The master of ceremonies looked at the prosecution seat, and Nangong took off and closed his eyes as if he had fallen asleep. Ouyang Yi gestured, Cao Yun nodded, and said, "Hu Yanping, you just said that Miss Wang took the initiative to post it on Sun Di's body on the grounds of explaining the report, may I ask, did you listen to Sun Di say this detail, or did you listen to Miss Wang." Because Hu Yanping is no longer a lawyer, Cao Yun directly called her by her name.

Hu Yanping said: "Miss Wang and I are classmates, and the relationship is average, so I still try my best to help her." Now that Miss Wang is revisiting the old case here, it is obvious that it is hype in nature, and it is very unfair to Sun Di. So I'll tell you the truth about what she told me at the time. ”

Cao Yun: "Lawyer Huyan, you don't need to explain so much. I'm just asking, who are you listening to about this detail?"

Hu Yanping: "Miss Wang." ”

Cao Yun nodded and said, "Then there is a huge problem, Miss Wang used to work in the trading company Xiaofa Group, and her job position was the public relations department. Ms. Wang has been in the administrative secretariat of Galaxy Group for less than a month and is still in the internship period. Ms. Wang's major in university is history. ”

Cao Yun took out more than a dozen copies: "These are some simple financial statements that I downloaded casually, Miss Wang can understand them, can you explain them? I will distribute them to you now, everyone can take a look, can you understand them?"

Cao Yun distributed: "The full name of the report taken by Miss Wang should be the capital budget plan of a subsidiary, which involves hundreds of projects, various names, and various accounts. It's not that I look down on Miss Wang, my assistant Wei Jun has studied finance, she can understand it if she looks through it carefully, but if she asks her to explain, she can't do it. Even if Miss Wang is a financial genius, she understands and understands it very well. And that report is the budget plan of the chemical subsidiary, which involves a lot of technical terms, and Miss Wang can even explain it?"

He Yingdao: "Lawyer Cao misunderstood, Miss Wang doesn't need a professional and clear explanation, and I believe she doesn't have the ability." She just casually explained that the main purpose was not on the report. If Sun Di is in the mood to listen to her explanation, it means that Sun Di is also interested in her. ”

Cao Yun said: "What Lawyer He said is very good, does Lawyer He want to deny Hu Yanping's explanation just now? If you want to deny the core details, should you deny other details? Since Hu Yanping lied about one detail, will he lie about other details? In your opinion, lawyer He, should Hu Yanping's explanation be adopted or not?"

He Ying can answer that Hu Yanping didn't lie, it was Miss Wang who lied and deceived Hu Yanping. But the problem arises again, Cao Yun will ask Miss Wang, who has been on the cruise ship, to testify on video, if Miss Wang denies that she and Hu Yanping said this, the situation will be even more difficult to clean up.

Hu Yanping stood on the defense side, making Cao Yun and the other three happy. It seems that two lawyers in the know will be mixed up to be invincible. But the truth is that once they take a position, there is room for what they say to be questioned.

Cao Yun sharply threw out a difficult question, which made the defense uncomfortable. The most uncomfortable thing is that He Ying can't deny Hu Yanping, which is equivalent to betraying his peers. Although Hu Yanping's license has been revoked, she still has a lot of judicial connections, and she will not leave the judicial circle in her future career.

The four of them began to discuss with each other, and after a while, He Ying replied: "Now it seems that lawyer Huyan has listened to the words of Miss Wang's family, so lawyer Huyan is not qualified to testify." ”

Cao Yun said: "Thank you, in addition, Lawyer He was Sun Di's lawyer at the time, and he is currently a partner of Galaxy Law Firm, and Sun Di has a subordinate relationship. I think it seems that Mr. Ho should avoid suspicion. The second dropped the Hu Yanping, and then stabbed at He Ying. Cao Yun doesn't follow the normal path, doesn't go to court to argue with you about the details of the case, but makes a fuss about his identity.

At first, Sima Luo thought that it was very immoral for Hu Yanping to abandon his position as Miss Wang's lawyer and switch to Sun Di's position as the defense. Listening to Cao Yunyi now, Hu Yanping is very convincing for the defense. On the contrary, because He Ying is Sun Di's lawyer, his support for Sun Di is position is not convincing. A loophole in Hu Yanping's testimony was caught by Cao Yun and Hu Yanping was eliminated. turned to destroy He Ying, who was suspected of having a position.

Sima Luo said to Yue Sanchi beside him: "The defense has lost, and the strength is uneven. ”

Excluding Cao Yun, Nangong Tengfei is a recognized lawyer, and Ouyang Yi is the king of criminal cases. On the other hand, although he is also a well-known lawyer, there is still a considerable gap in comparison. He Ying is the most famous, but unfortunately he belongs to the parties and is not convincing enough.

Galaxy Law Firm takes the scale route, and Universe Law Firm takes the elite route. He Ying of the Galaxy played against Ouyang Yi of the universe, which should have been the highlight of this court debate, but unfortunately Ouyang Yi has not yet come out, and He Ying has already lost three points.

He Ying retorted: "It is precisely because of my understanding of the case that I will stand on Sun Di's side very resolutely." It's just a defense meeting, and there is no need to avoid suspicion. ”

Cao Yun said: "I think Lawyer He is more suitable to be a witness, but if Lawyer He insists, we will continue with the next topic. ”

He Ying asked, "What topic?"

Cao Yun said: "The second debate is two parts, the first part, Sun Di took the initiative to touch Miss Wang, or Miss Wang took the initiative to touch Sun Di, the two prosecutors have explained very clearly, I have no doubt. The topic I want to talk about is whether Miss Wang offered a price of one million after the fact, which is also a detail clearly stated in Sun Di's transcript. ”

He Ying asked rhetorically: "Is there any significance in discussing this topic? ”

Cao Yun said: "I have only one question, why did Miss Wang dare to ask for a hush money of 1 million without recording, video, or scars? That is to say, judging from the evidence, Miss Wang did not have any evidence to prove that Sun Di violated her, and this kind of affair is not a big deal in the eyes of many people, and it is difficult to have an impact on Sun Di's reputation. So why did Miss Wang pay 1 million hush money? Especially when Miss Wang did not deliberately create any evidence of violation, why did she dare to extort 1 million?"

He Ying said: "There are billions of people on the earth, maybe Miss Wang is stupid?

Cao Yun: "No, on the contrary, Miss Wang is not an ordinary stupid, she is simply stupid." It doesn't make sense for us to argue like this, I personally think that Miss Wang's IQ and experience are at least above and below the average line, and Lawyer He thinks that Miss Wang is a stupid girl. Let's not say that since Miss Wang is a stupid girl, she will think of taking the opportunity to take the position. Who's right or wrong, I guess Miss Wang is also on the cruise, you can ask her out, and everyone ask some questions to see if she is really that stupid?"

He Yingdao: "This is a defense meeting, not a hearing. And a person's mind is constantly changing. I think Miss Wang thought that the matter of Fengyue would affect Sun Di's future afterwards, so she offered this price. ”

Cao Yundao: "It is very interesting that Miss Wang has a criminal record, and she was once arrested and imprisoned for blackmailing the president of Xiaofa Group. The blackmail was originally very safe, but Miss Wang saw that the president was at risk of being removed from his post and did not dare to be known to the outside world, so she offered a price of 500,000 yuan. In the end, because the president was still removed, the president called the police. Note that there is a huge problem here, Miss Wang has a video of her heart-to-heart conversation with the president. ”

Cao Yun said: "Compared with the two, under the establishment of Sun Di's testimony, Miss Wang is the judgment of the two. In the small case, she saw the opportunity and got the video, so as to blackmail 500,000 yuan. In the Sun Di case, she didn't see the right time, she didn't have any coercion, and she even asked for a million. I have only heard that people's personalities change, but I have not heard that people's experiences deteriorate. ”

Hu Yanping saw He Ying's moment, took the microphone and said, "If what you said is the truth, lawyer Cao, then after the police arrived, why did Miss Wang say that Sun Di violated her?"

This problem is very fatal, but Cao Yun has long pondered this problem, the sword has a double edge, since you draw the sword, then I will borrow the sword.

"This question is very good, Miss Wang said that Sun Di violated her, even if she is convicted, what good is Miss Wang? According to the law, the right shoulder belongs to the top of the wall, but the civil compensation for the right shoulder is very little, or even none. In terms of financial interests, Miss Wang is not beneficial. So why did Miss Wang lie?"

Hu Yanping replied: "After Miss Wang blackmailed one million and was rejected afterwards, she was angry and falsely accused Sun Di. So it is logical for Miss Wang to extort a million. ”

Cao Yun said: "It's not logical, because Miss Wang has a similar criminal record." ”

Ouyang Yi took the microphone and said: "Lawyer Cao has already explained that the blackmail of one million is not credible, but the defense did not explain this, but skipped the question and used the question to find an answer. This is a common method of confusion used by our lawyers, and we ask our lawyers not to use this method on this occasion. ”

What is the Law of Confusion?

A punches B, B calls the police, and A claims that he was hit by B. The police examined the injuries and found that B was only a skin injury and A was a minor injury. Both parties are at fault, and according to the legal theory of damages, B should compensate A for medical expenses, and A should compensate for B's medical expenses. Clearly, B paid a bigger price for this.

B did not hit A, but A confused the concept, and he changed the concept from unilateral assault to fighting, changing the nature of the matter, using self-harm to make himself a victim and making B criminally responsible.

For example, in the debate just now, the defense could not directly answer Cao Yun's question, so Hu Yanping used the question of what might or may not be to restrain Cao Yun's question. Hu Yanping thought that Miss Wang was angry after the blackmail of 1 million was rejected. This seems to contradict the previous question, but in reality it is only an explanation. When Miss Wang had not yet decided whether to extort 1 million, Hu Yanping blamed what happened later on Miss Wang's extortion of 1 million.

Ouyang Yi said: "According to the transcript, the three interrogation confessions, Miss Wang's answer to this question is completely consistent. Miss Wang had always been worried about her criminal record, and after the police arrived, Miss Wang knew that Sun Di would know about her criminal record sooner or later, so she put forward the claim that she had been violated. She knew that she couldn't fight Sun Di's lawyer team, and she had the mentality of striking first. ”

Ouyang Yi said: "We can deny Miss Wang's transcript and confession. What I want to say is that even if Miss Wang's extortion of 1 million is rejected, she will dare to be angry? Doesn't she know her criminal record? Doesn't she know Sun Di's strength?"

Ouyang Yi: "To sum up, the statement that Miss Wang blackmailed him for one million in Sun Di's transcript is very unbelievable. Not only does it not conform to Miss Wang's personality, personality, experience and IQ, but also violates the basic logic, Miss Wang really blackmailed one million and was rejected, and the police appeared, she should be calm, not make a big deal out of it. ”

At this time, Nangong Tengfei picked up the microphone: "He Ying, we are old rivals, you have a shortcoming called painting snakes." You arrive at the scene as soon as possible, and you have the time and opportunity to communicate with Sun Di. You shouldn't let Sun Di sue Miss Wang for blackmail, fortunately, Miss Wang has a lot of contradictions in the transcript and confession, plus she has a criminal record, so the matter was determined. Don't you think your strategy is risky? As a lawyer, it is enough to know that Miss Wang entered the guest room on her own initiative and did not need to add fuel to the fire. What about you? If you have to add blackmail, it will leave you with a handle. With Sun Di's status, what is the benefit of Miss Wang's imprisonment? A lawyer should look at the problem from the standpoint and interests of the employer, rather than being more ruthless means that you are more powerful. ”

"Nangong Tengfei, what are you that dare to teach Lao Tzu?" He Ying said angrily: "Do you have any other skills besides perjury?"

Nangong Tengfei replied slowly: "Yes, I have debuted for twenty-five years and fought seventy-eight civil lawsuits, with a winning rate of 74%. Nineteen criminal lawsuits were fought, of which the defendants in 10 cases were acquitted, the defendants in five cases were commuted, and the defendants in two cases were exempted from prison. That's what I'm capable of, and the data is here. What about your stats? Between the ages of 30 and 40, your winning rate in civil lawsuits is only 35%, because you will pat Sun Hai's sycophants, Galaxy Law Firm will hand over easy cases to you, and you will refuse difficult lawsuits, causing your winning rate to rise to 70%. It's only 70 percent. By that alone, I am qualified to teach you. ”

There is only one channel for microphone, and the master of ceremonies will not cut the microphone until a person finishes speaking, so as to avoid making a noise. Although He Ying shouted, everyone heard every word of Nangong Tengfei clearly.

Sima Luo didn't quite understand: "Senior sister, what is Nangong Tengfei doing?"

Yue Sanchi turned his head sideways and said in Sima Luo's ear: "Advertising, Nangong Tengfei has been very unhappy in the past few years, and has lost many important customers. Advertising was the purpose of his participation in this Flame Defense Meeting. He doesn't care about stepping on someone else's upper position, he has also stepped on Cao Yun. He now shows his strength with statistics, which is very effective. Applaud the old fox, and hope that he will continue to be unlucky. "If there is anything in the world that cannot be defeated, it is only fate, commonly known as luck.

Sima Luo said: "If I were a judge, I think Cao Yun's side would be more convincing." ”

Yue Sanchi nodded: "That's right, but you were also misled by Cao Yun." Cao Yun's position is that Miss Wang is accused of extortion, and it is enough for the criminal defendant to break a little or make the evidence doubtful. Cao Yun had no evidence to affirm that Miss Wang did not raise the extortion of one million, he only denied the one million because there was no evidence that Miss Wang extorted one million. My personal judgment is that the reason why Miss Wang said that she was violated after the police arrived is probably really annoyed and angry, that is, Sun Di did not meet her psychological expectations. But I don't think it's a million. ”

The master of ceremonies turned off the microphone and said, "Don't quarrel anymore, let's see what the three judges say." ”

The three retired judges watched the scene via video, with a slight delay, and after waiting for a while, the three judges gave their opinions. To sum up, they believe that Sun Di's claim that Miss Wang extorted one million is not credible. In addition, they very much agreed with what Nangong Tengfei said, as long as it was proved that Miss Wang took the initiative to go to the guest room, Sun Di would not have any trouble with the judiciary. The subtext is that the one million blackmail was added by He Ying to Sun Di, which is a losing move.

He Ying angrily smashed the microphone to the big screen and left the venue without looking back.

After a small scuffle, the master of ceremonies unveiled the core evidence previously stated.