Chapter 353: The Hardest Case (3)
Situ Yan's students asked Situ Yan, and Situ Yan whispered to the students: "Sonny ruled out the possibility of theft from the outside world, Cao Yun can completely put forward the theory of internal investigation, and the police can't determine who is suspected if they don't know the time of theft." But the three insiders who can open the safe are the agent, the personal assistant and Bai Ru herself. These three people have high incomes and are loyal to Bai Ru, and it is impossible for them to steal vases from the point of view. However, the law does not agree with human feelings, and Cao Yun can question it. But ......"
The student added: "This directly offends Bai Ru." ”
Situ Yan: "That's right, plus Sonny didn't read the manuscript and dissected the safe very clearly, which shows that Sonny is really trying his best to handle the case." In this way, Bai Ru will be emotionally biased towards Sonny. It's a shame that this guy isn't a lawyer. Cao Yun is not advancing now, nor is he retreating. Fortunately, the judge was willing to give Cao Yun a little more time. ”
Cao Yun said: "Third defendant, do you mean that the safe was not stolen?"
Sonny added: "Subjectively, we think so, it is extremely difficult to steal this safe, and people of the non-fungal sword butterfly level can't do it. But objectively, we must admit that there is still a very small possibility, and there are still capable people in the rivers and lakes. ”
Cao Yun: "What does the second defendant think about this?"
Who dares to hit me! Who dares to hit the two of us? Aim at Nangong Tengfei.
The big husband can bend and stretch, originally Lao Tzu wanted to kill you, since he couldn't kill you, let's cooperate to kill others.
Wang X egg, Nangong Tengfei scolded his mother in his heart, Cao Yun, you are a famous lawyer with a head and a face, and you suddenly shrank your head to be a wall grass? Are you ashamed? Do you lose a lawyer?
This question is so difficult to answer, if it is admitted that Sonny made a subjective judgment based on objective evidence, then the insurance company is fine, the police are fine, and the only thing left is the white shrimp auction.
Nangong Tengfei: "Here I want to ask Miss Bai a few questions, is it okay?"
Bai Ru nodded: "Yes." ”
Nangong Tengfei asked: "The vase was escorted to the studio by the auction house and put in the safe. Have you ever taken out a vase in the next three months?"
Bai Ru replied, "No." ”
Nangong Tengfei: "In the past three months, has the safe been used often?"
Bai Ru replied: "In addition to storing vases, the safe mainly places some cash and jewelry, some of which are owned by me personally, and the cash is used to reward studio employees. The number of times it should be opened in three months should not be much, between five and seven times, which is about this number. ”
Nangong Tengfei: "That ......"
Cao Yun: "What, do you suspect Miss Bai's personal assistant and agent?"
This dead villain!
That's what Nangong Tengfei meant, but he was ready to point it out very tactfully and make a little foreshadowing. Cao Yun went straight in single-handedly, so that Nangong Tengfei couldn't say it down.
Nangong Tengfei is very entangled now, and he must agree that what Bai Ru said is the truth, so the white shrimp auction will be very dangerous.
Nangong Tengfei: "The vase is worth six million, and six million is a lot of money. How much time does it take for ordinary employees in Miss Bai's studio, in addition to personal assistants and agents, to earn six million?"
Bai Ru was stunned for a moment, and thought for a while to look at the agent who heard the trial.
The judge nodded, and the agent stood up and replied: "The average monthly salary of the studio is 20,000 to 30,000 per person. ”
Nangong Tengfei: "Thank you! If I guessed correctly, the vase should be the most valuable item placed in the safe in recent years, and the possibility of theft by intentional employees cannot be ruled out." As the third defendant has just explained, the theft of the safe requires the theft of the key, and the password and mechanical gear authentication are relatively simple. For example, installing a covert camera will do the trick. ”
Nangong Tengfei looked at everyone, and everyone had no opinion on this. There is a real possibility.
Nangong Tengfei looked at Sonny: "May I ask the agent who is in charge of this case, that is, the lawyer of the third defendant, have you checked all the employees in the studio?"
Cao Yun you, what are you me?Sonny smoked above his head.
'Du Li' star studio is different from the big studio. Some stars in big studios are not only stars themselves, but also the bosses of stars, and the number of people in her studio is larger. Bai Ru belongs to her own studio, and all the staff in the studio are for her alone. These include, assistants, stylists, costume artists, makeup artists, PR teams, drivers, bodyguards, etc. Bai Ru's studio has 25 people.
25 people serve one person, so these people are idle? Of course not. For example, if Bai Ru wants to participate in an outdoor variety show, assistants, stylists, costume artists, makeup artists, drivers and bodyguards must follow. Touching up makeup, changing clothes, and styling after falling into the water all need to be prepared by these professionals in advance.
How to check 25 people? Is there a check?
Sonny's answer is no, there are too many people to check. For example, to check the private accounts of 25 people, the approval of the prosecutor is required, and it is almost impossible for the prosecutor to approve such a large-scale audit, which will seriously violate the privacy of individuals. The police had to find the most suspected of the 25 people so that the prosecutor would allow them to search for their personal accounts, etc.
Nangong Tengfei: "The lawyer of the third defendant said that they treated all the cases very fairly, and I wonder if there are any employees in the investigation studio?"
Sonny: "In recognition of Miss Bairu's charisma, and her ability to work as an agent in charge of the studio, I believe that there will be no criminals working in the studio. "Do you dare to deny it?
Cao Yun: Hey, did you two get the wrong lines?
Nangong Tengfei: "Miss Bai's charm and agent ability are beyond doubt. However, the two of them are so fortunate to work so hard, and there are always times when they are negligent. The police, as an impartial judicial body, did not conduct a survey of the employees of the studio, is this considered a work error?"
Sonny: "We didn't have a comprehensive investigation of the 25 employees, but I have already dismissed the possibility of them committing the crime through a cursory investigation. I'll explain it here, Miss Bai to see if it makes sense. ”
Judge: Grass, Lao Tzu is the arbitrator, you let Bai Ru see a fart.
Sonny: "None of the 25 employees had a criminal record, and none of the employee's immediate family members had a criminal record. Suppose that one of the 25 people has the heart to make a fortune by stealing, then who among the 25 people has the courage and ability? First of all, this person must know how the K137 works, in order to know under what conditions he can open the safe. Secondly, the safe is in the office of the agent and Miss Bai Ru, and it is impossible for ordinary employees to enter the office alone during working hours. ”
Sonny: "The second defendant, lawyer Nangong, said to install a hidden camera, and I want to tell you here that it is impossible. Miss Bai Ru is a household name in the Eastern Tang Dynasty and even in the world......"
Cao Yun squirted out a mouthful of mineral water!
Everyone looks at Cao Yun together, do you have an opinion?
Cao Yun coughed, unable to speak, and forced his throat: "Choking, you continue." "It seems to be holding Bai Ru, but it is actually using Bai Ru as a shield.
Sonny: "There are countless media and paparazzi who want to get the Bairu scoop, the exclusive insider, the exclusive report. If you look at the bodyguards of the two Miss Bai on the court, don't mention it, they are definitely professionals. If I'm not mistaken, the bodyguards will definitely check the bugging equipment frequently. Right?"
After the judge nodded, one of the bodyguards replied: "We will not allow cameras or bugging equipment in the studio, we are one of the best bodyguards in Baoyun and have the best anti-electronic equipment on the market." So it is impossible to install a camera inside the broker's office. "I said this with great confidence.
Sunny said: "Unless the second defendant's lawyer thinks that Miss Bai will open the safe in front of outsiders, how can you explain the password and authentication?"
Bai Ru: "That...... I seem to have opened the safe once or twice in the presence of outsiders. ”
"......" Sonny opened his mouth to look at Bai Ru: Death 38, what do you want? Believe it or not, Lao Tzu slapped you to death on the wall? If you don't speak, you will die?
Nangong Tengfei breathed a sigh of relief: "May I ask if the third lesson has understood these people and investigated them?"
Sonny reluctantly admitted, "No." We are not aware of this. ”
Nangong Tengfei: "Your Excellency, I think this case still needs three lessons for a comprehensive investigation. ”
The judge nodded: "Do the plaintiffs and defendants have any opinions?"
Bai Ru: "I don't think my guests would steal the safe. The office is also where she meets guests, and the people she can receive are people with ID cards. How could these people possibly go and steal the safe?
Cao Yun: "Of course, Miss Bai's guests are either rich or expensive, and six million is just pocket money for them, and we can trust it." ”
Nangong Tengfei: Grass! Why are you giving me a knife if you have nothing to do? Can I say that I can't believe it? It's so easy to throw the responsibility to the police, Cao Yun, what good do you do to trap me?
Cao Yun: If you have a disadvantage, it means that I have a disadvantage.
Sonny immediately said, "It's okay for both defendants to admit that Miss Bai's guests are fine?"
Cao Yun and Nangong Tengfei: "Yes. ”
Judge: "What the hell is ...... case?"
Sonny: "That means the police are agreeing with the conclusions. There were no thefts. Since there is no theft, how can a real vase become a fake?"
Cao Yun mended the knife: "Was the appraiser wrong, or was someone dropped in the middle of the escort?" Should this question be discussed after the police conduct a comprehensive investigation into the white shrimp auction?"
Sonny, Nangong Tengfei: grass mud horse, make up two knives, one person and one knife.
After Sonny's police conclusion was established, Cao Yun took advantage of the situation, and the police went to investigate the auction house. The future lawsuit will have nothing to do with shrimp insurance. As for who of you lives or dies, it's none of my business.
Nangong Tengfei tapped on the keyboard, and the picture appeared on the left and right of the big screen, which was a picture of a vase. Nangong Tengfei said: "You can see that the left is a fake, and the right is the real one from the auction house, the difference is not very big, but as long as you look carefully, you can still find a lot of flaws." ”
Cao Yundao: "Oppose the second defendant's lawyer misleading. Miss Bai is very busy, and it is impossible to have time to memorize all the details of the vase in her head. There is no contrast in Miss Bai's impression, and there is no obvious contrast without contrast. Moreover, Miss Bai is very trusting of the White Shrimp Auction House, assuming that the White Shrimp sends the fake to Miss Bai's safe, Miss Bai is unlikely to find out in the short term. ”
Cao Yun first and Sang Ni Gan, Nangong Tengfei and Sang Ni Gan, Cao Yun and Nangong Teng Fei Gan. There are no permanent friends, only unchanging interests.
Judge: "The objection is valid, the picture is misleading. ”
Nangong Tengfei is not in a hurry: "Everyone watch the video, this is the video of the vase being boxed and sealed and signed and sent to the studio." After the vase is sealed, it is sent to the studio, and the consignee confirms that the seal is valid. Now we will take a screenshot of the video and compare the sealed vase drawings with two real and fake vase pictures...... Isn't it obvious? The sealed vase is the genuine vase on the right. ”
Cao Yun: "It's not obvious. ”
Bai Ru said: "The picture screenshot effect is not good, but the vase that looks at the video should be a real vase." ”
Cao Yundao: "Since Miss Bai agrees, the police need to investigate the shooting time of the video, whether it is true or false, and whether the sealed signature can be faked." At the same time, whether the escort personnel have dropped the bag, etc. ”
Ah? It's your business again? Sonny looks at Cao Yun, aren't we allies? Why are you stabbing me?
Nangong Tengfei instantly became Sonny's new ally: "The lawyer of the first defendant, if you want to drop the bag, you have to buy the escort, there are four escorts, and they are the registered bodyguards of Baoyun Company. In addition, there were two white shrimp security guards who were bribed to accompany the escort. Six million vases need six people. Is this logical?"
Cao Yun didn't blink his eyes: "Yes." A million per person can buy a lot of ribs. ”
Sonny: "Judge, what do you see?"
Judge: "Do you want me to watch it now? Do I need to apologize after I see it?"
Sonny grinned, "No. ”
The judge said: "The argument of the first defendant's lawyer is very far-fetched, and it is unlikely that the escort process will be dropped subjectively. ”
Cao Yun: "From your subjective point of view, judge, where did the vase go?"
Cao Yun did it with the judge again, but on the other hand, Nangong Tengfei and Sonny didn't dare to breathe, because a knife would fly at any time.
The judge was asked: "The court has always relied on the police conclusion report, and since the police conclusion report is not theft, the plaintiff himself also recognizes that it is not theft." Then the possibility of theft can be ruled out in this case. ”
This excludes the insurance company?
Nangong Tengfei immediately raised his knife and went into battle: "Your Excellency, the possibility of theft cannot be ruled out." In addition to the theft, there may be another possibility, someone broke the vase by mistake, I wonder if the police have conducted an in-depth investigation into this?"
Nangong Tengfei first raised the knife and pointed at Bai Ru and the other three, and then slashed at Sonny with a single knife. Less than a minute after the two formed an alliance, they immediately turned their faces.
Sunny said: "The second defendant, lawyer Nangong, thinks that Miss Bai Ru, Bai Ru's agent, and Miss Bai Ru's personal assistant accidentally broke the vase? This is an accusation, suspected of defrauding insurance. Second Defendant Lawyer: Are you sure you want to file a case?"
Yes, you dare to say it, Lao Tzu will immediately arrest the three of them and return them to the police station, and pass through the hall one by one.
Cao Yundao: "Your Excellency, I think that although the second defendant provided video, photos and other evidence. Basically, the possibility of everyone committing the crime together is ruled out. Is there another possibility, that the auction house broke the vase? For the sake of the auction house's reputation, it dropped the vase?"
Sonny and Nangong Tengfei looked at Cao Yun, we are fighting, what do you mean?
Cao Yundao: "There are many possibilities in this case, as far as the insurance company I represent is concerned, as long as there is a clear conclusion, the insurance company has no reason to refuse compensation." After such a long trial, we also found that the main contradiction was between the auction house and the police. I applied for the revocation of the status of the first defendant of the shrimp insurance. ”
"Wait, I still have questions. Nangong Tengfei began to turn over the hole cards: "Miss Bai said that it was the first time to take a vase for people to appreciate, and found that it was a fake." When did the insurance company sign the insurance contract with Miss Bai?"
The trial agent raised his hand: "It was the vase to the safe The day after I contacted the insurance company and signed the policy after inspecting the vase. ”
Nangong Tengfei said: "That means that the insurance company has confirmed that the vase is genuine?"
Cao Yun was annoyed. I was too anxious, and the flaws that were revealed were caught by Nangong Tengfei. Since the insurance company has seen the vase, it means that there is no auction house.
Nangong Tengfei: "Now the first defendant and the third defendant can discuss the issue of whether it is theft, thank you." ”