Netizens praised the prosecutor Sun Xiaoli, and cursed Tan Aijing even more, like waves of the tide. Many have even called for an eight-year sentence that is too low and should be punishable by life or death.

There is a judge living in everyone's heart, but the standard for measuring crime is not law, but morality.

Through the bailiff, Tan Aijing presented two new pieces of evidence, a video and a diagnostic certificate. The video is Xiaomei's birthday, considering the protection of minors, Fang Chaoyang requested that the live broadcast camera should not be facing the big screen, and the volume should be lowered.

"Xiaomei, blow out the candles, sing the birthday song, and wish you a happy birthday......"

A cute little girl appeared on the video, with short ear-length hair, wearing a birthday hat, and in front of her, there was an eight-inch fruit cake with seven candles on it, which was taken by Tan Aijing last year.

It seems to be a harmonious and beautiful scene, but it is not difficult to see that Xiaomei looks very nervous, there is no smile on her little face, her body is slightly stiff, the candle is blown out several times, and the birthday song is also out of tune.

Tan Aijing appeared in the camera last, she hugged Xiaomei affectionately, pretending to be a mother and daughter.

Xiaomei leaned and subconsciously made a dodge move.

Another diagnosis certificate, from Uncle Tan Aijing, was diagnosed with mental illness by the Fourth People's Hospital.

The prosecutor also submitted new evidence, a copy from Xiaomei's second-grade teacher, in black and white, proving that Xiaomei's body often had bruises and purple scars, as well as several photos. The other is from Xiaomei herself, saying that she is often beaten, and her meals are limited to five minutes, and some words are not written well by children, so they are replaced by pinyin.

The court investigation phase is over, and the court argument phase begins.

"Before arguing, the court draws the attention of the prosecution and the defense to the fact that the debate should focus primarily on the determination of the charges, sentencing, and other controversial issues. First, the appellant Tan Aijing spoke. Fang Chaoyang said.

"Presiding judge and jurors, I feel wronged, very wronged! May I ask all of you here, which parent does not beat and scold the child, and it is not for the sake of the child's good, why can't the stepmother? Xiaomei has been with me for two years, and I have been very kind to her, but this child is very tough, and I have never called out to my mother, and I have suffered so much pressure in my heart that I can only cry secretly at night. The testimony of the teacher and Xiaomei is not true, and I have never abused her. ”

"The Inspector has the floor. Fang Chaoyang said.

"The appellant, Tam Ai-ching, is clearly a strong argument, and the corporal punishment of children in the general sense of parents is completely different from abuse, the former is very light and will not cause physical harm, while the latter is a long-term and purposeful act. Of course, even biological parents cannot abuse their own children. Sun Xiaoli said.

"I just hit it twice, and I didn't get hurt!" Tan Aijing almost roared, already out of proportion.

"It's been half a year, the child hasn't been discharged from the hospital, and he even writes with a pen tied to his hands, and this testimony has been written for seven days, isn't it called harm?" Sun Xiaoli asked.

"What kind of testimony will she write as a child, this is what someone else wrote for her to copy!" Tan Aijing's eyes purred and quibbled.

"We have a certificate from a medical professional. ”

"My uncle is mentally ill, I have a family inheritance, and he is often in a trance and impulsive. I ask the court for permission to conduct a psychiatric evaluation of myself. ”

"Reject the request!" Fang Chaoyang said.

"Why?"

"You speak in a coherent manner, without any signs of mental abnormality. ”

"It's short intermittent. ”

"Appellant Tan Aijing, this court reminds you not to use mental illness as a talisman. Even if you are, in sentencing, you will be in the state you were in at the time of the crime. Fang Chaoyang said.

"I can see it, you are all in a gang! Didn't the common people all say it, big caps, two ends up, after eating the plaintiff and the defendant! You are just afraid that netizens will smash the court and take me, a poor man, to open the knife!" Tan Aijing waved her arms and shouted.

"Appellant Tan Aijing, this court reminds you to pay attention to your words, obstruction of litigation, slander and contempt of court, which is also unlawful. Fang Chaoyang said coldly.

Tan Aijing opened her mouth, but lowered her head and remained silent.

"The presiding judge, discussing the crime of ill-treatment here seems to be a deviation from the first-instance verdict in this case. Gao Yiwei whispered.

"I know that this is a live broadcast, and it is also good to take this opportunity to give the public a legal popularization. ”

"I didn't think of that. Gao Yiwei admired.

"Appellant Tan Aijing, please make a final statement. Fang Chaoyang said downward.

"The sentence was too severe, I didn't beat her to death, she was disobedient at the time, and she was seven or eight years old! I was too impulsive, I didn't think about the consequences, if it was less than three years, I could still accept it. Tan Aijing said.

"Does the prosecutor have anything to add?"

"No, hopefully the court will dismiss the appeal. ”

"The court is now adjourned pending the verdict. Fang Chaoyang slammed down the gavel.

Ten minutes later, Fang Chaoyang, Gao Yiwei, and Mu Fan went back to the courtroom, and after knocking down the gavel again, Fang Chaoyang said loudly: "All stand up!"

Everyone stood up, and Fang Chaoyang announced the verdict: "This court believes that the first-instance sentencing is accurate, the crime of intentional injury is established, rejects Tan Aijing's appeal, and upholds the original judgment, this is the final judgment, and no further appeal shall be allowed." ”

"No!" Tan Aijing was completely paralyzed, and then was helped out of the courtroom by the bailiff.

"Before the court closes, I still have something to say, which has nothing to do with this case. I implore every parent to protect their children, not to make all kinds of excuses, and not to wait for misfortune to happen before they know that they regret it. ”

Closed!

Fang Chaoyang and the three of them left the courtroom, and at this time, it was already twelve o'clock at noon, and they hurried to the canteen to eat.

"Dean Chaoyang, I don't understand, Tan Aijing beat the child so hard, how can she not see the slightest remorse?" Gao Yiwei asked while pulling the food into his mouth.

Looking at the problem from a different angle, she can hear that she feels that she is raising children for others, and there is no merit and hard work, and she is also a stomach of grievances. Fang Chaoyang said.

"Actually, in my opinion, eight years in prison is still too light. Don't talk about a child, even a kitten or a puppy, you can't hurt it at will!" Mu Fan said.

"Wait until stricter laws are introduced to protect children and adolescents from harm. Fang Chaoyang said.

"Sun Xiaoli is also very powerful, and she dug out Tan Aijing's criminal motives. Gao Yiwei said.

"She wants her own children, so no matter how she looks at it, she feels awkward. Therefore, when I marry a wife, I should marry a virtuous wife, and my daughter-in-law will have a good temper and never beat and scold her children. Mu Fan had the tone of a passer-by.

"Because it's not a stepmother. Gao Yiwei said with a smile.

At this time, the clerk Xiao Zhao also ran over with a dinner plate, holding a mobile phone in one hand, and said with a smile: "Head, your popularity is soaring now, and everyone praises you, especially the last paragraph, which is too touching." ”

"I don't need to be famous, those words come from the heart. Fang Chaoyang said with a smile.

"Oh, the million-signature signature in Qiu Dali's case has moved again, and many of the signatories have left messages in the comments, demanding that the case be tried as soon as possible. Xiao Zhao said.

"They're really impatient. Fang Chaoyang shook his head and said.

"The nature of Qiu Dali's case is far more serious than Tan Aijing. Mu Fan had something to say, and he also advocated sentencing Qiu Dali to death.