Yue Sanchi turned his head to look at everyone: "The photo itself has a great impact on the actress, but it will not make the actress commit suicide, because of the existence of the first videotape and the endless blackmail of greed, which makes the actress fall into despair, and under the huge psychological pressure, she can't think about it for a while and commits suicide." Wang Shou used all kinds of lies to cover up the facts, but there was only one fact, and Wang Shou was the culprit. ”

Wang Shou howled: "I'm not, it's not me......" The judge raised his hand, the guards controlled him again, and the courtroom returned to quiet.

Judge No. 1 said, "What do the lawyers and prosecutors think about this?"

Situ Yan spoke first: "Judging from just now, Wang Shou's suspicion is indeed very big, but I am an old pedant, and I care more about the evidence." The evidence presented by Public Prosecutor No. 1 was not convincing. Wang Shou lied many times because he thought about it too much, which would undoubtedly make him more suspicious......"

Judge No. 1 reminded: "Please don't look at this matter from the perspective of a traditional court, and I have not asked you to judge Wang Shou. Putting everything aside, assuming you're an ordinary person, do you think Wang Shou is the culprit now?"

Situ Yan thought for a long time: "I'm sorry, I'm not an ordinary person after all, although I have some thoughts in my heart, but there is not enough evidence to convince me." The subtext is very clear, and he agrees in his heart that Wang Shou is the culprit.

Judge No. 1: "What does Public Prosecutor No. 2 think?"

Nangong Tengfei said: "I agree with Lawyer No. 3, subjectively we agree that Wang Shou is the culprit, but objectively speaking, there is a lack of strong evidence. So I can't answer your question head-on. ”

Judge No. 1: "What is Zhao Yan's lawyer's opinion?"

Sima Luo was distressed for a long time: "I don't answer this question. "If you don't speak for Wang Shou, you already explain his attitude.

Judge No. 1 said: "Assuming that the concept of innocence is removed, as a member of the jury, would you think that Wang Shou is the culprit?"

Sima Luo smiled bitterly: "I'm not a policeman, I'm not good at reasoning." If I were a member of the jury, I would probably think that Wang Shou was guilty. "He's still more honest.

Judge No. 1 asked, "Lawyer Cao, do you agree with their views?"

Cao Yun scratched his scalp very irritably, took out a cigarette in his pocket and lit one, although there was an explicit prohibition before, but the judge expressed his understanding and asked the guards not to stop it. Cao Yun didn't take the scene of the judge stopping the guards to heart at all. There was a fight going on inside him.

Situ Yan said: "Brother Cao, you can learn from someone, just agree with my opinion." ”

Nangong Tengfei smiled, disapproving.

Cao Yun looked at Situ Yan, a man in his fifties flashing with positive energy. The last time he confronted the Flame Court, he was the first to help himself take the blame, and in his opinion, he was a reckless and ignorant young man. This is also the case this time, which is a kind of care from seniors to juniors.

Under everyone's gaze, Cao Yun took a deep breath, approached the microphone and said, "I don't think Wang Shou is the culprit. ”

After a moment of silence, Judge No. 2 asked, "Lawyer Cao can finish his sentence." ”

Cao Yun asked, "Does the court already know who the culprit is?"

Judge No. 2 replied: "The judge in the courtroom plays the role of punishing, and if the judge directly identifies who is the culprit, it is equivalent to the judge kidnapping the courtroom." I can answer you positively, yes, the court believes that someone is the culprit, but it can't say whether it is Wang Shou, which will mislead the prosecutor and the lawyer. Moreover, the judge's personal judgment is not important. Lawyer Cao, from my personal point of view, it seems that you think there is someone else to culprit. Can you tell me, do you suspect who the culprit is? In court?"

Cao Yun said: "The prosecutor is very professional, and her questioning is to induce Wang Shou to say what she wants. Wang Shou suffered because he did not have a lawyer, and there was no lawyer to help him stop and ask the prosecutor to stop the induced questioning. For example, if I threw a brick downstairs on the 10th floor at about 8 a.m., the prosecutor only had to ask me to state the fact, but in fact whether the brick I threw caused someone's death was not proven. Maybe I threw the brick at 7:50, maybe it was thrown in the wrong direction. The prosecutor pointed out that no one could prove that I threw the brick at 7:50, only that I threw the brick. In this way, the jury, the hearing bench, and the judge, and even the defendant himself, will be misled. ”

Cao Yundao: "The same is true in this case, the prosecutor first induced Wang Shou, Wang Shou thought too much and made up some lies, which is a situation that the prosecutor is happy to see." So the prosecutor exposed the lie, and in this way, Wang Shou's image in the court was ruined. Coupled with the fact that he was unable to answer some questions, in fact, he did not need to answer the questions that these prosecutors had to prove. Because he couldn't answer these questions, he became the culprit. ”

Judge No. 2 said: "Lawyer Cao, this is a reversal. "Reverse extrapolation, commonly known as pseudo-afterthought, inferentially infers the process of the case in turn when the truth is known.

Judge No. 2 keenly felt that Cao Yun knew who the culprit was first, so he could deduce that Wang Shou was not the culprit. The reason is very simple, if Cao Yun didn't know who the culprit was, he wouldn't decisively say that Wang Shou was not the culprit. In the atmosphere of the trial just now, the people who can say such things must be the ones who know more things.

Cao Yun thought for a long time and said: "Have we always not treated the actress as a person, and the actress was forced to shoot a bad movie, because someone had the photo." As a normal person and a person with a certain amount of strength, wouldn't he want to get the photo back? I think the actress got the photo back, and I believe that this is the only photo. Otherwise, in the year from kidnapping to suicide, it is impossible for the actress to say nothing. Even if the actress is timid and afraid, she still has an agent company. The brokerage company will not hesitate to protect the cash cow of the actress. Money is the reason why many people are driven by profits. ”

Judge No. 2 asked, "And then?"

Cao Yun said: "I don't want to say it. ”

Judge No. 2 said, "Lawyer Cao, I hope you can respect the basic rules. In a normal court, you may be deprived of your lawyer's license for such behavior. On the other hand, since you think that there is someone else who killed the shadow queen, you don't want to say that it is equivalent to shielding a criminal. So far, after the video is posted on the Internet, how many people will ask you, who is the culprit? If I were you, since I opened my mouth, I should say what I think. ”

Cao Yun took a deep breath again and said, "I'm not worried about anything else, I'm just worried that I'm stealing the spotlight from the prosecutor." ”

Yue Sanchi said: "I didn't expect that Lawyer Cao was also an excellent detective, although I said, if I have it, I will change it, and if I don't, I will encourage it." Yue Sanchi's inner emotions were very complicated, and everything was developing in her expected trajectory, but she didn't expect to kill a Cao Biting Jin.

Cao Yun said: "I only want to say one doubt, to follow what I said above, since the actress thinks that the photos have been destroyed." So who will she turn to as soon as she receives the CD?"

After a few seconds, everyone looked at Shen Bing together. That's right, the actress was threatened by Shen Bing, and the actress thought that Shen Bing had fulfilled her promise, and now that new photos or even videos have appeared, the actress will definitely question Shen Bing. The most terrifying point is that Shen Bing never mentioned that he had contact with the actress before the actress committed suicide. Once Cao Yun's suspicion comes true, it means that Shen Bing has been lying and concealing it.

Yue Sanchi didn't seem surprised, and asked helplessly: "Wang Shou, you said that your videotape has not been handed over, so where is your videotape?"

Wang Shou got the opportunity to speak, and with tears in his eyes, he bowed to Cao Yun first, and then replied: "I have been keeping it at home, and I quietly destroyed the videotape after I was released from prison." ”

Yue Sanchi: "In those days, did Shen Bing go to your residence?"

Wang Shou: "I have been there, and I said that I had a quarrel with my wife and brought shochu and side dishes to my residence...... Yes...... Shen Bing...... You ......"

Shen Bing was furious: "You are a king X egg, you have a private collection of videotapes, and you have to wash an extra set of photos, it's not you, are there so many things? Be a lackey, be a dog, just steal things, and bite everywhere, make trouble everywhere, XXX!"

Shen Bing's rebuke made Wang Shouyan and the court quiet.

……

As Cao Yun thought, the actress must have a sense of protection. The actress only made one movie for Shen's Pictures and did not become a contracted star of Shen's Pictures, which already shows that the actress thinks that Shen Bing handed over all the evidence to her. So she wants this to be the end of it. In fact, it is also the same, but because of this bad movie, he was blamed by many fans, and at the suggestion of his agent, he temporarily stopped filming. The entertainment industry is like this, no matter how bad a topic is, it will be replaced by a new one. In other words, the audience has created the survival state of the entertainment industry.

Attracted by a famous director and a good script, the actress decided to make a comeback, which is also a great opportunity to make people rediscover themselves with a classic movie. What is a classic, such as Fa Ge has made a lot of movies, and many people are most impressed by two, one is the sunglasses Xiao Ma who burns dollars and lights cigarettes, and the other is the God of Gamblers who combs his hair after hairspray and comes out with BGM.

At this time, Wang Shou's blackmail letter came, and the actress's thinking returned to the haze incident she didn't want to recall a year ago, not to mention that the actress knew very well that a video in the disc was the first videotape. She immediately contacted Shen Bing. Shen Bing was also stunned, and immediately went to the villa of the queen. If there were only photos in the disc, Shen Bing would be suspicious of Zhao Yan, but adding the video would be more complicated. The only people who have the tape are him, Wang Shou and Li Sheng.

Li Sheng has slowly transformed into a businessman, and it is impossible to make trouble for himself. There was only Wang Shou, and Shen Bing contacted Li Sheng and learned that Wang Shou was short of money recently. He couldn't tell the actress about these things, the actress didn't expect to experience another nightmare a year later, she was very angry and told Shen Bing that if the outcome of this matter could not satisfy her, she would definitely call the police.

Shen Bing asked Wang Shou to drink, for the sake of insurance, after Wang Shou got drunk, in order not to alarm Wang Shou for the time being, he used Wang Shou's video recorder to copy a videotape and brought it to the villa of the actress. Shen Bing told the queen that this is the original tape of the video. The actress is not stupid either, and from the label on the tape, it was found that the copied videotape was new. The actress was completely enraged, hysterically accusing Shen Bing, and told Shen Bing that it was no longer the time for Shen Bing to play black, and gave Shen Bing an ultimatum to solve the matter within 24 hours.

After all, Shen Bing was born in Donghei, and he was also enraged, and gave the actress a slap in the face, telling the actress that she dared to call the police or whatever, and she would make the video public and let the actress be honest.

More than ten hours later, the actress committed suicide, and Shen Bing was scared half to death.

……

After Shen Bing finished speaking, the case became more and more detailed and complicated, because Shen Bing swore that he had absolutely not set aside the disc, and he was ready to solve the matter once and for all.

The information that was leaked out was the disc used by Wang Shou to burn and blackmail the actress, there is only one disc of this disc, and it is in the hands of the actress, so how can this disc flow to the market?

This time, there was no prosecutor to refute it, and to ask Shen Bing about his confession, everyone quietly pondered. Cao Yun was also a little confused, according to his opinion, the Flame Court was suspected of being misleading, and deliberately let the lawyer and prosecutor make wrong judgments, which led to Wang Shou's death. After that, the Flame Court held a second session to prosecute several lawyers and prosecutors, and if it succeeded, this slap basically destroyed at least half of the credibility of the Eastern Tang Dynasty Judiciary.

Cao Yun believes that the culprit is Shen Bing, and judging from Shen Bing's explanation, most of the cases are in line with Cao Yun's judgment. There is only one problem, although Shen Bing has participated in many things, he has not leaked photos.

According to the police investigation at the time, the disc appeared on the morning of the actress's suicide, and was frantically burned in an underground factory, and then sold by hawkers at various points. Generally speaking, people born in the 85s or 90s do not understand that before 2000, network technology was very backward, but the computer ownership rate reached a certain standard, and pirated CD-ROMs were very popular in this special period, and it was a special industry. The content includes apps, games, and some indescribable things. In particular, indescribable things could be viewed on DVDs, which were popular at the time, even without a computer.

Not to mention Cao Yun's confusion, the Flame Court is also a bit difficult to ride a tiger, the Flame Court has long known that Shen Bing lied, before the actress committed suicide, Shen Bing and the actress had many contacts, according to their thoughts, Shen Bing was the culprit and basically didn't run away. But what Shen Bing said made people have to believe it.

At this time, Yue Sanchi used the laptop on his seat to re-read the information given by the court. Everyone waited quietly.

After a long time, Yue Sanchi stood up and his eyes fell on Zhao Yan: "After the kidnapping case, although you and the actress were estranged, I could read that the actress forgave you." If I guessed correctly, you would say that it was Shen Bing who threatened you, or that you thought Shen Bing wanted to talk to the actress and promised that if the actress called the police, she would be willing to be a witness...... Don't open your mouth, I don't want to know the details, I just know that the actress has forgiven you at least to a certain extent, but your relationship is going strange. According to the information, on some occasions where you are openly present together, you are just very formulaic and friendly to each other. ”

.。 m.