…………

is different from Liao Cai's gnashing of teeth and Zhang Ruiming's brilliance and restraint.

The protagonist in this lawsuit, Wang Yingying, the boss of Tianjin Pharmaceutical Chemical, is out of place in this noisy trial scene. This business tycoon in Jingang City was sitting quietly in the dock with a disillusioned face at this time, and the bailiff Yue Tingyuan next to him had a majestic expression and a strict appearance, which made him short and cowering.

He clearly knew before that this trial would announce the end of his career, no matter how he struggled, under so many media lenses and so much attention, the IPO of Tianjin Pharmaceutical Chemical was completely out of play.

All mouths are golden, and they know the subtleties.

Wang Yingying has even smelled the murderous machine above, China has always done things first, and he pays attention to making a fortune with a muffled voice.

It's always the boots that fall to the ground that they hear the sound.

And on the other hand, if the sound has already been heard earth-shattering, the matter is basically decided.

In Wang Yingying's view, since he was tried in such a public with such fanfare today, the result was almost doomed, and the only question was whether he could get a suspended sentence.

Therefore, in the previous meetings in the detention center, unlike Liao Cai and other Taisho lawyer lawyers, who were still confident in their analysis and planning, he had always listened pessimistically and low-key, as if he was a bystander, talking about someone else's case.

At the last meeting, after learning that several "actions" against Zhang Ruiming had failed and the entire public opinion had fallen to the prosecution, Wang Yingying seemed to know the outcome, and closed his eyes and was silent for a while.

The merchant, who was proficient in poetry, finally chanted a poem: I alone do not work for its form. Xiao Da has no way to know the destiny of heaven.

Although the client was pessimistic and gave up, it did not affect the professionalism of the entrusted lawyer.

Defence lawyer Liao Cai was not affected by the change in the situation, and she knew that she still had a chance to turn the tables.

The first adjournment was due to the fact that after the prosecution submitted a new inspection report and video evidence, the trial was adjourned on the grounds that Liao Cai was requested to prepare for the new evidence.

More than half of the litigation procedures have been carried out in the last court session, and this second court session is mainly aimed at cross-examination and review of new evidence, as well as cross-examination and defense of new evidence, or new supplementary defense opinions can also be submitted.

Then, now that the war is rekindled, the first task of the defense is, of course, to defeat the prosecutor's last killer move - the inspection and appraisal report on the limit of harmful substances in the mother liquor of Yujin Pharmaceutical Chemical Wastewater.

"Report to the collegial panel, we believe that the No. 12 evidence procedure proposed by the prosecution is illegal and does not conform to the relevance of the evidence! Legality! We are completely unaware of the process of the other party's extraction of the samples, have not received any investigation procedures and documents, and do not have any evidence to prove that the extraction process is legal and effective! Moreover, it is impossible to prove that it was extracted from the production workshop of my client, and the inspection and appraisal report on the limit of harmful substances obtained from this is completely illegal! Our client has not received any investigation and evidence collection at all, but such an appraisal report suddenly appeared......? The prosecution is suspected of illegally obtaining evidence!"

This beautiful lawyer is not like words, and her temperament is even more good against the backdrop of the skirt, and when she asked, she was driven by Liao Cai's subdued tone, and the auditorium let out bursts of exclamations.

I don't know if I was amazed by her beauty, or impressed by her precedent momentum, but according to the eyes of those male observers, it is estimated that the former is more likely.

After listening to the presiding judge Zuo Ning with an expressionless face, he turned to the prosecution's seat and said, "What objections does the prosecution have to the defense's cross-examination?"

Zhang Ruiming was silent for a while, and began to answer: "The appraisal report supplemented by our prosecutor in the last trial meets the three characteristics of evidence, and the extraction process of the sample materials is supported by detailed video records and documents, and there is no illegal evidence collection as claimed by the opposing lawyer. The defence argument is unjustified. ”

"Oh, there are videos and documents that prove the evidence collection process?" Zuo Ning was still lukewarm to Zhang Ruiming, but compared to his previous deliberate cold face, this time his face, attitude and invisible support during the trial process had already made Zhang Ruiming overjoyed.

After all, Zhang Ruiming didn't make fun of this cold-faced old comrade who had broken a few gavels before, and now it's very good that people don't hold grudges.

"The report collegial panel, the video and documents of the evidence collection process have been attached to the attached page of this appraisal report. ”

"Well, I saw that. “

"No way! You didn't search...... You obviously didn't take any ......" Liao Cai looked incredulous at this time, she knew that the prosecution had conducted a raid on the production workshop of Tianjin Pharmaceutical and Chemical Industry with the Xijiang Branch and the Jingang Environmental Protection Bureau before, but wasn't that time stopped by Wang Yingying through pressure from above!? At that time, the prosecutor obviously didn't take any evidence away, so how did this inspection material fall into their hands?

Zhang Ruiming raised his eyebrows and responded to Liao Cai's question with a confident smile.

"Do I need to play video material?"

"Yes. ”

At Zuo Ning's signal, the clerk took out the disc in the attached page of the appraisal report in public and put it into the player card slot in the middle of the courtroom, and the video began to play:

At the beginning of the picture, the angle of view is relatively low, obviously from the position of a person's shoulder, it should be taken by a body police recorder clamped on the shoulder, in the middle of the picture is the back of a girl wearing a navy blue prosecutor's uniform, the girl is bending over and fiddling with something in front of the valve equipment of a huge tank, the background sound is noisy, Liao Cai understands at a glance - this is the scene of the aborted search operation.

"How's it going? Okay, huh?"

"How do I know how to get this thing, I can't get it out in half a day......"

The question in the background should be Wu Yun, a young prosecutor holding a law enforcement recorder, and it was the girl who answered, and at this time, the girl who had been facing away from the camera turned around, a delicate little face shining with excitement, and she was holding a PT test tube in one hand.

"Got it! got it!"

"I'm on the recorder, so I'll explain it quickly. ”

The female prosecutor Zhang Liang wanted to shout excitedly, but after being reminded by Wu Yun, she could only force her excitement: "Oh, oh, okay, our prosecutor took a sample of glyphosate mother liquor produced in the normal production process of the workshop at 11 a.m. on March 23, 2018 at the first mother liquor tank in the Tianjin Pharmaceutical Chemical Production Workshop, and the sample ......"

…………

This is the whole process of Wu Yun and Zhang Liang mentioning the inspection materials at that time.

After the video was played, before the presiding judge Zuo Ning could speak, Liao Cai said angrily: "This extraction video cannot prove the legality of this search, as far as I know, the operation was finally stopped! You have not been allowed to seal, seize, or freeze any evidence! There is no evidence at all to be taken away......

Zhang Ruiming chuckled and said: "Defense lawyer, I won't argue with you about the process of this search, at that time, you forced us not to carry out any sealing, seizure, or freezing measures through pressure...... But it didn't ask us not to take the samples! That's why this evidence was preserved, and even if it was suspended, the search was done with the permission of the superiors, and the documents were attached to it.

......Liao Cai wanted to argue something, but couldn't say anything, she knew that this evidence had tilted the scales in favor of the prosecution.

"What are the defendant's cross-examination opinions?" Zuo Ning turned to the defendant's dock according to the procedure

Wang Yingying seemed to be numb, and it took a few seconds before he reacted and said, "No...... There are opinions. ”

"Okay, next ......"

The prosecution believes that one of the unlicensed hazardous chemical tank trucks is the vehicle driven by Li Yongjian to carry glyphosate mother liquor, and this video data was also copied into the CD and submitted at the last minute in the last trial.

However, this evidence is a little flawed, after all, it is only an unlicensed dangerous car, and because of the deliberate blocking, there is no clear close-up shot, and there are problems in all three aspects of the evidence, so after some debate, the collegial panel is likely to exclude this evidence.

"Damn!" After being pulled back by Liao Cai, Zhang Ruiming raised his head dissatisfiedly, and just swept his gaze over Wang Yingying in the dock in the venue.

Wang Yingying, who had a dejected face, kept his head down during this trial, his expression was like a tree, and he no longer saw his original spirit. Zhang Ruiming glanced at him, and the complicated emotions in his heart were churning.

I do have reason to hate him, and during this period of time, I have been hacked one after another, whether it is those hooligans who pretend to be the Supervision Commission, or the real Supervision Commission who has been falsely accused and harmed, and the real Supervision Commission has taken measures against him, and even instructed Luo Zhai to frame himself and his wife before, all of this is very likely to be instructed by the former close friend of the Zhang family in front of him.

Although he almost killed his family and was imprisoned, Zhang Ruiming still hated the old man in front of him who had scolded Fang Qiu. After all, he was once taken care of and cared for by him, and even at the beginning, he wanted to exchange and compromise with himself through his resources.

But justice can be compromised?

"Next, does the prosecution have any evidence to provide?"

Zuo Ning's voice pulled Zhang Ruiming back to reality, Zhang Ruiming glanced back at Xie Qisheng, who had just been in the cross-examination, and the prosecutor, who was in the upper hand, suddenly fell into a strange silence, both of them were full of hesitation in their eyes, and even the assistant Zhang Liang next to him curled his mouth with a look of displeasure.

The eye contact between the prosecutors did not escape the eyes of Liao Cai on the other side.

Although it seems that the prosecution is now almost complete in the chain of evidence, she is not worried at all.