Chapter 182 - Presentation of Evidence and Cross-examination
After a little hesitation, Fang Chaoyang said frankly: "When I was a child, I also belonged to the timid group, and it happened that a big brother appeared and saved me, but he was injured because of it. ”
"He's such a nice guy, what's his name?"
Good?
He is the direct murderer of Miao Yi, his methods are cruel and cold-blooded, it is not a pity to die, Fang Chaoyang took a deep breath, waved his hand and said: "There are too many things that time can change, don't mention it." ”
"Judicial officer, to tell you the truth, from a personal point of view, I tend to sympathize with the defendant Yan Qi. ”
"Simple righteousness cannot be the standard, otherwise the world will be in chaos. In this respect, the law is ruthless, as it is the only standard for adjudication and enforcement. In the past trials, there were also lawyers who brought out the stories of keeping people under the knife in ancient times, and wanted to play the emotional card, but in fact, it would not work. Fang Chaoyang said.
"Excessive doting can indeed ruin a child. Mu Qing sighed with emotion.
"Parents are the first tutors of their children, and it is true that they should be guided correctly, but it is also not advisable to say that filial piety is produced under the stick, and to respect the independent personality of children, educators must work harder. Fang Chaoyang said.
Mu Qing didn't come for an interview, just to talk, the two were very relaxed and exchanged a lot, and the atmosphere was very pleasant.
Fang Chaoyang reminded Mu Qing that in publishing this kind of news, it is best to uphold an impartial and impartial attitude, and not to mix too many personal feelings in it, because the media has no power to make a judgment.
Mu Qing kept nodding, she also learned a lot from Fang Chaoyang, being a reporter is just blindly pursuing eyeballs, and in the end she can only become a third-rate reporter.
When the time came, the two ended their conversation, and Fang Chaoyang stepped onto the courtroom again and sat at the back of the judge's seat.
As the trial continued, Yan was brought back in, and his mental state did not appear to be as good as it had been in the morning, because he did not feel any sympathy from the judge.
In the courtroom, the effect of playing the sympathy card is not great, and taking the law as the criterion is the duty that every judge must adhere to, and the moral level has little impact.
"Let's present evidence in court and cross-examine the evidence. First, the prosecutor presents evidence to the court on the facts alleged in the indictment. Fang Chaoyang said.
At the public prosecution's seat, Li Chunlei got up and first presented a set of evidence, which was related to Yan Mengwei, and asked the court to organize cross-examination.
The bailiff took this set of documentary evidence, first showed it to the defender, the defender said that he had no objection, and then handed it over to the court, and the jurors Gao Yiwei and Mu Fan also read it, nodded and said that there was no objection, and then handed it over to the presiding judge official Chaoyang.
This set of evidence is mainly used to prove the fact of Yan Mengwei's murder, including the murder weapon involved in the case, the statements of the victim's family, the testimony of bystanders, and the relevant documents provided by the forensic doctor.
did not let Yan Qi check and sign or raise objections, but there was Yan Mengwei's signature on it, because the process of killing had nothing to do with Yan Qi.
Next, Li Chunlei presented another set of evidence, but it was related to Yan Qi.
These are the three professional books that the police searched in Yan Qi's home, "Anatomy of Birds", "Anatomy of Animals" and "Human Anatomy", in which the key pages are marked with red wavy lines, and the major arteries in the neck and legs can quickly cause excessive blood loss and death.
Among them, on "Human Anatomy", the part of the human neck artery is not only marked, but also has a word on it, kill, with three exclamation marks attached.
In addition, there are also purchase receipts and videos from Xinhua Bookstore, etc., which prove that these books were purchased by Yan Qi.
There is also a handwriting certificate, by extracting the font that Yan Qi used to write lesson plans, and after analysis, it is proved that the word "kill" was not written by Yan Mengwei, but came from Yan Qi.
"Ask the bailiff on duty to give the documentary evidence to the victim for inspection. Fang Chaoyang said.
Yan Qi's face was very gloomy, he looked at it carefully, and then handed it to the defender, and after Tian Yunsu read it, he was presented to the judge.
This time, Fang Chaoyang and the other three looked at it very seriously, and returned it to the prosecutor after a while.
"Defendant Yan Qi, have you seen clearly?" Fang Chaoyang asked.
"See clearly!"
"Any objections?"
"Yes!"
"If there is any objection, speak out. Fang Chaoyang said.
"I bought the book, but Xiaowei asked for it, because he didn't want to go out and meet people. The inspector has clearly marked it, not my own subjective will, and in addition, I did not write the killing word, and I have never touched these books after I bought them. Yan Qi said.
The prosecutor explained. Fang Chaoyang said.
"This is an authoritative handwriting certification, there will be no mistakes, you said that you didn't write, it doesn't mean that you didn't write, in addition, according to Yan Mengwei's confession, those key contents are what you marked. Li Chunlei said.
"The child's words are not credible, and this is recognized by the law, right? Also, I am the father he has always respected, and subtly, he may also imitate my handwriting. Yan Qi argued.
"We didn't find that Yan Mengwei was imitating your handwriting, and his handwriting was easily recognizable. ”
"I didn't write it! Why do you have to frame me? This is a crime that is intended to be added, what can one word say?" Yan Qi's green tendons on his neck were exposed, but his body movements were a little flustered.
"It's a hint that if you want to kill someone, start with the arteries in your neck. Li Chunlei said.
"Does the defender have any objections?" Fang Chaoyang asked.
"Yes!"
"Please comment. ”
"Presiding judge, I think it is too far-fetched to conclude that it is Yan Qi's handwriting based on just one word. This handwriting appraisal report is signed by only one industry expert, and its credibility is insufficient. Also, even if it is written by Yan Qi, he may have done it casually, in fact, many people have experienced this. Tian Yunsu said.
"The presiding judge, the prosecution requested, that an important witness be summoned to testify in court. Li Chunlei said.
Hearing this name, Yan Qi's whole body couldn't help shaking, and he subconsciously rubbed his nose vigorously to stabilize his emotions.
"Allowed, what's the name of the witness?" Fang Chaoyang asked.
"Ye Yu. ”
The witness Ye Yu arrived in court. Fang Chaoyang said.
The witness was not in the audience, the bailiff went out and brought it up, this girl about 20 years old, not tall, slender, melon seed face, small eyes, showing inner doubles, nose and mouth are very small, but the overall combination of facial features is just right, there is a slightly melancholy temperament beauty.
The girl was apparently coming to the courtroom for the first time, and was very reserved, standing behind the witness stand, bowing her head and rubbing her hands incessantly.
"Please sit down!" Fang Chaoyang said.
The girl sat down cautiously, turned her head to look at Yan Qi, and looked a little flustered, which shows that the prosecution has done a lot of work behind her back to allow her to testify in court.
"Please tell us your name, age and occupation. Fang Chaoyang said.
"My name is Ye Yu, I am 22 years old and I am a junior in college. "The girl's voice was so small that if she didn't have a microphone, she couldn't hear it clearly.