Nangong Tengfei: "Please note that Zhang Qian took a plane to a certain country after work on Friday, and if there was no accident, he could have returned to Dongtang before work on Monday." Zhang Qianren is already a dead person, and now the shameless police and unscrupulous lawyers are trying their best to let the dead people bear the blame. Let me ask, shouldn't the dead be guilty or innocent? What evidence does the police have to prove that Zhang Qian stole the vase?

Nangong Tengfei: "On the contrary, it is more intuitive to see the theft case of buying ghosts in Bairu's studio. There are witnesses, and the ghost testimonies show that he knew that the thief's target was the vase, and that he also knew the time of the thief's actions. There is physical evidence, and the ghost received a deposit of 300,000 yuan from the thief. That's right, the thief of the video denied that he had stolen, but the agreement between the thief and the ghost was that he would give another 700,000 after the deed was completed. Since the vase is fake, the thief does not need to give the inner ghost 700,000. That's why thieves lie. ”

Nangong Tengfei said: "To sum up, because of the personnel related to the vase, that is, the death of Zhang Qian, everyone can see the opportunity. Here I would like to say that even if he is a deceased, he has the rights and interests conferred by the law. ”

After saying this, Nangong Tengfei took a little breath. These words were very methodical, and for a while the audience was shocked, and the courtroom was silent.

It was Sonny who broke the silence: "You were prepared, why didn't you stand up against Cao Yun's video evidence?"

Nangong Tengfei smiled: "Isn't this you?"

The two of them negotiated to let Cao Yun out, divide the winners and losers with each other, and end the case. It's understandable that you're shameless, because you're shameless. Nangong Tengfei has no reputation, this is not right. I'm a double standard, you bite me.

Nangong Tengfei's words burned the flames of war to Cao Yun, and this fire was very ferocious. Nangong Tengfei shows that there are objectively theft cases, and the judiciary cannot choose to believe it because of the thief's words, and the judiciary believes in the evidence even more.

Cao Yun who stabbed this knife was very painful, and the damn old fox thought that he would let himself out. I didn't expect to think about the person who took the blame.

When Nangong Tengfei said this, even Bai Ru felt that it made sense. Regardless of Zhang Qian, there was indeed a theft in the studio, and someone invaded the safe, and the target was the vase of the safe. It's a fact.

There was no way, Cao Yun took his mobile phone to look at the information: "Let's first understand this Smoto, Smotu can tell the details of the communication with the inner ghost, and it is basically certain that Smotu is the one who invaded the safe in the studio." Between the four and thirty-seven years of the present Chinese New Year's Eve, Smotu is a native of Southeast Asian countries. His modus operandi is well documented, he never steps on the dots when he steals, and he never hacks into cameras and computers through hackers. He chose to buy the inner ghost. ”

Cao Yun said: "It can be determined that Simot committed the crime, there were four cases in four years, and he bought four ghosts." The offer price ranges from 100,000 yuan to 3 million yuan. The reason why these four cases were confirmed is because the police have solved the cases and caught the ghosts. According to the description of the inner ghost, Smotu and their contact were close to each other, and all the stolen money they received came from Malay accounts, and each time their transaction was a deposit of 30%, and then 70% after the matter was completed. ”

Cao Yun said: "In these four cases, Simot has not cheated any of the ghosts, and the money that should be given is not less. The balance has not been shortened. To say that the vase is not the biggest case that Smot has ever done, he has stolen the crown of Thailand, and it is worth a fortune. The cost of hiring an inner ghost is three million. Pay 900,000 first, and then 2.1 million, without missing a penny. ”

Cao Yun said: "Next, let's learn about the fake vase, which is an imitation handicraft produced in the Eastern Tang Dynasty. It can be purchased on Ceramic Street. Please note that Simot does not speak Chinese, and when he first came to the Eastern Tang Dynasty, how did he know where to buy fakes that were basically identical? ”

Cao Yun: "Back in the studio safe, Smotu can take the vase directly, and there is no need to leave a fake vase." He didn't care when the crime was confirmed, and he didn't have the need to cover it up. He's a thief, he's a wanted criminal, and we can't just look at his IQ with colored glasses because he's a wanted criminal. On the contrary, his IQ is quite good. ”

Cao Yun: "A person with such a reputation, just because he is a thief, everyone doesn't trust him, right? In addition, from the testimony of the inner ghost, we can know that Smotu consulted him a lot about the situation in the Eastern Tang City. For example, the police call, the speed of the police, the traffic situation, etc. There was never talk about where to buy fakes. ”

Cao Yun: "Don't talk about Simot, that is, we are familiar with the Eastern Tang Dynasty, and now we want to buy exactly the same fake, do you know where to buy it? Do you know the lawyer for the second defendant? Who knows about Ceramic Street, please raise your hand...... Nobody knows. I specifically learned that Ceramic Street is not a street, but the name of a shop. I have an assistant whose name is Hanko, and she is very serious about her work and found this place. ”

Cao Yun handed his mobile phone to the judge: "This is a photo that my assistant got from Ceramic Street, the pixel is not very high, but it can be seen that before the vase auction, Zhang Qian's wife entered the Ceramic Street store." When he left, he carried a bag in his hand, and it was vaguely visible that it was a cardboard box, roughly the same size as a vase. ”

Cao Yun: "That's right, this is also circumstantial evidence, which can't prove that Zhang Qian dropped the bag, or even that Zhang Qian's wife bought a fake vase." As lawyers, we must first speak of conscience. It doesn't matter, the theft is real, the police come to a conclusion, the judge decides the case, the insurance company loses money, and we close the case. However, there is another thing in this world called the truth, maybe we can't see the truth, maybe the truth is not willing to face us. But we can't create a truth with a clear conscience just because we don't know the truth. Thank you. ”

Compared with the first trial, this trial was a real thing. Nangong Tengfei and Cao Yun kept turning over their hole cards, which were unknown to the other party.

Nangong's sonorous awe-inspiring against Cao Yun raised the quality of the trial to a new height.

There was also a period of silence, and Nangong Tengfei said: "What Lawyer Cao said is very good, but there is one thing that is wrong. The law talks about evidence, and the truth is sometimes not something that the law can protect. Otherwise, there is no presumption of innocence. If the case is judged and investigated only based on subjective preferences, how many people will be wronged?"

Continuing to be silent, at this time the judge needs to make a stage summary, and if there are no problems, go directly to the final link: the original defendant's closing argument. Then, after a ten-minute to half-hour adjournment, the judge announced the final verdict.

In the second trial, Sonny became a presenter, and Nangong Tengfei and Cao Yun really fought with a knife. Nangong Tengfei's main evidence is that there was actually a theft in the studio, and there is no evidence that Zhang Qian stole the vase. Cao Yun interpreted his testimony from various aspects such as character and reputation, and the evidence was all circumstantial evidence.

There is a rather embarrassing place in the law of the Eastern Tang Dynasty, which was originally a civil law system, and has slowly changed to the law of the sea system in the past ten years. Evidence is the link that the civil law system pays attention to, and the character, credibility and logic proposed by Cao Yun belong to the link that the law of the sea system pays attention to.

The judge put his hand on the table, and tapped the table with his left thumb, and he was also entangled. If it is decided that the shrimp auction loses the lawsuit, then Cao Yun will ignore the various subjective evidences put forward, then there is no need to argue, which is also the weakness of the civil law system, only looking at the evidence. If the white shrimp auction is lost, it is a disregard for the evidence. The judge subjectively supported Cao Yun and objectively supported Nangong Tengfei. The momentum of the two sides is equal, and the reasons are relatively sufficient, and it is impossible to distinguish who has the upper hand, and it is difficult for them to adjudicate.

So the judge looked at Sonny, who was herding cattle and eating melons on the side: "What does the third defendant think?"

Sonny was stunned for half a second, big brother, the content of their debate has nothing to do with me.

The judge added: "From a police point of view, although you are a rookie police officer, I think you are still very capable. For the first time in my twenty years as a judge, I apologized to a lawyer. I'm angry, but it doesn't affect my opinion of your abilities. ”

Wow! It's so cool to be praised by others!

Cao Yun thinks that the judge is the-stirring stick, it's almost the same now, you just give a conclusion, and whoever loses will admit it. The judge was not reconciled to end up like this. Nangong Tengfei can understand the judge, and if the judge says such a thing, it means that judging from the current situation of the trial, the judge cannot draw a conclusion.

Sonny stood up: "As a police officer, I subjectively support the first defendant, Lawyer Cao. However, being a police officer also has to talk about evidence, and I am helpless to support the second defendant, lawyer Nangong. ”

I'll go! and give me an opinion.

In the stalemate, Cao Yun stood up and added: "The third defendant, what is the follow-up investigation of Zhang Qian's death by the police?"

Sunny said: "The case will be transferred to the national punishment, and the national punishment will communicate with the other party. Get the two corpses back through the channel of the stumbling foot, and there is basically nothing else to do. ”

Cao Yun asked: "In other words, the police have not been to the scene of the car accident?"

Sonny: "There's no need, we trust our counterparts in a certain country. ”

Cao Yun looked at his phone: "According to the statistical report, there is a relatively serious judicial ** in a certain country, are you sure that it is not Zhang Qian and his wife who have broken off their shells? The body has not been handed over, and you have not asked for DNA collection, is this considered a dereliction of duty?"

Sonny was just about to answer, but Nangong Tengfei made up for it: "Three million US dollars were remitted to Zhang Qian's wife's account, and the other party is a Malay account, have you communicated with the Malay police?"

Sonny felt very bad, how could he shoot himself, Sonny said: "The national punishment should communicate with Malay." ”

Nangong Tengfei asked: "Sanjie doesn't care about this matter? Everyone looks at the plaintiff, not to mention celebrities, charity ambassadors, etc., even if an ordinary citizen's private property is violated, the police have the obligation to help him." Now there are obvious clues that have not been pursued, is this considered a dereliction of duty?"

Sonny smiled bitterly: "Both, it's useless for you to force me." I'll look around, and you'll have to do it. Either you Cao Yun died, or he hung in Nangong. To tell you the truth, we are already very dedicated to Bai Ru, more than ordinary citizens. The Malay account is obviously a leather bag money account, and the bodies of Zhang Qian and his wife will be transported back sooner or later, and they can't hide their fake death. Besides, everyone has arrived in a certain country, and there is no need to fake death. ”

Sonny: "I have a proposal, and I understand that the judge is not going to decide right now. If the two defendants have no opinion, it is up to the plaintiff to decide who should pay the damages. ”

Cao Yun and Nangong Tengfei were stunned for a few seconds, this proposal sounded very good. But can you respect everyone's profession a little bit? In a civil litigation case, you let the plaintiff decide who will pay compensation, then there is still a yarn lawsuit?

Bai Ru said: "I respect the final decision of the court. ”

The judge finally concluded: "Judging from the current trial results, what the shrimp insurance lawyer said is reasonable and convincing. But the evidence is not in favor of shrimp insurance. It can be determined that there was indeed a case of stealing vases in Bai Ru's studio, and it is impossible to confirm that Zhang Qian stole vases. As a court, we cannot admit the testimony of a thief who has not been caught. If there are no problems with the parties, then please prepare and make closing arguments. ”

Oops! Cao Yun shouted in his heart that the judge had already expressed his attitude.

Sonny raised his hand, everyone look at Sonny, shut up!

Sonny completely ignored everyone's eyes and said, "Let me make a suggestion, Miss Bai Ru, you are not short of five million, and you are very clear about the trial of the case." Personally, I propose that you donate 5 million, and 2.5 million each from white shrimp and shrimp shrimp. It's good for everyone. The case can be made public, because the suspect is a repeat Southeast Asian offender who has not been arrested, or a serious suspect appraiser who has passed away, and it is impossible to determine who stole the real vase. Charity ambassador Bai Ru proposed that both parties contribute 2.5 million yuan each to donate the money to charity. Shrimp and White Shrimp agreed to this proposal, but insisted on donating in Bai Ru's name, and voluntarily increased the donation amount to donate 3 million, because Miss Bai Ru was a vase purchased by 6 million. ”

The judge said: "The third defendant's proposal is a settlement ......"

Cao Yun slapped the table with his left hand and stood up: "I'm sorry, I admit death." There must be a police conclusion, or a final court decision, for the insurance company to give the money. Shrimp Insurance Company is a company that abides by rules and regulations and self-discipline and will not violate the rules of the game for the sake of mud. ”

Cao Yun: "As far as the current trial is concerned, I can only play the last card. Please forgive me for the white shrimp auction...... After Ms. Bai Ru purchased the vase, she contacted the shrimp insurance company to apply for insurance. According to the industry regulations, the shrimp insurance company contacted the white shrimp auction and asked the white shrimp auction to send an appraiser to the scene to identify the vase. There are many appraisers that can be dispatched for the white shrimp auction, but why send Zhang Qian, the appraiser in charge of the vase?"

Nangong Tengfei replied: "White Shrimp Auction believes that Zhang Qian is the most familiar with this pair of vases, and it is the most authoritative for Zhang Qian to determine whether it is genuine." ”

Cao Yundao: "My understanding is the opposite, just because Zhang Qian is the appraiser and staff in charge of the vase, I can't ask him to appraise." The insurance company contacted Bai Shrimp with the attitude of trusting the white shrimp auction, and the white shrimp did not explain that Zhang Qian was the person in charge of the vase in the process. The insurance company can lose this case, and the loss is also lost because of the pit by the white shrimp auction. ”

Fade the bullet and put on the bayonet!