Zhang Ruiming felt that something was wrong, thinking of Wu Kaiming's offensive rhythm, coupled with the unexpected media, he deliberately carefully checked the crowd in the auditorium several times.

If it weren't for the war of public opinion, the master would not have made such a "tight" move at the beginning, today is a public interest lawsuit, and in terms of the situation, the killing power can't be killed.

"Tight" is a Go term, which refers to the move in the game of chess, where there is no room for play, all places are spelled to the fullest, and it is generally a special move in local combat.

And this trial, from the beginning, was tense, and in terms of the master's character, it was very unreasonable. Unless otherwise.

Sure enough, from a very low angle, Zhang Ruiming found that a guy in the auditorium was hiding a mobile phone and secretly filming the trial process.

Zhang Ruiming immediately understood that Wu Kaiming didn't want to fight a quick war at all, and he would never mediate, this time he first found a loophole in the prosecutor, and then used the off-the-board trick of secretly filming, plus the reporters brought by the court door, this is to find an opportunity to completely reverse this public interest lawsuit. They should still have hole cards in their hands.

It is very likely that the master wants to directly divert the focus of the case and play the "great shift".

Anyway, I can only beat this candid photo first. Zhang Ruiming immediately raised his hand to report the situation to the trial court, the bailiff wearing a judicial police uniform, stepped forward, rushed to the observer seat, dragged a sneaky young man from the observer seat, found a mobile phone secretly brought into the court from his trouser pocket, opened it and took a look, before Wu Kaiming angrily scolded Zhang Liang for not being a prosecutor in the post and had no qualifications to litigate, the video had been passed out, and there was only one icon on the WeChat chat record that the video had been transmitted, Zhang Ruiming shook his head with a wry smile, and looked at Wu Kaiming in the defendant's seat.

The old lawyer's face was expressionless, and he almost wrote a few big words on his face, "Everything has nothing to do with him", Zhang Ruiming had no doubt that Master Taishan collapsed in front of him and his expression remained unchanged, not to mention that he won this chess.

The presiding judge Lu Youliang also looked at Wu Kaiming, but he didn't notice any change in Wu Kaiming's expression, so he cleared his throat to disrupt the order of the court, and drove the kid out of the courtroom first.

But Zhang Ruiming is not so relaxed, it is completely conceivable that tomorrow in the media from all walks of life, the overwhelming questioning of himself and Zhang Liang, in the current public opinion environment, any mistake of the prosecutor will become the focus of the other party's attack, and the deputy procurator general Yan will not say that it doesn't matter at that time, but will only become the vanguard of criticism of himself.

Assistant Zhang Liang was already crying anxiously now, and Zhang Ruiming's hand gently knocked on her desk. Let her calm down first, and now he is more worried about the other hole card that Wu Kaiming should have.

Since he dares to go head-to-head in this absolutely disadvantaged civil public interest litigation lawsuit, and even dares to guide the media against the trend and cause a storm of public opinion, there is definitely a hole card that has not been played!

With the completion of the personnel checks and the completion of the proceedings for the recusal application, the crucial court investigation phase is next.

Presiding Judge Lu Youliang: "Now that the court investigation begins, first of all, please ask the public prosecutor to read out the indictment in court. ”

When Zhang Ruiming read out the indictment on behalf of the prosecutor, his consistently calm and powerful sentences maintained a high level of performance, and the logic was thorough, and the most important issue of the "drug runway case", that is, the relationship between proving the harm and the result, in this case, is the causal relationship between the laying of the plastic runway and the student's illness.

Presiding Judge Lu Youliang: "Did you hear clearly the indictment read out by the prosecutor just now?"

asked one by one, no one objected, and then Lu Youliang: "The following is for the defendant to state the illegal facts alleged in the indictment." ”

When the defendant had spoken, Wu Kaiming stood up to make a statement on behalf of Jingang City No. 4 Middle School. Leave the responsibility clean, from the municipal subject, to the environmental standards, to the construction supervision, full of tricks, clearly to defend the blameless, Zhang Ruiming even wanted to secretly give his master a praise, in front of ironclad evidence, dare to state like this, this is to break the kettle, the courage is commendable.

As soon as Wu Kaiming sat back in his seat, he sent a meaningful smile to Zhang Ruiming, and Zhang Ruiming understood that this was the master putting pressure on him.

Old fox, you're playing tricks again, let's see what your fox medicine is.

Zhang Ruiming was very surprised by Wu Kaiming's not-guilty defense, but he was not particularly worried that this public interest lawsuit was a very rare "official sue official" case in the country. In the eyes of the common people, the school belongs to your government, and the procuratorate is a state organ.

In the eyes of some people, the general "official sue official" is even synonymous with "dog eats dog".

But this time is different, this is a civil public interest lawsuit, Zhang Ruiming represents the identity of the prosecutor, and it is the state to recover the public welfare for the families who were victimized in the "drug runway" case. Therefore, Zhang Ruiming will be surprised by Master's ruin, but he is not afraid.

Because the prosecutor is on the side of justice and public welfare.

Once the statement process has passed, it is immediately time to summarize the focus and present evidence.

This link can be said to be the most critical moment of this public interest lawsuit, how to prove whether the plastic runway laid by No. 4 Middle School meets the standards, whether it is toxic and harmful, and whether there is a causal relationship with the symptoms of children. The appraisal report is the decisive factor.

And now there is one of the biggest problems, the current national testing standard for plastic runways "synthetic runway surface layer" (GB/T14833-2011). Although the national standard has a section on the limit of harmful substances in the runway surface layer of synthetic materials (4.2), in the most critical "judgment rule" (6.3) involving the test results, there is only one sentence: "When the control test results meet the requirements of 4.1.4 (physical properties of the runway surface layer of synthetic materials) of this standard, it is judged to be qualified." When the test result is unqualified, another double sample should be taken for inspection, if it is still unqualified, the batch of products is unqualified. ”

That is to say, basically, as long as it is tested according to the national standard, these "toxic runways" will be qualified!

This national standard was quite unreasonable at the beginning, but now with the passage of time, scientific and technological progress, coupled with the gradual attention to environmental pollution, this national standard has long been out of line with the reality, but it is the biggest problem in this case.

Therefore, Zhang Ruiming's litigation strategy is to bypass this logical problem, not to prove whether the "toxic runway" is qualified or not, but to directly take out the hospital diagnosis certificate of the students who have adverse reactions and the extraction data of harmful substances on the "toxic runway", directly bypass the problem of whether the "toxic runway" is compliant, and directly lead the focus of the dispute back to the pollution of the "toxic runway", which is a logical and thoughtful tactic.

Therefore, it is also deliberately for fear that Wu Kaiming will come up with a qualified appraisal report for the "toxic runway", because the identification of the limit of harmful substances in the surface layer of the runway of synthetic materials in this national standard is very troublesome, and it generally takes more than half a year to complete the whole procedure, so Zhang Ruiming's tactic is to file a public interest lawsuit as soon as possible, and promote the litigation process before this national standard that has long been in line with the reality of the trouble, in terms of tactics, it is a blitzkrieg, directly take the middle palace, and decide everything in one fell swoop!

For the sake of justice, but also for the children who have suffered from the "toxic runway".

Xiao Yifeng, male, 16 years old, a student in Class 412 of Jingang No. 4 High School, was diagnosed with acute laryngitis by the First People's Hospital of Jingang City;

Ding Zhou, male, 13 years old, a student of Class 322 of Jingang No. 4 Middle School, was diagnosed by Jingang First People's Hospital with: chronic bronchitis;

Wu Xiaoqin, female, 14 years old, a former student in Class 371 of Jingang No. 4 Middle School, was diagnosed by the First People's Hospital of Jingang with a type of hematopoietic stem cell malignant disease, which is commonly known as leukemia............

In the evidence stage, as Zhang Ruiming read aloud about the 17 students of the fourth middle school who were injured to varying degrees in the "drug runway" case. After hearing the diagnosis certificates issued by the First People's Hospital of Jingang and Hong Kong, the soft sighs of the observers were faintly heard from the auditorium.

Pity the hearts of parents all over the world, the most precious thing is always the child.

However, the master who knows the apprentice best is always the master, just after Zhang Ruiming gradually took the initiative, in the most critical part of the defendant's evidence, Wu Kaiming proposed to the collegial panel: "We have new important evidence to submit to the collegial panel, this is an inspection and appraisal report on the limit of harmful substances in the surface layer of the synthetic material runway of Jingang No. 4 Middle School!"

Sure enough, Zhang Ruiming suddenly felt a chill behind his back, and a stone was heavily blocked in his heart, this was an "evidence raid"! All the previous off-the-market moves and qualification objections were all tricks.

This is Wu Kaiming's hole card, Wu Kaiming is not ready to fight fast, he still has to grind his good apprentice to death step by step.

Although I don't know what method he used to make the inspection and appraisal that usually takes more than half a year to be issued in just three months, one thing is certain, this lawsuit is facing an unprecedented strong enemy.

Zhang Ruiming immediately responded: "Oppose! If the other party fails to present evidence after the time limit for presenting evidence, this evidence cannot be used and is invalid evidence!"

However, after reviewing the evidence in court and deliberating briefly, the collegial panel declared: "The objection is invalid, and this evidence has the three characteristics of evidence - authenticity, legitimacy, and relevance." It is related to the case, true and legal, and can be admissible as evidence. ”

Zhang Ruiming involuntarily clenched his fists, this evidence can be said to be direct evidence, so important, sure enough, the collegial panel will adopt it after the expiration of the time limit for presenting evidence.

The objection to Wu Kaiming's late presentation of evidence was rejected, and Zhang Ruiming could only watch as the collegial panel decided to adopt this national standard inspection and appraisal out of consideration for the importance of this evidence.

There was no way, in this critical situation, Zhang Ruiming decided to withdraw his troops for the time being: he applied to the collegial panel for an adjournment to prepare to refute the new evidence.

The moment the adjournment was announced under the gavel of the presiding judge. Zhang Ruiming felt particularly tired for a moment, looking at his mentor Wu Kaiming, who took the initiative to come over and shake hands with him, Zhang Ruiming stretched out his right hand, and this time Zhang Ruiming shook this respectable opponent hard,

"It's been a long time, and I don't come to sit in the house when I pass by, last time your senior sister Liao said that you saw her in the courtyard of a case last time, just like a cat saw a mouse, you have a cold face,"

Zhang Ruiming's face was a little embarrassed, and he explained with a dry smile: "No, master, that is in court, it's the same case, out of the principle of avoidance, it's not good for me to talk too much to Senior Sister Liao, make amends, make amends, next time I will explain to Senior Sister in person." ”

Wu Kaiming gently patted Zhang Ruiming on the shoulder: "Zhang Jian, you are now the deputy chief of the Civil Banking Section, and you are a prosecutor in the court, but we still have friendship in life, and we have time to come out and get together." ”

"Definitely, definitely," Zhang Ruiming replied with a slightly red face.

In his heart, he said to himself: "Come on, Master, you can find out all the tricks in this case, since you want to drag it out, then I will accompany you to the end." ”