Chapter 15: Rebuttal
Cattle!
This Liu Lin really has a very thorough study of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms"!
The students present were all convinced by her words, and they were really convinced.
Even Zhao Xining has to admire, to be honest, although she has watched "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", she does not understand it so thoroughly and deeply as Liu Lin at all.
"Sima Yi ostensibly fell into Zhuge Liang's empty city plan, but in fact, he was a fake plan, true wisdom, slightly better than Zhuge Liang, you said that Zhuge Liang is powerful, obviously he is still in the most shallow understanding of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", without any depth. Liu Lin unceremoniously hit Xiao Han and said.
This is also a slap in the face of Professor Liu in disguise, isn't it a master of literary literacy?
Even the understanding of famous books is so shallow, can this be called a master?
Professor Liu coughed dryly a few times to hide his embarrassment.
"Let's be quiet, let's listen to what Xiao Han has to say. ”
Su Ziqi just wants to make Xiao Han lose face, what kind of thing, dare to come to their classroom, breathe the air of the same classroom, and deserve this waste?
Everyone's eyes were on Xiao Han.
Zhao Xining whispered: "Male ticket, or you should surrender, don't discuss "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" with Liu Lin, in this regard, Professor Liu is not her opponent." ”
She is also afraid that Xiao Han will make a big joke, this is her appointed male ticket, and making jokes is equivalent to her making jokes, which is very embarrassing.
Xiao Han smiled and began to respond to Liu Lin: "What you just said has no substantive evidence, it's all based on subjective speculation." ”
Subjective speculation?
Brother, do you want to hang like this, what Liu Lin said is reasonable, you actually say that she is subjectively speculating?
The students present all scoffed.
Su Ziqi sneered and muttered, "Waste is waste, it's really interesting to talk." ”
A contemptuous smile appeared at the corner of Liu Lin's mouth: "You said that I was subjectively speculating, so can you answer me the following questions."
Why didn't Sima Yi dare to attack? It was just that he was afraid that there would be an ambush in the city, but in such a city, how many people could be ambushed in it, wouldn't it be possible to send a small team of men and horses in to investigate?
Sima Yi walked to the city tower, and he could see Zhuge Liang stroking the piano on the city wall with a calm expression, and he also heard his piano sound, which was not far, so it was not far away, couldn't you ask a sharpshooter to shoot Zhuge Liang down with an arrow?
The disparity between the forces of the two sides is very huge, Sima Yi has more than 100,000 troops, and he has surrounded this city, besieging it but not attacking it, there is a lack of food and water, and the city will be destroyed sooner or later, why should he just turn around and run?"
I'll go!
This is the soul of the three consecutive questions, according to such a statement, Sima Yi does have a problem, it seems that he really knows the truth that the rabbit dies and the dog cooks, and the bird hides the bow, Zhuge Liang, who deliberately let go, later generations said that he was suspicious and made a big joke, but in fact he had great wisdom and long-term vision.
The students present were deeply immersed in Liu Lin's words.
Professor Liu was wiping sweat, and he had to admit that this female student named Liu Lin had really studied "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" to life, and her attainments in this famous book were even deeper than him.
Zhao Xining was thinking about how to answer these three questions, but after thinking about it for a long time, he couldn't come up with a reason.
Xiao Han chuckled lightly and said, "These questions you mentioned seem to be very reasonable, but in fact, they are all untenable. ”
Oh, my God!
Big brother, do you want to be so arrogant, it's still untenable, who wouldn't be able to talk about it, you can give a reasonable explanation.
The students present were a little unaccustomed to Xiao Han's way of speaking.
"Male ticket, pay attention to the words, or we will surrender, there is no need to fight with her for this. Zhao Xining said embarrassedly.
"It's okay, I happen to have a little bit of research on this book. ”
Xiao Han comforted, and then said to Liu Lin, "Let's talk about the first point first, suppose you are Sima Yi and send a small team of people to investigate, there are two consequences that you have to consider."
One is to delay time, what if Zhuge Liang really has an ambush, time is life, you can not care about your own life, but what about the lives of hundreds of thousands of troops?
The second is that although Zhuge Liang has few soldiers, he occupies a favorable terrain and has sharp weapons such as crossbows, so it is a piece of cake to eliminate a small team of men and horses, so after a small team of men and horses is eliminated, do you continue to send a second team or withdraw the army?
There is another point that you may have to consider, that is, Zhuge Liang has always been known for being stable in his work, and in the face of such a powerful opponent, you dare to risk the lives of hundreds of thousands of troops?"
it!
is amazing, and immediately refuted Liu Lin's first point, which is indeed ...... Makes sense.
The faces of the students present showed surprise.
Liu Lin's complexion changed slightly, and Su Ziqi's face froze, her eyes widened, and she couldn't believe that Xiao Han could say such a powerful rebuttal.
Zhao Xining blinked his apricot eyes, and his pretty face was full of surprise.
Professor Liu was also indescribably shocked, he didn't even drink the tea, staring at Xiao Han with blazing eyes, looking forward to Xiao Han's next words.
The corners of Xiao Han's mouth outlined a smile, and then said: "Now let's talk about your second doubt, in ancient wars, it seems that they like to move their mouths before the war, if it is a siege, it is natural that one side is on the next side, and there is a way that a gentleman does not move his mouth, but there are people who do not follow the rules, and those who speak well will suddenly come with an arrow, and the beautiful name is that the soldiers are not tired of cheating."
But don't forget, the object you are talking to is Zhuge Liang, is that the person you want to shoot down? Besides, if it is really so easy to shoot to death, who would dare to stand on the city wall and speak, if I were Zhuge Liang, I would definitely take this factor into account and take preventive measures before using the empty city plan, all in all, it is impossible for Sima Yi to hurt Zhuge Liang with such a small trick as releasing cold arrows. ”
Refute a little more?
It's too fierce.
Everyone thought that what Liu Lin said was reasonable enough, but now it seems that what Xiao Han said is even more reasonable and convincing.
Liu Lin's face was a little ugly.
Xiao Han was not in a hurry, and continued: "There is also your third point, besieging but not attacking, first of all, the disparity in strength between the two sides, this is known to onlookers, Sima Yi as a party does not know, secondly, what if Zhuge Liang really has an ambush, what if there is an internal and external attack."
In addition, Zhuge Liang is good at formations and inventions, if he uses complex terrain to attack water or fire, you should not know the truth that the army is defeated like a mountain, once frustrated, the whole army panicked, ran around, what is the use of more soldiers. If you are Sima Yi, then do you want to stabilize your whole body and retreat or do you gamble on him, huh?"
In the last sentence, the sword pointed directly at Liu Lin.
The whole classroom was quiet again, Xiao Han's rebuttal was too strong, and Liu Lin's three questions were arranged clearly.
Liu Lin frowned, biting her lip and staring at him, her face was blue for a while, and she couldn't find any words to respond for a while.