readx;?“ In addition, it is necessary for me to make an explanation here," Liao Xiaoqian continued, "I guarantee that every sentence, every word, every word, every word, and even every punctuation mark of the first-instance adjudication committee's discussion record and the second-instance collegial panel's deliberation record, which I am about to recount below, are completely consistent with the original text." Pen, fun, pavilion www. biquge。 Info Secretary Bao, you can go to the court at the right time to transfer the original files of the original discussion records of the first-instance adjudication committee and the review records of the second-instance collegial panel and compare them with the words I am about to retell, if there is a difference in one word, I am willing to accept any treatment of me personally by the organization!"

Seeing Liao Xiaoqian's statement, Bao Feiyang couldn't help but be secretly frightened. Being able to recite the meeting materials of the first and second trials more than ten years ago word for word, it is conceivable how much Liao Xiaoqian, a woman who looked soft and weak, was tortured in conscience when she served as the clerk of the second instance of Rao Jianshan's corruption case. Otherwise, how could she adopt such an exaggerated way to memorize all the materials of the first and second trials of such a case?

"Xiao Li," Bao Feiyang said to Li Daren, who was sitting next to Liao Xiaoqian, "When Director Liao speaks later, you can make a record of Director Liao's speech." ”

Originally, Liao Xiaoqian, the director of the Office of the Legal and Political Commissar, was in charge of the minutes of this meeting, but now she has to speak. Feiyang, the work package of this record, could only be temporarily handed over to his secretary to take over.

"Yes!" Li Daren responded, stretched out his hand to take the meeting minutes handed over by Liao Xiaoqian, spread it out on the table in front of him, and was ready to record at any time.

"Okay, I will now begin to retell the discussion record of the adjudication committee of the first instance and the deliberation record of the collegial panel of the second instance, and in the process of my retelling, if you feel that what I said is inconsistent with your memory, you can call me to stop at any time, and we will have further confrontation. ”

After Liao Xiaoqian finished saying this to Xiang Zhijiang, she began to formally retell the material engraved in her mind, and she first retold the minutes of the discussion meeting of the adjudication committee of the Fengnan District People's Court on the Rao Jianshan corruption case.

At the very beginning of the meeting, Bi Xiaolin, the presiding judge of the Rao Jianshan corruption case, made a report to the adjudication committee of the Fengnan District People's Court, and he said: Leaders of the court, all members of the adjudication committee, when the adjudication committee held a meeting and discussion the previous time, they held that the defendant Rao Jianshan's conduct did not constitute the crime of embezzlement, and even if it was applied according to several elements of the crime of embezzlement of public funds, it was not completely complied with. However, this case is a case to which the relevant departments and leaders attach great importance, and the opinion of the higher court is that it should be sentenced to life imprisonment in accordance with the crime of embezzlement of public funds. ”

After Bi Xiaolin, the presiding judge of the first instance, spoke, Qi Kaige, president of the Fengnan District Court, who made a speech, and his opinion was very brief, just one sentence: Then Rao Jianshan will be sentenced to life imprisonment for the crime of embezzlement of public funds. Qi Kaige was followed by Vice President Zhou Luping's speech, she said: Supporting the sentencing opinion of the higher court, it is okay to be convicted according to the crime of embezzlement of public funds, and life imprisonment. The remaining members of the adjudication committee also agreed to convict Rao Jianshan of embezzlement of public funds and sentence him to life imprisonment in accordance with the opinion of the higher court. ”

Speaking of this, Liao Xiaoqian stopped and looked at Xiang Zhijiang, "President Xiang, what is wrong with the results of the first-instance discussion of Rao Jianshan's corruption case by the Adjudication Committee of the Fengnan District People's Court that I repeated?"

Xiang Zhijiang hid his face in the smoke, and replied angrily: "It's been too long, I can't remember it clearly!"

Liao Xiaoqian turned her head to look at Qiu Quanyong again and said, "Chief Prosecutor Qiu, at that time, you were the second-instance prosecutor of Rao Jianshan's embezzlement of public funds, I would like to ask you, is there anything that does not match your memory about the results of the first-instance discussion meeting of the adjudication committee of the Fengnan District People's Court on Rao Jianshan's corruption case that I just recounted?"

Qiu Quanyong replied with a dark face: "How can I remember the case more than ten years ago so clearly?"

Liao Xiaoqian naturally knew that Xiang Zhijiang and Qiu Quanyong didn't remember, but they just didn't want to admit that what they had just retold was completely correct, so they deduced that it took too long to remember clearly. But it doesn't matter, anyway, the original files of the results of the discussion of the adjudication committee of the Fengnan District People's Court are all there, and when the time comes, let Bao Feiyang call it out and check it, isn't everything clear?

"Since both Procurator General Qiu and President Xiang can't remember the materials of the first trial, let me talk about the situation of the second trial. This was personally experienced and participated in by both Procurator General Qiu and President Xiang, and because of the investigation and trial of Rao Jianshan's corruption case, he was awarded a personal second-class meritorious service and was commended by his superiors, so he should remember the details of the case at that time relatively clearly, right?"

Liao Xiaoqian's eyes swept over Qiu Quanyong and Xiang Zhijiang, then withdrew it, looked at Bao Feiyang, and then reported: "After the first-instance verdict was announced, Rao Jianshan immediately chose to appeal, and the Municipal Intermediate Court accepted Rao Jianshan's appeal and launched the second instance. ”

"President Xiang was the presiding judge of the second-instance trial at that time, and I was the clerk of the second-instance trial. When the collegial panel deliberated on Rao Jianshan's appeal, President Xiang Zhijiang expressed his position at the time, saying: "From a legal point of view, I believe that the defendant Rao Jianshan does not have the elements for the establishment of the crime of embezzlement of public funds, and even the elements for the crime of embezzlement of public funds are insufficient. However, considering that this case has been closely watched and questioned by many departments and leaders in the city. Personally, I still agree with the conviction and sentencing of the defendant Rao Jianshan by the court of first instance, and therefore recommend that the appeal of the defendant Rao Jianshan be rejected and the first-instance judgment of the Fengnan District People's Court be upheld." ”

"Judge Gong Shenghui said in his next speech: 'I personally think that this case does not constitute the crime of embezzlement of public funds from a legal point of view, but considering the opinions and requirements of the superior leaders, and this case is a case assigned by the above, and the above also put forward important opinions when it is assigned, so I agree with the opinion of the presiding judge Another judge Fang Haoqiang said in his speech: ' This case lacks the necessary elements for the crime of embezzlement of public funds, but considering the opinions of the superior leaders and relevant departments, it is recommended that the original judgment of the court of first instance be upheld. In the end, the collegial panel reached an unanimous opinion: 'From a legal point of view, the current evidence and facts in Rao Jianshan's case cannot prove that the defendant Rao Jianshan committed the crime of embezzlement of public funds. However, considering that this case is a case that the leaders have interrogated and paid attention to, and the leaders also have detailed requirements, this collegial panel hereby makes the following judgment, that is, to reject the appeal of the defendant Rao Jianshan and uphold the original judgment made by the court of first instance!'"

There was silence in the conference room, if Liao Xiaoqian told the real facts, then there was no need to read other materials, just transfer the collegial records of the first and second trials, which was enough to prove that Rao Jianshan's embezzlement of public funds was a completely unjust case!

After telling all the materials she had in one go, Liao Xiaoqian felt much more comfortable, even if she was removed from her post and opened to public office now, she didn't feel so guilty in her heart.

She raised her head and looked at Xiang Zhijiang calmly, and asked, "President Xiang, do you think there is anything inconsistent with the facts in my restatement of the opinions of the collegial panel of the second instance?" (~^~)