[The fat man gets up early and works hard to code words, rushing, rushing, rushing, rushing, this article is deeply touching]

Because it has been popular recently that BJ students are easy to get admitted to Tsinghua University and Peking University, will BJ students be inferior to those champions in other provinces?

If, after entering Peking University and Tsinghua University, regional differences do not affect the height of individual development, does it mean that the existing selection system is reasonable?

Talked to her a lot. The pen "Fun" Pavilion www.biquge.info also reflected on a lot of this issue. To sum up, let me talk about my feelings and opinions:

I think it's important for me to start by saying that I'm just stating what I've seen over the years. My hometown is in the countryside, I studied in a small county middle school in junior high school, came to the provincial capital city in high school, was admitted to Tsinghua University in college, and tutored students during college, I have personally experienced the differences in educational resources in various regions of China with different levels of development.

As for whether the society is fair and whether the system is reasonable, it is beyond the scope of my discussion. So if you think that the phenomenon I am describing is unfair, then please think clearly: I am the actual experiencer and bearer of the unfair experience you are talking about.

I believe that my answer still expresses the hearts of some people, so I also hope that some people will not equate agreeing with my answer to maintain the system, thank you.

As a foreign candidate, I used to wishfully think that Tsinghua University and Peking University have a lot of enrollment places in BJ, so BJ students must be weaker than us. Hehe, Lao Tzu is coming to Tsinghua University, you just wait to give us the bottom.

Some students in the group questioned the role of talent, and thought that I said that students in big cities have more opportunities to develop their talents, so they should be admitted if they are of higher quality. The most important value of talent is not to compare and assess, the biggest role of talent is to enrich students' lives and make people happy.

I said that small county students are prone to lack the opportunity to develop their talents, not that their quality is inferior, but that they are too easy to take the first place as their only hobby, but when they arrive at a famous university with strong competitors, the first place is far away from them, it is too difficult to find the joy of life.

There is an interesting point of view, which means that "students who are admitted to Tsinghua University and Peking University from backward areas have their own merits, so they ......". This sentence is in line with most people's thinking, but based on my actual observation over the years, for students from areas with relatively poor education who are admitted to prestigious schools, the negative effects of this idea far outweigh the positive effects. For them, the most important thing is not to believe in their own excellence but to accept their ordinariness, not to blindly believe that their myths will continue in primary and secondary school, but to start by completing every homework independently and keeping up with every class.

And their ordinariness is not completely indistinct, but ordinary in an excellent environment. But it is true that there are many people who do not complete the transformation of mentality from "hero" to "mortal" and fall into depravity. But as long as those who persevere, the final achievements are still good, but in the environment they compare, their achievements are still "ordinary".

As a result, in fact, the performance of BJ students is relatively good on the whole, and in fact, it is the small county town that is more likely to fall to the bottom of the famous universities......

The educational conditions of small counties are backward, and the top students invest more time in their studies in order to be admitted to prestigious universities than students in big cities in Beijing and Shanghai, and their interests and hobbies and vision are inferior.

And what are the advantages of BJ students?

I won't talk about the controversial things like vision and talent, just academics.

BJ's strength in basic education is unimaginable to me when I was out of town.

I have tutored high school students to participate in physics competitions for a long time at a teaching institution in BJ, and I have also led tutors for many years.

Moreover, I found that although Tsinghua Peking University has a large number of enrollment places in BJ, few children from BJ indigenous families with low education level are admitted to Tsinghua Peking University.

As far as my life experience in BJ is concerned, although Qingbei's enrollment ratio in BJ is much higher than that of other provinces, for many native-born old BJs, Qingbei is still so far away.

I can even say that most of the enrollment places of Tsinghua Peking University in BJ are divided by the descendants of those outsiders who were admitted to BJ through their own efforts in the early years and stayed in BJ.

Most of the BJ students I met at Tsinghua University have very high education levels and work in government agencies, universities, research institutes, high-tech enterprises, etc.

You only have to think about how many students are admitted to BJ's colleges and universities every year, and then stay in BJ to continue their development, you can understand that the group of BJ's students' parents compared with the group of parents of students from other places has an ever-expanding advantage in terms of educational level.

Many of the students majoring in pure science at Tsinghua University and Peking University choose middle school teachers because of the pressure of employment.

When I was doing physics competitions, the teacher explained a lot of topics, and after I understood these questions, I did them very concisely and straightforwardly. When I tell my students, they think it's so simple and straightforward.

Other answers and comments repeatedly mention the fact that the difficulty of the BJ college entrance examination questions is relatively small. However, the difficulty of BJ's daily training for top students is definitely not small. In addition, teachers with higher levels often explain difficult things very simply, so BJ's top students often think that what they learn is very simple.

Students who study well are not deliberately taught, but they are often nurtured. It is much easier for parents and teachers with a relatively high level of education to cultivate students with good grades.

The top students at BJ's level are very strong. And the trend in recent years is that BJ's best students choose to go abroad directly instead of going to Tsinghua University and Peking University.

Finally, I would like to say to those candidates from other places who are about to enter Tsinghua University and Peking University, especially those from small counties: You have indeed made much more efforts than BJ candidates, but your extra efforts have not been used to learn new knowledge, but only repetitive training to make fewer mistakes, and many of your future BJ students have already gone far, far in the university courses.

Three more points:

1 I am just stating the facts, and I am not expressing the opinion that "it is reasonable for BJ people to be admitted to Tsinghua University and Peking University".

2 I have found that there are some people who are keen to use the example of the founding leaders.

Indeed, from the perspective of today's people, China's founding leaders generally did not have a high level of education and did not go to prestigious schools, but considering the low literacy rate and the huge number of illiterates in China at that time, the war, The fact that famines are frequent, and that they are able to study in school, and that they are exposed to all kinds of political ideas while studying, shows that in today's increasingly popular university education, it is true that they are not highly educated from the perspective of today's people, but from the perspective of their time, they are really far ahead of the vast majority of people.

3. China's relatively backward economic regions did have a golden age of basic education, but this golden age is about to become history, and the gap between backward areas and big cities in basic education is widening.

My father was studying in a rural village in SC, and his high school math teacher was a professor in the mathematics department of SC University.

Why?

Cultural Revolution.

The Cultural Revolution did harm many outstanding intellectuals. Many intellectuals who had a lot of potential were forced to be reformed through labor, but what is quite black and humorous is that this has caused many children in remote and backward areas to receive a better education by mistake, such as my father.

In that era, students in big cities such as BJSH were too involved in the political movement, but people from backward areas like my father had time to study with peace of mind and learned a lot under the guidance of the devolved intellectuals.

My father's generation rose to prominence soon after the college entrance examination.

When my father's generation was taking the entrance examination, the dual system of urban and rural areas was very strict, farmers were peasants, cadres were cadres, and many outstanding children from rural areas were eager to get rid of their peasant status, coupled with information blockage, and their willingness to apply for the examination was often seriously lower than their level. Many students who were originally very good at learning have accidentally become primary and secondary school teachers in small counties. With their solid foundation, they have created the second wave of miracles in basic education in backward areas. I vividly remember that when I was in junior high school, a middle-aged chemistry teacher was more proficient than many young math teachers in doing junior high school math competition problems, like chopping melons and vegetables.

But this second wave of miracles is gradually moving away from us. Because such an excellent teacher in a small county town will be quickly poached by middle schools in big cities, and this wave of people has also reached the age of retirement.

Taking SC as an example, the students who have been admitted to Tsinghua University and Peking University are relatively average in various cities and counties. However, in recent years, Tsinghua Peking University's enrollment quota in SC has been increasingly monopolized by several super middle schools, and the surrounding small counties, the first grade can be admitted to Sichuan University of Electronic Science and Technology, thank God.

And the golden age of basic education in that small county town was won at the cost of countless outstanding intellectuals who were forced to take root at the grassroots level to engage in basic education.

And now, I'm afraid that such a situation will never happen again, so after the miracle, there will be no miracle.

Starting Point Chinese www.qidian.com welcome book friends to come and read, the latest, fastest and most popular serialized works are all original at Starting Point!