The drama "Mansion Gate 1912" is not unfamiliar to "house fans" at all, it can be said that it came out after a long time, and in the end, after watching a few episodes, "house fans" all shouted disappointment, and walked out of the mansion gate, the TV series lost the most fascinating elements of the rise and fall of the family and the nation, and became Bai Jingqi's entrepreneurial story, as well as the continuation of the story of several women, and then shoehorned in a little spy war and suspense, the taste seems to be a little wrong. Pen @ fun @ pavilion wWw. ｂｉｑUｇE。 ｉｎｆｏ

In the original version of "Mansion Gate 1912", Chen Baoguo, Siqin Gaowa, and Liu Peiqi are fortunately still there, which has also become the only lifesaver for this drama, and the most attractive point for the audience is the performance of these old people.

The play mainly tells the story of Bai Jingqi's second entrepreneurship in Jinan, and in 1912, the seventh master Bai Jingqi founded the Heiqitang Chinese medicine shop in Shandong.

During the period of the Beiyang government, the society was in ruins, the Kuomintang, the People, and the Party were cunning and robbing, and Bai Jingqi experienced all kinds of open and secret battles, swords and swords, life and death, love and hatred.

In the play, Mr. Guo wants to put some positive energy in more, with positive energy as the main theme of the play, for example, Bai Jingqi finally got the secret recipe through hard work and saved Li Min's life, which well conveyed the positive energy elements of entrepreneurship.

Of course, at the end of the story, the seventh master, who has always been based on integrity, got the secret book he once dreamed of. Make the purest and high-quality medicine to save the world!

The story clearly expresses the life theme of "honesty and trustworthiness" is the foundation of the world, and since then this drama has also well interpreted the slogan and expectation of reuniting positive energy at the beginning of the broadcast.

However, after the broadcast of the original version of "Mansion Gate 1912" in the previous life, the response can only be said to be mediocre, for this TV series, the audience's evaluation is only Chen Baoguo and the spirit of the first part, compared with the previous one, although this sequel cannot be said to be bad, but it is obviously unsatisfactory, if "Mansion Gate" can be called a classic, then "Mansion Gate 1912" can only be said to be a not bad drama at most.

Speaking of which, "Mansion Gate 1912" is really not bad, compared with many shoddy TV series, it is even more exciting, but it is precisely because the first part is too classic, and every character in the play is deeply rooted in the hearts of the people, which led to the fact that after "Mansion Gate 1912" was broadcast in the previous life, many viewers couldn't help but feel that they lost the "soul" of the first part, and it was evaluated as a hybrid version of a period drama and an idol drama.

The smell of the house has changed, which makes some viewers nostalgic for the old version on the Internet, and the most harsh evaluation is: It is far worse than the first part, and I don't feel tired of watching the first part countless times, and I didn't stick to this episode.

At the beginning of the broadcast, the original version of "Mansion Gate 1912" was promoted under the banner of "original team", but after a few episodes, the audience found that this "original team" was actually only Bai Jingqi left.

He is still the one who is not afraid of the sky, the earth, and a little bit of a dumbfounded gentleman in the capital, and the second grandmother is a poor "soy sauce" character with few scenes, which surprised the audience the most and was also badly criticized, that is, Yang Jiuhong's brutal and spicy style from Jose Fei, suddenly became He Qing's version of gentle and virtuous, and some viewers commented: "The seventh master is still the seventh master, Jiuhong is no longer Jiuhong." ”

As a female character who was depicted in the first mansion, Yang Jiuhong's role was even more than Bai Jingqi's original wife Huang Chun, almost running through three-quarters of the plot.

Between Yang Jiuhong, the top "Sister Yao", and Bai Jingqi, an ill-fated emotional story was staged, which also touched the hearts of the audience at that time.

At that time, Jose Fei's performance was greatly praised, and she herself interpreted the mental journey of an aunt and wife vividly with her dramatic lines and smart and charming eyes and expressions.

So when "Mansion Gate 1912" was broadcast, many viewers spontaneously began to miss the old version of Josefei, although He Qing was beautiful and her appearance was first-class, but she couldn't play Yang Jiuhong's energy, and she turned a fierce girl into a small jasper.

In his previous life, before the broadcast, Mr. Guo said that Yang Jiuhong in this version would change to a gentle route, but this change is obviously a big failure in the eyes of some viewers, and it is seriously inconsistent with the plot of the first part.

Because "Mansion Gate 1912" is a story from the first part of "Mansion Gate" for ten years, and then Yang Jiuhong returned to Jinan when she became pregnant for the second time.

In "Mansion Gate 1912", in the story, Yang Jiuhong raised her belly, but as soon as He Qing appeared, she was like a lady in distress, completely gentle and virtuous, even if the word "Sister Yao" came out of her mouth, it was really difficult for the audience to equate her with Fengchen.

Yang Jiuhong has more motherhood, less charm, and is a pampered noblewoman, but she can no longer shout the "grandfather" who made the seventh master disarm and made the audience sigh.

He Qing stubbornly played Yang Jiuhong into Huang Chun, who had no temper and spoke badly, more than 108,000 miles worse than Jose Fei.

is undoubtedly disappointing, as an aunt from Sister Yao, Yang Jiuhong is completely a bitter housewife in "Mansion Gate 1912", while giving birth to her husband, she silently endures her husband's search for a mistress, crying and crying, without the strong and tenacious charm of Jose's Fei version's personality.

Jose's flying version of Yang Jiuhong back then, walked the tightrope for the seventh master and love, and lost his daughter and became domineering, that is called a vivid, look at this one in turn, the lines are all back, no emotion, no expression, poking in front of the camera, just to be eye-catching.

Song Zheng also felt twisted when he watched this drama in his last life, and felt that He Qing would be okay if he played Xiangxiu, but the role of Yang Jiuhong was really not suitable for her, and she gave people the feeling of being a good family.

Bai Jingqi played by Mr. Chen Baoguo continues the spirit of the first part, but in terms of age, Bai Jingqi, who is in his 30s in the plot, is obviously a little old, Chen Baoguo retains Bai Jingqi's soul, and he still looks like he is "affectionate and responsible", but the young master Bai Qi who sang "Look at the black hole in front of me, it must be the thief's lair, wait for me to rush forward and kill him cleanly".

In terms of plot, Bai Jingqi's business war part is quite important in the first part, but "Mansion Gate 1912" is almost halfway through, and the business war is still in a moderate stage, giving people the feeling that the seventh master went to Jinan Mansion completely on vacation and took out pickled girls.

In addition, in the original version of "Mansion Gate 1912", many new actors such as Guo Banzhu and Liang Tian were also added.

Song Zheng also saw the appearance of Guo Banzhu and Liang Tian, and immediately had a feeling of "I Love My Home", "Mansion Gate", and "Yanjing Cross Talk Conference".

It can be said that the classic play "Mansion Gate" will be staged again, in addition to the theme song that retains the same style, the rise and fall of the big family, the integration of personal and national destinies, if it cannot be tasted again.

Of course, it's not good if it's too demanding, after all, in general, the storyline of "Mansion Gate 1912" is thrilling as a whole, although there is no sophistication in the house, and you come and go in business, but Mr. Guo is also hardworking, dedicating an ordinary treasure hunt adventure and Xiao San'er's ambiguous love, just in terms of story, it can't be said to be a dog's tail mink.

Although Mr. Chen Baoguo is old, his performance is as steady as ever, Bai Jingqi's chivalrous courage is fully revealed, Siqin Gaowa's aura is too strong, and the scene is also very domineering, performing the momentum of the heroine in the middle of the girl, but the second grandmother is fat, Guo is the class master, Aunt Yu's performance is decent, and playing a gangster boss who is not light or heavy and a military advisor with crooked ideas is also in place, although as soon as these two come out, there is a feeling that they are talking about "Dream of the Western Expedition".

However, these people are generally not a big problem, they can be regarded as seeking progress in stability, and the others are not good in the choice of actors, except for the previously mentioned He Qing, and Wang Zhifei, who plays the seventh master's opponent Tian Zixing.

In Song Zheng's previous life, when he was watching, he couldn't help but shout at the TV every time: Can you speak louder? Can you speak clearly? Can you not look so much like a passerby?

Every time it is Wang Zhifei's turn to appear, he looks inarticulate, and he is still a killer like this?

It's a blessing to have survived.

and Zhang Xinyi, Song Zheng doesn't know if she was brought in by Wang Zhifei, she looks very beautiful, but her grasp of the characters has completely collapsed, and she is stunned to play a brave and knowledgeable heroine, anti-feudal, and anti-superstitious strong woman into a little swallow in "Huanzhu Gege".

In the previous life, the biggest controversy in the whole drama also came from this new heroine, in the previous story of "Mansion Gate", all female characters are inseparable from the rules, etiquette, even Bai Yuting, who is married to the photo, has the shadow of tradition.

Only Lu Qingqing is completely a character of the new era, her aura, personality, behavior, and thinking habits are incompatible with the characters in the mansion.

She can scold the second grandmother as an "old witch", and she will also give the seventh master a new lease of life.

Old Man Guo believes that Lu Qingqing is a fresh wind, in order to blow away the rotten atmosphere of the mansion door.

However, more viewers still think that Lu Qingqing played by Zhang Xinyi is a little annoying, in terms of role, Lu Qingqing is the only woman who makes the seventh master fall into a love war, and her little girl's behavior is a weakening of the seventh master's heroism.

In terms of actors, Zhang Xinyi's performance is a little excessive, and even a little noisy, which does not fit well with the pattern and tonality of the whole play.

I don't know how Zhang Xinyi in the original version understands Mr. Guo's definition of this role, but under Zhang Xinyi's interpretation, Lu Qingqing has become a dumbfounded person who is more alive than Xiaoyanzi.

But in fact, after reading the script of "Mansion Gate 1912", Song Zheng analyzed the old man's original intention, and felt that this was definitely not the case, Lu Qingqing should be a little eccentric like Huang Rong, a little arrogant on the outside, but kind in heart, and has her own opinions.

She admires a man with a personality like Qiye, but by no means fell in love with him from the beginning, at least not like the feeling of falling in love in a second as shown in the original TV series.

Don't forget, Lu Qingqing is a woman who has seen the world, has enough immunity to excellent men, and she also knows that the seventh master has two wives.

Under the idea of feminism, she may have thought that the seventh master was just a rich man who liked to show mercy everywhere and wanted to tease him.

For example, plots such as peeing in the cornfield and letting the seventh master buy food, etc., are just out of a naughty mentality, wanting to challenge the patience of the seventh master, and at the same time trying to prove his charm, and she is by no means the willful Miss Jiao like Zhang Xinyi showed.

In the process of getting along with the two, Lu Qingqing gradually felt the personality charm of the seventh master, and found that he was a responsible and responsible man, and unconsciously fell in love with him.

And, later, when she realized that she was really in love with this man, she felt guilty about Yang Jiuhong and her beliefs.

Lu Qingqing's final death should be like Carmen, an idealist's highest pursuit of love, this should be Lu Qingqing's mental journey, and it is more in line with Lu Qingqing's personality, this point, Zhang Yixin did not show it at all, and she had a shameless "little San'er" posture throughout the whole process, only using coquettishness to seduce the seventh master, which is why Zhang Xinyi's interpretation of Lu Qingqing is so unpopular.

Lu Qingqing should be a woman with a lot of connotation, and there is another point that can be proved, the second grandmother in the play likes Lu Qingqing quite much, the second grandmother is a legend in her life, who has never seen it, if Lu Qingqing really only pretends to be bold with her voice, the second grandmother will not appreciate her so much, and will not treat her like this, which shows that she can see that Lu Qingqing is definitely a thoughtful woman who is difficult for ordinary people to control, and the most important thing is that she sees her own shadow in her.

To sum up, the actor's failure to interpret the role will undoubtedly bring devastating disasters to the role, Zhang Xinyi is to Lu Qingqing, just like the queen's ex-husband is to Guo Jing, which is a serious mistake in casting.

To put it mildly, He Qing, Wang Zhifei, Zhang Xinyi, these are the three of them who ruined this drama alive.

In this regard, Song Zheng can only regret in his last life that Old Man Guo chose the wrong person.

The actor is not in the right way, let's talk about the plot next, Mr. Guo's setting is no problem, it can be seen that the old man wants to show a lot of things, but there are some parts that the old man is really not good at.

This is also why, "Mansion Gate" created a win-win situation for ratings and word-of-mouth, creating a classic of period dramas, "Mansion Gate 1912", as the third part of the "Mansion Gate Series", caused controversy among fans on the Internet, and even some viewers felt that "Mansion Gate 1912" was really insulting to the name of "Mansion Gate".

Although "Mansion Gate 1912" rarely retains the main actors Chen Baoguo, Siqin Gaowa, Liu Peiqi, plus the "loyal escort" of Mr. Guo, but because the first two parts have reached the finale, "Mansion Gate 1912" can only choose this time section after the Xinhai Revolution in 1912, and it is easy to have many discrepancies with the previous part.

For example, in the previous plot, Yang Jiuhong obviously had a miscarriage on the train to Jinan, but in this one, she actually had a big belly and gave birth to a child.

Loopholes like these emerge endlessly throughout the play.

In addition, if the first two "Mansion Gate" have a strong cultural heritage, then this "Mansion Gate 1912" seems to be more market-oriented, and many fans of the drama said that the actor matching and plot setting of this "New Mansion Gate" are a bit "stewed".

There are a lot of new faces, but it's a bit messy to watch, the relationship between the seventh master and Lu Qingqing is pure nonsense, and the poor and amusing lines fill the whole plot, and the story connotation is very weak.

The various baggage in the film is very similar to a popcorn movie, amused for the sake of amusement, lacking depth, where did the original sense of humor of "Mansion Gate" come from?

It is dialogue, Beijing flavor, and satire, such as the scene in Jinan in the first part, Chen Baoguo and Jiang Wen, through a five-minute dialogue, a corrupt official is vividly displayed.

There are some scenes in the new drama, purely by pretending to be stupid and stunned as a joke, which feels too superficial.

I have to say that even Mr. Guo has no choice but to bow to the market, there is no doubt that the first part of "Mansion Gate" is a classic, the second part is actually not so good, and the third part has not been able to jump out of the circle of "sequel curse" in terms of ratings and word of mouth.

Regarding the marketization trend of this drama, Song Zheng can only say that the show is a bit like "a plate of weird tofu", the first two are undoubtedly dramas, but this one is more like a light comedy, Bai Qiye, a living bandit who has set off the trend of "wolf man", has lost a lot of personality, and was taken by Zhang Xinyi to talk about love, mixed with a group of comedians shaking their burdens.

Of course, the fundamental reason for the formation of this style actually lies in positioning, in the current TV drama market, the ratings are a knife, and Mr. Guo may also be set in this way in order to get close to the tastes of young people.

Regarding Mr. Guo's helplessness, Song Zheng could feel it when he first read the first draft of "Mansion Gate 1912" at his home, and he could deeply understand Mr. Guo's feelings for "Mansion Gate".

Originally, Mr. Guo was going to continue filming with the first part, but there were too many problems that could not be designed, such as the catastrophe, such as what would happen in that catastrophe.

Probably because the feelings are still there, and the story cannot be continued to be written, so Mr. Guo chose to shoot "Mansion Gate 1912".

It's just that the sun has set, and although candles can't be replaced, they can still be used reluctantly.

Old man Guo can only take the trouble to add new elements such as suspense, house fighting, and old and young love to this TV series that tells the history of Bai Jingqi's struggle in Jinan, trying to make it more glorious, but unfortunately, at least the original version in the previous life was not a success.

"Mansion Gate 1912" is still a good TV series, especially in period dramas, it is a masterpiece that takes into account both quality and entertainment, but it is still a lot worse than the first one.

has lost the background of the times, the main actors are aging, the replaced actors are not full of charm, and the new actors are out of place, all of which make the audience very uncomfortable.

Fortunately, "Mansion Gate 1912" itself has a loud signboard, a strong story, and the performances of Chen Baoguo and several protagonists are wonderful, and they finally kept this signboard.

And the biggest discomfort of "Mansion Gate 1912" lies in the change.

In "Mansion Gate 2", actively cooperating with the public-private partnership, responding to the transformation, and handing in the secret recipe have made the seventh master lose a lot of color, and the virtuous woman version of Li Xiangxiu played by Jiang Shan is not as brave and strong as the pretty girl in the first part.

But what no one expected was that in "Mansion Gate 1912", Bai Qiye, who was young and vigorous, also lost his charm.

Chen Baoguo's role as Bai Jingqi is already natural, but you must not think about it, at this time, Bai Jingqi should be a middle-aged man in his 30s and in the prime of life, because he is already like a grandfather in the play.

Of course, what can't be considered is how the seventh master is passive everywhere this time, and has been led by the nose by the opponent, and in the end, the trouble is getting bigger and bigger, and he can only rely on the second grandmother to go out of the mountain to clean up the mess.

In short, the entire "Mansion Gate 1912" cannot be compared with the first "Mansion Gate", no matter how hard the candles flicker, they are still not as bright as the sun. The audience will remember the classics, but there is really no way to enshrine "Mansion Gate 1912" as a classic.

If the first part of the mansion gate is a great drama like a family history, this drama is at most a small farce, but the big drama has the grandeur of the big drama, and the farce has the excitement of the farce.

Song Zheng always believes that a TV series, the most important thing is to have a good script, a good story, a house, the actor is the furniture, as for the rest is an embellishment, the screenwriter and director of this drama are all one person, telling the story of Bai Jingqi's own Heiqizhuang in Shandong in 1912, the whole drama is chased by people from all walks of life to snatch the secret book of the Nine Dynasties and Bai Jingqi, Lu Qingqing, Tian Zixing The emotional struggle and entanglement between the two lines run through it, the story is very strong, and each episode will give Guan Zhong a new plot progress, which is also unexpected, this is also Song Zheng's last life, no matter how disappointed he was, he did not give up halfway, the reason for persisting in reading it.

It's just that it only happens in such a small space, just a few people, just these two things, it is impossible to develop into a big drama, it is destined to be just a small farce, just to find a way to play more lively, obviously found that the soundtrack of Peking Opera in the new drama is more and more dense, and the music used in the old drama is the same, but the use in the old drama is not so intensive, but every time it appears, it must be a very important scene, and there is a more deafening feeling.

But "Mansion Gate 1912" seems to use this kind of lively soundtrack to make up for the lack of scenes, but it makes the audience feel less and less feeling.

Generally speaking, Song Zheng still likes this drama very much, but it is still a little insufficient, for example, the Beijing films that are full of in the play, he personally likes Beijing films very much, full of "how to stubble, I want to stubble" and so on.

But the question is, although the protagonist is a person from the capital, the location of the story is in the land of Qilu, and it is a bit inappropriate in a place where the local language is so distinctive?

There is also the historical facts, the seventh master at every turn, "why not fight the Japanese" or something, although the Japanese have always been our enemies, but at that time, the contradiction with the Japanese, should not be to the point of taking this as the standard, serious anti-Japanese resistance, but also around 1937 to become vigorous.

But on the whole, it's still very good, the green gang, bandits, warlords, the instability of the situation, these aspects are very consistent and real.

The first time Song Zheng saw this script was at Mr. Guo's house, and what he saw at that time was not much different from the original TV series filmed in his previous life.

At that time, Song Zheng also put forward some opinions according to some thoughts after watching this TV series in his previous life, as well as various criticisms of the drama "Mansion Gate 1912" on the Internet.

After it was finally confirmed that he would play the role of Bai Jingqi, the script sent by Mr. Guo had been greatly changed.

Although the main framework has not changed, the content filled in it is not as blunt as the original, deliberate, and there is still some distance from the first part, but it can also be called a rare good story.

On August 25, Song Zheng and Lin Xinru officially joined the group, and Wu Xiubo joined the group with them, he will play the role of Tian Zixing in the play, in the previous "Mansion Gate 2", Wu Xiubo played the Japanese Tian Mu, and this time it is also the second time that he and Mr. Guo have joined hands.

In addition, Mr. Guo finally adopted Song Zheng's suggestion and gave up He Qinglai to play Yang Jiuhong, and instead chose an actress named Wang Tong.

Song Zheng doesn't have a deep impression of Wang Tong, and in her previous life, she only watched a "Flat Dan Girl" she filmed, and she gave people the feeling that she could act and knew how to act.

The other roles have not changed much, and the recently famous Guo Banzhu is still fortunate to participate, and when the crew gathers, when he sees Song Zheng, it is immediately like seeing a relative.

Guo has also filmed TV series before, but they are all cameo roles, this time he played such an important role at once, or the first time the eldest girl went to the sedan chair, and he cooperated with Mr. Guo, don't look at him not in the film and television industry, but he also knows the weight of Mr. Guo in this circle, and he looks sincerely afraid.

If you really want to say nervous, it has to be Song Zheng, because the Bai Jingqi played by Mr. Chen Baoguo before was too classic, and now let him interpret such a classic image on the screen, to be honest, he has no bottom.