"Clannad" ended perfectly in a climax, lasted for a year, and brought people countless touches and countless good memories. However, it is impossible for any work to have only one voice, especially a highly popular work, and the more popular it is, the more controversial it will be.

EVA is a clear example of this, even though it's been a long time since it ended, and people are still talking about it. "Clannad" has also ushered in this step, and it can be said that these controversial voices are a recognition of "Clannad" - real gold is not afraid of fire, and excellent works are never afraid of any criticism.

"Clannad" is simply a cancer of society, the plot of dog blood is deliberately tear-jerking for the sake of tears, Nagisa Furukawa, who is sick, and Okazaki got married just after graduation, and they did not wear a condom to guide zhì unexpectedly pregnant, which is the source of a qiē tragedy. And Nagisa is also a fool, his body is weak like that, and he still insists on having the remaining children, even if he has a child, why don't he go to the hospital? I haven't thought about what to do if I have a lot of bleeding? What should I do if I have all kinds of emergencies? Can I just find a doctor to be better than the conditions of the hospital? If this is the case, then the hospital has also set up an obstetrics and gynecology department to deal with hair, and it will be closed directly. ”

"In such a situation, Nagisa death is normal - it is their own death, and it is a miracle that Xiao Xi can survive - a miracle created by the author himself, I think Xiao Xi would definitely not have survived if it were not for the porter to let Xiao Xi live. In this way, Okazaki will fall into complete despair, and he will never get a chance to atone for his sins. The headstrong and childish request to have a child at home seems touching, but it seems ridiculous to me. This is irresponsible for yourself and your children. It is also irresponsible to parents and husbands. ”

"I deceived enough tears with Nagisa. sent a bento, so the next wave of tears hit Xiaoxi's body. The wife died, and the SB father actually left the child alone! By the way, maybe this would be easier to create conflicts, if Okazaki worked hard to raise him, would the tears still be so strong after that? Will Xiaoxi still have a chance to say the phrase 'The only place to cry is the toilet and Dad's arms'? Although the conscience was finally discovered, it was too late, and Xiaoxi completed his tear-jerking mission. After receiving the bento, I was finally able to leave this bloody world - Xiaoxi's life experience is not pitiful, I think the most pitiful thing is that she has such a pair of SB parents, living in that world, it is simply a kind of sin, and death is liberation!"

"Okazaki's approach,It's not as good as his father, who has always looked down on him.,If it's all dead here.,Maybe I'll think this is a film that can at least make me happy.,But in the end, this is a special big resurrection technique! I was completely disgusted by this trick, as if I had swallowed a fly. ”

"I'm looking at the mess of news right now. 'Post-90s** gave birth to a child and was unwilling to raise it, and his grandparents sued on his behalf', 'Underage couples gave birth to children out of wedlock and refused to raise them without economic foundation', 'Underage girls were pregnant unmarried, and they didn't know who the child's father was', 'The baby's corpse appeared in the toilet of the Internet café, and his underage mother was arrested on suspicion of murdering the child', all of them watched "clannad" to learn to talk about love, but none of them had any hair, except for the mouth. Love's has no ability at all, using his parents' money to soak girls, and if something happens, they are all irresponsible, "clannad" is a piece of garbage, a cancer!"

A netizen named "Immovable" quoted a bunch of social news and flattened "clannad" as useless.

It immediately attracted a siege from "clannad" fans.

The black and white mask posted: ""Clannad" is not a piece of garbage except for reading the file and being more bloody? Isn't it natural for other people to want to create people because of their affection? You get married and don't have children? Besides, after graduating from high school, the young couple are not highly educated, Okazaki can only sell some coolies to make money, and later when Okazaki had the opportunity to get a better job, he lost the opportunity because of his father. The resentment towards my father deepened. Furukawa played a key role in this at this time, so that the father and son could understand each other. Isn't it realistic here? In order to support his wife, he worked hard, but because of his low education, he could only sell coolies. Furukawa didn't die just because he gave birth to a child, Furukawa was already very weak, and there was a story about seeing a doctor before that it might be dangerous to give birth to a child, and Furukawa also wanted to give birth to an heir for Okazaki. Furukawa's condition could not be found out in the hospital, and going to the hospital was just a psychological comfort, but it could not actually solve the problem, and the doctors felt that they could give birth at home, because the family environment had a good effect on the mother's mood. But because of Furukawa's death, Okazaki gave up the responsibility of raising the child like a dead heart. (The two high school students were very immature when they decided to be together, but Okazaki later grew from a kid who graduated from high school to a man who could take responsibility, and took up the responsibility of raising his daughter again.) Finally, he took his daughter on a journey to bring the story to its climax, and Okazaki also experienced the difficulties of his father at that time. In addition to such things as light jade, the story has ups and downs, which can move me and make me understand a lot of things. Why don't you tell me how the story should develop?"

Artoria followed sarcastically: "I should have been dropped out of school in high school for falling in love, and then I had a small quarrel for three days and a big quarrel for five days, and after the breakup, I was found by the woman's father to break the dog's legs, right, right, hehe." It's even more strange that you never saw this kind of news when there wasn't "clannad"? Anyway, it wasn't long ago that someone counted that since "clannad" aired, there have been a lot less of such news than before. You've gone to great lengths to dig up a few pieces of news to spray, but you don't look at the missing ones, and you've had a positive impact that a guy like you with a dirty dark mind will never understand. ”

In the face of the siege of everyone, he did not move and did not lose his momentum at all.

"You said that the little couple are in love, and they want to make people when they get married? Love a fart, Nagisa's health is very bad, and Okazaki doesn't know that in such a situation, he doesn't pay attention to Nagisa's body, and he still wants to have a child...... This is a rebellious high school graduate's impulse in the lower body, and the physiological need is to get pregnant unexpectedly. It's just that you don't understand love to make the following tragedy. ”

"Okazaki lost a good job because of his father—what if he lost it? Thousands of jobs awaited him. If you lose your job, you can find it again, or blame him for being too incompetent, not everyone in this world is born to do certain things, you can find it by looking for it, how many people have changed industries after stepping into society, and slowly learn and progress in their work, as long as he is literate, there is nothing that he can never do. It just depends on whether he is willing to work hard. If Okazaki is hard work, then he looks down on the people in society who are really working hard. ”

"I can't afford to support my family because I don't have a stable job, my wife is not in good health, and I'm still anxious to have a child? Nagisa insists on having the children left, or giving birth at home - showing the lack of education for the perennial school and the lack of education, and treating the birth of a family and children as child's play. Insisting on not going to the hospital was her own irresponsible and willful behavior towards her family, and she died by herself. And because of Nagisa's death. Okazaki's heart is like ashes and he gives up the responsibility of raising his children - it is obviously the crystallization of two, but his heart is like ashes, the so-called 'love' of these two people is too ridiculous and naïve, and it seems too scum to give up raising them for a while. ”

"It's because of the super bloody reading file,Director zhì such a mediocre life film has become garbage.,Until the first half of Okazaki and Nagisa fell in love, it was still a good campus animation.,In the second half, the porter in order to create contradictions and tear-jerking effects,Deliberately added the setting that makes the protagonist extremely stupid and childish and willful.,And then let the mother and son die in this setting to win the audience's tears.,I didn't see a touching plot in it.,It's full of rebellion, Childish and irresponsible, such a scumbag protagonist should not be redeemed in the end, or commit suicide with regret or die alone, to enlighten the world!"

Although the rhetoric is very intense, it is clearly organized, which angers fans at the same time, but also makes fans unable to refute, which is really annoying.

Some fans even suspect that this is Huang Shaotian's spray again, because this strong troll style really makes people think of the "bad" troll Huang Shaotian.

So much so that Huang Shaotian had to stand up in person and resolutely draw a line with this person to prove his innocence. After all, he is a celebrity, everyone knows him, if he is burdened with the black pot because of someone else's spraying, and something dangerous happens to him in the end, he will not be unjustly killed.

As for the opinion of "Clannad", as a romance drama, he likes this work very much, and the only thing he feels unhappy about is the final reading of the big resurrection, which suddenly turned his previously moved tears into a joke, which is also the only flaw of "Clannad" in the opinion of some viewers.

Cao Jun also joined in the controversy: "I think 'clannad' should be viewed from another perspective, just as people can't be born with certain things, these are learned, and people can't be born mature, and 'clannad' is the life of all kinds of characters, depicting the story of going from naivety to maturity." In the beginning, the two of them were indeed naïve, very naïve, and that's true, but it is precisely because of their naivety that people can reflect on themselves so deeply, and let people follow the protagonist of the story to mature together - how can you see a rainbow without weather?"

"If you describe the style of the two from the perspective of maturity at the beginning, this is a failure - because they started out as just two high school students, and they have never even experienced society, how can they talk about maturity? Because Okazaki is not good at studying, and the director himself can't find a good job, what you see in it is a negative story, mocking and spitting on the protagonist, but what I see is a positive story - isn't Okazaki's story a kind of admonition to us? If you don't study hard and work hard to enrich yourself, even if you meet a good girl like Nagisa, you won't be able to give your loved ones a happy life and get maturity from Okazaki's body, and I think this is exactly what the master really wants to tell us. ”

"And the final reading of the great resurrection, although it seems to be very inconsistent, lowers the previous emotion, but I don't think "clannad" is sold by moving. The final twist is very blunt, very abrupt, making people laugh and cry, and suddenly return from the story to reality. But if you think about it carefully, doesn't this mean that these fictional stories have a chance to be repeated, but what about life? There is no chance to repeat them in real life! Cherish life, cherish happiness, and cherish life!"

"'Clannad' is life!" (To be continued......