What happened later was much more than the comrades of the sub-bureau introduced so lightly. Pen Fun Pavilion wWw. ｂiquge。 ｉｎfo

Ding Guocai died, and the whole town knew that Tao Yuling poisoned her, and even Tao Yuling herself admitted more than once that she did it. Murder pays for life, a murderer not only was not shot, but let her go, and even turned in front of her every day.

Nanzhou City has become Nanzhou District, and its economic development is extremely fast.

She has changed from a farmer to a citizen, her family has changed from a rural area to an urban-rural area, and the government has compensation for land acquisition and house demolition.

Ding Guocai died, she was a family member, although she was still a criminal suspect on bail pending trial, her political power and property rights were not deprived, and she received hundreds of thousands of yuan in various compensations, and her life became more and more nourishing.

When it comes to both family affection and money, Ding's family naturally did not agree, and found Nangang from Nanzhou, Jiangcheng from Nangang, and then BJ from Jiangcheng.

Party committees and governments at all levels, public security departments at all levels, and people's congresses and political conferences at all levels...... As long as you can go, all kinds of report letters and reaction materials are packed into a woven bag.

There are materials turned around at both ends in three days, and there are instructions from leaders every three or five days, and the village, town and district are also very headaches, as soon as there is an important event or inspection by the superiors, they will arrange people to go to Ding's house to keep an eye on it, and do the work hard, so that they don't have to wait in a hurry, so that they can believe in the government.

The pressure from all sides was finally concentrated in the sub-bureau, and the sub-bureau had no choice, so Tao Yuling was imprisoned in the detention center as soon as it couldn't bear it.

The Ding family didn't agree, and Tao Yuling didn't agree either.

As soon as I saw the police handling the case, she claimed that she was angry, she was a woman, and the Ding family always bullied her, how pitiful she was, and what was wrong with saying a few angry words.

If you have evidence, you shot me, but if you don't have evidence, why should you arrest someone?

She has the money and her mother's family to help her come up with ideas, hire a lawyer, and the Ding family petitions her to defend her rights through her relatives and lawyers. The public security organs could not know the law and violated the law, and the letter-visit departments at all levels transferred a bunch of reporting materials, and the higher authorities gave instructions, and the sub-bureaus had no choice but to release the people.

In the past two years, they have been arrested and released in this way, which not only does not conform to laws and regulations, but also delays work, and seriously affects the image of the public security organs and even the party and government.

Figuring out the ins and outs, the "old handsome" turned sideways and asked, "Comrade Jiang Ming, what do you think?"

The pre-trial brigade is responsible for the pre-trial work of major cases and the examination and control of evidence, and the opinion of Captain Jiang Ming is very important.

The superiors will come to inspect in a few days, and this case has been dragged on in the sub-bureau for two years, and now the city bureau can no longer delay it, and now is not the time to make peace with the mud.

He took a deep breath and said bluntly: "Report to the leaders, we have carefully studied the case materials, and we believe that the reason why the 9.22 case encountered serious setbacks in the litigation process was caused by a variety of reasons, and it can be said that this is a typical case with poor quality of case handling.

On the one hand, the criminal suspect Tao Yuling confessed to the facts of her crime. On the other hand, due to the insufficient evidence collected by the case-handling unit at that time, especially the lack of physical evidence to directly identify the crime, it was impossible to transfer the case for prosecution. In the course of handling cases, the principle of 'emphasizing evidence, investigation and research, and not believing confessions' was violated.

On the day she was brought into the case, Tao Yuling fully confessed the facts of her crime of poisoning and murder, and investigators also collected more than a dozen pieces of circumstantial evidence on the same day. At this point, the investigators had a mindset in their minds that the case was already in place, and they did not extract other evidence, especially physical evidence that could directly determine the facts of the crime. ”

Today, we will not only put this case to the end, but also sum up the lessons, and then we must investigate the responsibility.

Teng Baojin, secretary of the Nanzhou District Political and Legal Committee and director of the Public Security Bureau, was really shot while lying down, and he was the deputy head of the district at the time of the incident, and he was not the deputy head of the district in charge of public security.

The deputy director of criminal investigation and the head of the criminal police brigade were also transferred in the past two years, and the transfer of their predecessors had something to do with this case.

The case dragged on, the problem was never resolved, and the city bureau did not care whether they were shot while lying down, and although they could not be held responsible, they had to do a lot of work in the future. If the work is not done properly, it is their responsibility to do anything else.

In short, promotions are in trouble.

The three of them remained silent and sat at the table smoking one cigarette after another.

Han Bo was very sympathetic to their "experience", and once again picked up a stack of suspects' transcripts and listened to Captain Jiang's summary and analysis while reading them.

For example, the deceased's sisters Ding Guomin and Ding Guomei both mentioned in their testimony that there was blood on the floor and bed in the house at the scene, blood on Tao Yuling's shoes, and half a bowl of wine on the coffee table, and the pungent smell of pesticides in the wine. On one of the scene's covers, there was a folded, lumpy patch of blood on it, like something used for gagging, and a long hair.

Although the scene has been damaged after two days, it is still necessary to restore the scene, carefully investigate and fully extract the physical evidence. In addition, in terms of autopsy, there are also problems of lack of depth and detail, and there are no autopsy records, no autopsy photos, and no pathological examination in the litigation file. ”

Jiang Ming looked down at his notes, and continued: "Two years is not a long time, but it is not a short time, especially in terms of criminal technology, which has undergone tremendous changes in the past two years. What were the conditions before the Han detachment came back, and what are the technical conditions now, the city bureau is like this, not to mention the sub-bureau.

It is worth mentioning that after receiving the instructions of the Wei detachment, we inquired about some information. The 'Wanling' fly medicine used by the criminal suspect Tao Yuling for poisoning was an imported drug, which was not recorded in the domestic pesticide variety manual at that time, and it was not until June 28, 2000 that the Ministry of Agriculture had no information on this drug, but the lethal amount of poisoning of this drug was still inconclusive.

According to the information released by the Pesticide Information Station of the Ministry of Agriculture, the expiration date of this drug is 5 days. In this case, when the stomach contents and blood of the corpse were sent to the provincial department for examination, it was already the sixth day after the incident. There are only four possibilities, one is that the test is not timely, and the poison has been decomposed. Second, the number of samples is insufficient, the concentration is low, and even toxic components are difficult to detect.

Third, the provincial department lacked experience in the detection of unusual drugs at that time. Fourth, there were no toxic components in the samples. Combined with the investigative work, I am more convinced of the first three possibilities. In other words, this has a lot to do with the way of handling cases at that time, especially the scientific and technological content of forensic technology and the knowledge level of forensic technicians. ”

Objectivity and impartiality.

How to deal with the case at that time, the technical conditions of criminal law were very backward at that time.

After the abduction in Liangzhuang, including the arrest of Gu Xingui from Beihe, Lao Lu's opinion could play a role in the conviction and sentencing of the trafficker and fugitive Gu Xingui, and the then secretary of the county party committee was able to set the tone, and the county political and legal committee was able to coordinate with the public procuratorate and law to handle the case.

At present, with "trial as the center," party and government leaders are interfering less and less in the trial of cases, and judicial organs are demanding more and more on case-handling procedures, especially evidence.

The case happened at a juncture in the construction of the legal system, and the police handling the case did not keep up with the times, and the level of criminal science was relatively backward, which directly led to the fact that a case that was not complicated left with so many "sequelae".

Three days of two-head training, every three to five exams.

The grassroots police are full of complaints, but if they don't strengthen their studies and improve their professional skills, can they?

"Lao Shuai" sighed secretly, looked back at Han Bo, the leader of the new generation of police, and wanted to hear his opinion as a legal expert and forensic technology expert.

"After such a long time, the body has long been cremated, all the key physical evidence is gone, and the polygraph results cannot be used as evidence, no matter how the investigation is supplemented, it does not meet the conditions for transfer for prosecution. There is always a price to be paid for social change, and the same is true for the building of the legal system, and my opinion is that 'there is no doubt about the guilt', summing up lessons, taking the initiative to review with the superiors, and actively doing work for the relatives of the deceased. ”

"Duan detachment?"

"Let people go, can you still make mistakes again and again. ”

"Duan detachment, Han detachment, but ......" It's easy to release people, I've been caught several times and let go several times, what to do after the key is released, Teng Baojin wants to stop talking.

Knowing that Tao Yuling was suspected of committing a major crime, she was as aggrieved as Han Bo as she was at large, but the person sitting here was not Bao Qingtian, and it was impossible to say that if you put on the guillotine, you would go to the guillotine like Bao Qingtian, the law is the law and must be obeyed.

"Tengju, just like the Duan detachment said, we can't make mistakes again and again. ”

Han Bo looked at the two peers beside him, held up the few transcripts he had just read, and said solemnly: "If there is a problem at work, there is a problem, and if there is a problem, you have to face it, and you have to bear the corresponding consequences." Jiang Da just said a few points, and I will add one more point, if nothing else, the police handling the case did not find out the basic situation of Tao Yuling, and to be exact, it was not reflected in the materials.

She is not a primary school culture, she is illiterate, and she can't read a lot of words. Her primary school education is estimated to have been filled in by the village cadres when she was eradicated, and then entered into the household registration information. It can also be seen from these materials that she is a bit neurotic, and belongs to the kind of woman who likes to mess around at a moment. ”

"I didn't really notice that. Jiang Da subconsciously stood up, looking embarrassed.

"It's not about the big picture, the question now is how to do a good job of working with the relatives of the deceased. Han Bo shook his head and motioned for him to sit down.

Wei Guoqiang took over the conversation and said conclusively: "If you release people, you can only release them, and you can't lock them up anymore." When she put it, she warned Tao Yuling, it's not that she has no money, it's not that she has nowhere to go, what's the point of staying in Ding's house again, let her go as far as she wants, and let her stop looking for trouble. (To be continued.) )