It is no wonder that Wu Kaiming, an old Jianghu, his litigation strategy is based on the emotions of the represented, and the Jingang Municipal Bureau of Natural Resources is extremely angry at the public interest lawsuit suddenly filed by the Jingang Municipal Procuratorate, and the counterattack attitude is also very tough, clearly to fight it out, and will not easily admit defeat. As the acting lawyer, Wu Kaiming, of course, must also consider the opinions of the represented unit and win directly in court, which will not give Zhang Ruiming a weak illusion.

Zhang Ruiming glanced back at the auditorium, there were still a few minutes before the official start of the trial, but Zhang Ruiming's face had begun to show a little anxiety, this time Wu Kaiming and their representatives failed to achieve the goal of "closed trial", but obviously did something tricks, at this time it was close to the trial, in this public interest litigation courtroom, there were not a few people seated, and the most important thing was that the people Zhang Ruiming was waiting for had not yet arrived.

He bowed his head and asked Zhang Liang, "What's the situation? What about Committee Members Zhou and Committee Members You who contacted us earlier? Why haven't you come yet?"

Zhang Liang looked back at the empty auditorium, and his eyes were full of doubts: "I don't know, when we came in before, no one answered when I called, could it be the release of pigeons?"

These two CPPCC members are judicial supervisors and representatives of the masses who are designated by the Tianjin and Hong Kong City Procuratorate, and today Zhang Ruiming specially invited the two to come over, because he expected that Wu Kaiming would suppress the media and news, and wanted to use the special status of these two people to exert a little pressure on the Bureau of Natural Resources and Wu Kaiming.

Unexpectedly, these two people didn't even see a figure at this time.

"Minister, why don't I get in touch with them and see if they're stuck in traffic?"

Zhang Liang wanted to make amends, but Zhang Ruiming stopped her.

"What's the matter, don't you still have to rely on these two committee members today, what are you stopping me from......

Zhang Ruiming just shook his head with a bitter face: "We came all the way just now, and today is so smooth, how can it be blocked on the road......"

"Minister, then you mean that the Taisho Office stopped them?"

The next words, Zhang Ruiming didn't say it clearly, he just shook his head and motioned for Zhang Liang to skip this matter, this little girl had a puzzled look, but Zhang Ruiming was insightful in his heart.

When I contacted the two a few days ago, the two committee members agreed that they would come over to observe the hearing today, but after only a few days, they immediately changed their attitude and thought about it...... Zhang Ruiming looked up at the opposite side at this time, Wu Kaiming was looking down and whispering to a leader of the Bureau of Natural Resources, looking up from time to time to glance at Zhang Ruiming, and the atmosphere between the two parties was gradually becoming cold.

As the electronic clock hanging on the wall moves towards 9:30 a.m., this major case involving many powerful departments in Tianjin and Hong Kong is about to kick off.

…………

The female clerk of today's public interest litigation court is obviously more experienced than the young Judge Chen, she saw that the time was on time, she glanced up at both sides, and saw that the number of people had also arrived, and it was time for the court to start, but the presiding judge sitting on the trial table behind her was still busy sorting out the materials and documents, she looked up at the monitor on the top of the trial table, and she knew

Dao: Today's case is very important, and there may be many important people who are staring at the open network of the trial, watching the live broadcast of this trial every inch.

But now that Judge Chen hadn't been able to figure out her paperwork for a few minutes, the experienced female clerk thought for a while, then suddenly stood up straight, adjusted the expression on her face, and began to slowly check the attendance of the parties and other litigation participants in court, giving the young presiding judge time to adjust.

"Attorney ad litem?"

Wu Kaiming replied in a mellow voice: "To"

"Wu Kaiming of Taizheng Law Firm?"

"What is your ID ......?"

"Hmm. ”

Wu Kaiming's expression was very relaxed, and his answer seemed a little lazy, in stark contrast to the young judge on the trial table, as if he was the protagonist here. And when the clerk asked, "Is the public interest litigation prosecutor in court?", Zhang Ruiming's heart passed by with a warm current, and he finally had another opportunity to scold Fang Xuan in court. His heart was touched.

He replied in a mellow tone, "Here." ”

…………

"After the verification is completed, the public interest litigation plaintiff and the litigation participants are invited to sit in the court......"

After the clerk has checked and ascertained the appearance of the parties and other participants in the proceedings, he must invite both parties to the court according to the procedure, although the two parties, who are not considered novices, have already sat in their seats.

The next court discipline reading session was uneventful.

"All observers are requested to remain quiet, and now read out the rules of the court: 1. Observers must remain quiet, and must not applaud, make noise, make noise, or engage in other acts that obstruct trial activities......"

I don't know if it's Zhang Ruiming's illusion, he feels that the clerk's reading speed is particularly slow today, obviously giving the presiding judge time to find something, and sure enough, when Judge Chen finally packed up his things, the clerk here also finished reading out the discipline.

“…… All members of the collegial panel are invited to enter the courtroom. ”

From beginning to end, it was obvious that someone wanted to handle this case in a low-key manner, and even the auditorium was empty, so naturally the whole link was a little lax, and the members of the collegial panel sat on the trial table long before the clerk invited him to enter the courtroom.

In the past, when he was in the Public Prosecution Department, Zhang Ruiming had held too many "fast courts" with not so rigorous procedures, and Zhang Ruiming was not surprised by the current scene, the only thing he was worried about was that this young Judge Chen's face was too raw, and he was too tender, and the more such a "rookie egg", the more susceptible he was to the influence from above......

"Report to the presiding judge, the prosecutor and the participants in the proceedings have all arrived in court, the courtroom is ready, please instruct the court to open!"

Judge Chen glanced left and right, his eyes were obviously a little distant, and his attitude was not so firm, as if he was routine, his right hand numbly picked up the gavel, and "ding", this person was so tender that even the gavel was not half ringing, and the one Zhang Ruiming knew had a cold attitude in the Tianjin Pharmaceutical and Chemical case, and loved this gavel

's sense of ceremony, Judge Zuo Ning, who is accustomed to striking the gavel loudly, is just two extremes.

But no matter how novice he is, he is also a dignified presiding judge, after a slightly flawed beginning, this Judge Zuo gradually found his senses, coughed a little, and announced loudly: "The Sixth Public Interest Litigation Trial Division of the Intermediate People's Court of Jingang City, Nanzhou Province, today has an open trial on the case of the Jingang City Natural Resources Bureau, the defendant unit of the Jingang City People's Procuratorate in Nanzhou Province filing an administrative public interest lawsuit with this court, for not recovering the state-owned land transfer fee in accordance with the law. Now for the trial!"

The gavel is sounding again! The pre-trial preparation stage has ended, and the trial stage has officially begun!

…………

The first step in the hearing is the identity of the defendant in the public interest litigation and the time when the administrative public interest litigation complaint was received.

"On July 2, 2019, the Jingang Municipal Bureau of Natural Resources, the defendant unit of the Jingang Municipal People's Procuratorate in Nanzhou Province filed an administrative public interest lawsuit against this court, and on July 2, 2019, the Jingang Municipal Bureau of Natural Resources, the defendant unit of the Jingang Municipal People's Procuratorate filed an administrative public interest lawsuit with this court, and this court decided to accept the case on July 13, 2019. In accordance with the relevant provisions of the Administrative Litigation Development of the People's Republic of China, this court shall hear the case in open court in accordance with the ordinary procedures of the first-instance public prosecution case. ”

After reading out the opening remarks and introducing the information of the three collegial panel members, he began to introduce the participants in the litigation according to the procedure: "...... The Jingang Municipal People's Procuratorate appointed Zhang Ruiming and Zhang Liang to appear in court to support the administrative public interest litigation; Dazheng Law Firm was entrusted by the defendant Jingang Municipal Bureau of Natural Resources to appoint Dazheng Law Firm lawyers Wu Kaiming and Dong Gang to appear in court to represent the defendant in the litigation, and the Jingang Municipal Bureau of Natural Resources appointed the unit to ......"

After switching to the People's Bank of China, Zhang Ruiming had far fewer opportunities to hear these words than when he was in the Public Prosecution Division, and at this time, it sounded faintly a sense of nobility from the inside out.

“…… The parties and agents ad litem are now informed of the procedural rights they enjoy in accordance with the law during the course of court proceedings:

(1) Applications may be made for the recusal of collegial panel members, clerks, public interest litigation prosecutors, evaluators, and translators;

(2) Evidence may be submitted, applications may be made to notify new witnesses to appear in court, new evidence may be collected, and new appraisals or inquests or inspections may be conducted;

(3) The entrusted agent may......

After a lengthy process, the trial finally entered the substantive court investigation phase.

"Now to start the court investigation, first ask the public interest litigation prosecutor to read out the administrative public interest litigation complaint in court. ”

Although there has been a period of time without a real battle in the court, but Zhang Ruiming's foundation is still there, when he read out the administrative public interest litigation complaint on behalf of the Jingang Municipal Procuratorate, his speech was calm, his voice was full, and its content was much less than Zhang Liang next to him expected, this girl still had some doubts at first, why Zhang Ruiming read out the complaint in about three minutes, and the content was really concise, but she immediately reacted, the reason for this is that Zhang Ruiming had taught her a few years ago: the complaint should be as concise as possible, especially the content should be a little rougher, so as to avoid too much disclosure of the prosecution's litigation strategy and thinking trend, which is also what Zhang Ruiming often teaches her, learning to "hide clumsy", which is much more meaningful than appearing smart.

()

Set a small goal first, such as remembering in 1 second: book guest residence