In the court trial case, Lu Yihang believed that the little man had threatened to kill the little girl's family, so even if the two knew each other, there was a great threat for the little man to invade the little girl's house. Nine-Tails believes that the little girl and the little man are completely incapable of fighting each other in size and strength. The little girl took advantage of the little man's unpreparedness and attacked the little man from behind with a hammer. In other words, at that time, the little man had let down his guard and was in a quiet and non-threatening state.

The two sides argued with reason, and in the process of questioning the little girl, Nine-Tails was unexpectedly prepared by Lu Yihang very complete and comprehensive. Nine-Tails analyzes the position, movements, behavior, etc., and debunks the lies in the little girl's transcript one by one.

Nine-Tails: Did you pour the water, or did the little boy pour it himself?

Little Girl: I'm down.

Nine-Tails: With your back to the little man?

Little Girl: yes.

Nine-Tails: You said in your transcript that you were always in a state of nervousness and alertness, and the little man was only two meters away from you, but you dared to pour water with your back to her. Depending on the amount of water coming out of the water dispenser, it takes at least six seconds to fill a cup. You're not scared for those six seconds?

Little Girl: I fell on my side.

Nine-Tails: Left or Right?

Little Girl: I can't remember.

Nine-Tails: Let me remind you that your water dispenser is placed in a concave position, with a refrigerator on the left and a screen on the right.

Similar inquiries were released one by one, and the little girl was unable to resist. There is also a nine-tailed question, open the door to receive the little man after calling the police, or attack the little man and then call the police? There is no sign of damage to the door, why don't you hide and wait for the police to arrive, but open the door and invite the little man to enter?

Lu Yihang was not fully prepared, he could parry, but he couldn't. For example, when the little man was invited in, it was the alarm center that asked the little girl to calm down and appease the intruder, and the little girl opened the door only after she misunderstood. It seems that it can be said of the past. Nine-tails asked, she went from the second floor to the first floor, and then opened the door, just to appease the little man's emotions? Lu Yihang replied, and the little girl did not say that she was on the second floor. Nine-Tails presented evidence, and during the call to the police, the police center asked if the little girl was safe now? The little girl replied that it was safe and hid under the bed. The little girl's house has four beds, and only the bed in the master bedroom on the second floor can be crammed into a large living person.

The nine tails will be recorded, the police call, the confession, the details of the scene are fully penetrated, the police phone is used to verify the scene, the confession is responded to on the spot, and the police call is explained by the confession. Similar to a one-push-one.

For example, if someone calls and says he's working overtime, then he confirms that he's in the company. Twenty minutes later, someone posted on Moments, saying that the moon was round. It means that he saw the moon. But this again contradicts the overtime narrative. Because the company is located where the moon cannot be seen.

Nine-Tails' one-push-one tactics completely crushed Lu Yihang, and the little girl couldn't answer Nine-Tails' multiple questions head-on in court. Although there is still a court in the first instance, the result is already doomed.

What's worse is that the Nine-Tails persuaded Lu Yihang and persuaded Lu Yihang to believe that the little girl was the murderer, which made Lu Yihang completely lose his fighting spirit.

After the trial, Lu Yihang sat on the steps very depressed, and Cao Yun, who was hearing the trial, passed by, helped him up, and comforted him: "I just ordered pork ribs, remember to pay for it." ”

Roaring, Lu Yihang just wants to roar at the sky, wants to roar loudly......

But Lu Yihang didn't blame Cao Yun for his strange sarcasm. Cao Yun once reminded Lu Yihang very seriously that the strength of the Nine-Tails is very strong. The Nine-Tails are strong in the invincibility of local battles. Cao Yun played against the Nine-Tails, spent a lot of energy to understand the Nine-Tails, and finally decided to adopt the tactics of avoiding the real and attacking the false. Lawyers like Cao Yun don't dare to have a hard time with the Nine-Tails, and it is reasonable for Lu Yihang to be hit and sunk.

......

Lu Yihang hung his head, and Sima Luo, a good engine oil on the side, asked: "Cao Yun, can the little girl's case be overturned?"

Cao Yun said: "Before answering this question, you must first answer me a question, in this case, Yihang first believed that the little girl was innocent, and it was legitimate defense. After the court trial, Yihang changed his views and agreed with the Nine-Tails. Hypothetically, I said that the hypothetical little girl is innocent, because the prosecutor is too powerful, which leads to the occurrence of unjust cases, and even leads to the unjust death of the little girl. What do you think about this? All four, you can talk about it. ”

Having analyzed the reasons why a lawyer is stronger than a prosecutor, this is now an analysis of the problem that prosecutors are stronger than lawyers. This question is also a very real and common problem. Although the overall level of prosecutors is not high, the quality of legal practitioners is uneven. Many criminal defendants do not have the money to hire a lawyer, and the court will assign them a lawyer through legal aid. In most cases, the lawyers assigned by legal aid are either incompetent or perfunctory. After all, it is a market economy, and you get what you pay for. So what if it's a planned economy? No one is going to try to get better.

Lu Yihang asked rhetorically: "Lawyer Cao, do you think the little girl is innocent?"

Cao Yun replied: "You no longer trust your client, you should resign." Wind and snow, what do you think?"

Feng Xue looked up at everyone and replied: "The police university has taken relevant questions, and the standard answer is: whether the suspect is guilty or not has nothing to do with the police. The teacher told us that the police can catch the wrong person, and whether the suspect is guilty or not has nothing to do with the police, but with lawyers, prosecutors and judges. According to big data statistics, in the absence of criminal records, in the course of multiple police interrogations, the probability of a suspect who insists that he has not done anything bad is not high. ”

Feng Xue: "On the other hand, if the criminal pleads guilty, the police will quickly transfer the case to the prosecutor. If the offender pleads not guilty, the police will supplement the investigation. In this case, the little girl insisted that she was innocent, and according to big data, she should be innocent. But big data does not include felonies. When a felony suspect pleads not guilty, the prosecution must have a substantial preponderance of the evidence before the suspect can be formally charged with what we call ironclad evidence. ”

Sonny: "People are asking, lawyers are stupid, prosecutors are geniuses, will it lead to unjust cases." ”

Feng Xue was silent for a while and said, "My mentor told me that after the law appears, those who can escape the punishment of the law are smart people. Then there were lawyers, and those who could get away with the law became rich, because rich people could hire smart people to defend them. Lawyer Cao: What you are talking about is a relatively rare situation, and in most cases, the prosecutor's comprehensive ability is not as good as that of a lawyer. ”

Seeing everyone waiting, Feng Xue could only continue: "The law is a yardstick and a transparent boundary. Just like the college entrance examination, we are pursuing fairness as much as possible. The reality is much more complex, with geographical and artificial inequality. The provinces do not unify the examination papers, and the number of places admitted to prestigious schools in the province and so on. Those who score 500 points in the A test can go to prestigious schools, and those who score 600 points in B can only go to two books. Isn't that unfair? It's not fair, but it's been done as much as possible. The same is true of the law, and there must be a world of difference between hiring Miss Gao and hiring lawyer Cao in terms of the outcome of the trial. ”

"......" Gao Shan Xing looked out the window, the weather was very good today. What did Feng Xue just say? I didn't hear that.

Cao Yun applauded: "That's a good point. The problem with the little girl's case is that the little girl's lawyer can't fight the prosecutor. Is that little girl necessarily guilty?"

Lu Yihang: "Lawyer Cao, you went to the trial. It should be seen that the little girl is full of loopholes when answering the nine-tailed question, and it is difficult to justify herself. When I was in a hurry, I couldn't tell me clearly, I didn't know. ”

Cao Yun said: "Yihang, you have read all the information before you go to the trial, and I am not sure if the little girl is guilty." But I don't think you believed in the little girl very much from the beginning...... Or, next time I appear in court, I'll be an assistant, and we'll bet on 300 ribs?"

Feng Xue reminds: "It is illegal for private bets to exceed a certain amount. ”

Sonny was upset: "You care." "Young people are young people, and they don't speak through their brains. What I just said is very good, and it should be a plus. Don't interject when you shouldn't. Compared with the college students who have just left school in the snow, except for the alpine apricots, all of them are considered bosses.

The wind and snow immediately fell silent.

Cao Yun smiled: "Feng Xue is right, this is not right. Besides, I may not be available, my sister is getting married next week, and I should have gone a week early. ”

Gao Shan Xing's emotional intelligence is not low, alleviating the awkward atmosphere, and knowingly asked, "Your sister?"

"Lu Ping, don't you have an invitation?"

Gao Shan Xing was stunned: "I really haven't received the invitation." ”

Cao Yun was also stunned: "Let's change the topic again?" How are these ribs pickled?"

Everyone commented casually, after Cao Yun contacted Lu Qun, he showed his mobile phone to Gao Shan Xing, and Lu Qun replied to Cao Yun: "Gao Shan Xing has a relationship with me, and has nothing to do with Lu Ping, so Lu Ping will personally call and invite." ”

Soon the ribs were finished, everyone chatted and drank tea, and Sonny mentioned the flames. Cao Yun first said that he had nothing to do with Blaze, and he didn't know about all the issues related to Blaze and hyenas, and he didn't participate. Others are naturally less informed.

After three rounds of tea, they took their leave.

After getting into the car, Sonny asked, "Fengxue, let's say Cao Yun can help the little girl overturn the case, because you interjected, he didn't appear in court." What do you think?"

Wind and snow: "......"

"People don't treat you as an outsider, they don't see you as a pure policeman, that's why they openly say the gambling contract. That's right, your behavior is right, and it's right to stop others from breaking the law......" Sonny said halfway, looking at Fengxue with a chagrined expression: "Forget it, it's okay, you are indeed right, you are the police, you should say so." ”

Feng Xue: "Is it right?"

Sonny: "You can measure it that way. We arrested a big poisonous bird, and a witness testified that he had stolen his wallet, would you handle it separately and notify the police station to take the witness away and investigate his theft?"

Feng Xue didn't dare to answer.

Sonny: "Cao Yun belongs to the small boss level, Li Mo gave him a lot of green lights, why? Li Mo gave him the green light because Cao Yun was handsome? Of course not, it was because Cao Yun had this ability, so he had the green light." Assuming that Cao Yun and Lu Yihang really gambled, and you arrested them, Cao Yun called Li Long, would Li Long give Cao Yun this face?"

There was silence in the car for a long time, and Feng Xue asked: "If because of what I said, the little girl was finally convicted......

Sonny said: "No, Cao Yun will not change his views and thoughts because you are happy or unhappy, you are not qualified yet." People just said that because the atmosphere was awkward, giving you steps. ”

......

As Sonny said, Fengxue didn't know if Cao Yun and Lu Yihang had bet on ribs, but Cao Yun attended the trial of the little girl's case three days later. The case has already been heard once, and if there are no new witnesses and new clues in this court, the closing arguments will be made, the jury will give their opinions, and the judge will make a ruling based on the opinions, and the first trial will be concluded.

Nine-tails entered the courtroom, and when he saw Cao Yun at first sight, his heart couldn't help but beat. Nine-tails took a deep breath and sat down silently, she would rather admit that she was Huaichun than admit that she saw Cao Yun's weak heart. Nine-Tails looked through her own information, and the information she had gave her a great sense of security. It's her weapon, the perfect powerful weapon.

At the beginning of the trial, Cao Yun stood up first: "The defense requests witness No. 1 to appear in court. ”

Nine-tails looked at the No. 1 witness information, and it was a woman named Chiko. Cao Yun did not say anything about Qianzi's situation. Since the witness was only presented to the court yesterday afternoon, Nine-Tails did not know that there was such a witness until this morning, and she did not inquire about Chiko's background. However, the Nine-Tails are confident that they did not find out the existence of Chiko among the people involved.

Chiko was indeed not involved in the case, she is a psychologist, and she testified in court about one thing, proving two academic terms. The first term is retrograde forgetfulness, and the second term is post-traumatic emergency disorder.

To put it simply, sometimes people can't remember the information when an accident happens. This is not uncommon in medicine and is relatively common in judicial circles. Most of them are women who are persecuted (the law stipulates that women over the age of 14 are considered women, and it is illegal for any woman over the age of 14 not to recognize her status as a woman), who are unable to recall the details of the previous persecution, and whose memories before and after the persecution are fragmented.

Chiko told everyone that this is the self-protection of the human body. When a person is very disgusted with things, he will selectively forget about them as a way to protect himself. Just like crying and fainting at the sight of a loved one's death, extreme grief causes the brain to choose to protect the person and make him unconscious.

Cao Yun asked the little girl if this was the case, and Qianzi said that she was not sure if the little girl had it or not. She just said that there was a possibility. Because many diagnoses in psychology are subjective diagnoses, unlike traditional medicine, there are X-rays and laboratory reports. It has also led to psychology being considered pseudoscience by many scientists. Because science that can't be proven is not science.

Cao Yun: "The reason why the defendant's confession, transcripts, and words were confused during the trial, and even the words did not reach the meaning were because the defendant was frightened, her brain deceived her, and she made up some information in her own brain and believed it. Following witness No. 1's statement, I implore the judge to skip the question of the witness at the scene for the time being. ”

The judge asked, "Please be clear." Of course, he understood what Cao Yun meant, but he had to take into account the jury's situation.

Cao Yundao: "To prove the defendant's innocence, it is not necessarily necessary to fully understand the situation at the scene of the crime at that time. Since the prosecution questioned the defendant about the scene at the last court session, the defendant's answers were unsatisfactory and unsatisfactory, and it was easy to leave a wrong impression on the jury. Witness No. 1 stated that the defendant may have a mental disorder and therefore implored the judge to allow him to skip the question of the scene of the crime for the time being. ”

The judge said: "If the defendant can be proven guilty or innocent in other areas, of course it can." ”

"Thank you, Judge. Cao Yun took the information: "First of all, we have to get to know what kind of person the defendant is? This is a summary of my her: she is a delicate woman who has been well-respected since she was a child. There are no records of violations, not even speeding or parking tickets. Defendant Hai is a volunteer at the Home of the Wanderers, and spends half a day a week volunteering. The homeless house is to take in all kinds of pet cats and dogs abandoned by their owners. I have a copy of the comments of the volunteers of the Homeless House on the accused, so you can listen to them as you like. ”