Chapter 484: Analysis
Bai Xue nodded in agreement with Zuo Luo's statement that the lawyer's motive for committing the crime was not established, and continued: "Next is the nanny, the nanny is the elder of the deceased's family of two dynasties, in her twenties because of the loss of her husband in the countryside, was despised by the villagers, and the first job she came to work in the city was the nanny of the deceased's parents' family. After the death of the deceased's parents, she became the deceased's nanny, and she served the deceased's parents' family for fourteen years and the deceased for fourteen years. According to the lawyer, the deceased was planning to fire the nanny because the nanny had grown up with her and had the attitude of an adoptive mother. The deceased's first marriage was a nanny matchmaking, but after the marriage, the deceased found that her husband was a scumbag. In the second marriage with A, the nanny was very opposed and gave A many times ugly, which made the deceased who loved A very dissatisfied. The most important thing is that before the death of the deceased's parents, ask the nanny to help watch the deceased, and at the same time promise that the deceased will let the deceased give the nanny a pension to the end, and even if the nanny wants to go home in the future, the deceased will give the nanny a sum of money. According to our understanding, the nanny often mentions that the deceased's parents explain their own affairs, and the deceased's behavior is quite restricted, and the deceased was more tolerant because of the parents' confession earlier, but he has lost patience with the nanny, and after falling in love with A, he fully revealed his emotions. The nanny chatted with the neighbor's nanny, and the nanny meant that the conflict between her and the deceased was due to A's provocation. ”
Bai Xue: "The biggest conflict is that the deceased intends to give two commercial houses to A, and the nanny is firmly opposed, she said that one of them is the old owner's residence. The deceased insisted, and the nanny was very angry, and when the food was served, she deliberately poured the hot food on A. The deceased was very annoyed and asked the nanny to pack up and go home on the spot. The nanny later admitted her mistake and begged, the deceased felt unhappy and persuaded the nanny to be dismissed, and the deceased agreed that according to normal circumstances, there would be a new nanny to interview tomorrow, and if successful, the nanny would leave the post immediately. The lawyer said that the deceased had prepared four million for the nanny, which was a thank you for taking care of her over the years. The money babysitter didn't know. ”
Bai Xue: "The nanny has a clear time to commit the crime, the first time period, when A and the lawyer are in the living room, the nanny is wandering nearby, as for how much time it will disappear, the lawyer and A can't say clearly. Asked if they had seen the babysitter go upstairs, they weren't sure. The second time period is when the police arrive, and the nanny goes upstairs alone to look for the deceased. ”
"Is the villa soundproofed very well?"
"Yes, the villa is a newly renovated villa, the deceased paid great attention to sleep because of the pressure of work, and also said that the deceased should never disturb the deceased during the nap, the deceased would have a very bad temper at that time, even to himself. Therefore, the doors and windows of the bedroom are specially designed, and during the nap, it is customary for the deceased's mobile phone to be transferred to his assistant and not to answer any calls. ”
Bai Xue said: "The murder weapon is a fruit knife on the fruit basket in the bedroom, a knife stabbed in the heart, the physical evidence team simulated, go upstairs, kill, go downstairs, the process only takes twenty seconds." Judging from the scene, the deceased and the murderer did not go through any verbal communication, and the murderer took advantage of the deceased's sleeping state to do it directly, very resolute and decisive, and at the same time had certain medical knowledge. ”
In homicide cases, if there is a strong will to kill someone, if there is no medical common sense, there is usually not only one knife, unless you are frightened. But judging from the scene, the murderer has long been mature and thinking about killing.
Bai Xue said: "The last suspect, the deceased's ex-husband was a surgeon who was addicted to gambling and not only lost his job, but also went into debt. He had plenty of time to commit the crime, but according to the analysis of the criminal police team, his suspicion was very small, because he came to find the deceased with the purpose of borrowing money, but it didn't make sense to kill the deceased without any dialogue. ”
Zoro said: "In the first case, the deceased and her ex-husband met, maybe the deceased saw her ex-husband who came in in the living room, and then went upstairs to rest, she didn't want her new husband to know." The ex-husband went from the backyard stairs to the bedroom, the two fell apart, and the ex-husband turned back and killed the deceased after leaving. In the second case, the ex-husband did not know the news of the deceased's remarriage, and came to borrow money that day, and suddenly heard about it, and his psychology was seriously shocked. ”
Bai Xue nodded, she didn't analyze, and continued: "The residences and related items of several suspects have been legally searched, and no items related to the murder of the deceased have been found. ”
There are basically so many details of the case, and the rest is to read the information yourself.
Ten minutes later, Zoro asked, "What do you think, Sherlock Holmes Sue?"
Su Cheng looked at the big screen and said: "There are several accidents in this case that make me uncomfortable, the first accident, the time when B appeared, it happened to be the deceased's lunch break, of course, B has been deceived by A, and it is logical to hear the news and kill him." The second accident is that the time when the deceased's ex-husband borrowed money happened to be the time of the deceased's wedding banquet. In the third accident, the deceased's ex-husband, who was tangled in the back door, became a witness, proving that no one climbed over the back wall. Detective Left, what do you think?"
"There are a few suspicions, B stabbed A, the nanny was close to the gate at the time, intercepted B, scuffled outside the door, the lawyer helped, everything was in line with common sense and logic, and it was no problem. The problem was that the lawyer subdued B and asked the nanny to call the property security guard, but why didn't she call the hospital? It was the security guard who called the hospital, and the hospital confirmed that if it was a few minutes late, it would be a matter of probability whether A could be saved. Secondly, they had five minutes during the time when the ambulance took A away, and the ambulance took A until the patrol arrived, and they had another three to four minutes, so why didn't they think to inform the deceased?
Su Cheng touched his chin, pondered Zuoluo's words, and said, "If you want to talk about doubts, I care about a contradiction. B is A's girlfriend, knowing that her boyfriend is suddenly getting married, and the bride is not herself, she is on fire, and she has a murder weapon, which is reasonable. But why is there only one knife? One knife is normal, but combined with her desperate resistance and struggle outside the gate, I think there should be a few more knives. ”
"Be serious, what about handling the case?" Zuo Luo said: "Is it interesting to ridicule A? From my personal point of view, I can understand A's behavior." Having said that, why is it that when a woman marries a rich man, she is a talented woman, and if a man marries a rich man, she is a scumbag? The charm of money, whether you admit it or not, is there. Watching A's video just now, I think the deceased's feelings for A moved A's heart. ”
Su Cheng agreed, and said: "At present, except for the opportunity for the nanny to go upstairs after a police officer arrives, it seems that the opportunities for others to kill people are not sufficient." In fact, the nanny was close to invisibility, and when A and the lawyer were talking about the transfer of the commercial house, she was angry in her heart and quietly went upstairs to kill the deceased, so it was impossible for her to go to the deceased's bedroom alone after the police arrived. Killing the deceased after the police arrive is a stupid opportunity. ”
Song Kai interjected: "I know criminals who are ten times stupider than this. ”
Zuo Luo asked Song Kai not to speak and asked, "Detective Su, what do you mean?"
"If this case is not a nanny murder, then it must be a conspiracy to commit murder. Su Cheng explained: "Everyone lacks a favorable opportunity to kill, but two people can create an opportunity to kill, and create accidents and contradictions." ”
Su Cheng took a marker pen and wrote on the paper plate: "The first group, A and B, there is a considerable possibility of collusion, the power of love." But their combination has been under the noses of lawyers and nannies, and their collusion has created no real opportunities. The second group, A and the lawyer, conspired together to create a considerable opportunity, and during the paperwork details, the nanny went to the kitchen to clean up, and they provided each other with proof of presence. However, they collude with one large and one small, and it is difficult to coordinate. ”
Zoro asked: "You said that the lawyer called the security guard, but did not call an ambulance, could it be that he wanted to take the opportunity to kill A?
"That's right, both the lawyer and the nanny subconsciously wanted to kill A, so they deliberately ignored the fact that A was stabbed and delayed calling the hospital. The nanny must be eager for A to die, and the lawyer may be envious and jealous of A?" Su Cheng continued: "The next group of combinations, the lawyer and the nanny, these two have not known each other for a year or two, both of them are unwilling, and they may conspire." The lawyer dragged A in the living room, and the nanny went upstairs from the backyard to kill the deceased, but after the police arrived, the nanny went to find the deceased alone, which was not right, plus the murderer and the deceased did not have a dialogue, and went straight to the action, I have ruled out the possibility that the nanny is the murderer. ”
Zoro asked, "Will you want to get away with it?"
"No, the murderer in this case did a good job, and the overly complicated plan will leave flaws, so I'll rule out the nanny for the time being. Su Cheng said: "The lawyer and the ex-husband conspired, this may seem to be the most likely to succeed, the lawyer dragged the person, called the ex-husband or notified by other means, the ex-husband climbed over, from the backyard stairs to the second floor to kill people." The formation of this conspiracy required that both of them hated the deceased, and judging from the interrogation video, it seems to rule out this possibility, and both of them lacked interest in the death of the deceased. ”
Su Cheng: "A conspired with her ex-husband, this is a bit nonsense...... Actually, I'm concerned about the possibility of B and her ex-husband colluding. ”
"Oh?"
"B created a big 'sweep' chaos, struggled to resist, and created opportunities and time for her ex-husband, so as to ensure that the living room was lively during this time period, and no one would pay attention to the story from the backyard to the upstairs. Secondly, how can the ex-husband leave? The back door wall, since there is a back door, there must be a door, just open the door and leave. I see that the back door is an automatic pop lock, the inside is easy to open, and it is locked as soon as it is closed. This solves the accident of the ex-husband, as well as the accident of B. ”
Zoro asked, "What is the possibility of their conspiracy?"
"They both lost their lovers, but after looking at A's injuries, I felt that B should not be a conspirator. The knife was so hard that it missed the point, but it almost killed someone. Su Cheng asked, "Is this considered an attempted murder, or is it intentional wounding?"
Zuo Luo said: "It depends on subjective will, B carried a murder weapon, and the part of the stab was close to the vital point, which is an attempted murder." The plot is three to ten years, and A's attitude is quite guilty of B, and if victim A intercedes, it is estimated that it will be three years...... That's right, B doesn't seem to make sense to conspire with people, the target is the deceased, she doesn't need to hang herself for three years, she can smash things, bite people and other means, and she can also achieve the goal of making noise. ”
Su Cheng asked rhetorically: "Can't run away from the crime?"
Zuo Luo nodded: "Physical evidence, human witnesses, confessions, and the act of carrying a murder weapon, the criminal crime belongs to the public prosecution, and even if you bring a lawyer team, you can't run away." ”
Su Cheng thought thoughtfully: "Is the search warrant of these people still valid?"
"To reapply. "Here it is again, there is that expression again, and what is guessed. Su Cheng also speculated before, but that was the meaning of taking it out and discussing it with everyone.
"Then reapply, I want search warrants from A, B, lawyer and ex-husband, personal information, mobile phone, Internet information, residence, personal belongings. ”
Zuo Luo hurriedly said: "No, the search warrant can be applied, but they are only suspects at the moment, and there is no clear evidence." It is not possible to search in all aspects. For example, it is more difficult to live, and it is easy to inquire about personal information. In particular......"
Zuo Luo was halfway through his words, someone knocked on the door, and after Zuo Luo said please come in, Lu Yi appeared. Zuo Luo looked at Lu Ren and finished what he said: "Especially when there is an internal affairs bureau staring at it." ”
Lu Yiyi smiled awkwardly: "It doesn't seem to be very popular, I was in the seventh group last time, isn't it just a chores." ”
Song Kai and Bai Xue stepped forward to shake hands with Lu Yi: "Welcome, welcome to the supervision." ”
Lu Yiyi said modestly: "Miscellaneous, miscellaneous, do you drink water?" Su Cheng, your black tea?"
"Yes. Su Cheng replied, and Lu Yi immediately entered the boiling water room.
Su Cheng looked at the big screen and looked at the details of the last search warrant, last time there was a search of several residences, in fact, only B and the lawyer had a residence, the nanny lived in a villa, A also lived in a villa, and her ex-husband is now living in a college classmate's house. Su Cheng thought for a while: "I want a search warrant for personal information." ”
Zuo Luo said: "Do you have to sell Guanzi?"
"It's about Detective Su's reputation, and it must be sold. ”
Lu Yi came out with water: "Your atmosphere is much better than I thought, and you put yourself into work so quickly." ”
Zoro said: "What's the matter? I still have to give your Internal Affairs Bureau a New Year's greeting before we can start work?"
"Huh. This is a normal attitude, Lu Ren put a handful of water in front of Zuo Luo: "Zuo team, I just mix some salary......"
Bai Xue couldn't listen to it: "Lu Yi, you mix up your salary, your level of lying is too low." If you say that, I think you have bad intentions. ”
Lu Ren laughed at himself: "I'm just a watchdog, you should scold." ”
Zoro was also a little embarrassed to say this, and said: "Okay, it's all for work, I understand your work, although I hate you, but your existence is very meaningful." But ......"
Lu Yi accepted it in front, but when he heard it, he was slightly nervous: "But?"
"You, Lu Yi, are getting more and more cunning now. Before, you felt some human affection between the seven groups of us. Today, I look at you respectfully, and I began to learn the antiques of the Internal Affairs Bureau, hiding a knife in my smile, and being murderous and restrained. Zoro stood up: "It's okay, if we have a favor in our two departments, there is no law." ”
Lu Ren was a little helpless: "Either I say that there are few people and friends in the Internal Affairs Bureau, and I am grateful to the left team if you can understand this step." ”
Speaking of which, Su Cheng's phone vibrate, looked at the number, smiled helplessly, and answered the phone: "Hey......" Find this site to search for "CM" or enter the URL:.