Chapter 492: Court Battle (I)

Cao Yun got into Ouyang Yi's car and said with a smile: "I should have an assistant and let Ouyang you be my driver, I am very afraid." ”

Ouyang Yi drove the car, no joke: "The director of the southern suburbs police station is a very good friend of mine. ”

Cao Yun: "Give your friend who was on duty on the day of the crime?"

Ouyang Yi nodded: "Bad news, Zhuge Ming also asked him for the duty sheet." ”

After Ouyang Yi hung up Cao Yun's phone, the director called. doesn't say anything else, it's just about the weather, the body, and the relationship between husband and wife. Ouyang Yi heard some meaning and asked, "Zhuge Ming is looking for you?"

Director: "I can't say that. ”

Ouyang Yi: "He took the duty sheet?"

Director: "I can't say that either. ”

The prosecutor looking for the police station to get the duty sheet is different from the lawyer looking for the police station to get the duty sheet, Zhuge Ming can go directly to the police station to ask for the duty sheet. If the lawyer needs to apply, and the application may be rejected, the lawyer must apply to the court, and only through the court's warrant can he find the police station to get the duty sheet.

When Cao Yun heard this, his heart ached: ", trouble." ”

Ouyang Yi: "We are about to be beheaded by Zhuge Ming." "White slash is an unwritten term in the industry, which means that it is completely suppressed by the other party, without any opportunity and ability to resist. White chop is the most reluctant term in the work of lawyers. Lawyers such as Cao Yun have to struggle to the death to get rid of the fate of being beheaded in vain.

But for now, the situation is not optimistic.

Cao Yun: "Our only bargaining chip is Yue Sanqi who pleads not guilty." ”

Ouyang Yi: "Is there anything to gain from going to Thailand?"

Cao Yun smiled bitterly: "The first harvest when I went to Thailand: the case of framing Yue Sanchi was jointly handled by the Grand Alliance and Blaze. The second harvest: arranging the case scene is a CA business talent. The third harvest: Yue Sanchi took other people's things, which is what people must take back unconditionally. There's also good news: there will be no extra-rule obstruction of us. ”

Ouyang Yi burst into tears: "You might as well not go, at least I still have some hope in my heart." ”

Cao Yun sighed: "This damn scene. ”

Ouyang Yi: "There is still hope in my heart." I think it's a good thing, and now it's you, not me, that people are paying attention. In this way, you do something to distract from it, which is your forte. I'm going to visit an old friend and ask for a technical question. ”

Cao Yun: "It seems that you have some ideas?"

Ouyang Yi: "It's always been, but I'm not sure I'm right." ”

Cao Yun: "Okay, I'll be left to the task of making trouble." "Scene is Ouyang Yi's forte.

……

The second trial of the defendant's homicide case was held.

The prosecution continued to question the defendant's testimony, and Zhuge Ming made a doubtful decision on whether Ye Lan invited the defendant to the villa with the statement of doubt.

Ouyang Yi: "The prosecution used inappropriate words, and through the first trial, it was determined that my client was invited by Ye Lan to Villa 7. ”

Zhuge Ming was noncommittal: "May I ask the defense, do you agree to agree with my point of view below: Ye Lan only invited the defendant to Villa 7 and did not participate in the follow-up affairs. ”

Zhuge Ming saw that the two of them were silent: "We can put forward a hypothesis that Ye Lan is the defendant's informant, and the defendant colluded with Ye Lan to arrange Jiang Hanyue's murder case. Ye Lan and her ex-boyfriend sang and laughed, and their testimony was knocked out. It seems to be subjectively stated that the defendant was falsely accused. ”

Zhuge Ming: "Due to the situation in the first trial, Ye Lan's confession no longer has legal effect. As a prosecutor, I don't have a way to understand the story behind the case, I prefer to know what the story is in the process of the case. Whether it is proposed by the defense: the defendant was framed, or we proposed that Ye Lan and the defendant colluded. Facts and evidence cannot be avoided. Since Ye Lan's testimony cannot win the court's trust, we will temporarily skip Ye Lan's invitation in the defendant's testimony and continue to read the defendant's testimony. ”

Zhuge Ming: "According to the defendant's testimony, the defendant fainted in Villa No. 7 and appeared in Villa No. 29, which was about an eight-minute drive in between. The defendant claimed that his vehicle was parked on the side of the road in Villa No. 5, when in fact the vehicle appeared on the side of the road in Villa No. 29. In order to illustrate, I applied for our third witness, Liu Xun, a patrol officer of the southern suburbs police station, to testify in court. ”

The judge said: "The application is approved, and the witness is invited to appear in court." ”

Liu Xun arrived at the witness stand, and Zhuge Ming asked: "Witness, how do you arrange the patrol of the villa group at night, I mean that the villa goes all the way to the fifth road, by the way, what is the particularity of all the way to the fifth road?"

Liu Xun replied: "The villa complex in the southern suburbs is very large, but the occupancy rate and sale rate have been very low. All the way to the Wulu villa group, they are far away from the necessities of life, and there are few residents. Because of the scarcity of households, there are some security problems. Therefore, under the coordination of the city hall, the villa that goes all the way to the fifth road can be replaced by the villa behind the sixth road. At present, only five families live in the southeast direction of Wulu Road, and no one lives in other villas. ”

Liu Xun: "In order to avoid vacant villas from becoming dens for selling X and gambling X, the southern suburbs police station has strengthened patrols on the first and fifth roads. From 6 p.m. to 6 a.m. the next morning, two patrol cars continued to patrol the area. ”

Zhuge Ming asked: "What will you do if you find a car parked on the side of the road or someone walking on the road during the patrol?"

Liu Xun said: "All intercepts." All those who show up at night all the way to the fifth road are to be questioned. When we find a parked vehicle on the side of the road, we will also actively contact the owner of the vehicle until we get a clear answer. ”

Zhuge Ming said: "Witness, you should know that the case tried by this court occurred at about ten o'clock in the evening, what do you want to say." ”

As witnesses for the defence or prosecution, they communicate with the defence or prosecution before they go to court.

Liu Xun knew what Zhuge Ming was going to ask, and said: "On the day of the crime, it was the No. 81 and No. 83 patrol cars, each car had three police officers, and I was the driver of the No. 83 patrol car. A car cruises from five to one, and one car cruises from one to five. At half past nine, car No. 81 returned to the police station to change shifts. ”

Zhuge Ming asked: "Sudden shift change?"

Liu Xun: "No, it's a daily shift. There are a lot of jobs at the police station, there are normal 9-to-5 copywriting jobs, and there are 24-hour jobs. Car No. 83 is a normal patrol car, and Car No. 81 is a patrol car that was added half a year ago to enhance the control of uninhabited places in the villa complex. No. 81 is at 2 p.m. and from 2 p.m. to 6 p.m., and the patrol lot is the southern suburbs road. After six o'clock, the traffic on the southern suburbs road was greatly reduced, and the patrol was carried out in the villa complex. So their shift change time is half past nine in the evening. The two vehicles are staggered to change shifts, so that there will be no control gaps. ”

Zhuge Ming nodded: "At 9:45 p.m. on the day of the crime, a car was parked on the side of the road in Villa 5. During this time, a woman entered the car, which drove to the side of the road in Villa 29. Until the police arrived at Villa 29, the patrol police never found the vehicle. Is this normal?"

Liu Xun said: "It is possible during this time period, but there is a great chance of chance. Our patrol cars do not have a speed limit and are usually slower. In the case of patrol car 83, I like to keep the speed at 20-25 when I am a driver, another colleague likes 25-35, and another colleague likes to keep it at 40. Who drives the patrol every day is decided by our improvised guessing. ”

Zhuge Ming said: "It is possible that the vehicle will not be discovered, but it is more likely to be discovered." ”

Liu Xun nodded: "That's right." ”

Ouyang Yi raised his hand, Zhuge Ming signaled him to speak, and Ouyang Yi said, "Is it possible that someone is monitoring the location of your vehicle?"

Liu Xun: "In terms of my professional knowledge, I can't rule out such a possibility. ”

Zhuge Ming: "No, according to the defendant's testimony, Ye Lan invited the defendant to Villa No. 5, and the defendant drove from his home to Villa No. 5, and it was not necessary to arrive early or late, maybe he would meet the patrol car." Once the patrol officer asks about the identity of the accused, there is no way to talk about the so-called false accusation plan. This is why I suspect that Ye Lan and the defendant colluded to kill Jiang Hanyue. ”

Zhuge Ming looked at Yue Sanqi: "Defendant, you live in a villa purchased by a girl named Ye Le?"

Yue Sanchi nodded: "Yes, she is my friend." ”

Zhuge Ming: "You have a separate study, even if Ye Le is not allowed to enter without permission." ”

Yue Sanqi changed his calm expression, and smiled helplessly: "Yes." ”

Zhuge Ming: "What secrets are in this room?"

Yue Sanchi: "There are some ...... There are some devices, including software permissions, etc. ”

Zhuge Ming asked, "Is it legal?"

Yue Sanchi: "The equipment is legal, but you need to apply for it when you use the equipment, and you can only use it after getting approval. ”

Zhuge Ming: "Is there a mobile phone signal monitor?"

Yue Sanchi: "Yes." ”

Zhuge Ming: "Can you check the phone numbers of the vast majority of people in the Eastern Tang Dynasty?"

Yue Sanchi: "Yes. ”

Zhuge Ming: "At the same time, there is a real patrol car location connected to the command center in your computer. ”

"Yes, but I want to make it clear that these are the devices that can be equipped in my purview. ”

Zhuge Ming: "But ......"

Yue Sanchi shook his head lightly, and replied helplessly: "But the use of these equipment needs to be approved, or to set up a project." "Yue Sanchi has the right to investigate on his own, and he can file a case without approval, and Yue Sanchi only needs to notify the chief prosecutor in writing: start filing a case for investigation on a certain day, a certain month, and a certain year. No approval is required, and no explanation is required to anyone for the time being. However, regardless of whether there is a result of the investigation or not, it must be reported, and a record of the case must be made during the filing of the case.

Zhuge Ming: "At the time of the case, did you have the right to file a case for investigation?"

Yue Sanchi pondered for a long time: "No." ”

Zhuge Ming asked: "Did you use the equipment?" ”

Yue Sanchi looked at Cao Yun and Ouyang Yi, she forgot to explain this matter, but even if she explained, I am afraid it will not help.

Zhuge Ming asked: "Do you use equipment to monitor the location of citizens or police cars in violation of regulations?"

Yue Sanchi nodded: "I admit that some public officials are monitored for positioning, and the location of police cars is not monitored." ”

Zhuge Ming asked: "Where was the public official you called at that time?"

Yue Sanqi: "Near the villa complex." ”

Zhuge Ming asked, "Who are the public officials?"

Yue Sanchi smiled bitterly: "Don't you have an answer?"

Zhuge Ming: "I need you to say." ”

Yue Sanchi: "Prosecutor Sachiko Kuchio." ”

Zhuge Ming: "Are you filing a case to investigate Sachiko Nine-Tails?"

Yue Sanchi: "No, I'm monitoring Cao Yun, and the target is Cao Yun's father, Cao Lie." ”

Zhuge Ming: "But according to your computer, you monitor both of them at the same time. ”

Yue Sanchi: "That's because their signals have been together." ”

Zhuge Ming: "You don't monitor Nine-Tails Sachiko, how do you know that her mobile phone signal is with Cao Yun's?"

"......" monitored the prosecutor for no reason and was suspected of abusing his power.

Zhuge Ming: "Could it be that Cao Yun has a special relationship with Nine-Tails Sachiko?

Yue Sanqi had a headache, and shook his head with his left hand: "I refuse to answer this question." ”

Ouyang Yi said: "Defendant, please answer truthfully." "Zhuge Ming is a point to break the face and accuse you of abusing the state apparatus. If you don't answer, you are first found to be abusing the state apparatus, and secondly, you can monitor the location of police cars.

Yue Sanqi: "I ......"

Cao Yun received a distress signal: "Oppose, whether my client abuses his power, or uses his power legally." Not only is her behavior irrelevant to this case, but in view of the special nature of our client's work and the possibility of special case handling, it is inconvenient and should not explain this section in court. ”

Zhuge Ming: "Your Excellency, my question is directly related to this case. I have to prove that the defendant has ......"

Cao Yun: "We accept the instructions of our client to own and use the official technology. Accept the statement that my client has the ability to monitor police cars. As for whether our client used or abused his power, it has nothing to do with this case. ”

Zhuge Ming: "The determination of abuse and use can fully explain the defendant's style of conduct. ”

Cao Yun: "My client is only a suspect now, and we don't know if she is investigating the case alone. In view of the fact that the investigations of my clients are all major cases, and the prosecution is from the Attorney General's Office. The abuse and use of power did not affect the progress of the trial, so I have reason to suspect that the prosecutor was so aggressive because my client was investigating a collective corruption incident in the Attorney General's Office. "Not an inch of land.

Zhuge Ming pointed to Cao Yun, he couldn't speak for a long time, is he shameless to know the limit?

The judge ruled that "in view of the special nature of the defendant's work, it cannot be ruled out that he is investigating the Attorney General's Office, and his abuse or use of power is not directly related to the case, so the defense objection is valid." The prosecution is not allowed to ask questions about matters and details that are not relevant to the case. ”

Zhuge Ming: "Your Excellency, there is a direct relationship, please listen to my explanation......"

Cao Yun interrupted again: "Prosecutor, your clothes are Anima, and your belt is Qu Nima, this set can't be made without 10,000 handfuls." How much do you earn a month?"

Zhuge Ming: "My account is publicly subject to supervision and investigation, and it has nothing to do with this case. ”

Cao Yun: "I think your question has something to do with this case, and you think that your question has nothing to do with this case, so it doesn't matter? Can you be arrogant if you're bald? You dare to oppose the judge's ruling? Since you want to question the defendant, first of all, I have to question you whether your income is legal." ”

Zhuge Ming was furious: "What does my bald head have to do with the case? You are a personal attack." ”

Cao Yun: "Do you think the bald are inferior?"

Zhuge Ming: "No. ”

Cao Yun: "Since I didn't, why do you think I'm a personal attack." ”

Zhuge Ming: "Because you deliberately explained the bald head." ”

Cao Yun: "I also specifically explained that I am a handsome guy, am I despising a handsome guy?"

The judge struck the hammer: "Both of them are people with status, please restrain your emotions." ”

The two looked at each other for a while and sat down, Zhuge Mingteng jumped up: "Your Excellency, he gave me the middle finger." ”

Cao Yun: "I didn't. ”

Zhuge Ming: "If you erect it, someone will definitely see it in the hearing seat." ”

Cao Yun: "I put up my index finger." Your Excellency, he has framed my personality, and he has framed me for despising his bald head. ”

"Grass!" Zhuge Ming rushed out of the control seat, and the bailiff hurriedly blocked it. Cao Yun was not to be outdone, rolled up his sleeves, stepped on the chair, and stubbornly assed: "Come to the grass." ”

The judge stroked his forehead and said weakly: "Now the court is adjourned for half an hour, everyone calm down." The court will be held in half an hour, and if the two of you are still in this mood, don't blame me for being polite. "It's still good in ancient times, in ancient times, each person hit fifty boards on the buttocks first. Noisy, noisy, noisy sister.

The judge hammered: "Adjournment." ”

Everyone left the table, and the bailiff escorted both sides into their respective small rooms. The people in the industry who heard the trial were full of discussions. The main thing is to debate whether the emotions of the two are true or false. Summing up, Zhuge Ming is not right whether it is true or false, because there are two people on the other side, and you only have one person.

There are some discrepancies in the facts, in fact, both of them are on fire.

Entering the small room, Cao Yun slapped the table: "The dead bald head is so arrogant, if you don't give him some color, I really think I am a cow." ”

Zhuge Ming pulled his tie: "Little rabbit, see if Lao Tzu can't kill you, roar!"

Ouyang Yi and the glasses girl could only comfort their companions separately.