Ma Lilan's argument made many fans of the law school team in the field really feel unprecedented pressure.

Perhaps only the speech of Yu Meiqin in the semi-finals of last year's Freshman Cup when she acted as the opponent could barely win Ma Lilan's argument today.

Especially among those fans, the small number of people who only watched the academy competition and had not understood the strength of the Academy of Sciences before were even more dumbfounded by the sudden acceleration of the pace of the competition.

After all, in the internal debate competition of the university, because the number of masters is small, most teams do not have enough talents to squander, and the people who are often placed in the first debate position only have the advantages of typhoon, body language and timbre, and the quick response is mostly a shortcoming.

And Ma Lilan's words just now, from the second paragraph, have been conclusively piercing the narrowness problem in the square theory, and beating it up, which has really not appeared in the opponents encountered in law schools before.

The team of the Academy of Geological Sciences really doesn't exist as a mediocre hand.

The two sides rested for a few dozen seconds and immediately entered into a nervous cross-questioning.

On the law school side, Yu Meiqin and Nan Xiaoyuan matched high and low, one main defense and one main attack, and they were at loggerheads with each other.

On the side of the Academy of Earth Sciences team, the state of the two girls, Mi Suli, the second debater, and Niu Zeqian, the third debate, are not far behind.

Nan Xiaoyuan: "May I ask the opponent's defense friend, just now you said that 'a professional is not a professional who does not know anything other than the skills that are directly used in the work', and even took 'a programmer who plays basketball well is also a professional' as an example." Well, I know the law very well now, but I also dance to the level that I can dance to a professional singer. Do you think I'm a specialist or a generalist?"

Misuri: "This has to be analyzed on a case-by-case basis, are you better at dancing than Jolin Tsai's B**? If so, I admit that you are a generalist." ”

Nan Xiaoyuan suddenly became angry, and said in her heart that this guy is here to find faults? But fortunately, her psychological quality is quite good, and she immediately changed her face to another topic: "It turns out that in the eyes of the opponent's debater, an amateur dancer who is also a dancer must be better than Jolin Tsai to be called a generalist! It seems that the world in the eyes of the opponent's debater does not need the general public to build and contribute, and only a few top geniuses are needed in each of the most subdivided fields, right?"

Mi Suli immediately circled the battlefield immediately: "I didn't say that you don't need the contribution of ordinary people, but I believe that Senior Sister Nan, your greatest contribution and value to the society in the future should be enough to rely on your legal literacy to serve the society." As for dancing, anyway, Jolin Tsai's MV is copied 10,000 times, and 100 million times is also copied, we have Jolin Tsai to watch, isn't it enough?"

At the law school, Yu Meiqin waited for Nan Xiaoyuan to finish asking, and immediately followed seamlessly: "Then let's change the example - I believe that the opponent's debaters know that I and this classmate Feng are both on the debate team, which has brought so many collisions of ideas to everyone." We are also the anchors of the school station, bringing countless conversations and entertainment to the majority of students.

Feng is also a senior legal aid worker, and a big V who blogs to popularize the law and provide knowledge services—I think according to the meaning of the opponent's defense friend, his value only needs to focus on one aspect?"

Yu Meiqin's example is very close to life, with living persuasive power, and the audience in the audience can't help but laugh, feeling very cordial and convincing.

Niu Zeqian, the third debater of the Academy of Earth Sciences, immediately continued to ridicule each other when he heard this......

In general, the cross-questioning session between the two sides bites the distinction between specialists and generalists, carefully picking out the words, trying to change the definition to their own side and make their own words cover more "united front".

This is a competition that focuses more on debating skills than on experience and insight.

In the eyes of the layman, the scene is not very good-looking, but the staggered progression of hand-to-hand is very rich. At the very least, it can be said that the second and third debates of these two teams are very professional in mentality and style.

After both sides have used up about two-thirds of the number of question opportunities, the definition fence is firmly established, and then everyone uses the last two question opportunities to talk about something of practical significance, which can be regarded as a complete and clear definition of the negotiation framework.

In just a few minutes of confrontation, Feng Jianxiong and Su Qin, who were still in a state of spectatorship, roughly felt the level of their teammates on the other side-

The level of Mi Su Li and Niu Zeqian may be slightly inferior to Yu Meiqin, but they can both suppress Nan Xiaoyuan.

Tian Haimo, who stood on the rostrum to control the rhythm of the game, listened to the speeches of both sides, and secretly scored and judged in his heart:

"Being able to use the time of four questions in each of the cross-question sessions to completely circle the scope of the confrontation is already very efficient - it is obvious that both sides have a certain point to stop, I should have watched the match between HKUST and Wanwan Shih-Hsin University last year, so I can't play too many tricks on the definition and scope of the problem.

When Hong Kong Can played with Taibazi, the scope scale of that definition was pulled for most of the whole half, which was too unatmospheric......"

Tian Haimo thought so, and in her heart she was expecting Feng Jianxiong and Su Qin to come up with a free confrontation with Bai Zhizhong, who had an obvious fork in the road. After all, the issue between the two sides has already taken two more steps forward.

……

It's time for free debate.

Su Qin, the former No. 1 troll of Jinling Normal University, finally waited for the moment to exert his power.

Professional, restrained, and point-to-point, he is tired of playing.

Even in today's arena, those peripheral encounters that were relatively unexciting in the eyes of the onlookers, but could score points from the judges, he had already let his three teammates complete it.

At this moment, he just wanted to defeat Feng Jianxiong in a way that everyone could understand.

He stood up.

"Look, Senior Su is about to speak!" All the students in the audience who supported the Academy of Geosciences or the senior students in the audience spread rumors before he could speak, and then applauded.

The rumors were very soft, and the applause was very enthusiastic, so those unnutritious words were deaf to both sides and the moderator at the debate table.

Tian Haimo spent 15 seconds maintaining order, and pinched the watch to stop the timer, and then signaled: "Su Qin, please start." ”

"Thank you, host. Su Qin smiled gracefully and nodded slightly to Tian Haimo, and then cleared his throat,

"Feng Jianxiong, the other teammates on both sides of you and I have talked a lot about the differences in the definition of generalist and specialist. I don't think there's any point in wasting time on this.

Because everyone's endowment and talent are different, some people can absorb new knowledge and new insights at a glance, while others have to work slowly, and it is ridiculous to compare geniuses and fools with each other. So, I hope that in the rest of the debate, you will stand under the 'ideal model of the constant energy of a person's overall energy' and discuss the question of the value of expertise and generalism – do you dare?"

Su Qin's words were neither fast nor slow, and they cooperated well with body language, which made people have a tendency to integrate into the speech environment inexplicably. Although the sentences are quite long and the sentences are relatively complicated, more than ninety percent of the audience actually felt that there was no reading disorder.

Su Qin's spraying skills, sure enough, have moisturized things silently, and it is time for fire.

Feng Jianxiong's answer was more concise and neat, "Of course, it can be summed up as 'conservation of energy, conservation of total knowledge'." ”

Su Qin immediately launched an offensive: "Okay, may I ask if there is an assistant engineer now, assuming that the IQ is very average, just 100, he can represent the general public." At this time, he will devote the remaining 30% of his energy to improving his professional quality, making it easier to get promotions and salary increases, and creating greater value for the society;

Feng Jianxiong pondered his sentence and answered this question cautiously: "Cultivating sentiment may not directly produce benefits, but generalists don't necessarily have to spend time cultivating sentiment." I don't think if this assistant engineer can spend a little time on management or other methodology, it is not known that he will achieve more than improve his professional skills.

Secondly, everyone's energy concentration is limited by objective physiological factors, when a person has 15 hours of disposable time a day, the effect of taking out all 15 hours of study, the effect will definitely not reach 1.5 times that of only 10 hours of study. Because the effect of talent improvement and the cost of investment are not linearly proportional.

A person spends 500 hours to learn a course to 90 points, maybe he needs to spend another 500 hours to improve to 95 points, the closer to the full score, the slower the improvement, maybe some people's talent is limited, let him learn a course for a lifetime, can not learn 100 full marks.

And if he reaches 90 points and spends the extra 500 hours on a new course, he may be able to learn another skill with 80~90 points. At this time, how can it be said that two more skills with 90 points are not as valuable to society as one with 95 points?"

Feng Jianxiong's approachable remarks suddenly made countless scumbags who assaulted before the exam feel very cordial.

"That's right! Those who have already scored 90 points in the test want to improve to 95, how difficult it is to improve it! Those who fail the course will be relatively easy to take the test for more than 60 in a few days!"

Su Qin on the field can naturally feel the swaying from the audience.

"It seems that the attempt to attack from the perspective of 'conservation of effort' is a bit of an underestimation of Feng Jianxiong. Su Qin was thinking so quickly in his mind that he decided to fine-tune it.

His mind moved, and he continued to say: "Please pay attention to the opponent's debate friend, today's debate topic is a trend-oriented debate topic, talking about 'under the current social development situation', who can eat more generalists or specialists. Therefore, if you talk about it in isolation from the context of the technical environment, it makes no sense.

Let's take the media industry as an example, the Internet is developing rapidly, and the growth rate is increasing even faster every year. Seven or eight years ago, when Ren Xianqi was popular all over the treasure island, Xiangjiang was still listening to Andy Lau and Jacky Cheung Faye Wong. The impact of the import of cultural products from all sides in our mainland is also relatively even, and the audience's head content preferences are not so concentrated.

But now? We can see that the Hong Kong music scene has completely declined, and at most there is Eason Chan among the male singers who is barely resisting, but who can compare with Zhou Jielun, who is in full swing and sweeping the Asian Chinese music scene? Unfortunately, no.

So, do you admit that the development of the Internet and even the new era of media and other technologies is amplifying the Matthew effect of 'the winner kills all, the strong gets stronger, the second drink soup, the third dies'?"

"Amplify the Matthew effect? Of course I admit this, but does this have anything to do with today's debate?" Feng Jianxiong very keenly and frankly recognized this animal-animal harmless view.

"Of course it matters!" Su Qin thought he had a plan, and hurriedly said, "Then do you admit that in the environment where the winner kills all and only the first place in each subdivision is needed to have the value of survival, even if it takes 1,000 class hours to raise one course to 95 points, it is far more valuable than using the same amount of time to raise two courses to 90 points?"

Because once a person can't be the first in a certain segment, especially those where the results can be replicated at an unbounded cost, then what he has learned is meaningless. Just like a person who imitates Zhou Jielun's singing, even if you can learn Zhou Jielun's ninety-five percent singing skills, is it valuable? No, this world only needs to listen to one Zhou Jielun, what is the difference between a high imitation and a dead corpse?"