Chapter 38: Unacceptable Reasoning

Liu Zichen got too many things needed in Liu Xiaoquan's body, and the Beiting Detective Agency's investigation and understanding of Liu Xiaoquan was finally able to gather his information together, and the face of this man who seemed to be different from the inside was gradually being clearly presented to the world.

Li Yiting believes that the Liu Xiaoquan learned from Liu Xu'er's mouth should be the real Liu Xiaoquan, what this person shows in other places is the side he is willing to let others see, and his other side, that is, the face under the split personality, is very hidden, except for his sister, it is difficult for anyone to capture, so he is often blinded by his introverted appearance, and it was not until this prophecy event that everyone paid too much attention to him.

Shen Mingyue was quite surprised by Liu Xiaoquan's split personality, she knew that when she was in college, Liu Xiaoquan did behave a little strangely, but it was far from being so serious, she said her thoughts, " If we can now be sure that Liu Xiaoquan does have a split personality, then his conditions as a murderer are actually very insufficient, because what these cases show is obviously very precise design and logic, and it is impossible for a person with a bad spirit to deal with it, even if he sometimes has a bad brain, but in the case of an illness, I am afraid that it is difficult to control his own behavior, how can he use his brain to design exquisitely?"

Liu Zichen didn't quite agree with Shen Mingyue's opinion, she smiled, "But it may also be because of his illness that Liu Xiaoquan made a criminal move in a mentally disordered situation, as for those ideas, it may be that he thought about it when he was normal, or it may be that this kind of personality problem does not affect his intelligence!"

"Sister Zichen, do you also think that Xiao Quan is a murderer now?" Shen Mingyue was a little difficult to accept, after all, Liu Zichen had always stood by her side before, but now she disagreed with her point of view.

Liu Zichen didn't know how to express her thoughts, since she saw Liu Xiao'er, she did deepen her suspicion of Liu Xiaoquan, but there was still no evidence, speaking like this might hurt Shen Mingyue's heart, and she was a little anxious just now.

"Mingyue, I don't think anyone is a murderer, I'm just doing some analysis from a mental point of view, don't think about it. Liu Zichen comforted her, and then suddenly remembered another person, so he changed the topic, "By the way, there is another suspect Yege, what kind of role does he play in these cases?"

Li Yiting did not forget this strange thief, and did not mention it because this person was really missing, there were no clues at all, and he couldn't find many places, in order to ensure that the case was not deviated, he temporarily gave up looking for Yege, and just asked the police to urge the local police station to assist in the search.

Judging from the feedback from all sides, it is indeed difficult to judge what kind of situation Yege is at present, but Tong Yangyang was indeed found in his home, which is ironclad evidence, so Ruge must have something to do with the case, and he will never be able to escape this!

Chen Tianyu has been paying attention to the argument between Shen Mingyue and Liu Zichen, he knows that Mingyue is a little subjective now because of her special relationship with Liu Xiaoquan, so he must maintain the independence of the investigation and not mix too many emotions in it, so he simply put forward a hypothesis.

"It may also be like this, the whole case is a huge scam from the beginning of the prophecy of the Monkey Island Cableway, and the one who manipulated all this may really be Liu Xiaoquan, who directed and acted in such a play, and then personally carried out the murder of the old man, Tong Minghai, Hou Hong and Liu Changshou!"

Li Yiting was quite surprised, how could Chen Tianyu make a direct judgment under such circumstances? If there was a mistake in this line, as a leader, it was very likely that everyone's investigation findings would be deviated, and this did not seem to be the style of the Beiting Detective Agency.

Shen Mingyue naturally couldn't accept it even more, she said unhappily, "Why do you all think that Liu Xiaoquan killed someone? How could he plan so many complicated murders by himself? Moreover, he has never done anything bad in the past!"

"Mingyue, don't worry, listen to Tianyu first!" Liu Zichen grabbed Shen Mingyue's arm and told her to calm down.

For such a bold speculation, Li Yiting is also very puzzled, Liu Xiaoquan is the most suspicious, this is true, but if he is the planner and implementer of the whole case, according to the current evidence, it is still far behind.

So he asked, "Tianyu, what is the conclusive basis for you to say that?"

Chen Tianyu looked at Li Yiting, then at Liu Zichen and Shen Mingyue, and made a detailed analysis, "Zichen has determined from Liu Xu'er that Liu Xiaoquan has a genetic factor of split personality, and judging from his daily performance after graduation, this factor has obviously flinched and affected his life, which should also be the main reason why he has stayed at home for many years and is unwilling to go out to work and socialize." We all know that mental problems are not visible in normal times, but once they occur, they are uncontrollable, so it is untenable to use whether Liu Xiaoquan has done bad things or other behaviors before to rule out the possibility that he did not commit a crime. In addition, with Liu Xiaoquan's professionalism and ingenuity, designing these cases is not just on paper, he is not a fool, but he is a little separated at the mental level, and his wisdom and brain power are not affected at all, so the conditions for committing crimes are also available. ”

"Then Fourth Brother, what is his motive for committing the crime? Those who died and Xiao Quan had no grievances, why should they kill them, not to mention his own father!" Shen Mingyue interrupted Chen Tianyu and questioned impatiently.

Chen Tianyu didn't care, he could understand Shen Mingyue's mood, and then he was going to explain the motive, "According to the police investigation, there are contradictions between Liu Xiaoquan and Tong Minghai and Hou Hong. First of all, someone saw Liu Wuer playing in the community one day, when Tong Minghai also took his daughter Yangyang outside, as a result, Liu Wuer and Yangyang had a dispute over the swing in the center of the community, the two little girls had a good temper, but when they got together for toys, it was different, they all wanted to play first, and Tong Minghai naturally spoiled his daughter, so he blocked Liu Wu'er aside, let Tong Yangyang play first, and taught Liu Wu'er a few words in his mouth, presumably Liu Wu'er would definitely tell Liu Xiaoquan about it, this is indeed not a big deal, but for Liu Xiaoquan, a person with personality disorders, bullying his favorite sister may be a very serious mistake。 Secondly, Ji Jing once liked and pursued Liu Xiaoquan, this matter is normal in college, men and women love very freely, but Ji Jing's mother Hou Hong inquired about it through some channel, because Liu Changshou's business outside is doing well, the Liu family is very good, and because Yuan Hui'e has a good relationship with herself, so she originally intended to fulfill it, but Liu Xiaoquan later rejected Ji Jing, which made Hou Hong very dissatisfied, and once found Liu Xiaoquan for this, but Liu Xiaoquan ignored her at all. ”

Shen Mingyue didn't expect Chen Tianyu to know so much, the secret agent police investigated carefully, in fact, although there are these connections, there are not many contradictions, but on Liu Xiaoquan, these can indeed be pursued, but she still asked, "Even if there are these connections, what about the two others?"

"As for Liu Changshou, it is true that he is Liu Xiaoquan's father, but we all know very well that Liu Changshou and Yuan Hui'e both like their daughter Liu Xu'er, and they are not satisfied with this son who is not very successful, presumably there must be some favoritism at home, for Liu Xiaoquan's character, these may become the fuse of revenge. Of course, the old man who died first had nothing to do with Liu Xiaoquan except for meeting him on the Monkey Island Cableway, so I suspected that his death was really an accident, and it was also possible that the murderer was suspicious and disturbed our vision. ”

Chen Tianyu rarely analyzed so many things in one breath, felt that his mouth was very dry, and went to pour a large glass of water to drink. The series of cases pressed on the heads of everyone in the Beiting Detective Agency, which made everyone breathless, and he had to lead by example and lead everyone to clear their minds as soon as possible.

Shen Mingyue still didn't give up, she had to admit death today, and she wanted to defend her classmates without ironclad evidence, so she asked again, "Even if he has a motive, how did he carry out these murders?" Our current investigation, except for a few suspicions, basically doesn't seem to be man-made!"

"The deaths of Tong Minghai and Hou Hong, we have already deduced, I still say the same sentence, the first case is left aside for the time being, these two cases are obviously human actions in them. Let's talk about Tong Minghai first, he was hit by a forklift, and then flew into the music fountain square, but the driver of the forklift said that there was a problem with the car, so he didn't listen to the call, otherwise with the master's skills and experience, how could a good person hit someone and drag it for so long? Therefore, his car is very likely to be tampered with, and this person is Liu Xiaoquan. Then, Tong Minghai fell to the concrete floor, and someone was in the duty room of the square, turning on the switch, allowing the fountain to lift Tong Minghai up and then fall down, which eventually led to his death. ”

Li Yiting obviously heard a huge flaw from Chen Tianyu's analysis, he was very strange about what happened to Chen Tianyu today, not only did he talk so much, but he also often had loopholes, but according to his understanding of Tianyu, the Buddha was deliberately released, perhaps to mobilize everyone's enthusiasm. Therefore, Li Yiting did not break it.

But he didn't say it, Shen Mingyue would definitely not let it go, she immediately brought it up, "Fourth brother, what are you kidding, that forklift was originally driving in a good manner, and the driver master has always been there, if you want to do something, you can only stop there for a little time." But the location where the forklift is parked, at least seven or eight hundred meters away from the place where the fountain in the music square is controlled, and there are steps on the road that cannot be crossed, how can Liu Xiaoquan just break the car and immediately run so far, and he can't fly!"

Chen Tianyu naturally knew this problem, so he immediately replied, "What Mingyue said is right, so Liu Xiaoquan may not be a person, he may have helpers, don't forget the night song." ”

"Is it him?" Shen Mingyue suddenly realized, if he said so, the doubts he was sure of would no longer exist.

Chen Tianyu continued, "Hou Hong's death is even better, the roast duck oven may have been put by Liu Xiaoquan in advance, as for Hou Hong's time and route for grocery shopping, because Liu Xiaoquan's mother and Hou Hong are very familiar and often buy vegetables together, so it will naturally reach the ears of his son, and then he arranged everything there in advance." Even if Hou Hong hadn't choked on the chili powder, she might have stopped for something else and been hit by a hook when she got there. ”

Shen Mingyue was still looking for flaws, "How can there be so many coincidences, how can chili powder be a coincidence, what about the seafood, what about the electric fan, what about the water on the ground, is the entire vegetable market Liu Xiaoquan?"

For Mingyue's successive questions, Chen Tianyu can't answer each of them perfectly, if that's the case, he has already confirmed the evidence of Liu Xiaoquan's crime, which is naturally far from being reached. His purpose, as Li Yiting guessed, needs to put forward reasoning by himself, and then let others, mainly Shen Mingyue, who is trying his best to excuse Liu Xiaoquan, refute it, so that he will have a good chance to find the place that can be determined at present, and he can also distinguish the details that have no evidence, so as to grasp these as the focus of the next work.

Chen Tianyu still wanted to finish speaking, "And Liu Changshou, I am very willing to be sure that Liu Xu'er was not involved in this case, so he and his daughter encountered a wave crisis on the beach, which should be an accident." Facts have proved that neither Liu Changshou, who is in poor health, nor Liu Fuer, who is petite, has not been harmed on the beach, but they have encountered some surprises. Later, when they entered the locker room, the snake that Liu Wuer saw should have been deliberately put in by someone else, in order to scare Liu Xue'er, so as to attract his father's help to kill him when he came out. ”

"But at that time, the barbecue grill was on fire, and Liu Xiaoquan was with his mother Yuan Hui'e to extinguish the fire!" Shen Mingyue once again found proof of his classmate's alibi.

"That's right, but it's still that reason, Liu Xiaoquan didn't commit the crime alone, such as Yege, he didn't appear in front of people, and he could completely manipulate all this in secret. ”

With Yege as a potential helper, many situations where the doppelgangers lack skills can be explained, although Shen Mingyue still disagrees with Chen Tianyu's speculation, but indeed many doubts have been explained thoroughly.

Chen Tianyu felt that he had discussed enough, as for the relationship between Liu Xiaoquan and Yege, neither they nor the police had found anything yet, and Yege had temporarily lost track of him.

"Mingyue, Zichen, you still continue to investigate Liu Xiaoquan, hoping to be fair and objective. Chen Tianyu specially reminded that no matter what, Mingyue still plays a very important role in this case, especially in the place related to Liu Xiaoquan.

At this time, Liu Zichen received a phone call, and she saw that it happened to be Liu Xiaoquan's mother Yuan Hui'e. Zichen thought that Yuan Hui'e was worried about her daughter Liu Xu'er and wanted to ask about Su'er's situation here, so she connected. It's just that I didn't expect that on the phone, Yuan Hui'e anxiously said another thing to her.

Liu Xiaoquan is also missing!