During the trial, Shangguanwen explained from the perspective of psychology that the deceased had the mentality of touching porcelain, but lacked the courage to touch porcelain. Men crossing the road not once or twice, men can be seen crossing the road at least twice a day on the same road section. The colleague persuaded the man, and the man replied that if he was hit, the driver would be unlucky.

After the first hearing, the judge wanted the case to be settled. The man was at fault first, that's for sure, the prosecution could not prove the driver's mistake from the process, only from the results. The judge mediated and asked the driver to compensate the deceased a certain amount of money, and the case was closed.

Shangguanwen asked Bai Su what he meant, and Bai Su told Shangguanwen that Lao Li had driven him for thirty years and had not had any accidents. Can't be ruined by a bastard. As a result, Shangguanwen not only did not accept mediation, but also sued the family of the deceased to compensate for the loss of the vehicle.

In the end, the case was heard four times, and finally Shangguanwen won the case, and the driver was not only not guilty, but the family of the deceased must pay 150,000 yuan in compensation for the damage to the car. What's even more ruthless is that more than 60 days later, Shangguanwen applied for compulsory enforcement, did not accept the postponement of mediation, and the court seized and auctioned the deceased's property with a 27-year mortgage in accordance with the law.

It can be seen that Shangguanwen is very loyal to Bai Su. Being able to serve as a department head and senior manager under the leadership of the president is a necessary quality. That little money is not money at all for Bai Su, her purpose is to maintain her driver, and even at the expense of telling the truth. After all, Shangguanwen's aggressive pursuit and killing does not conform to the mainstream morality of society, and it is very rich and unkind.

Cao Yun did not know Shangguanwen through this case, but had a better understanding of Bai Su. You don't need to know Shangguanwen, the director of the legal department of the Universe Group, there is definitely nothing to say about the strength. However, the number of court arguments is not many, and it is difficult to say how much strength he can exert during the trial. It's a pity that the information doesn't explain the reason why Shangguanwen participated in Xu's father's case, and Cao Yun is even more curious about this.

Looking at the information on Xu's father's case, it is basically the same as that of the police and the prosecution. However, there are more explanations from Xu's father and the chartered wife.

The day of the crime was the night after the first cold wave hit last winter, and Wang Xia died between 10:50 and 11 o'clock. Xu's father said that after he left Wang's fish soup at 10:30 that night, he went to squat and step on the charter wife, and found that the charter wife went home from the mahjong parlor opposite his house at 11:5. If the evidence is true, it can be proved that Xu's father is not the murderer.

In the list of witnesses, the charter wife is prominently listed, and it also includes the owner of the mahjong parlor, who is also a friend of the charter wife.

Among the witnesses was a person who was a very stranger to Cao Yun, his name was Okazaki, and he was the owner of a fish soup shop near Wang's fish soup, which was not very close, and the distance between the two shops was more than 300 meters in a straight line. Okazaki, like Xu's father, was a second-time palace officer, and it was specifically noted that they were cellmates, and the second time the two were released from prison only two months apart.

Could it be that Okazaki is the murderer?

……

The quality of the food has dropped significantly, and it is no longer a buffet, nor is it an order. It's a boxed lunch. Two meat and one vegetable, the taste has also dropped a notch.

After dinner, rested all night, and after breakfast, the first trial of Xu's father's case began.

The hearing was not only Cao Yun, but also six or seven young lawyers, all of whom were slightly older than Cao Yun and had just handled or were about to handle cases independently. The first is to chase exposure, and the second is to accumulate experience. At the same time, it also shows that the Flame Court did not take the police into account at least in this trial. It also explains the reason for the decline in the quality of the meals. There are too many people, and most of them are unrelated people. For example, a jury is eleven people who do not need to exist, do you agree not guilty and the real court will change the verdict of not guilty?

Judge No. 1: "Given the position of the police, this trial may end at any time. I also explain to the police that you definitely want to catch us, and even if you have clues, please wait until the case is heard. Do not interrupt this hearing. For we are crying out for a man who has been wronged by you and sentenced to death. ”

Judge No. 1: "The trial begins." ”

Sima Luo began to read the indictment, Cao Yun looked at the defense seat, Guo Xiaotian, Shangguanwen were all listed, and Xu Na was also among them. Little girl, what are you doing to make a fuss?

After Sima Luo finished reading, Guo Xiaotian stood up first: "My name is Guo Xiaotian, and I am a lawyer from Galaxy Law Firm, and I will explain here that I did not voluntarily go to the Flame Court. Since I'm here, I'll definitely do my best. To get back to business, first of all, I have a question about a detail that the prosecution said. The prosecution said that the couple met Xu's father near Wang's fish soup at around 11 p.m. on the day of the crime. Can you invite them to attend?"

Judge No. 1 said: "The couple man can attend, and the couple woman is already someone else's wife and is abroad." ”

So the couple man sat on the witness stand, during which waiter No. 1 took the camera and asked Cao Yun: "Lawyer Cao, what do you think is the reason for Lawyer Guo's move?"

Cao Yun looked at the camera and was stunned for a moment, and then replied: "It is confirmed that there are two groups of witnesses who are still near Wang's fish soup at about eleven o'clock, one is a couple, and the other is a shopkeeper on the street." The defence must first knock out the testimony of these two groups before it can continue with the defense. ”

"What does it mean to knock out?"

Cao Yun said: "Let the testimony be doubtful, and the testimony with doubtful points will not be accepted." ”

"Thank you, Mr. Cao. ”

Attendant No. 1 then interviewed another young lawyer who was hearing.

Cao Yun once wondered if the Flame Court had received permission from the police, and became more and more arrogant.

Couple men enter the witness box.

Guo Xiaotian was very calm, walked to the witness stand and asked, "Witness, did you describe your appearance to the police first, or did the police give you the photo first?"

The couple man replied: "The police collected eyewitnesses, and I passed through that section of the road before and after the crime, so I went to the police station." The police handed me a photo of the suspect and asked if it was him. My ex-girlfriend and I didn't answer right away, saying that the person was wearing a raincoat. The police passed the PS and changed the raincoat on, and I think it was him. ”

"Think?"

"No, it's him. ”

Guo Xiaotian asked: "You and the defendant staggered by, and the testimony said that the distance was only about one meter." You're on the shoulder of the road and he's staggered under the shoulder on a three-wheeled motorcycle. Excuse me, did you see the defendant wearing a raincoat on his head?"

The couple man replied, "No." ”

Guo Xiaotian asked, "Has his hair been dyed?"

The couple man replied, "No." ”

Guo Xiaotian returned to the defense bench and enlarged the photo on the projector, which was a photo of Xu's father holding a sign and wearing a prison uniform when he was arrested, with his hairstyle open in three or seven, and a pinch of white dyed hair in the seventh part. Guo Xiaotian said: "The photo of the witness identified by the police is a photo of the defendant taken by the relevant department half a year ago. The defendant's hair was dyed when he cut his hair the week before the crime. In other words, the witness did not see the accused. ”

Sima Luo approached the microphone: "Lawyer Guo, may I ask, how do you know that the defendant's hair was dyed a week before the crime?"

Guo Xiaotian: "The information given to me by the court, please watch the video." ”

A short video, filming a barber shop, the owner explained that Xu's father dyed his hair on his side. finished, Guo Xiaotian said: "The day of the crime was 11 o'clock in the evening, and the defendant went to the fish market at 3 o'clock in the morning to pick up the goods, and then went back to open the morning market. Even without a video description, Xu's father didn't have time to dye his hair. ”

Sima Luo said: "On a rainy day, I didn't bring a raincoat and hat, and my hair was glued together, and the area of this handful of white hair was not large, and it was easy for black hair to cover white hair." In addition, you can see that the witness was on the left side at the time, and the witness testimony said that the defendant turned back, and according to the simulation at that time, it was impossible for the defendant to turn his whole head when he turned back. Half a head, most of the side of the face. It just so happens that the hair on the side of the face is black. Mr. Guo's challenge is completely untenable. ”

Guo Xiaotian said: "Prosecutor Sima, don't ignore the point, the police are suspected of inducing people to recognize people." According to psychology, when a young person who is still in a state of love looks at someone else, the chance of recognizing it the next day is almost zero. This is a survey report done by an American university, where a hundred young couples in love and a stranger staggered by, the stranger turned back and called their names, and the couple looked back at the stranger. The next day, couples were asked to choose strangers from twenty photos, and only two groups of couples chose the right ones and admitted that they guessed. ”

"American University Report?" Sima Luo asked mockingly, "Do you believe it too?"

Judge No. 1 said: "We commissioned a special research survey from a university in the United States, and this is the specific content of the report. “

After the judge finished speaking, the waiter took out a stack of folders and handed out a copy to the defense bench, the prosecution seat, the jury, and even the hearing.

Cao Yun glanced at it a few times and knew that this material was real. Because the school is a prestigious school, there is a clear signature on it, and it cannot be perjury if the authenticity is checked afterwards. Otherwise, the Flame Court will be settled. said that Guo Xiaotian was defending, but in fact, the Flame Court used various resources to collect information to defend Xu's father.

Sima Luo looked at it for a while, closed the information and frowned.

Guo Xiaotian smiled with satisfaction and said, "This proves that the testimony of the witnesses is not credible." ”

When Cao Yun heard this, he raised his hand, and everyone paused for a while, as if the judge was also whispering something. Judge No. 1: "Lawyer Cao, the hearing person does not have the right to speak. However, because Mr. Cao's ability is obvious to all, I can give you a chance. ”

The waiter brought the microphone, and Cao Yun asked, "Excuse me, how many experimental reports have been made by the Flame Court on the testimony of couples? Based on my knowledge of the courtroom, I believe that there is a test report that simulates the situation at the scene. I think purely personally, maybe there is, maybe not. I think if there is, it should also be shown for the jury's reference. ”

After a few seconds, Judge No. 1 replied, "No, it's too late, just this test report." ”

Cao Yun: "I'm sorry. ”

After Sima Luo was awakened, he immediately pursued: "This report has no value, as lawyer Cao said, the environment at that time is completely inconsistent with the test report. In addition, there is another detail, the defendant was driving a tricycle that was relatively noisy, although the speed was not fast, it ran over the waterhole and the water splashed on the trouser legs of the couple woman, which made the couple very annoyed. The defendant heard the lover's cry and looked back, did not stop, did not apologize, which would have left a deeper impression on the couple. ”

Guo Xiaotian didn't refute, and Xu Na, who was on the defense bench, suddenly took the wheat and asked angrily: "Lawyer Cao, if you don't defend my father, forget it, why do you want to hurt him?"

Cao Yun sighed: "I don't plan to harm anyone, I just hope that the trial will be fairer." If you think I'm hurting your father, then I'm sorry not to listen. ”

As soon as Cao Yun stood up, Judge No. 2 said, "Lawyer Cao, you leave the seat now, and any evidence in favor of the defendant will be suspected of falsification." It is better to stay as a supervisor and supervise this trial. ”

Shangguan Wen said two words in Xu Na's ear, and Xu Na said reluctantly: "I'm sorry Lawyer Cao, I was too excited to say the wrong thing, please stay." ”

Cao Yun made a dispensable gesture and sat down.

Amazing, what is the origin of this No. 2 judge? He can immediately see through his own thoughts and think of the consequences.

Cao Yun questioned the evidence, which was very reasonable, but was kicked out of the courtroom by the defendant's daughter. In this way, the fairness of the trial is greatly reduced. Judge No. 2 did not retreat but advanced, retained Cao Yun, and gave him the right to supervise, which is a very positive behavior.

After everyone was quiet, Guo Xiaotian said: "The testimony of the witnesses is still doubtful, and the police photos have played a somewhat misleading role. The witness also explained just now that he and his girlfriend did not draw conclusions when they looked at the defendant's face. The police put on the raincoat before the witness could draw conclusions. The credibility of witness testimony is questionable, and I strongly recommend that the jury and the judge include the witness testimony as evidence for reference, not as evidence for determining whether the defendant is guilty. ”

A young lawyer in the hearing room raised his hand, because of Cao Yun, the trial mode has changed. The young lawyer took the microphone and said, "I personally agree with Lawyer Guo's statement that the witness may have been misled. ”

The three judges exchanged a few words with each other, and Judge No. 1 said, "Those who agree with Lawyer Guo's views on the hearing seats, please raise your hand." "it, they scolded their mother in their hearts. Do you understand what it means to listen to the trial? But since you give Cao Yun a back door, you can't say anything if you don't give someone else a back door. Cao Yun is different, Cao Yun actually helped Sima Luo refute Guo Xiaotian.

This does not prove the level of Sima's failure, because this evidence was put forward on an ad hoc basis.

Seven people were heard, and six raised their hands. Judge No. 1 said: "Please ask other lawyers except Lawyer Cao to move the jury seat, since you like it, then be a juror." ”

The six looked at each other, and the guard had already drawn a gun and pointed it at one of the lawyers, who immediately realized that he was in the Flame Courtroom, not the real courtroom, and immediately moved to the jury bench, and the others left for the jury bench. The number of jurors reached seventeen.

Judge No. 2 said: "Lawyer Cao put forward an opinion, and the opinion influenced the final verdict. If any of you can make a similar observation, we would welcome it. If it's just grandstanding and deceiving the camera, don't blame us for being polite. Who can you agree with? If you can only agree on your own behalf, don't waste everyone's time. The court session continued. ”

Guo Xiaotian and Shangguan Wen discussed a few words, and Shangguan Wen stood up: "Please ask the second eyewitness in this case, the owner of the convenience store across the street from Wangjiayutang, to appear in court." ”

During the witness's appearance in court, Shangguanwen explained the situation: "The boss has been chasing the serial, the serial will end at eleven o'clock, and the TV station will rebroadcast the evening news at eleven o'clock. The boss claimed that he was used to the end of the TV series feature film, and closed the door while listening to the ending song. Just as the door was closing, he saw the defendant coming out of Wang's fish soup and greeted the defendant. This is the scene street, a very narrow street, with pedestrian shoulders on both sides, the actual distance between the two stores is twelve meters, there are street lights, and the line of sight is not very bad. The police and prosecutors agreed with the convenience store owner's testimony. ”

。 m.