After Jiang Chundong finished speaking, he put down the page-turning pen: "My speech is over." ”

As soon as he sat down, Du Shaoxing stood up.

"Your Excellency, I have some questions about the testimony of the witnesses, and allow me to ask them questions. ”

The judge granted.

"It's still that question," Du Shaoxing walked up to Xu Bozhi, "Mr. Xu, was there a big fire in the flower room at that time?

He wants to deny the testimony of witnesses.

Xu Bozhi knew that the other party was going to play the trick, and said clearly and affirmatively: "I can be sure that I am not mistaken." ”

"How are you sure?" Du Shaoxing was not in a hurry to refute him, "You also inhaled an excessive amount of smoke at that time, and your body was in a semi-comatose state, how did you determine it?"

Xu Bo couldn't answer at the moment.

Du Shaoxing is very famous in the lawyer circle, what he is best at is avoiding the important and trivial, secretly changing concepts, and is very good at guiding people's thinking in the direction that is beneficial to him.

Du Shaoxing handed over the report on the table: "Your Excellency, jurors, this is a report from the trace inspection department, these two pieces of evidence have been seriously oxidized because they have been buried in the ground for too long, and there are no residual fingerprints or blood stains on them. He interrupted and paused, "In other words, these two pieces of evidence are not pointed, as for why my client was present when the police found the evidence, this is very easy to explain, the place where the evidence is located is the Locke family, which is my client's home." He looked at the jurors, "What's wrong with my client showing up in his own home? Moreover, he just wanted to take care of the flower room, and unintentionally dug up these two so-called pieces of evidence, that's all, what can this prove?"

Clever tongue like a spring, able to speak well.

The name is worthy of being a name, and the dead can also be said to be alive.

"Your Excellency," Du Shaoxing applied to the judge, "please allow me to summon our witness No. 1." ”

The judge answered, and the clerk called the witnesses aloud.

The first witness of the No. 1 defendant Luo Changde was Peng Xian, who came up in prison clothes, and he stood on the witness stand, and Du Shaoxing went over: "Mr. Peng, can you introduce yourself first?"

Peng Xian Xian faced the front: "Your Excellency, jurors, my name is Peng Xian Xian, I am currently serving my sentence in the Western Prison, before I was imprisoned, I was a gardener, and I have been helping to take care of the flower room in the Luo family. After he paused, he added, "The witness just now Abin was the apprentice he accepted at that time." ”

After the identity of the witness was introduced, Du Shaoxing began to ask: "Can you tell us why you are in prison?"

Before going to court, he confessed, and Peng Xianxian replied 1510: "Eight years ago, I was so gambling that I lost a sum of money, and I couldn't pay it back for a while, so I made a deal with the owner at the time. ”

"What deal?"

"She helped me pay my bills, I helped her kill people. ”

Du Shaoxing step by step: "Is the person who made the deal with you in court now?"

"In. Peng Xian's eyes swept around the court.

Du Shaoxing then asked, "Who is she?"

Peng Xian raised his hand and pointed to Luo Qinghe in the dock: "She is the second defendant." ”

Buy murder.

Du Shaoxing just wants to illustrate this.

"Your Excellency," he said, presenting the evidence in court, "this is a recording kept by our witness Peng Xianxian during his dealings with Defendant No. 2, and it is clearly stated that Defendant No. 2 instructed our witness to set fire to the murder. He emphasized, "The trace inspection department has tested it, and the recording is the original and has not been tampered with." ”

The clerk then played the tape.

The noise was strong, but I could still hear the content.

"Miss, please help me. ”

"Help? Then Master Peng, do you want to do something for me too?"

"Miss, just say it. ”

"My mother's favorite to come to this trellis when she was alive, how about you help me burn it for her?"

"Is it just a burnt shed?"

"By the way, I burned some unclean things as well. ”

"What do you mean?"

"Locke's unclean things, is there anything else?"

This is the end of the conversation, and the jury members are all thoughtful after listening to it.

Jiang Chundong, the lawyer of the second defendant, stood up at this time and asked Peng Xianxian: "Witness, did my client personally ask you to burn Luo San or Tang Guangji at that time?"

Peng Xian did not answer.

Jiang Chundong looked into his eyes and raised his tone a little: "Witness, please answer my question, did my client personally say that you should burn Luo San and Tang Guangji?"

Peng Xian glanced at Du Shaoxing before answering, "No." "But I know who she's referring to." ”

"You know?" Jiang Chundong immediately seized the loophole, "In other words, these are all your conjectures?"

When Prophet Peng heard that it was wrong, he immediately shook his head: "No, the eldest lady has always been unaccustomed to Luo San, and she always tortures him on weekdays, what she means is for me to help her get rid of the thorn in her eye." ”

So what, as long as Luo Qinghe didn't say it himself.

Jiang Chundong methodically refuted the testimony of the witnesses: "Mr. Peng, you are all your personal conjecture, there is no basis at all, my client was experiencing the pain of losing her mother at the time, this flower room made her see things and think about people, so I let you deal with it, but never let you set fire to kill people, it was you who privately speculated and imagined the meaning of her words." ”

Peng Xian shook his head: "No—"

Jiang Chundong interrupted: "Moreover, eight years ago, you were so gambling. He went to the courtroom and looked at the jury, "Your Excellency, jurors, a prisoner who is addicted to gambling and can set fire to murder for money, if someone gives him money, will he do anything?"

He is trying to weaken the credibility of the testimony by reducing the impression score of the witnesses, after all, Peng Xianshen is a prisoner serving a prison sentence, and the credibility of his words will have a certain impact.

Du Shaoxing knew this habitual method best, and immediately stood up: "Your Excellency, the speculation of the lawyer of the second defendant has seriously slandered my witnesses, and has also rejected the attitude of all prisoners serving sentences to rehabilitate themselves, and I ask Your Excellency Judge to dismiss it." ”

The judge struck the gavel: "Lawyer for the second defendant, please pay attention to your remarks. ”

Jiang Chundong was silent, his question had been asked, and he sat back in his seat.

Du Shaoxing continued to defend: "I don't know if any of you here heard a piece of news at the end of last year? This is what the financial news section says," he took out a magazine from the table and read it according to it, "On the Zhangjiang Bridge, two cars collided, and Uncle Luo suffered a tragic accident and died in a fall into the river. ”

At that time, the news of Luo Changde's death was also in the news, which caused a lot of sensation in the business world, and many people in the audience knew about it.

"This happened right after my client received this recording. Du Shaoxing asked the jury members, "Isn't it a coincidence?"

He put down the magazine and spoke again, the words were sonorous and loud: "My client just got the recording evidence, he was kidnapped, and on the way back from the ransom of the second defendant, the car that my client was riding was hit by a large truck on the Zhangjiang Bridge and under the bridge, and the second defendant who was originally sitting in the same car as my client was not in the car at the moment of the accident, and did not even call the police at the first time, and the police had not recovered my client's body under the Zhangjiang River at that time, and the Locke family announced the death." He took a breath and asked himself, "Is it all a coincidence?"

It's a coincidence.

There are too many coincidences, and they are artificial.

Du Shaoxing led to his question: "Like you are killing people and killing people?" After asking, he faced Luo Qinghe, his tone suddenly accelerated, and he pressed every sentence, "Defendant No. 2, you can't make a plan, and you have another plan, in order to cover up your crime, you bite back on my client, and put all the charges of arson and murder on my client, so there is such a sad scene today, father and daughter turn against each other and go to court." ”

Luo Qinghe's face did not change, and he didn't react at all.

In terms of this psychological quality, it is indeed much stronger than Luo Changde.

Du Shaoxing was not in a hurry to see her true form revealed, and continued to present the evidence in court: "Your Excellency, this is a bank remittance bill, and the payee is the family of the owner of the car that caused the accident on the Zhangjiang Bridge. He himself has passed away, it is liver cancer, this money, several turnovers before remitted to his wife's account, because it is not a formal remittance channel, can not find the sender, but the time of remittance is just the third day after Zhang Jiang's car accident. In addition, the second defendant, Luo Qinghe, took out a sum of money from his private account the day before the car accident, and at present, the whereabouts of the money cannot be found, but the amount just coincides with the money received by the wife of the owner of the car who caused the accident.

"Jurors, just imagine, a patient with advanced liver cancer, one foot has already entered the coffin, what else can afford to get such a huge sum of money, unless," Du Shaoxing looked at Luo Qinghe, "unless he kills for others, exchanging his life for his life." ”

At this point in defense, Luo Changde seemed to have won it, the corners of his mouth were frantically raised, and he looked at Luo Qinghe proudly and defiantly.

"Defendant No. 2," Du Shaoxing asked Luo Qinghe, "what is the relationship between you and my client?"

Luo Qinghe was silent, from beginning to end, he just didn't say a word.

Du Shaoxing finally played another wave of emotional cards, and his emotions were very passionate: "I will answer for you, you are father and daughter, and you are blood relatives." He complained and accused, "In order to cover up the truth of the fire eight years ago, you did not hesitate to kidnap and murder your biological father, and even today, you have no intention of repenting, and you have put all the charges of murder on your father's head, and you will not be disturbed by your conscience and humanity to do such a thing that is unconscionable and unethical?"

Luo Qinghe picked the corners of his mouth, as if he felt funny, his hands hung down on his stomach, and he brushed his lower abdomen for a while.

Her lawyer, Jiang Chundong, did not refute either.

The direction of their defense is very clear, they don't debate their innocence, as long as Luo Changde is convicted of murder.

Her hole cards are still to come.

On Du Shaoxing's side, the argument was not guilty: "Finally, I want to reiterate to the judge and all the jurors, the second defendant has always claimed that my client killed someone in the fire, but my client did not have any motive to kill at all, the victim Tang Guangji was my client's right-hand man at that time, and the victim Luo San was the adopted son of the Luo family, and basically did not have much contact with my client, unlike the second defendant, who was incompatible with the victim Luo San." Du Shaoxing once again emphasized, "My client has no motive to kill. ”

There is not even a motive for the killing, how can the crime of intentional homicide be established.

At this moment, the door was pushed open, and Jiang Zhi and Zhou Xufang came in.

Jiang Chundong, who had been silent, stood up and refuted Du Shaoxing's last sentence: "There is a motive to kill." ”

Luo Changde glanced back at Jiang Zhi.

Luo Qinghe also raised his eyes, the show was about to begin.

Jiang Chundong walked to the front of the stage: "Your Excellency, please allow me to summon our No. 3 witness. ”

The judge granted.

Witness No. 3 came to court, it was Luo Yinghe, as soon as she came in, Xu Yunci stood up and shouted uncontrollably: "Yinghe, you come back for me!" She shouted, "Luo Yinghe, did you hear it!"

Luo Yinghe turned a deaf ear and walked to the witness stand.

Xu Yunci rushed out of his seat: "Luo Yinghe!"

The judge then rang the gavel and shouted in a deep voice, "Silence." ”

Xu Yunci stared at her daughter with red eyes, but it was Luo Huaiyu next to her, her face did not change from beginning to end, as if it was not his Luo family's case, watching the fire on the other side, he just raised his head and glanced at Jiang Zhi.

What a big game of chess.

Jiang Zhi took Zhou Xufang and sat down next to Zhou Qingrang.

The trial continued, and Jiang Chundong walked up to Luo Yinghe: "Witness, introduce yourself first." ”

She looked at the audience and said, "I'm Luo Yinghe." ”

The opposing lawyer, Du Shaoxing, didn't understand this for a while, so he looked at Luo Changde, and he was also in a fog, and he couldn't figure out why the situation suddenly changed.

Jiang Chundong began to ask Luo Yinghe: "What is the relationship between you and the two defendants?"