Chapter 198: No Suspicion of Guilt
"There are fast and slow walks, sometimes it takes an hour, sometimes it takes 30 minutes, and as for the mileage, I am not engaged in geographical planning, nor have I measured it with a ruler, how can I know. Shang Zaijun shrugged his shoulders and continued to quibble, looking very aggrieved.
"You should know that you pass through the fields in the middle!"
"Obviously, everyone likes to grow wheat, and the wind blows the wheat waves, which looks very pleasant. ”
Shang Zaijun avoided the cornfield in words, still wanting to clear up, and the case had nothing to do with him. Yuan Dan had been prepared for this for a long time, and reminded: "Shang Zaijun, according to the survey, 20 years ago, most of the farmers in Fuyu Village planted corn that was resistant to drought and flooding, and the yield was No. 3. ”
"I don't farm, I don't know about corn varieties, and after so many years, who can remember it so clearly. "Shang Zaijun said.
"Just now you also said that you clearly remember that the fields you passed by were planted with wheat, and the wind blew the wheat waves, why is it not clear now?" Yuan Dan took advantage of the situation to continue to ask.
"Objections, the prosecution uses a provocative questioning method. Chi Weiran raised his hand again.
"The objection is valid, the prosecutor, try to ask questions about what is relevant to the facts of the case. Fang Chaoyang said.
"Defendant Shang Zaijun, who are you with from 8 to 10 p.m. on June 25 20 years ago?" asked Yuan Dan.
"I don't remember exactly, but at that time I was usually at home, sitting around the table with my wife and talking about the past. ”
Shang Zaijun made a favorable argument that his wife had been dead for many years and could not be investigated, let alone collected.
"Yang Yunhe, do you know you?" asked Yuan Dan again.
"Acquaintance, living neighbors. ”
"According to the certificate he provided, he went to your house that night, and only your wife and daughter were at home. Yuan Dan said.
"He lies, who doesn't know, he doesn't talk the door, like a, chewing his tongue. Also, after so much time, how could he remember that it happened yesterday, there was something wrong with this person's quality!" Shang Zaijun actually showed some anger, obviously, he didn't know about this situation.
"It was because of your daughter's condition, he was so impressed, he stayed at your house for twenty minutes and offered a folk remedy for mumps. Yuan Dan said.
"Believe him, my daughter is already dead!"
"Your wife knows you don't believe it, and she doesn't tell you about it. ”
"Objections, the prosecution should not use inferential words to mislead the court. Chi Weiran raised his hand again.
The objection was invalid, and the prosecution continued to question. Fang Chaoyang said with annoyance.
The trial seems to have entered the debate link in advance, because Shang Zaijun repeatedly quibbled and confused the public, in Fang Chaoyang's view, he did all this in vain, the police and the prosecution did not rush the case this time, and collected a lot of evidence.
"Defendant Shang Zaijun, according to the forensic examination, the time when Wu Lanfang was killed was at 9:10 that night, and at that time, Yang Yunhe was at your house, and you couldn't show an alibi at all. Yuan Dan said.
"Objection, a very important article in law, there is no doubt about the guilt, and the prosecution has violated this basic principle. Chi Weiran raised his hand again.
"Your argument is untenable at all, whether you have sufficient time to commit the crime is a very important link in the investigation and handling of the case. Yuan Dan did not back down.
"Even if there is a time to commit the crime, it cannot be proved that there was participation in the case, and a conviction requires sufficient evidence, not arbitrary inference. Chi didn't say yet.
"This is not an arbitrary inference, the defendant has a strong motive to kill, sufficient conditions to commit the crime, and a confession that can form a complete chain of evidence. Yuan Dan said.
"Lei Fumin also had a confession back then, but was he not overturned in the end?" Chi Weiran's tone was aggressive.
Fang Chaoyang slammed down the gavel, stopped the debate, and said: "Don't say it, you will leave enough time for the debate, and the collegial panel will screen it by itself." ”
Yuan Dan and Chi Weiran both sat down angrily, and after half a minute, Yuan Dan remembered that there was still a procedure to complete, and got up again and said, "Presiding judge, the prosecution has finished questioning." ”
"Please sit down, does the defense still have anything to ask the defendant?" Fang Chaoyang turned his head and asked.
"Yes!" Yao Wuyan said.
"Ask!"
"Reporter, when did you hear the news of Wu Lanfang's killing?" asked Yao Wuyan.
"Objections, the defence's questioning was improper, and the defendant could not be left out of the matter. Yuan Dan immediately expressed strong dissatisfaction.
"The objection is valid, and the defence cannot use this method of questioning. Fang Chaoyang said.
"The presiding judge, before the conclusion of the trial, cannot subjectively convict the defendant. Yao Wuyan has a heartbeat.
"The defense should note that the defendant is standing here, which is the identity of the suspect, and do not position him as a third party unrelated to the case. Fang Chaoyang said dissatisfied, Yao Wuyan was clearly arguing with strong words.
In court, the presiding judge must obey the words, this is the rule, otherwise he will be expelled from the courtroom. Yao Wuyan took a deep breath, suppressed her emotions, and continued to ask: "Defendant, please recall carefully, did you have any direct contact with Wu Lanfang?"
"Nope!"
"Do you know her?"
"I can't talk about acquaintance, I met her on the road, she is a good girl, she is very beautiful, she is quiet, her father is a good person, and he used to help take care of my mother, and occasionally send some vegetables. Shang Zaijun kept his voice calm, as if he was telling someone else's story.
"So, the relationship between the two of you is not bad?" Yao Wuyan continued.
"I am grateful to him for helping to take care of my mother, and after Wu Lanfang was killed, I also donated money to his second daughter so that she could go to college. ”
"Defendant, what kind of donation method did you use?"
"Anonymous, the charity has a list of people who need to donate every year, I saw Wu Lanhua's name, so I designated the money to donate to her, it is not easy, her father is a disabled person, and her sister was killed, and she has not been compensated. Shang Zaijun had a compassionate and compassionate tone.
"It's hard to imagine that a kind-hearted person who donates money to education can be associated with a tragic murder. Yao Wuyan seemed to sigh with emotion.
"Objection, donating money to school has nothing to do with the murder, and the defense cannot clear the defendant's name in this way. Yuan Dan raised his hand sensitively.
"I'm just stating one such thing. Yao Wuyan's neck was stretched, and he was very unhappy to be repeatedly robbed of white and opposed.
"The objection is valid, and the defense should not ask about what is not relevant to the case. Fang Chaoyang said with a cold face.
Yao Wuyan stomped his feet, sat down, and Chi Weiran raised his hand and said, "Presiding judge, I have a question I want to ask the defendant." ”
"Allowed. ”
"Defendant, please recall carefully, where were you on June 25?" Chi Weiran asked directly.