As Sonny looks for a job, the hyena disintegrates. More than a dozen people surrendered to the police in three days, and they also bit out some accomplices. Unfortunately, due to structural problems, the hyena's senior personnel have never been found. At the same time, the fork took the initiative to contact the police, and the police found a large number of firearms and ammunition in a warehouse.

All gone?

……

Sima Luo returned to the law firm to continue his studies, and at the same time brought a case.

A woman was on the phone at the top of the staircase, two men walked behind her, one man pushed the woman, and the woman rolled down. He became vegetative due to brain damage and was treated in the hospital.

The police arrested the suspect Da Hu according to the surveillance, but Da Hu has a twin brother named Xiaohu, and Xiaohu's lawyer is Nangong Tengfei. Dahu's lawyer is Ouyang Yi. Both tigers denied the accusations, saying that the person who monitored the video was not themselves. The uncle who walked the stairs with the suspect at the time was Shuanghu's uncle, who said he couldn't be sure whether the big tiger was the big tiger or the little tiger.

It was the birthday of Uncle Shuanghu's daughter, and seven or eight relatives went to the box to sing together. The uncle and a certain tiger went to the bathroom, and after passing the staircase, a certain tiger walked behind the uncle and pushed the victim down the stairs, but the uncle did not even notice. After going to the toilet, I didn't find it when I went back to the box, and the police didn't know until 15 minutes later.

According to the transcripts made by the police, two relatives preferred that Dahu and his uncle go to the bathroom together. However, the box was dimly lit, everyone was singing, and the two brothers were wearing almost identical hairstyles, so everyone could not clearly identify them. The police interviewed Xiaohu's colleagues and friends, and in their explanations, Xiaohu was violent. Big Tiger is a modest and elegant otaku. The police knew that one of them was a murderer, but the evidence was limited and it was impossible to determine who the killer was. The prosecutor in charge of this case is Wang Lei, who is currently in a state of self-autism.

Let's not talk about criminality, everyone knows about high-altitude throwing objects. If the perpetrator cannot be found, and if the business within the scope cannot self-exclude suspicion, then all the owners who may throw objects within the scope must bear civil liability and compensate the victims for their losses. Can this be the case with the civil prosecution part of this case?

There is no way, throwing objects from high altitudes is a relatively special case, so it is a very rare inference of civil guilt. The inference of guilt assumes that you are guilty, and if you cannot prove your innocence, then you are guilty, with a strong sitting. The inference of innocence, assuming that you are innocent and the prosecution can prove that you are guilty, you are guilty.

The victim's current medical expenses have reached 600,000 yuan. Shuanghu is a rich second generation, and their father and uncle are in the clothing wholesale business together. Although it is not a big fortune, there are still hundreds of millions of total assets.

After watching the video and listening to Sima Luo's explanation, everyone watched Cao Yun together. Cao Yun supported his chin with one hand and squinted his eyes, stretched out a slap, and broke off his little tail finger: "Wang Lei vs. Ouyang Yi and Nangong Tengfei!" Is this a joke?

Ring finger: "The only strong witness is their father's business partner, and there is also a blood relationship." ”

Middle finger: "The Twin Tigers clearly have collusion and are very loyal, with their father at the core. It is impossible to sow discord between them. ”

Index finger: "Neither Tiger is married, and it is impossible to open the gap from the spouse who is most likely to know the truth." ”

Thumbs up: "With your income and attitude, you're also here to rub the lawyer." ”

Sima Luo asked: "Why do you say it?"

Lu Yihang explained: "Sonny came to rub it a few days ago. ”

Sima Luo: "Sonny applied for the Southern Branch. ”

Lu Yihang was surprised: "Sonny wants to be a policeman?"

Sima Luo nodded: "He has passed the written test, and yesterday he was assessed by the ability of the South Branch, endurance, physical strength, observation, etc., and Sonny got a full score." However, I heard that Director Li is trying to find a way to remove him. ”

Cao Yun said: "Is Li Long stupid, how useful it is to let Sonny be a policeman." Sonny, you're ready to go undercover for the 'Extensive Reading' gang. What, you're not going? You're fired. For Sonny, he was going to die, forcing him to resign. ”

Sima Luo: "Not everyone thinks the same way as you, Director Li has also considered the possibility that Sonny just wants a job...... Of course, Cao Yun, your thoughts are particularly positive and heartwarming, I believe that Director Li has not thought it through. After all, not everyone can compare with Cao Yun in terms of IQ. ”

Cao Yun said: "It's useless to pat yourself on the back, this case can't be beaten." If you have 100,000 yuan in consultation fees, I can still give some advice, not to death, at least to the death. If you don't pay a penny to rub the lawyer, will you be my son? What's more, the prosecution Wang Lei and I have a woolen relationship? On the contrary, the two lawyers on the defense side have a good personal relationship with me, so why should I harm others and benefit myself?"

Sima Luo: "Justice, Cao Yun, I know that you have justice in your heart. You see the victim is still lying in the hospital, her daughter wiping her face with tears all day long, this is her husband, who has aged twenty years overnight. They only hope that the perpetrators will be brought to justice. ”

Cao Yun asked, "Have they given up civil compensation?"

Sima Luo: "This ...... How is it possible, the cost of medicine is very expensive. ”

Cao Yun asked, "Do they want Shuanghu to compensate for the medical expenses, or will they be brought to justice?"

Sima Luo read out a little meaning: "Cao Yun, what do you mean?"

Cao Yun said: "The difficulty of bringing them to justice is really high, the defense invited two old foxes, in such an advantageous situation, they will lose the lawsuit, maybe they will commit suicide to apologize." In the case of medical expenses, civil compensation ...... I reluctantly communicated with them. But Sima Luo, are you embarrassed to ask me to sell favors? Favors will disappear after selling them a few more times, and favors are also limited. ”

"This ......" can be shameless, but it is the most difficult to repay the debt of favors. This matter is not Sima Luo's own business, it is Wang Lei's business, and it can even be said to be the police's business. Step by step, in the end, it came to Cao Yun to communicate with the opposing lawyer, and Sima Luo himself felt that it was too much.

Cao Yun said: "That's it, I'll give you the favor again, and I'll explain the way to lose nine and win one." As for the actual operation, it's up to you. If you can convict each other, civil compensation will naturally be available. ”

"Hmm. Sima Luo replied ashamedly.

"First of all, you have to identify the murderer, and you must tell the murderer, which is the main premise. Cao Yun said: "Let me ask you, do you think the real murderer is the big tiger or the little tiger?

Sima Luo: "According to the profile, Dahu is not sociable and is more introverted. Xiaohu was detained twice for fighting, and he also beat his ex-girlfriend, who called the police, and finally the two parties reconciled and broke up. Personally, I think it should be Xiaohu. ”

Wei Jun: "Big Tiger." ”

Lu Yihang: "Big Tiger." ”

Yun Yin: "What the hell? I also choose the big tiger." ”

Gao Shan Xing: "Big Tiger." ”

Everyone looked at Gao Shan Xing together, and Gao Shan Xing said: "What, can't I choose the big tiger?"

"Wei Jun, what do you think?"

Wei Jun said: "If you hit Ms. Wang with a fire extinguisher, I think it's Xiaohu." But the insidious push, I don't think it's in line with Xiaohu's character. ”

"One voyage. ”

Lu Yihang said: "I also analyze from personality, the big tiger may be lower to hide for the little tiger, and the little tiger is more willing to hide for the big tiger." ”

Cao Yun said: "I also judge from character......

Yun Yin: "Hey, and my ......"

Cao Yun: "Say it." ”

Yun Yin said: "Introverts usually don't go to the toilet with their elders. ”

Cao Yun was surprised: "Wow, you actually said what I thought." ”

Yun Yin: "How great is your idea? My idea is really amazing, so your idea this time is also great." ”

Cao Yun said: "It's just that it's more likely, and I don't rule out the possibility that Dahu and Uncle are very close." However, for an unsociable and introverted person, not to mention peeing with their elders, they will choose a separate urinal pool when they see a stranger. Nine losses and one win, the first thing to do is to bet on the right person. Sue the big tiger. ”

Sima Luo: "And then?"

Cao Yun said: "The first trial is extremely important, and it can even be said that the final word is the first court, and the first court must be won." The method is to torture the details. You first question the witness Xiaohu, and your aim is to overturn the possibility that he and his uncle will go to the toilet. But Nangong Tengfei will definitely guard against this hand. Xiaohu's answer must be that he went to the toilet with other people that night, and he doesn't remember if it was his uncle. According to the surveillance, the uncle went to the toilet once and went to the toilet with a certain tiger. Xiaohu couldn't answer that he didn't go to the toilet with his uncle, otherwise it would be equivalent to confirming that Dahu was a murderer. ”

Cao Yun: "According to the surveillance video, a certain tiger went to the toilet alone. At this time, evidence was presented, and according to the testimony, the big and small tigers each went to the bathroom. Xiaohu said that he went to the bathroom with someone, but Dahu said that he didn't remember, according to the monitoring and the confessions of both parties, it is certain that Xiaohu is the murderer. ”

Sima Luo: "I don't understand. Yes, since we have a confession, we have evidence. Why don't you just sue Xiaohu?"

Cao Yun said: "Sima, you didn't see the key point of the reversal of the case. This case is difficult to fight, not because neither of them admits that they are murderers. The difficult point of this case is that both of them admit that they are murderers. As I said earlier, surveillance can be used to match confessions and transcripts to force liars out of court interrogations. What if Xiaohu admits that he pushed people at this time?"

Sima Luo: "Isn't that all happy?"

Cao Yun said: "Then Dahu also admitted that he pushed people? Both sides said that they went to the bathroom with their uncle?"

Sima Luo thought for a while: "Then the confession is invalid, and the surveillance evidence cannot show who went to the bathroom with the uncle." ”

Cao Yun said: "That's right, Ouyang Yi and Nangong Tengfei will definitely hide this hand, they must have noticed that there are contradictions between the testimony and the video evidence." There's rough work ahead, and you'll do it. Next up is the technical work. ”

Cao Yun said: "There are a total of four urinal pools in the bathroom, and Xiaohu will answer first, which urinal pool my uncle and he have chosen. There are several options at this time, the first, I don't remember. The second, he's one, me, three, or something like that. The third, I'm in the fourth urinal against the wall, I don't remember which urinal my uncle was in. ”

Cao Yun: "First bet on whether they colluded with each other on the details, and then ask the witness uncle to attend, and ask him to explain which urinal pool he and a certain tiger chose." Finally, Dahu was asked to appear in court and ask the same question. ”

Cao Yun: "The winning side of a win is to underestimate the enemy, Nangong Tengfei and Ouyang Yi did not take Wang Lei in their eyes, they may not have colluded with this detail." Once a question is asked, it is full of loopholes. At this time, there was already a premise, and both tigers admitted that they were murderers. Next, if the confessions of the big and small tigers are inconsistent. For example, Xiaohu said, my first uncle is three, and Big Tiger said, my fourth uncle is two. Uncle said: I am two, and a certain tiger is four. Make sure that the big tiger is telling the truth, and the little tiger has suffered for others. So the murderer is the big tiger. ”

Sima Luo asked: "You just said that there are three options, and the three people answered that there are many possible combinations. ”

Cao Yun said: "This is technical work, which needs to be grasped and analyzed by the prosecutor on the spot. Once the prosecutor made the right bet and the two barristers underestimated the enemy, the opportunity came. At this time, whether or not the conviction can be carried out depends entirely on the prosecutor. I can't replace Wang Lei, I have proposed this method, how to implement the method, you need to complete it. ”

Cao Yun said: "In order to make them even more light, you don't even have a direct connection with this case. These two barristers have a very high level of practice, and they also have a lot of work on their hands. You can't put all your energy into a more mundane case. It's enough for me to slap the clouds, why should I go to get a hammer? Everyone has inertia, and here is the chance to win. Also, once the question is asked, they will certainly ask for an adjournment on various grounds, and you have to take precautions to persuade the judge to refuse the adjournment. ”

Cao Yun said: "If you want to say that this case is also very interesting, if I were a prosecutor, I wouldn't be able to win." Sima Luo, you can't win. But Wang Lei has a glimmer of hope that he can win. ”

Sima Luo took a deep breath: "This ...... seems to be a little embarrassed Wang Lei. It is necessary to make a quick judgment among the three possibilities, ask the right question, and ask the right person to kill with one blow. ”

Cao Yun said: "There is also the rhythm of questioning. If Nangong Tengfei and Ouyang Yi have a slightly obvious hint action, they immediately raise an objection and ask the judge to warn them. You only get one chance. ”

Sima Luo raised his head and smiled bitterly: "It's really nine losses and one win." ”

Cao Yun said: "At least there is still a chance to struggle." ”

Lu Yihang raised his hand: "Lawyer Cao, I communicated with Sun Di's lawyer again about Mo Wei's case a few days ago. The opposing lawyer hinted to me very tactfully that Sun Di now has time and is idle to panic. Sun Di was not afraid to go to court at all. ”

Cao Yun clapped his palm: "I'll just say that there is something wrong, Sun Di is driving by himself, which is not right in itself." He is really idle, is it because he has nothing to have fun by framing Mo Wei? Why is he idle, he is the acting chairman of the board of directors, in charge of the big galaxy. "The commissary owner has to work more than 12 hours a day.

Lu Yihang said: "I learned about the situation through previous customers and several middle-level managers of the administrative department of the Galaxy headquarters. After the management group took over the management of Galaxy, it refused any business interference from Sun Di. It is rumored that the management group is so confident, and it is Sun Hai who supports them. In addition, the directors superficially respected Sun Di, but the substantive work was not handed over to Sun Di. Sun Di's work is only to listen to the report at every board meeting. Sun Di himself did not put forward opinions and suggestions, which seemed even more insignificant. ”

Cao Yun said: "This is a bit difficult. If Sun Di is really idle and bored, Mo Wei is in big trouble. That can only take a step back and actively compensate in exchange for the punishment of community service. ”

Yun Yin said: "Do you want to sell favors in this case? My brother is Wang Hui, the president of Xingyun Shao, and he has a good relationship with Sun Di. ”

Cao Yun said: "If the connections are used at this step, the lawyer will lose completely." Cao Yun has also proposed a similar method before, just ask Sun Xueyi and Sun to talk. It's really not good, just smash 120,000 yuan in the past, and take down the grievances, and the judge may not be sentenced to prison. “

Mo Wei's losses cannot be reduced through a lawyer, so what is the difference between having this lawyer and not having this lawyer?