"When violence becomes a habit, when beatings become a habit, I admit that I have always been under a thick shadow psychologically, which makes me depressed, irritable, lose my happiness, and always want to get rid of it. Because of the estrangement, the relationship between mother and son seems to have become harmonious, but the scars of the past are too thick, and there is always an insurmountable gap between us. I used my excellent performance in school to exchange escape for a quiet life, but she never stopped interfering, and even forced me to get engaged to a disabled girl I didn't know. After being refused, my face was swollen, and I tried to awaken her conscious consciousness by not fighting back, but to no avail. In my eyes, she has turned into a devil and cannot be avoided. Shu Chenglong said, showing a sad look and a long sigh.

After waiting for half a minute, Shu Chenglong didn't continue, and Fang Chaoyang asked, "Defendant, are you finished?"

"There is another sentence, she beat me violently, I already feel like I am about to die, and it is out of desperation that I resist excessively. "Shu Chenglong said.

"You can't prove that the victim violently attacked you. Yuan Dan couldn't help but say.

"You can't prove that I wasn't violently attacked. On the corner of Jackie Chan's mouth, a sneer hung up.

This is the most concentrated focus of this case, at the time of the crime, whether Shu Chenglong was slapped continuously by Jiang Chunhua at that time, but there is one point, just because of the slap, strangled his mother, and it must not be called excessive defense.

The process from the time the victim is choked to the time of death, which lasts several minutes, and the defendant should be able to judge that the victim has lost the ability to resist and stop.

"Now, the advocate can express his or her defense. Fang Chaoyang said.

Yan Ze straightened his hair, slowly stood up, and said: "Honorable presiding judge and jurors, this case involving the defendant is indeed deeply regrettable and sad, a mother died tragically at the hands of her son, which is unacceptable to the world. The examples we have seen are of sons who pay the price for their mothers. Originally, I didn't want to accept this lawsuit, but as a lawyer, I knew that I couldn't be emotional, so I came anyway. ”

Yan Ze's opening remarks were selfish, serving as a defense lawyer for Shu Chenglong was unacceptable in the eyes of the public, and the voice of scolding him had already appeared on the Internet, what to defend the beast, to exonerate the murderer, and so on.

He must first make his position clear that he does not think that Shu Chenglong's killing of his mother is correct, and his defense is only to protect the rights of the defendant.

"I have the following doubts about this case. First, as the defendant said, he has been subjected to domestic violence since he was a child, and there is a huge psychological shadow that affects his adult personality, which should be appropriately understood; second, if the victim Jiang Chunhua injured important nerve parts when she slapped the defendant in the face, it also caused the victim's personality to change and become unable to control himself, go to extremes, and have excessive defense. Third, the victim's Jiang Chunhua's style problem will also lead to the defendant's psychological deformity, which is also a factor that cannot be ignored. In short, it is hoped that the court will pay attention to the inducement behind the defendant's mother murder and give leniency. Yan Ze talked eloquently, the second of which is what he thinks is the most effective evidence for debate.

"Don't talk nonsense, there's nothing wrong with my mother's style. Shu Chenglong denied it again with a cold face.

Yan Ze spread his hands, said that he had finished speaking, and sat down helplessly, he couldn't figure it out, after Shu Chenglong killed his mother, he had no intention of repenting, and always emphasized the childhood damage caused to him by his mother. However, on the issue of mother's style, he has repeatedly protected him, why in the end?

"The prosecutor may respond to the defender's arguments. Fang Chaoyang said.

"The prosecution believes that the defender's extreme arguments are untenable. Yuan Dan immediately retorted.

In court, this is not unusual, and sometimes the arguments between the prosecution and the debate are so intense that neither one will back down.

Several trial judges are trying to clear up more clues from the debate, and analyze while listening to what content is true and effective, and has reference value in sentencing.

Yuan Dan also stood up and continued: "First of all, the defendant's psychological shadow problem cannot be an excuse for him to kill someone, although there is a conflict between mother and son, but the victim Jiang Chunhua never had the idea of hurting his son. Another very important point is that according to the prosecution's understanding, after the defendant reached the age of 14, the victim Jiang Chunhua did not beat him again, and even treated this son very well, and many people said that Jiang Chunhua was proud of his son. ”

At this moment, Shu Chenglong was in a fugue, as if he was reminiscing about the past, and he did not refute this, but the expression on his face was cloudy and uncertain.

"Secondly, the slap injured important nerves, which is only the defender's inference. The victim did not use extreme methods to threaten the defendant's personal safety, therefore, there was no excessive defense, and the defendant continued to choke the victim's neck, and after he was unable to resist, he still did not give up halfway, which directly led to his death of suffocation, which is intentional homicide. ”

This theory is tenable, and some people in the audience can't help but nod, on the whole, Shu Chenglong's murderous behavior is very obvious, and there is no excuse.

"With regard to the third point raised by the defender, the prosecution believes that it is completely far-fetched and irrelevant. The problem of a mother's style may cause the child to be disliked, but in a society governed by the rule of law, this is an individual right, and the mother cannot be killed because of this. Yuan Dan finally said.

At this moment, a choked voice came from the auditorium, "Why are you so ruthless, can't you let Xiaolong go?"

It was Shu Chenglong's father who spoke, at this moment, he was already in tears, although he was not highly educated, but he could also hear that the prosecution was very tight about his son's crime and refused to stop.

"No, murder is a felony, and the law does not tolerate mercy. Yuan Dan replied.

"Alas, that woman, not honest!" Shu Jackie Chan's father wiped his tears.

"Silence, no speakers from the auditorium. Fang Chaoyang knocked on the gavel, he could understand the mood of this simple farmer, but this was a courtroom, not a place to interject casually.

Shu Chenglong's father lowered his head, and Shu Chenglong also looked back at his father, tears appeared in his eyes for the first time, and he said four words, "Dad, I'm sorry." ”

killed his mother, had no remorse, but felt sorry for his father, what kind of mentality Shu Chenglong had, it was unpredictable.

"Defendant, do you have any new opinions to talk about?" Fang Chaoyang asked.

"It's not easy for my dad, he blocked I don't know how many slaps he gave me when he was a child, and he was powerless to resist in the face of such a vicious woman. I remember one time, my father did something with my mother in order to protect me, but when I fell asleep at night, my mother slashed me in the arm, and the blood stained the sheets red......"

"Defendant, there is no need to say these things that are not related to the facts of the case. Fang Chaoyang stopped.

"Presiding judge, let me say again, do you think that I look like my father? No, I look like my mother, alas, in fact, I have known for a long time that everything is not what it seems. Shu Chenglong sighed.