teacher", he was directly confused.

Damn, this paper has written all the arguments that I have come up with! And I have written a lot of arguments that I didn't think of at all, this ...... This still doesn't let people live!

Tomorrow night, I will be connected to Li Yiru by video, and as a result, every argument I have will come from this article, and there is no novel argument, so won't I be ridiculed to death by netizens?

Holy!

Which turtle bastard wrote this paper, you wrote it in a timely manner, what do you want me to PK with Li Yiru tomorrow?

When I open my mouth at that time, everything I say is the content that netizens have seen, so do you still use yourself to say it?

"Wangzi Little Steamed Bun" Your uncle, you are our PK and then send the paper, you are a pit father!

No, we must find new arguments to refute Li Yiru's arguments outside of this paper!

He scratched his ears and cheeks, hollowed out his thoughts, and after 20 minutes, he didn't come up with a new argument!

Sun Zheng was in a hurry, and in the university group and the graduate student group, he @δΊ†ζ‰€ζœ‰δΊΊ: Let's take a look at the article "Some Analyses of Refuting the Falsification of the Later Teacher's Table", and then help me find some new arguments, thank you.

Whether my grandson can keep this face tomorrow night depends on everyone, thank you.

The classmates in the group replied one after another:

"No problem!"

"Don't worry!"

"Okay, little thing!"

……

Sun Zheng relieved his heart at this time, and then scolded again: "Wangzi little steamed bun, you little bastard! You have killed me, where are you sacred? Fortunately, I have many classmates who study history, hum!"