"There was no beating, but the scolding was very ugly, and he threatened to cut his sister's face with a knife if he didn't pay back the money. Ba Zhiman said.

"Appellant, how did you get the fruit knife?" Tian Yunsu asked again.

The two of them held down their sister, and the other moved their hands, and they put down the fruit knife casually, so close to me that they could reach it. ”

"Why don't they guard against you?"

"They may think that I am a coward, a bastard, and dare not do anything at all. Ba Zhiman said.

"Did the three of them say anything to you when they violated your sister?" asked Tian Yunsu.

"Objection, the defense is guiding the appellant!" Sun Xiaoli raised her hand.

The objection was invalid and the appellant answered the question. Fang Chaoyang said.

They said......" Ba Zhiman hesitated.

"Say what?"

"They said, when they're happy enough, let my sister and I show them that kind of thing!

There was a commotion in the auditorium, and everyone's faces were full of anger, which was terrifying, if what Ba Zhiman said was true, then these bastards really deserved to go to hell.

"Did this sentence stimulate you?" Tian Yunsu asked.

"Yes, in addition, they also viciously threatened to turn me into a eunuch and cut off our Ba family! I think they are extremely vicious and can do it!"

"Presiding Judge, after my questioning, I would like to say one more thing, in this case, if there is no effective resistance, it is really impossible to imagine what kind of outcome this pair of siblings will face. Tian Yunsu said.

Seeing that the time was not too early, Fang Chaoyang met with the two jurors to discuss, and announced that the trial would end in the morning and that the trial would continue in the afternoon.

The appellant, Ba Zhiman, was taken down, his body still shaking, and his anger still did not subside.

The trial is not over yet, but the news about the case has been noisy, and it can be seen everywhere on the Internet, and it has a certain tendencies.

Ba Zhiman's sister and brother are pitiful, and the money lenders and debt collectors are demons, and they call for the early elimination of this ugly phenomenon.

Especially Ba Zhiman's last words, after they were put on the Internet, they caused an uproar, and netizens cursed that the debt collector was a beast, and pigs and dogs were not as good, and they actually wanted to force their sisters and brothers' close relatives to do that kind of thing.

Fang Chaoyang sat in his office, flipped through a few such news, and felt that some of them were mishandled, and such a case should not be tried in public.

At this moment, the phone on the desk rang, it was an unfamiliar mobile phone number.

"Hello, who is it?" Fang Chaoyang picked up the phone and asked.

"Is it the Municipal Courtyard?" said a man's voice from inside.

"Yes!"

"Are you Judge Fang Chaoyang?"

"It's me, is there anything wrong?" Fang Chaoyang asked.

"Alas, I don't know, should I help a group of Ba Zhiman sisters and brothers?" the man sighed.

"I don't understand, what do you mean by gang?"

"I have a not-so-good hobby, that is, I like to look around with a telescope, and just that day, I saw three men in the window on the 6th floor opposite, controlling a pair of siblings. The man said.

"It's Sister and Brother Ba Zhiman, right?" Fang Chaoyang said sensitively.

"It should be!" the man hesitated.

"If so, you can appear in court as a witness. Fang Chaoyang said.

"I was exempted from going to court, I was birdwatching, and I also took a video. ”

"You've also made videos about other people's privacy, right?"

"No, really not!" the man was a little flustered, and then said that he had missed it, "This video of their sister and brother has not been deleted." ”

"This is a very important piece of evidence. ”

"However, I was afraid that after providing it, I would be arrested, but I felt very bad in my heart, and I always felt sorry for the two siblings. The man said.

"Has it spread?" Fang Chaoyang asked.

"How can it spread!"

"Well, if you behave like this, you will be punished by the police at most, and you will not go to jail, and if you behave well, you may be exempted. Fang Chaoyang said.

"Great, I'll give you the video right away, I know, you're a decent judge. The man finally breathed a sigh of relief.

"Don't give it to me, contact Ba Zhiman's lawyer, Lawyer Tian, and I'll give you her mobile phone number. Fang Chaoyang said.

"You say!"

Fang Chaoyang held the phone in one hand and found the phone book from the drawer with the other, flipped to Tian Yunsu's phone, and then told the man on the other end of the phone.

The man made a note of it, said thank you, and hung up.

When the trial was about to start in the afternoon, Fang Chaoyang received a call from Tian Yunsu, she said excitedly that she had obtained this evidence, and the shooting was very clear, judging from the scene at that time, Ba Zhiman did not lie.

"Okay, let's show it in court!" Fang Chaoyang said.

"Judicial officer, I am confident that I can win this case. Tian Yunsu said.

"As long as I can demonstrate righteousness, I will support it. ”

At half past one in the afternoon, Fang Chaoyang and the other three came to the court again, and then, Ba Zhiman was brought up again, but his expression was quite frustrated.

The prosecutor's question in the morning had put him in a passive situation, and then Tian Yunsu's question was very skillful, but it still couldn't change anything.

"Now let's present and cross-examine the evidence in court, does the prosecution have any new evidence?" Fang Chaoyang asked.

"No!" Sun Xiaoli said.

"Does the defense have new evidence?"

"Yes!" Tian Yunsu raised his hand and said.

"New evidence can be presented to the court. Fang Chaoyang agreed.

Tian Yunsu took out a USB flash drive, which was handed over to the judge's seat by the bailiff, and said at the same time: "This new evidence is designed to be private, and I hope that the collegial panel will not play it publicly." ”

"Allow!" Fang Chaoyang agreed.

The bailiff sent a laptop, and after plugging in the USB flash drive, there was indeed a video file inside, Fang Chaoyang clicked on the file, and a silent video began to play.

Gao Yiwei and Xu Wei also came to see, the picture was a half-drawn curtain, but as the camera zoomed in, the angle of the shooting happened to take pictures of everything in the house, and even the appearance of the people was very clear.

In the first two hours, it was all some gestures of comparison and stroke, which could only be fast-forwarded, with Ba Zhiman being beaten on the sofa cushion in the middle, and the final shot, Ba Chuxia was surrounded by three men, his shirt was completely missing, and his jeans were also pulled up to his knees.

"Inspector take a look at it too!" Fang Chaoyang said.

The bailiff held the laptop to the two prosecutors, who skimmed it quickly and nodded toward the judge's box.

The USB flash drive was returned to Tian Yunsu, and Fang Chaoyang knocked down the gavel and announced: "Due to the emergence of important new evidence in this case, this court announces that it will be remanded to the district court for retrial, and I also hope that the police and the prosecution can conduct further investigation into this case." ”