Chapter 380: Mutual Evidence

"Defendant, when you were a child, what extreme beatings did your mother do to you?" Yan Ze continued to ask.

"It's too much, I can't remember it anymore, my dad knew, she tied me up and beat me, and once, almost stuffed me into a water tank and drowned. "Shu Chenglong said.

"Did the victim kick you in an important part while you choked the victim's neck?"

"No, no!" Shu Chenglong hesitated.

"Presiding judge, the defense has finished asking questions!" Yan Ze said.

The prosecution has additional questions. Yuan Dan raised his hand.

"Allow!" Fang Chaoyang agreed.

"Where did you leave the kitchen knife used to dissect the corpse?" asked Yuan Dan.

"Thrown underneath the Tomie Bridge. "Shu Chenglong said.

"In this way, you passed the Tomie Bridge on foot, but you have once explained that you fled in a bus at that time, how can this be explained?"

"I sat by the window, opened the window, and threw it down as the car was moving. "Shu Chenglong said.

"You have so much strength, did the people in the same car raise any objections?"

"Nope!"

"Presiding Judge, the prosecution's interrogation is over!" said Yuan Dan.

Regarding the whereabouts of the murder weapon, there is an explanation in the file, and it is the same as what Shu Chenglong said. This is suspicious, the police test, it is indeed possible to throw a kitchen knife under the bridge from the car, but it requires a certain amount of strength and coincidence, a slight deviation, it may be blocked by the guardrail on the bridge and fall on the bridge deck.

And the bus that Shu Chenglong was riding in was a very old model, and the windows could indeed be opened.

Shu Chenglong only has this kind of statement, and he has been interrogated many times, but there is no breakthrough, so it can only be like this.

Jiang Chunhua died of suffocation, in other words, the murder weapon that caused her death was Shu Jackie Chan's hands, and whether the kitchen knife that dismembered the body was found or not would not affect the verdict.

First, the prosecutor presents evidence to the court on the facts alleged in the indictment. Fang Chaoyang said.

Li Chunlei got up and first presented an autopsy report, which detailed the results of the forensic dissection, the victim died of asphyxiation, and just four hours after his death, his legs were cut off.

There is also a set of photographs, focusing on the victim's neck, which obviously has the fingerprints left by the defendant Shu Chenglong.

"Ask the bailiff on duty to give the autopsy report to the defendant to see. Fang Chaoyang said.

The bailiff on duty stepped forward and took the autopsy report to Shu Chenglong, he just glanced at it, then turned his head away, not wanting to look at it again.

"Defendant Shu Chenglong, have you seen clearly?" Fang Chaoyang asked in a cold voice.

"See clearly!"

"Look carefully, don't deal with it. ”

Shu Chenglong showed an extremely helpless look, read the autopsy report hard, and said, "Presiding Judge, I really saw it clearly this time." ”

Then, the autopsy report was passed to Yan Ze, and he looked at it very carefully, indicating that after seeing it clearly, the bailiff handed it over to the judge.

Fang Chaoyang and the three of them also checked separately, the corpse was covered with corpse spots and decomposed, but it was not difficult to see that the deceased had a good appearance and a good body shape before his death, and he was also a woman with charm.

Gao Yiwei and Xu Wei both nodded, indicating that they had no objection to this, and the bailiff returned the report to the public prosecution seat.

"Defendant Shu Chenglong, do you have any objections to the autopsy report presented by the prosecutor?" asked Fang Chaoyang.

"Nope!"

"Does the defender have any objections?" Fang Chaoyang turned his head and asked.

"Yes!" Yan Ze raised his hand and said.

"What are the objections?"

"The defense argues that there were flaws in the autopsy report and that there was no detailed examination of the deceased's organs, such as the deceased's lungs, which had tuberculosis and were not labeled. Yan Ze said.

"The deceased died of airway obstruction and suffocation, regardless of whether he had lung disease or not. Li Chunlei emphasized.

"The defense believes that it is relevant, and relevant evidence will be presented later. Yan Ze did not budge.

The prosecution continued to present evidence. Fang Chaoyang said.

Li Chunlei took out the fingerprint identification report again, which clearly showed that the fingerprints on the victim's neck were consistent with Shu Chenglong's fingerprints.

Shu Chenglong has no opinion on this, he has never denied that he strangled his mother, but repeatedly insisted that he was in a hurry and impulsive at that time.

The prosecution also showed a photograph of a kitchen knife, which was based on Shu Chenglong's confession and traces of the cut on the body, and found a similar kitchen knife, which was not used at the time of the crime.

Shu Chenglong looked at the photo carefully, said that he had no objection, the kitchen knife he used was almost the same as this one, and said that he originally wanted to buy a boning knife, but he didn't buy it in the supermarket.

There is also a very important piece of evidence, that is, Shu Chenglong's confession, after it was presented, he also said that there was no objection, and he did confess it frankly.

After the prosecution presented a set of evidence, Fang Chaoyang said: "The defense, you can present your evidence." ”

Yan Ze first took out a hospital diagnosis certificate ten years ago, for this reason, he also made a lot of efforts, and the diagnosis certificate proved that the victim Jiang Chunhua suffered from tuberculosis, but it has been cured, and there is a shadow in the lungs.

"Now that it's cured, this evidence doesn't have much value. Li Chunlei said.

"The defense believes that the victim suffered from tuberculosis, although it has been cured, it has affected lung function, breathing is not good, and the defendant's pinching and pressing only triggered potential physical hazards. Yan Ze said.

"This is a quibble, the obstruction of the airway, the direct cause of death, and it was directly caused by the defendant. Li Chunlei said.

"I hope the court will consider the opinion of the defense, and in addition, there is a diagnosis here, the defendant Shu Chenglong, who also suffers from lung disease, some signs of tuberculosis, and his mother's infection has also caused damage to his psyche. Yan Ze showed another copy of Shu Chenglong's diagnosis.

"I wasn't sick, it was the school that organized an inspection, there were a lot of people, and the hospital made a mistake. ”

Shu Chenglong denied this and refused to admit the fact of his illness, which made Yan Ze a little embarrassed, and almost wanted to say something disrespectful.

It's just that Yan Ze thought of being punished for being banned from the trial for half a year because of contempt of the court last time, but he still held back.

The prosecution continued to present evidence. Fang Chaoyang said.

Li Chunlei raised a piece of paper in his hand and said: "This is a testimony, from a female classmate that the defendant met on the way to buy a kitchen knife, and the witness was unwilling to testify in court, and asked not to release his name. ”

"I don't remember meeting my classmates. Shu Chenglong denied it again.

"You don't remember, it doesn't mean it didn't happen, the testimony shows that the defendant said hello to the witness, and the conversation was very simple, what to do, what to eat. However, the witness remembered that the defendant's cheeks did not have any redness, swelling or scars, and it did not look like he had just been beaten. Li Chunlei said.