2386 The outlook is unpredictable
In addition to Italy's "Daily Fact", Germany's "Die Zeit" and the UK's "Screen" both gave two stars.
Germany's "Die Zeit": "The film firmly grabs the audience's attention with an eerie opening in a cold tone, and it is very attractive from the setting to the concept, and the cold mechanical performance is the icing on the cake." However, after entering the middle section, he began to get lost, and the director did not seem to be able to determine the focus of his narrative 100%, not only losing the biggest core of black humor: 'human beings transformed into animals', but also wavering on the themes of love and family, relationship and class, causing all the energy accumulated in the first half to disappear. ”
Later, the magazine also wrote an in-depth film review to analyze, from the entire story framework to the main clues to the branch layout, and then deeply analyzed the beginning and end of the plot, expressing deep regret for the "chaos" of the final product, and they believe that "Eggels-Lanthimos has the opportunity to shoot a classic masterpiece that will go down in history".
At the same time, the article also emphasized the excellence of the entire cast, not only Lan Li, Ben Whishaw, Rachel Weisz and John C. Reilly and other actors all gave wonderful performances, and the seemingly wooden but ingenious performance method gave the characters more connotations worth excavating, which is why the article believes that "movies have countless possibilities".
"In the whole script, or the whole movie, the only character with a clear context and three-dimensional image is David played by Lan Li Hall.
The emotional ups and downs and the step-by-step advancement of thoughts, complete and vivid, delicate and profound, Lan Li-Hall gives the character infinite possibilities within the limited space, but unfortunately, this is the only complete role, and the lack of details of the other characters leaves the actors with no more room to play, and also limits the further progress of the film.
In the end, the result is that David and other characters, David and the main plot line are also slightly separated, because the real core idea of the characters and the plot is not clearly established, and the condensed power is in a state of collapse, which in turn affects the audience's resonance. ”
Later, this article entered the sight of the "Lobster" crew, and Lan Li even took the initiative to share the views of the article with Ogels, and the two sides exchanged their opinions.
During the promotion period of the film, Oucks also publicly expressed his gratitude, not only thanking the reporters of the German "Die Zeit" magazine, which learned a lot, but also mentioning the discussion between him and Lan Li before the start of the filming, obviously they were aware of the problem and tried to make adjustments.
"As they said, Lan Li's role is undoubtedly the most complete and clearest, because Lan Li knows what he is doing, and he also knows where he should go, this movie can reach the current height, Lan Li's role is far bigger than imagined;
I think that's why we need to keep learning and growing. ”
Not only did Ogles humbly accept the opinion and complete the review, but he also sincerely expounded the small episode of being critical of Lan Li at the beginning, so that he really realized the irreplaceable importance of a good actor for the whole film.
Such a gesture won a lot of applause in North America and Europe, and people not only did not complain about "lobster" because of this, but also generated more interest.
This also allowed "The Lobster" to secure a good spot during the awards season – and of course, that's another story.
Back to the Festival de Cannes.
The last media outlet to give a two-star rating was the British "screen".
"Indeed, 'The Lobster' is a work of no other, a deafening work, a mirror-like representation of our lives, which makes us reflect on our own marital relationships and social classes, and the cold lines of a scalpel outline the framework of an entire era. The mastery skills shown by Eggles Lanthimos through the movie initially showed the style of a master, but the gap between him and Stanley Kubrick lies in the humanistic care -
The film's thematic core is cold, detached, and even somewhat triumphant, like New York intellectuals mocking other poets for pretending to care about the world. It's arrogant and arrogant, and it doesn't resonate with the audience.
But we still can't deny that Lancemos did boldly challenge the sensitive nerves of some people, and we can't deny that the performance of Lanley Hall and Rachel Weisz has a keen and delicate touch that gives the film something more profound.
It's just that we're not sure exactly what 'something' is. ”
These are the 10 media reviews of the official Cannes house catalogue.
It is difficult to get too many clues from the score of the house magazine, no one can predict the prospect of "Lobster" in Cannes this year, judging from the current mainstream trend, the French media has generally expressed a positive attitude, which is precisely in line with the aesthetic style of the Coen brothers, and it is indeed very promising to win the award.
But the direction of the wind is only the direction of the wind, and the media cannot accurately predict the preferences of the jury, which is not new in the three major European film festivals.
In the end, the official house catalogue was released, two five-star, four three-star, three two-star, and one one-star, and finally in the evaluation of four out of four, "Lobster" got two points and seven points.
A closer look shows that, firstly, the reviews are relatively average, and secondly, the positive reviews are greater than the negative ones, with the number of five-star ratings higher than the number of one-star ratings, and the number of three-star ratings higher than the number of two-star ratings. In other words, on the whole, the comments on "Lobster" are still trending towards a positive trend amid debate and heated discussions.
The average score of 2.7 is the most direct manifestation of this.
For the Cannes Film Festival, only a three-point work can be called a "classic", such as "Drunken Country Folk" two years ago, but in the history of the Cannes Film Festival, there are only about 20 works that can win more than three points, which is very rare.
At 2.7 points, this is already a very good evaluation, so what is the position of "Lobster" in the main competition unit - the official house book in your hand can be seen at a glance.
Today is the sixth day of the Cannes Film Festival, and the annual event has just passed the halfway point, and the screening plans of the main competition, directors' fortnight, un of a concern, etc., are steadily unfolding, among which the most watched main competition unit has screened eight works, and all the scores have been publicly presented:
"Sea Street Diary", 2.5.
"The Story of the Story", 2.0.
"Son of Saul", 2.8.
"My Mother", 2.7.
"Aokigahara Jukai", 0.6.
"My King", 1.4.
"Market Law", 2.3.
"Lobster", 2.7.
There is no need to analyze at all, the overall pattern of the main competition unit is very clear.
Gus Van Sant's "Aokigahara Tree Sea" landed in Cannes under the long-awaited, but was hit by an unprecedented full-scale hit on the streets, and this work starring Matthew McConaughey has faced a lot of criticism and created the lowest house magazine rating in Cannes since the 21st century, which is particularly tragic.
Hungarian director Laszlo-Nemes' feature film debut "Son of Saul" was rejected by the Berlinale main competition at the beginning of the year, and despite being able to screen it out of competition, the main creative team decided to abandon Berlin and come to Cannes, where it was a huge success, currently leading the highest score in the house book with 2.8 points, and also won a full house at the premiere, with both the Coen brothers and Sienna Miller in tears.
And then...... Italian director Nanni-Moretti's new film "My Mother" and Eggs Lansmoss's "The Lobster" also temporarily tied for second place in the house magazine with a score of 2.7, which is even better than the Japanese director Hirokazu Kore-eda's topical work "Sea Street Diary".
So, what does this mean exactly?
The answer is: it doesn't mean anything.
The house book is the house book, the rating is the score, and the award is another matter, and the aesthetics of the media journalists cannot represent the opinions and opinions of the jury.
But one thing is certain: "Lobster" is far from hitting the streets, and even not as harsh and harsh as the verbal criticism that "Detachment" faced at the beginning; after "I Fight Cancer", Lan Li, who once again challenged comedy performance, unexpectedly refreshed the public's impression and brought novel performances again.
It can be said that the blue gift, which just won the second Oscar not long ago, still maintains its consistently high level.
That's enough.
What's more, even if it hits the streets, Lan Li can still detonate the discussion craze of reporters, so this has no impact on reporters.
"So, how does it feel?" waited for Lan Li to finish reading the house book, and Bradley threw an introduction.
Lan Li pursed the corners of his lips, "I really want to see the two works of 'Son of Thor' and 'Aokigahara Jukai'. "One highest score and one lowest score.
Bradley couldn't help but laugh.
Gavin asked curiously, "Why? Is it just because of good and bad reviews?"
"Part of the reason. I have to admit that Gus was the only thing that made Gus shoot that gave the media such a low score. Lan Li glanced at the house catalogue again: six one stars, four media outlets refused to comment, which is really terrible, "If I remember correctly, when 'Elephant' premiered in Cannes, it was so controversial that there were even reporters who fought at the press conference. I guess that's the case with this work?"
In his previous life, Lan Li had never watched the work "Aokigahara Jukai" because he didn't think it was necessary, but now that his perspective and ideas have changed, he did have some curiosity.
"Previously, Christopher Nolan personally confirmed that the number one choice for 'Interstellar' was Matthew McConaughey, but in the end you were chosen to play it. After missing this work, Matthew's works in the past two years seem to have failed to meet expectations, and it is generally considered to be a little golden man curse, and this time 'Aokigahara Jukai' is facing such an encounter, what do you think?"