Looking at this atmosphere, Edogawa was also quite satisfied, this is what she wanted to achieve, she deliberately came up with a mathematical deduction problem that did not seem too difficult, which made people have the illusion of "I can solve it".

If Doyle can't even answer such a "simple" question, then it can prove that he is not a great master of reasoning at all.

"Mr. Doyle, publish your answers. The host Kojima said loudly.

"I'm old, where can I figure out this kind of topic, now is the age of young people. Doyle smiled calmly, covered himself with paper, and motioned for himself to admit defeat.

Everyone present was looking at each other, couldn't a reasoning master like Doyle be able to calculate such a "simple" topic?

But Edogawa was resentful in his heart, and Doyle couldn't answer at first, but he wanted to say, "I'm old, and now is the age of young people", which makes people sound as if they are deliberately letting the younger generation.

This old fellow is so cunning!

Just as he was thinking like this, Kojima and Su Huai announced the answer, and Su Huai unfolded his answer paper:

"It was C who took D's umbrella, and C's umbrella was taken by E. ”

The audience looked at Edogawa, and only the beautiful overseer who made the question knew the answer.

Edogawa showed a slightly surprised look in his eyes, but he looked at Su Huai and asked curiously:

"Mr. Su, can you explain your thinking of solving the problem?"

She obviously didn't believe that Su Huai had calculated the answer.

Doyle also said beside him: "I looked at Mr. Su just now, I didn't even move the pen a few times, and I solved it so quickly, is there any advanced mathematical formula in Huaxia that can sort out such a complex topic at once." If there is a Mr. Su, you must teach us well. ”

Doyle's words sounded like asking for advice, but in fact he was full of doubts, he didn't believe that Su Huai had calculated it, and he always felt that he was more likely to guess it like the first question.

Su Huai shook his head: "Mr. Doyle praised it falsely, where is there any clever formula here, I just calculated it step by step." ”

Su Huai knew that the other party questioned him for good luck, so he also intended to show off, and explained in detail to the audience:

In fact, this question is just a step-by-step calculation. ”

Saying that, Su Huai asked the camera to come over, and while writing on the paper, he asked the camera to give a close-up.

"The first step of the question conditions supervised by Edogawa can be drawn to the following conclusions.

The umbrella that A takes can only be C or E.

The umbrella that B takes can only be A or E's.

The umbrella that C takes can only be A or D's.

The umbrella that D takes can only be A or B.

The umbrella that E takes can only be B or C.

Then the second step:

Let's assume that A takes C's umbrella, then E can only take B's, D can only take A's, C can only take D, and B can only take E's.

But in this way, B and E swapped umbrellas, which is not in line with the title.

Step 3.

I assume that the umbrella that A takes out is E's, so I can deduce that the umbrella that B takes is A's, the umbrella that C takes is D's, the umbrella that D takes is B's, and E takes back C's.

As a result, all the conditions of the question are satisfied, so the correct answer in the end is to take out D's umbrella, and C's umbrella is taken by E. ”

After Su Huai finished the whole process of inference, the audience at the scene looked at each other, you look at me, I look at yours, and they are all asking, "Do you understand?"

Many people are confused, these five letters are going around, Su Huai said it as if it was very relaxed, but it was so big that no one could understand it at all?

No one knows whether Su Huai's reasoning is right or not......

Until Li Chang, the criminal policeman in the audience, applauded directly in admiration and shouted:

"Mr. Su is so good, with clear thinking and rigorous reasoning, which is really eye-opening. The detective fans in the seats, this can be sure that Su Huai's inference is correct, and they all pretended to understand and applauded.

As long as one person applauds, everyone else follows suit, but in fact, few people at the scene understand it at all......

Edogawa looked at Su Huai with those eyes with heavy eyeshadow, but he felt that this was a little incredible.

This question is indeed not difficult, the difficulty lies in the extremely high requirements for the speed of reasoning, if Su Huai uses the "coincidental" hypothetical method, it is not unusual to get the correct answer.

But Su Huai actually used the most orthodox reasoning logic.

He divided into three steps, each of which ruled out the wrong route, and then came up with the only answer.

Even a highly trained person like Edogawa, a top-notch math and quick arithmetic expert, must take at least 30 seconds to deduce this problem.

You must know that this topic is so complicated that it probably doesn't take more than 20 seconds for ordinary people to figure out the logic of the problem just after reviewing the question.

Coupled with the pressure and expectations given by the audience in this kind of live broadcast, it is impossible for Edogawa himself to answer within the stipulated time.

And Su Huai did it easily, could it be that he, a celebrity in the literary world, really has professional training in mathematical logic?

Where does he have the time?

At this time, Doyle suddenly laughed, and seemed to have noticed an extremely interesting thing:

"Superintendent Edogawa, it seems that you are underestimating Mr. Su with this question, Mr. Su has seen people, and he must have heard of this question. ”

He didn't answer, but Su Huai did, so the result was naturally because Su Huai had heard it.

Otherwise, how could they have calculated so clearly in such a short period of time?

Qiu Shuzhen listened in the audience, immediately stood up, and said angrily: "Obviously the answer came up, how can you say that Teacher Su has heard it? Didn't you come up with the question yourself?"

At this time, Edogawa next to him also nodded and said: "I also think that Mr. Su should have heard it, otherwise it should be impossible to answer so accurately, 30 seconds, his three-step deduction time should not be enough." ”

Doyle and Edogawa, one is scheming, the other is logical and quick-thinking, and the two sing and harmonize, but everyone has to believe that Su Huai has really heard this topic.

In the face of these two people's testimony, Su Huai just smiled freely and said:

"Since the two of you want to say it, just say it, no one can prove it anyway. ”

Although the other party was deliberately slandering him, Su Huai knew that they were right, when he was in school, he had indeed seen a lot of similar puzzle-solving and reasoning questions, and he had done almost all the IQ test questions, and he had memorized all the abilities in his head, so when Edogawa said the question, the answer had already jumped out of his mind.

But of course he wouldn't be stupid to admit it, after all, it was not only about his reputation Su Huai, but also about the reputation of Song Ci and "Records of Clearing Grievances".

The two sides insisted on their own words, and there was a stalemate.

At this time, I suddenly heard someone in the audience stand up and say loudly:

"Who said that no one can prove it, we can prove it in the number of research institutes~~"