"Now that anyone can buy a private car, who still shows off because they have a car at home? The opponent's defense friend kept saying that buying a private car mainly satisfies social needs, isn't it too dark in his heart? This is the heart of a villain to live the belly of a gentleman!" Yang Weiwei responded and argued.

Feng Jianxiong: "Defensive social needs are also social needs. Selling Mercedes-Benz BMWs is enough for people to show off what others don't have, but buying an Alto BYD can prove that 'I can afford what everyone can afford'.

Otherwise, if it is purely for practical value, with the congestion level of first-tier cities such as Hujiang and Beijing, and even foreign megacities, driving in urban areas is not as cost-effective as subway and other public transportation. ”

Yang Weiwei: "This statement is pure reasoning, and there is no real evidence. Then let me ask you again, how much labor and how much GDP is currently supported by the automobile industry, do you know the other side?"

Feng Jianxiong shrugged: "I don't need to know, this has nothing to do with today's debate." ”

Yang Weiwei's face changed: "Why is it irrelevant? Today, China's automobile industry alone has fed tens of millions of industrial chain laborers and created trillions of GDP." Even if, as the opponent's defense friend just said, buying a car is not only convenient, but also more of a social comparison need.

If the government does not limit the number of private cars, and only allows the market to use congestion, sewage and other means to force those who are not too eager to drive their own cars to 'drive less after buying them, and park at home until they have to do so', wouldn't it be better than not allowing anyone to buy them? At least then the government can still sell so many cars and boost the industrial chain and asset stock. It's also a huge help in promoting employment!"

Feng Jianxiong: "First of all, it turns out that the opponent called wasting resources for excessive production 'pulling the economy', then you'd better go back to the era of extensive economy, and never talk about industrial upgrading and backward production capacity elimination!"

Second, we say that even if the government restricts the number of private cars, it is currently limited by zoning and sharding. For example, the current implementation of the Beijing and Hujiang licensing restriction policies only restricts local residents from playing cards on their own and on the local daily road.

If a resident just wants to buy a car to put there just to show off socially, he can still buy it, but he needs a license plate from Shanglangfang or Gusu or Xiuzhou, and he can't usually drive into the city. However, this does not prevent them from occasionally driving into Beijing and Shanghai as foreign cars, nor does it prevent them from taking pictures of their cars in their garages and sharing QQ space.

As for the fact that the license plate photographed is not a local license plate, the effect of pretending to be forced is reduced - this is not a problem at all, because the license plate is expensive, and people with local license plates can better show off their wealth invisibly, and it is easier to distinguish the hierarchy of showing off their wealth than when there was no such threshold!"

……

The final stage of the free debate almost became a special heated confrontation between Feng Jianxiong and Yang Weiwei. The rest of the teammates on both sides gradually began to lose track of their thoughts.

Yang Weiwei exhausted her last tricks, and failed to nail the square to any ideologically incorrect political label such as "undermining the people's free choice and exacerbating social injustice".

She felt parched and weak.

Even the killer features that were originally intended to be saved for the concluding statement were completely exhausted in advance.

Finally, there are 3-minute closing remarks by each.

Yu Meiqin VS Yang Weiwei, whose lines were exhausted in advance.

Yang Weiwei's strength was originally only inferior to Feng Jianxiong, but it should be slightly better than Yu Meiqin, the second player of Jinling Normal University.

However, Yang Weiwei, who was squeezed dry, was almost on par with Yu Meiqin.

Coupled with her excessive mental exhaustion, she couldn't turn the tables in the last three minutes.

Neither side once again elevated the idea of "new wine in old bottles" in their closing arguments, and basically just made a solid summary.

"It seems that the positive side should have won, and the key is that the positive side has studied the specific administrative methods and methods according to law of 'how to limit cars' too thoroughly. The opposing side wants to rely on ideological attacks to smear them, but basically there is no play. Among the judges, Professor Zhang of Peking University and Professor Jiang of Fudan University almost thought so.

"The attack is very specific, very detailed, with the style of a parliamentary debate. Feng Jianxiong of Jinling Normal University, if he is willing to go to politics, and he is going to foreign countries to engage in politics, it is estimated that the future will not be small. However, Huaxia does not need to be questioned by the parliament, so this kind of effort is wasted. This is the idea of two poet judges, Yu Qiuyu and Beidao.

While everyone had their own opinions, as Yang Weiwei sat down a little weakly, the host Sa Beining finally announced:

"I now declare the conclusion of the closing arguments of the parties. Please take a break and wait for the judges to ask the final questions to both sides, and then give the review results. ”

"Please ask the jury to choose the guest questioners!"

"Come on, I know a little bit about administrative inquiries. On the jury, Chen Wenqian, a self-styled writer, volunteered to sell her qualifications and try to convince the other four judges to let her ask questions.

However, she has served as Wanwan's propaganda minister, and her political experience is indeed much richer than that of the other four pure scholars. She had put up this shelf so shamelessly, and no one had anything to object to her.

Chen Wenqian had long been unhappy with Feng Jianxiong. When she was in China in China, she happened to be a judge of Feng Jianxiong twice, and she voted against them at that time.

The main thing is that she is a senior Muyang dog and a cent-brain-dead fruit fan, or she would not have been the propaganda minister of the green camp at the beginning.

When Feng Jianxiong sprayed Qiao Lao Thief wildly, she already had some of the battle of wills and couldn't stand it.

At today's game, although Feng Jianxiong was only talking about the possibility of restricting the administration of vehicles in the air, he did not say that "is it possible for the current mainland government to do as well as I said when facing this practical problem?"

However, when Chen Wenqian's words were heard in Chen Wenqian's ears, he couldn't say anything uncomfortable, as if Feng Jianxiong was standing up for mainland politicians, bragging about something they couldn't do and didn't deserve to do.

"I can't do it with the government that is free and supervised, can you do it?" Chen Wenqian had this idea in her mind at the moment.

This makes her feel a lot like taking down the fig leaf of mainland cuisine to show her cultural superiority.

In the attention of the host and the audience, Chen Wenqian put on a pro-people posture, took the microphone slowly, and first asked the opponent a painless question - mainly about "If the opposition does not support the government to limit the number of private cars in the city through administrative means, then how to specifically solve the problems of urban congestion and pollution".

It's a cliché but you can't say it's wrong. In fact, in the course of the debate, the pros have attacked this point many times in fragments, and the opposing side has also answered one after another.

Chen Wenqian's question now is obviously asking about a direction in which the opposing side has been fully prepared, and it is purely to give the opposing side a chance to systematically sort out its thinking again.

The other four judges frowned slightly when they heard this, and said in their hearts, isn't this a special question?

Although this kind of pulling bias frame is not obvious in form, it is obvious from the perspective of "feeding moves".

Yang Weiwei hurriedly seized this opportunity and stated it again, taking the opportunity to sort out the opposing party's system more smoothly.

Chen Wenqian nodded, a hint of fierceness flashed in her eyes.

"Next, I would also like to ask the positive side a question: You just said in the debate that 'the government can implement a policy of limiting the number of private cars on the basis of absolutely satisfying the two prerequisites of administering according to law and taking from the people and using it for the people,' and you also emphasized the role of the government in planning and guiding, believing that this can replace administrative coercion.

What I want to ask is: Do you think that government measures that are not administratively compulsory, but only have the leverage effect of planning and guidance, can really solve these complex urban governance problems? As far as I know, when the Los Angeles government was planning the city, it planned a bunch of satellite city communities that could be self-sufficient to form a closed loop of work, life, and consumption.

But the result: At present, there is still a need for large-scale cross-district commuting, and urban congestion is miserable. Can the government really solve the problem by relying on its own predictions and guidance? If not, will you have to resort to those additional means of 'administering according to law' at that time?"

"Hiss......" "What are you asking this question?"

The other two writers, the poet judges, were either unconscious or shuddering.

Professor Zhang of Peking University and Professor Jiang of Fudan University thought so: "Hold grass, this kind of problem is too bullying to ask fresh college students, right? If such a detailed and specific problem of urban governance and administration can be solved, people will directly replace Arnold Schwarzenegger as governor of California, why are they still studying in college?"

"As a senior politician, it's too much to pick on college students with such an operational question, it's too shameful!"

The audience didn't think there was anything wrong, but just thought that this question was brainy, interesting, and mentally ill people had a wide range of ideas. Even among the opposing team members, there were three who just watched Chen Wenqian ask questions happily, but they didn't realize how deep the artistic conception of pulling the bias frame was.

On the side of Zhong S University, only Yang Weiwei felt ashamed.

"This writer Chen has helped us too much...... How can there be a feeling of 'if you really win with this, you really won't be able to win'?"

"No! How can you think like that! The current situation is still clearly at a disadvantage for us! If we don't rely on this kind of off-the-market surprise, how can we win!"

Yang Weiwei didn't have a long time in her brain, because Feng Jianxiong only thought for a few seconds before she began to answer this question.

"I don't know why Ms. Chen has this idea of living a gentleman's belly with the heart of a villain.

It is very common for policies formulated in accordance with the law to fail to achieve their intended purpose. How can one maliciously speculate that the government will go beyond the scope of administration according to law and arbitrarily use coercive measures that infringe on citizens' rights?

What's more, in my opinion, the urban problems of Los Angeles were completely caused by the incompetence of the relevant government decisions in California back then, and what they couldn't do doesn't mean that others can't do it. ”

Smack!

Click!

A place for chins, dentures, eyeballs, spectacle lenses.

Feng Jianxiong only used two opening sentences, which made the audience stunned.

Who else?

Eighteen years after the International College Debating Tournament was held, who else dares to spray so arrogantly?