"If you say it in your heart, you don't have a position. Xia Xue put down the teacup and said, "It doesn't matter, it's like a big debate, after choosing a side, it's right to win." ”

"The mentality can be a big debate, but in the actual performance, you must be humble and you must be soy sauce. Zhang Yifu sighed again, and instructed Wen Tianming and Ruan Mei, "Go for some comprehensive information on the Kezhou Dam and the Sanmenxia Dam, and it is best to take into account both water and electricity." ”

When they heard this, they immediately got up and went into the middle of the bookshelf.

"You're really making a big fuss. Xia Xue still felt that Zhang Yifu's behavior was a bit exaggerated.

Indeed, Zhang Yifu himself feels exaggerated, those things are in his head, why bother?

"Hey, a different way of dating, like you said, looking for the feeling of a big debate. Zhang Yifu smiled indifferently, "It's time to play." ”

People are different, the moon before the flowers can't satisfy Xia Xue, she needs a collision of thoughts, a violent collision, and then if she is happy, she may be able to use her left hand to spiral rule to bump again, of course, if possible, Zhang Yifu also hopes to gain something from Xia Xue's thinking, after all, it is a water conservancy family.

Sure enough, as soon as she teased her with this method, Xia Xue was slightly moved.

"Well, let's debate. Xia Xue put down the teacup and showed a hint of excitement, "Then let's first prepare the arguments, predict the opponent's arguments, and prepare enough arguments to argue and refute." ”

"Well, let's mention it one by one. Zhang Yifu said with a smile, "Since it is playing, it should not be limited to the scope of the power system, and all aspects of the comprehensive and all-round can be involved." Let's assume that you are a supporter and I am an opposition, take turns to put forward arguments, write them down, and then find arguments to refute. ”

Xia Xue's whole person entered the state. "The benefits are huge, with an installed capacity of 20 million kilowatts, and the annual power generation is expected to be close to 100 billion kilowatt hours after the units are fully put into operation." That's almost one-seventh of the country's annual electricity generation now, and it's a renewable natural energy source. ”

“……”

"Huh?"

"You count these ......"

"My dad's study is full of these things......

"Okay then......" Zhang Yifu also immediately raised an objection. "The resettlement project costs the people and money, uprooted their hometowns, and sacrifices are strict. ”

Xia Xue wrote down Zhang Yifu's arguments on a piece of paper, and was not in a hurry to refute them, and followed up with words: "Develop clean energy, improve efficiency, and protect the environment." ”

Zhang Yifu once again raised an objection: "Destroying the inherent ecology will cause a nationwide climate and geological impact. ”

Xia Xue: "On my side, it's the opposite-flood control and drought control. Control the water level. ”

Zhang Yifu: "Take it for granted. Sanmenxia failed in the past, and the reservoir silted up far more sediment than expected, and although it was rebuilt many times, it still posed a threat to the Weihe River basin. ”

Xia Xue: "Hey, it's boring to talk about Sanmenxia, right?"

"Why can't you talk about it, don't you use the facts of iron?"

"You want to use the failure of the Sanmenxia dam decades ago to negate the success of the Xiaolangdi and Kezhou dams?"

"Can the scale of the Xiaolangdike Dam be compared with Sanxi? Sanmenxia is the first dam of the Yellow River, so should it not be compared with the first dam of the Yangtze River?"

"Don't play tricks, the so-called first in Sanmenxia is the first in construction time. At that time, the hydropower technology was not mature at all, and the first in Sanxi referred to the first in scale, and now the technology is very mature. ”

"Are you ripe? Are you sure you can support a 20 million kilowatt hydropower station? Is it enough to deal with the world's largest overflow? Have you ever experienced the Sanmenxia disaster?"

"What year was that? Because you were afraid to stop, and what breakthrough was risk-free?"

"That is, you have to gamble the fate of a country for this breakthrough?"

"It's not gambling, it's argumentation, and if the argument is successful, it's not called gambling. ”

"Who doesn't know that the current argument follows the will of the leadership? The hard-line experts who really oppose it have not been invited to join the argument group at all, and perhaps every word you say now is fueling the fire. ”

"Not at all, it's my free will, and now that the technology is mature, there's a huge demand for power generation. Fossil energy consumption is strict, even if there are all kinds of drawbacks. It doesn't outweigh the benefits. Instead, you make all sorts of arguments. It's nothing more than being afraid of making mistakes, taking responsibility, and finding a reason for your cowardice. ”

"Oh......"

"Oh what?"

"Look, do you have a position? Zhang Yifu smiled and stopped arguing, "Do you obviously support it, and you don't support it because of interests, it's support in the real sense." ”

"Ah......" Xia Xue covered her mouth suddenly, "It turns out that I support ......"

Zhang Yifu laughed and said: "The angle you stand from is also great - human progress comes from adventure and breakthrough. ”

"I said that?" Xia Xue didn't react to what she said at all.

"I didn't say it, but the core meaning was this. Zhang Yifu pointed at himself innocently, "You still call me a coward......"

"I didn't mean that......"

"But in your subconscious, those opposition are cowards, right? Afraid of affecting the climate, afraid of affecting the geology, afraid of accidents, afraid of dam collapse, afraid of war......

“……”

"I don't think so. Zhang Yifu changed his tone and said gently, "I think they are warriors, daring to firmly contradict authority at such a time, fighting their own future and reputation to oppose this project that will be implemented, this is by no means cowardly, they know very well what kind of danger it will bring if they express these remarks at such a time, but they are still duty-bound, what do you think they are for?"

"Stick to what you believe in and respect your profession. ”

"It's not that complicated, just two words, patriotic. Zhang Yifu pointed to his feet, "They know that they were born here, they will die here, their sons and grandchildren will be the same as themselves, they can't bear the completion of what they think is obviously wrong in this land, they don't want to see this great river undergo drastic changes, they don't want to bear the infamy of their children and grandchildren a hundred years later." ”

Xia Xue pondered for a long time: "Standing on this position, I can understand what you said, but can they really be so sure of the so-called geological upheaval and disaster?"

"No one can be sure that this is an unprecedented project, an unprecedented change, and there is no way to determine his danger, but to speculate on it according to his own will by virtue of man's knowledge and experience. ”

"Do you think these disasters will happen as they say?"

"I'm just a little bit of a scholar, I don't even have the capital to 'think', I just instinctively want to protect myself and don't want to get involved in disputes. Zhang Yifu leaned back in the chair and smiled indifferently, "So at least one thing you are right, I am a coward." ”

"......" Xia Xue's body trembled slightly, and she stepped forward to hold Zhang Yifu's hand, "I know you're not, you're a supporter, right?"

“…… How so?"

"Huh. Xia Xue looked around and made sure that Wen Tianming and they were still looking for information on the bookshelf in the distance, so she whispered word by word, "Because you have a power power hidden in your heart, without Sanxi, what kind of power are you talking about?"

Zhang Yifu's body was shocked in an instant, and goosebumps began to appear all over his body.

My dear baby...... When did you become so talkative?

Yes, Sanxi is an unstoppable historical process, since the grandfather Sun Yat-sen began to eye, has been through countless arguments, countless failures and successful attempts, and now the technology has indeed matured, enough to build a world's first hydropower station. You can say that this is the will of the leadership, the interests of a small number of people in power, but you can't deny it.

As Xia Xue said, the benefits are certain, the losses are uncertain, and even Zhang Yifu, who has "come over", is still unable to assess the negative impacts.

Floods, droughts, earthquakes, etc., those things did happen after the impoundment of Sanxi, but apart from God, there is no direct evidence to conclude that it was Sanxi Daozhì, just rumors, and some people are more inclined to think that it is Sanxi Daozhì, and any "expert" who jumps out to say how Sanxi harms his descendants can win many echoes.

If he jumped out before the construction of Three Creeks, he could be praised as a warrior.

If you jump again after Sanxi is implemented, it is just a grandstand and a clown who uses the opportunity to promote himself.

If Sanxi is really wrong, then what people of insight need to do is to make amends for him, to deal with the danger he has brought, and to propose a possible remedy, instead of frequently expressing Sanxi's danger in the media and using the public psychology to raise his reputation.

Yes, the public is more inclined to believe in the negative effects of Three Creeks, why?

Because some people benefit, but the masses do not.

Because regardless of whether there is Sanxi or not, the public has electricity, and they all pay this amount of electricity.

Because some people keep telling them that earthquakes, droughts, floods, and floods are all caused by Sanxi.

However, Sanxi's vigorous promotion of the electric power industry, its outstanding achievements in the world hydropower field, and its important role in the strategic pattern of the country's hydropower technology export have all been selectively ignored.

The public's hatred of interest groups and their indignation at the disaster have created those "intellectuals" who spare no effort to preach the danger, and in the final analysis, the people who can really study and demonstrate the danger of Sanxi after the completion of Sanxi, and the people who can really do something, will not jump out.

The most ironic thing is that most of the angry people, when faced with the cadres of the Sanxi Group, are mostly humble and respectful, and if there is a way to work in such a unit, they will simply dream of laughing.

If Three Creeks was a mistake, it was the greatest mistake in the history of world engineering.

But to prove it, maybe a hundred years, two hundred years later, the good guys, the bad guys, the villains and the foolish people have all been put into the ground, and Zhang Yifu is just a touch of dust and loess.

Zhang Yifu also wants to follow his will like Xia Xue, but if he wants to be worthy of his heart, I think I can do it, so I will do it.

But it's really hard for him to be so simple.

"You...... Are you going to go to northern Hubei Province?" Zhang Yifu looked at the clear summer snow and asked indifferently. (To be continued)