According to Feng Jianxiong's memories of his previous life, the fierce struggle for milk pouring in the domestic agriculture and animal husbandry industry should not have intensified until 08.

The main reason is that the "three cows" milk powder incident broke out that year, and then the domestic cattle farmers mixed various things into milk to improve the detection indicators were all exposed by the media. A large number of well-known dairy companies dislike the inconvenience of controlling the quality of loose milk sources, so they simply import reconstituted milk powder directly.

However, the world is different after all.

In this world, it seems that the reputation of domestic dairy companies has been stinky for several years in advance, and there have been several incidents of domestic dairy farmers backlogging and pouring milk due to the change of corporate procurement to imports, and the media have also reported it.

At this moment, Ma Zhonglu put forward this argument, which naturally made many students feel concerned.

After all, although Feng Jianxiong is a campus celebrity, he is the kind of "foolish person" who makes a name for himself by daring to say big things, so among his fans, black fans are not much less than brainless fans.

"Yes, if there is no agricultural production subsidy, then let this industrial crisis hurt the farmers' enthusiasm for production, and in the future, farmers will not farm or raise cattle, what will be done about food safety?"

"That's it, I've always felt that Feng Jianxiong is despicable in his eloquence, but his character is really not good, and he always says discordant things!"

Many people who eat melons irresponsibly make up their brains - well, in fact, they can't even count as brain supplements, they can only be called spinal supplements. Because they didn't go through their brains when they said this, their thoughts only swirled around their spinal cords, and they spewed straight out.

Thankfully, they didn't get to spray for a few seconds.

"Ridiculous!" Feng Jianxiong refuted Ma Zhonglu's hasty and imprecise judgment in just two words, "If those who blindly expand backward production capacity are not duly punished by the laws of the market, will they still have the motivation to optimize the allocation of means of production? This is the basic law of the market economy, Mr. Ma, you actually turn a blind eye?"

This is an obvious and low-level loophole, and after Feng Jianxiong finished speaking, he didn't expect to get many points.

He believed that Ma Zhonglu just said it too hastily just now, and he didn't have time to organize his words thoroughly.

Sure enough, Ma Zhonglu's face only changed slightly, and in less than two seconds, he immediately reacted: "I take the dairy industry as an example, just because this example is relatively close to our lives, please don't maliciously emphasize the particularity of the dairy industry!"

It's no secret that the milk industry is overprotected and has led to poor capacity allocation, which can be problematic. But that's only because of the natural nature of primary dairy products that have a short shelf life. Raw milk must be sold within a week even if it is properly sterilized, so blindly expanding production is harmful.

But grain is different, grain can be easily stored for a long time, COFCO as long as it wants, there is no problem in expanding the inventory by 200 million tons a year. Therefore, even if the peasants are lured by the subsidy policy to diversify their grain, there is nothing wrong with that! As long as the state purchases reserves in a timely manner, does it not just strengthen China's food security?"

The audience was just briefly shaken, and was pulled back by Ma Zhonglu.

He also pinched a handful of sweat himself, and said in his heart that he was impatient just now, and he didn't speak comprehensively, and was caught by Feng Jianxiong of an opportunity, but fortunately, the leak was plugged immediately.

"This guy is so qualified to be my only opponent, I really can't be negligent at all. Ma Zhonglu secretly thought about it, and compared Feng Jianxiong with the opponents he had encountered in the previous rounds in his heart, and had to admit that Feng Jianxiong was the strongest he had encountered so far.

"Well, I also believe that you didn't mean to make such a low-level mistake. I don't bother to rely on the opponent's low-level mistakes to score," Feng Jianxiong didn't bite the bite, but lightly let go of the opponent's previous intightness, "Now, let's get to the point." ”

The audience couldn't help but be aroused their curiosity again: the confrontation just now was just a warm-up for the opening remarks?

Ma Zhonglu's expression was grim, and he also sensed a hint of danger.

"I'll focus on two points," Feng Jianxiong cleared his throat and stretched out two fingers slowly but firmly,

"First, the other side keeps saying that providing subsidized macroeconomic regulation and control to China's agricultural producers can play the same role in guiding production capacity as similar policies of capital attention to the state - but I want to say, you think too much, the effect of this kind of regulation and control does not exist at all.

Second, even if I take another 10,000 steps back and discuss it from the standpoint of acknowledging the existence of such a regulatory effect, I would like to say that there is not a dime between increasing the country's strategic reserves and encouraging peasants to grow grain. In other words, if you want to increase your strategic reserves, you just need to buy them, why do you have to grow them yourself? Can't you buy them!"

As he spoke, he did not sit down, but maintained the posture of stretching out two fingers, and stood there proudly, as if waiting for Ma Zhonglu to ask why.

"What? How is it possible? What is Feng Jianxiong talking about? How can I not understand the logic behind it at all?"

"Listening to the sentence structure of the cause and effect, it seems to be very strict, although I don't understand the reason......"

This time, not only the people who eat melons whispered so much, but even Hao Fang, a debater from the Academy of Earth Sciences, was also very generous, which shows that Feng Jianxiong's words were very sudden.

Hao Fang is just a debate, and the technical characteristics are similar to Shi Nico, that is, her voice is good, and she thinks that Ma Zhonglu is talented and good-looking, so she wants to get close to the male god before joining the academy debate team.

can also beat the opponent's non-strain players into confusion, which shows how sudden Feng Jianxiong's words are.

"Why do you say that the regulation and control effect of China's subsidies is not as good as that of foreign countries? Feng Jianxiong, when you speak, you have to talk about evidence! What is it that you just throw out a point of view?" Ma Zhonglu stared at the other party, and his heart was also running at high speed, wondering what amazing evidence the other party would say.

"Of course I'll give you convincing proof. Feng Jianxiong didn't care about this, "First of all, you people, when you see the 'pouring milk' incident, you follow the heckling, thinking of the history and political textbooks that 'capital pays attention to the evils of the system, and capital pays attention to the country's In the Great Depression, the capitalists would rather pour milk into the river than sell it to the hungry and cold workers to drink'—don't you dare to say that you didn't think of these words in the book on impulse when you saw the milk dumping incident?"

"I ...... I did think about it. But this ...... Is there anything wrong with this?" Ma Zhonglu felt that the aura of danger was even worse, but he had to admit it according to Feng Jianxiong's meaning.

The last time he had this kind of dangerous feeling was when Senior Su pointed out an irrational mistake of believing too much in experience during a training session.

"Capital pays attention to the evil of pouring milk, which has been repeatedly demonstrated in history and political textbooks for decades, is there also a problem with the logic behind this?" Ma Zhonglu was still thinking like this after answering.

He asked himself to be a very speculative, absolutely rational person, and never blindly following blind believers.

However, the key point is that Feng Jianxiong's questioning this time is too unexpected, and it is difficult for anyone who has received social attention and education to wonder if there is another hidden truth behind such incidents as "pouring milk".

After all, this is an inertial thinking that has been determined for decades.

Even if you have to doubt everything, such as Ma Zhonglu, you don't doubt this point.

"The problem is that the pouring milk of dairy farmers in my country and the pouring milk that capital pays attention to are not the same nature!"

As soon as Feng Jianxiong's words came out, the audience was shaken.

Even Tian Haimo, the judge and host, couldn't help but speak: "Student Feng, please be careful not to speak in a grandstanding way, if it makes sense, you can finish it in one go." ”

"Thank you for the reminder, I'll take note. Feng Jianxiong bowed politely, then turned to Ma Zhonglu, and taught the other party how to behave in passing,

"Mr. Ma, as a debater, we need to think rationally, not emotionally. Thinking with emotion is an unprofessional performance.

Why do I say that these two types of milk dumping incidents are very different? Let's look at the economic logic behind this. In capital-conscious countries, dairy farmers are very capital-intensive, large ranchers, and large ranchers. Which of the big ranchers in Australia or Argentina is not a strong presence in 'transstate and county'?

In Europe and the United States, agricultural workers are generally less than 2% of the country's industrial population, and there are strong industry self-regulatory associations. However, there are nearly half of China's agricultural practitioners, and the overall planning of the industry does not exist, so it is doomed that China's agricultural practitioners cannot unite to advance and retreat together, just as China's workers are not as easy to strike as European and American countries. ”

Feng Jianxiong said, pausing slightly for two seconds for the other party and the judges to digest.

In 05, the urbanization process was still relatively low, and the agricultural population was relatively large, and then the country basically created 20 million jobs every year to drive to the city. So Feng Jianxiong's words are right.

Then, he continued: "Now, let's look at the motives of capital to pay attention to the pouring milk. According to Marx, milk is poured because there is an oversupply – at least too much for those who can afford it. So if there are 100,000 tons of milk on the market, each ton of milk can only be sold for 3,000 yuan, and when it is reduced to 50,000 tons of milk, the high price of each ton of milk can be restored to 10,000 yuan.

At this time, sell 100,000 tons at a low price without pouring milk, and return 300 million yuan, and pour out 50,000 tons and sell the rest at a high price, and return 500 million yuan - so after pouring half of it, sell it again, and the capitalists as a whole collect more money, and it is time to pour!

However, there is a logic behind this - when there are only a few dozen or hundreds of large dairy owners in a country, and they can be restrained by industry self-regulatory associations, they can reach a monopoly and advance and retreat together. For example, the association draws up a paper contract, everyone signs it, and if they don't do it, they will be severely punished. According to this contract, everyone is allowed to throw away 50% of their own production, and no one is allowed to take advantage of others. Historically, non-fresh agricultural products in Europe and the United States have been systematically eliminated in this way.

But what about at home? Can the peasants organize themselves into monopolistic organizations? We have only a small peasant economy that fights for itself. If you dump half of the total capacity of milk, you can maintain the market price and increase the total revenue of the entire industry - it looks beautiful, but the question is whose milk is poured in? If you are a small farmer and you are asked to pour all your milk, and your neighbor only shouts slogans and does not pour milk, and when you and other wronged people finish pouring milk and the price of milk has risen, will you sell it?"