"Why?" Yun Yin asked, this price can be said to be unprecedented and unprecedented.

Jiuwei said: "I also think that this case is too heavy, and there is a certain room for manipulation, why don't you take it Cao Yun?"

Cao Yun said: "The first reason is the problem of human feelings. I can't offend a lot of people for the sake of a retired director. For example, Ma Yuan and I have a good relationship, and I will not offend him for no reason. The second reason is the issue of public opinion. I don't take these key people into account in this daily life, but this case is not just a complaint. Strictly speaking, it was already a duel between good and evil, because no one could convince them that Wang Sun was not guilty to death. ”

Cao Yun: "The third reason is to put aside the identity of a lawyer. I personally believe that although Wang Sun's sin is not to death, death is not necessarily unjust. Dead or alive. ”

Cao Yun: "The fourth reason is that the difficulty is too high. I looked at the photocopied materials, and there was no strong evidence from Wang Sun's side that he had no intention of killing the deceased. On the contrary, the money, the DNA of her face, the torn tunics, and the bruises on the deceased's body all indicate that she was brutally murdered against the top of the wall. ”

Cao Yun looked at the nine tails: "You are also a person with a lawyer's certificate, so if you are interested, take the case." ”

Yun Yin said: "Cao Yun, I'm here to help you pull business." It is said that Wang Zhan also found Fang Yuan, the country's No. 1 lawyer. ”

Fang Yuan, male, 54 years old, his criminal victory rate is much lower than Ouyang Yi's. But his power lies not in torture, but in avoiding death. He's an expert at it. Fang Yuan took over more than fifteen cases of hanging review, one was not guilty, seven were hanged, and the remaining seven criminals involved were exempted from the death penalty.

Fang Yuan is known in the industry as a death-free official.

Cao Yun nodded: "Very good, very good." ”

Yun Yin: "Then?"

Cao Yun nodded again: "Then that's it, ...... Don't be so big, it's best to clean up the house. ”

Yun Yin was speechless, you didn't like this house together. In other words, Cao Yun really didn't fancy this house, and too many people were needed to maintain the operation of this manor. However, one thing is one thing, Cao Yun doesn't want to take this case.

There is no shortage of money, Cao Yun is no longer short. There are hundreds of millions of people, and they don't care much about hundreds of millions, and Cao Yun can't spend them anyway. Of course, a few hundred million less is a matter of concern.

……

After sending Yun Yin away, Cao Yun said to the Nine Tails: "Aren't you idle and bored? You asked Sima Luo to send you all the information about Wang Sun's case." We have a trial after dinner, and you are the prosecutor for the retrial, and I am the defense lawyer. ”

Nine-Tails: "Wait, retrial? You have to apply before a retrial, and the application needs to be approved, and it's usually very difficult to be approved." After the application is approved, a hearing will be held to review the need for a retrial. ”

Cao Yundao: "This case was a model case of Tianma Law Firm at that time, and the pressure of public opinion on the judiciary is a fact. I'm quite familiar with this case. We have all done it all, including application, hearing, and retrial. They will be jurors or judges. "It's been a long time since classes have been held, and there are ready-made prosecutors to practice, so you don't have to use them in vain.

Not only can he practice his hands, but Wei Jun and Lu Yihang can also practice with the nine tails. Cao Yun's familiarity with the Nine-Tails has reached the point where she sold her, and she not only helped herself count the money, but also thanked herself.

……

Everyone came back in the afternoon and was very interested in the game. The greatest sense of accomplishment as a lawyer is to win a lawsuit that is impossible to win.

If you want to talk about the death penalty review lawsuit, you have to mention Fang Yuan. Fang Yuan is the best at using sympathy cards, and he himself is an important member of the civil anti-death penalty group. He held high the banner of anti-death punishment and led a group of exploited people to exert pressure on justice, and he was portrayed as an anti-death penalty hero.

This cannot but mention the situation in the Eastern Tang Dynasty, where the death sentences of each Tang Dynasty had to be submitted to the Minister of Justice for approval and signature. The Minister of Justice was reluctant to sign such a letter because it could easily be attacked by political opponents. There have even been cases of people who have delayed for two years and still do not sign after retiring.

However, the chances of applying for reconsideration are very low. Most death row inmates are only retaining their lives, not being spared death.

The application needs a reason, and it cannot be only a subjective reason, such as remorse, etc., which will definitely not be approved. Second, the reasons presented cannot be those of the defense in the first and second trials. For example, in the case of Wang Sun, the circumstances of the guilty plea have been denied, and it is impossible to write an application on this ground.

There were still twenty minutes before the court session, and Jiuwei and Cao Yun sat very close. After all, Cao Yun only has memory, and he needs accurate details, so he must look at the materials that Nine-Tails got back. Although the Nine-Tails knew about the Wang Sun case, it was the first time that they were in such a short period of preparation, and they were quite embarrassed. A table of materials was scattered around.

Lu Yihang counted the seconds: "The last ten minutes." ”

Nine-tails couldn't find what he wanted, Cao Yun sat there and read the confession leisurely to interfere with himself, so Nine-Tails used violence to push Cao Yun's head and push it aside.

"Wow!" the onlookers exclaimed, seeing the violent side of the Nine-Tails for the first time.

Nine-Tails didn't have time to pay attention, she still had some information that she hadn't seen. Later, the whole person pressed on Cao Yun's back, and the probe reached out to find information. The audience looked at each other, Lu Yihang shook his head, he thought that Cao Yun could not calculate so accurately, and it was still difficult to eat tofu so accurately.

Ye Jiao shook her head, she thought that Cao Yun was deliberately interfering with the Nine-Tails to achieve the purpose of physical contact.

Gao Shan Xing is noncommittal, what is wrong with eating tofu? You are next to each other, who eats whose tofu is not certain?

……

"It's time!" Lu Yihang's words fell, and the nine-tails sat down and let out a big breath. Its otherwise neat hair was disheveled. Nine-Tails apparently noticed this, biting the rubber band and holding his hair temporarily.

Girls bite rubber bands and hold their hair with their hands is an alternative beauty, Cao Yun stared and watched. Nine-tails glared angrily, Cao Yun smiled and continued to watch.

Ye Jiao walked by the Nine-Tails and said in his ear, "He deliberately made you angry. "Sit in your seat.

The three judges sat in the center, and on the left and right were Cao Yun and the Nine Tails. Gao Shan Xing spoke first: "That Cao Yun, you come first." ”

Cao Yundao: "The reason why I asked for a review of Wang Sun's death sentence is because I think Wang Sun and the deceased were in a relationship at that time. There is no such thing as a failed tip. ”

The three judges threw toast at Cao Yun together.

"What the hell?" Cao Yun slapped the toast off, picked up a transcript and said, "This is the testimony of the deceased's boyfriend, who persuaded the deceased to stop working for Wang Sun a month ago. The two also quarreled because of this, and the deceased's boyfriend complained to himself, saying that he had no money, and you looked down on me and so on. This was mentioned in the transcript by both the deceased's friend and the deceased's boyfriend's friend in response to police interpersonal questioning. ”

Cao Yun: "Her boyfriend suspected that the deceased had an affair with Wang Sun. According to Wang Sun's confession, the deceased asked him to resign, and Wang Sun offered ten times the price to keep the deceased. At the same time, a gift was given to the deceased, a ticket to a concert. Her boyfriend quarreled again with the deceased over the concert, because there was only one ticket, and the concert featured the deceased's favorite star. Her boyfriend decided that Wang Sun was sitting next door. In the end, the deceased's boyfriend took a ticket to attend the concert, and sure enough, Wang Sun sat next door. After returning home, the two sides quarreled again. ”

Cao Yun: "So to a certain extent, there is indeed an ambiguous relationship between Wang Sun and the deceased. ”

Nine-Tails: "The question is not whether Wang Sun has a love for the deceased, but whether the deceased has an ambiguous heart for Wang Sun." ”

Cao Yun: "This question can be explained in Exhibit No. 59, which is recorded in a diary. It was raining heavily after work, and Wang Sun sent an umbrella downstairs. According to the diary, I can't imagine that Xiaobawang's heart also has its delicate side. He's actually not that annoying. ”

Cao Yun: "It's not once or twice that Wang Sun got drunk outside, and the deceased stayed overnight many times, all because Wang Sun was drunk. There was even a time when the deceased went to a bar at one o'clock in the morning to fish for Wang Sun. It can be seen that the deceased's feelings for Wang Sun are not only the feelings of the employer and the employee. ”

Cao Yun: "Lu Yihang, do we have feelings?"

Lu Yihang: "No, you're a vampire. ”

Cao Yun is very satisfied with Lu Yihang's cooperation: "Looking at society, the pure employer-employee relationship is very cold. It can even be said that it is a relationship of mutual utilization. In this case, it is clear that the relationship between Wang Sun and the deceased has exceeded this relationship. I agree that the deceased did not formally associate with Wang Sun, but I must also admit that the deceased has been in a state of vacillation. ”

Gao Shan Xing: "Although I know that I am full of nonsense, but there is some truth in what I said, how did you do it?"

Cao Yundao: "It's very simple, confusing concepts. Nine-Tails can put me to death if he makes a counter-argument. That is the poverty of the dead and the good-heartedness. ”

Ye Jiao reminded in a low voice: "Two." ”

Cao Yun tilted his head and let out a murderous aura, and Ye Jiao bowed his head to apologize.

Cao Yun said: "The deceased was a very kind girl, and in her world, there is only beauty. She believes that even the worst person has his merits. The same is true for Wang Sun. The dead did not fall in love, or were shaken. Looking at the actual case, only when Wang Sun has no one to take care of him and is drunk, the deceased will accompany Wang Sun. ”

Cao Yun: "Furthermore, lawyer Cao also said that Wang Sun offered ten times the salary to make the deceased give up his resignation. For the deceased, ten times the salary meant many, many things to her. She also didn't want to lose her employer because she was slacking off at work. In other words, it's a kind of helplessness of life. The reason why the deceased took care of the drunk Wang Sun was also partly due to the high salary offered by Wang Sun. It is true that employers and employees do not have much affection, but executives with high salaries do not want their bosses to fall even if they have no feelings for them. Because the collapse of the boss will inevitably directly affect the interests of the executives. ”

Cao Yun: "Let's look at exhibit No. 59 again, lawyer Cao said that the diary shows that the deceased had a certain affection for Wang Sun. I think it's the opposite, and it can be seen between the lines that it is not easy for the deceased to find a little bit of merit in Wang Sun. And this sentence: in fact he is not that nasty. It means that the deceased originally hated Wang Sun very much, and after sending the umbrella, Wang Sun just made her less annoying and still hating. ”

Cao Yun: "Let's watch the concert again, and the protagonist of the concert is the deceased's favorite singer. Even so, in order to appease his boyfriend, the deceased finally gave the ticket to his boyfriend and gave up the opportunity to get close to his idol. It can be understood in this way, first, the deceased was very frank with his boyfriend, and thought that he had nothing to do with Wang Sun. Second, the deceased's boyfriend has surpassed idols in the deceased's heart. ”

Cao Yun: "Lawyer Cao has repeatedly mentioned the issue of the quarrel between the deceased and her boyfriend, and the core is Wang Sun. One shows that the deceased's boyfriend loved the deceased, and the other the deceased did not take advantage of the situation to break up, or show friendship with Wang Sun, which proves that the deceased had no love for Wang Sun. ”

Cao Yun: "Therefore, Lawyer Cao's statement that the deceased had ambiguity with Wang Sun is purely conjecture. ”

Judge Gao Shan Xing slapped the table: "If the application is not approved, go back and wait for death." ”

Cao Yun: "Wait, judge, don't worry! We got two pieces of information from the previous debate. The first message is that the deceased does not love Wang Sun. The second message, Wang Sun likes the dead. ”

Cao Yun: "The reason for my second application is that Wang Sun did not have the intention of killing the deceased, it was just an accident. First of all, let's make a clear question, does a strong kiss represent a tipping wall? According to the statistics of the tipping case, very few people will kiss the victim by force, and the most common actions are beating, intimidating, and tearing clothes. Only after the girl stops resisting, there is a strong kissing action. ”

Cao Yun began to explain the case in detail, arguing that the reason why Wang Sun was angry was not because the deceased rebelled against the top of his wall, but because he refused to show his love. His goal was always to kiss strongly, and after the deceased's head hit the wall, Wang Sun still kissed lightly, not lightly.

According to Wang Sun's confession, after the girl's head hit the wall, he thought for a while that the girl had given up resistance and accepted him. In this case, it should be the crime of negligence causing death, not the crime of intentional homicide.

Cao Yun jumped to the side of the Nine-Tails again and began to refute his remarks. Judging from the scene, Wang Sun grabbed the deceased's clothes and pushed them, and pushed the deceased to the wall with his own impact force, and the force was beyond what people could bear.

Cao Yun jumped back and argued from the theory of human self-preservation that according to human instinct, when the deceased is pushed to the wall, he should have his back against the wall and absorb the power from his back. The deceased is the head absorbs the power, there is only one possibility, last night the deceased because of the all-night, coupled with the previous resistance, too much force, lack of oxygen in the brain, lack of judgment in the body function. His death was not a foreseeable result for Wang Sun, so the theory of intentional homicide is not valid.

Cao Yun jumped again, and after the deceased died, Wang Sun stopped attacking. In other words, it is impossible for Wang Sun to stop attacking before the death of the deceased. So even if the deceased instinctively used his back to hit the wall to protect himself for the first time, he couldn't resist Wang Sun's second attack and third attack. And from the description of the other party, it can be explained that Wang Sun's purpose is to make the deceased give up resistance, and he will not hesitate to die as a means to make the deceased give up resistance.

Cao Yun jumped back again......

Nine-Tails was tired, and for the first time, she felt the gap between real and up close. Cao Yun's greatest ability is to turn the evidence in favor of the deceased into unfavorable evidence for the deceased, or for the deceased. It can also turn the evidence against the criminal into a criminal with great benefit.

Cao Yun analyzed several reasons that were enough to pass the review. Cao Yun refuted Cao Yun on several reasons, which made the review impossible.

In ancient times, a girl went on a blind date, and the other party was handsome and shy: it was all up to her parents. The other party is ugly, and the daughter still wants to be filial to her parents again, and she doesn't want to leave lightly. Although the results of the above two reasons are very different, they have their similarities. That's the truth. Both horizontal and vertical make sense.

The Nine-Tails didn't know that Lu Yihang and Wei Jun had always coveted Cao Yun's ability, but it was difficult to show it when they were present. The worst thing is that you can't imitate it, and you lose your own style, and the result is easy to be misunderstood for a quibble. Now they don't dare to play like this, and they use it in a flash of inspiration, and they don't dare to use it as their main defense strategy.

This is not a deep level, Cao Yun started classes for one purpose, but is there any other purpose? Why did Cao Yun ask questions and answer them by himself? Why did Cao Yun put forward multiple reasons for appealing?

Yun Yin left in the morning, and after making an appointment with the Nine Tails to hold the court in the evening, Cao Yun contacted Ma Yuan privately. Cao Yun and Ma Yuan are familiar, no matter what, Ma Yuan wants to accept Cao Yun as his son-in-law, but it's a pity that the young man doesn't call. As for Wang Zhan, I don't know. Ma Yuan talked about Wang Zhan, and after being silent for a long time, he replied: The hatred is as deep as the sea.

After receiving a lot of information, the Nine-Tails, with its firm judicial character, will inevitably feed all the information back to the prosecution. Once Fang Yuan used the same reasons as Cao Yun in the application and hearing, the prosecution could draw a scoop according to the gourd and cover Fang Yuan. As for whether Wang Sun's final unjust death was the Fa-rectification, Cao Yun didn't care.

From the perspective of Cao Yun's values, Wang Sun's life is not more expensive than the life of the deceased. Cao Yun cares about right and wrong, not dead or alive. Because that's the judge's business.