June 8, 2010.

Jiangnan Provincial High People's Court.

After more than half a year of fighting, the sacred moment is coming.

“…… This court held that, based on the available evidence and ascertained facts, it should be determined that the plaintiff's claim for restriction on the way in which the defendant's property ownership was exercised was not established. Moreover, the plaintiff's claims against the consumer, as well as the subsequent adjustment of the terms of the user agreement, constitute an obstruction to the consumer's overall property ownership......

The court ruled that the plaintiff's claim that it had the right to restrict the defendant's use of the mobile phone with a cracked version of the IOS system was groundless in law. However, the plaintiff may, to the extent permitted by law, exercise its right to remedy the defendant's breach of the user agreement in accordance with the law......"

“…… The defendant's claim to invalidate the relevant overlord clauses in the plaintiff's user agreement was also rejected because there is no provision for public interest litigation in the current laws of China. The decision in this case is limited to the validity of the ......"

The lengthy verdict, thirty or forty pages, one page read in five minutes, and most of the morning passed—and there were still many appendices that had not been read.

In fact, in many ordinary civil cases, if the judgment cannot be made immediately after the debate, they will choose to announce the judgment on a regular basis, notify them when the time comes, and send the judgment directly. Basically, we don't waste everyone's time, and we will hold a special court session again, gather everyone, and then just read a verdict.

The application of "pronouncing a judgment in court" is often a situation where there is substantial content and gains from the courtroom debate on the same day, which is sufficient to influence the immediate delivery of the judgment.

And today's case between Ma and Sha and Apple is purely because the social impact is too great, so there is obviously no "substantial" debate between the two sides, so you still have to find people to read it together.

Of course, limited to "substantial".

"Theoretical" debates still exist, because the Provincial High Court is also responsible for fully conveying the spirit of the SPC's explanation reply to the parties and their representatives. It's just that after the communication, the agents of both sides have no chance to resist, and they just need to stand firm after being beaten.

As the reading ended, there was a slight click in the auditorium.

After all, it was noon, and the court also considered the solemnity of the environment very much, and specially chose a courtroom with large windows on both sides and very good lighting to announce the verdict.

The picture is to let the media friends give some face, don't make a fuss with magnesium lights, make it like a Kodak theater, and destroy the sacred solemnity of the courtroom.

"It was turned over by horses and yarn!"

"What the hell is the explanation of the "Property Law" that I said before the verdict!

"Article 4 of the Property Law: The property rights of the state, collectives, private individuals and other rights holders shall be protected by law and shall not be infringed upon by any unit or individual.

Article 7: The acquisition and exercise of property rights shall comply with the law, respect social morality, and shall not harm the public interest and the legitimate rights and interests of others. It shall not be infringed upon by any unit or individual. , except as otherwise provided by law.

Article 23: The creation and transfer of movable property rights shall take effect from the time of delivery, unless otherwise provided by law.

Article 35: Where a real right is or may be obstructed, the right holder may request that the obstruction be removed or the danger eliminated.

I can understand every word of the literal meaning, and I can understand every sentence when it is connected! Why does it feel like it has become a book from heaven when it comes to application? After making a fuss for a long time, just a few principled general outline things can still be used for more than half a year?

"It's so against the sky, there are really people who can stand up to their waists and say to international giants like Apple, 'My mother is in breach of contract, but my mother just wants to give up the warranty while insisting on violating it to the end'." It's so domineering. ”

Countless whispers are about to converge into business review and law review articles, landing in the space of well-known bloggers, or the cover article headlines of top financial and business weeklies.

I have to say that ordinary reporters and people who eat melons are very slow to respond to the judicial interpretation, which is why they are so surprised. Until the last moment, they still thought that "upholding the original verdict" was a high probability event.

The final conclusion, of course, blew up the whole public opinion.

However, with the exception of a few stubborn diehard fruit fans, most people are still willing to accept the legal principles behind this.

After all, Feng Jianxiong occupies the justice of heaven and the vicissitudes of life.

Du Qiuming looked defeated, gritted his teeth and twisted his head to the side, as if he didn't want to be photographed, and he was embarrassed to squeeze out immediately to flash people. That disgusting feeling is really not going to stay or staying - he knows that if he doesn't leave, the reporters at least can't rush to the plaintiff's bench and put the microphone to his mouth.

Feng Jianxiong and Yu Meiqin sat across from him lightly, and they didn't provoke, but just looked at him very gentlemanly/ladylike.

Finally, when Du Qiuming finally left, Feng Jianxiong intercepted him in the corridor and handed him a cigar.

"Director Du, we actually have no grudges or grudges. It was Liu Chuandong's old cannon who designed my woman at the beginning, and it has nothing to do with you, I understand. You just took the initiative to send it to the door in business and were cheated by me twice, how can I mind. So, don't have a psychological burden. As long as you don't want to continue to give away heads, I won't stir up trouble. ”

Du Qiuming listened almost to the smoke, but he couldn't refute it.

Feng Jianxiong really doesn't need to hold a grudge against him.

Because from beginning to end, Du Qiuming had no ability to let Feng Jianxiong suffer even a little loss. I also gave a lot of equipment, experience and money.

How can a man hate a monster that gives away a human head?

Seeing that he hadn't come out of adversity yet, Feng Jianxiong could only do his last effort and patted Du Qiuming's shoulder very sincerely:

"Let's look at things from a different perspective. Earthling, you are the first monster I personally killed in seconds after I officially got my lawyer's license. You are actually qualified to be killed by Feng Jianxiong after getting a lawyer's certificate and unlocking the skill of turning a regular, which is enough for you to blow for a lifetime.

In the future, other lawyers who are qualified to unlock this achievement will definitely have a higher status than you, not lower than you-nah, the guy who is lower than you, I will let Sister Meiqin go for seconds, and I won't do it myself. Worse opponents, maybe let Nicole go to the second. ”

Du Qiuming's face turned from red to white, from white to blue, from blue to purple, and finally spurted out a mouthful of old blood.

……

"Unexpectedly...... It's true...... Finally...... Win!"

Yu Meiqin forced Ya'an's self-esteem posture, and when she fled into Feng Jianxiong's car, she let out a long breath and couldn't help crying.

She didn't even sit in the passenger seat as usual, but hugged and sobbed in the back seat with Ma and Sa.

It's a dreamy scenario.

Although the result is already known, the shock of the atmosphere still makes Yu Meiqin feel like a dream.

It's a kind of emptiness, a moment of not knowing where to go.

It's hard to describe in words.

However, if there is a kind of "liver/krypton is an online game for many years, and finally suddenly opens up the ultimate BOSS/achievement, and the realization feels boring" life experience, most of them can understand.

For example, if someone spent a few years in the TBC era of World of Warcraft to become the first in the global sunwell, the flower applause network touted countless times. But after a year and a half, I found that LK was open again, and the achievements of the past and the forced style of brushing no longer have the value of showing off, maybe it will be so enlightened.

As a lawyer, the highest-level opponents that can be killed in a lifetime are nothing more than Apple, Google, Amazon, and at most Microsoft Qualcomm.

Now, following Feng Jianxiong's paddling, Yu Meiqin has achieved the pinnacle of her life of "speaking up" ahead of schedule, what are you doing next? Why is it that the eyes are shining, and I can't find where the next NPC to take over the task is?

Once the sea was difficult to water, and the high places were unbearable.

No one gave Yu Meiqin a task, so she had to find it herself.

Ma and Saben were also very moved and excited. However, she was moved not by herself, but by putting herself in Feng Jianxiong's shoes: Brother Xiong is awesome, a man who can make the impossible possible...... Phew, why is it so unlucky, how can Uncle Mu's Flegg stand up randomly!

Anyway, she was proud of Brother Xiong and cried with joy.

Two girls who don't know why, with different emotions and the same tears, rubbed each other in a little noise.

Caochangmen is not far from Mochou Lake, Feng Jianxiong blocked four red lights, but still arrived within 15 minutes.

Until he parked the car in the garage, the girls in the back seat were still chirping and chatting with each other and gossiping.

Feng Jianxiong chose to understand very intimately, and did not pull out the car key, but just put a genuine light music CD into the car audio and video, and adjusted the volume to soothe it, so that the girls could fully release it, and finally calm down themselves.

Of course, he knows that there are very few people who listen to CDs these days, and it is a complete waste to load CDs on luxury cars.

But when life reaches a certain level, isn't it just to waste something different from others?

When Yu Meiqin's mentality was almost recovered, Feng Jianxiong turned off the volume just right, opened the rear door, and took Yu Meiqin's hand very gentlemanly and helped her out of the car. also patted the girl on the shoulder:

"If you want to rely on eloquence to do chivalrous righteousness, you just made the beginning. Don't take the lawsuit as the whole story, your potential to redress society is far greater than the impact of the courtroom. Follow me to think about how to make good use of this wave of lawsuits and completely blacken Apple's goodwill. If you win the lawsuit, lose the social impact, and you can't get any benefits, I Feng someone will not do it. ”

was persuaded by Feng Jianxiong so step by step, Yu Meiqin suddenly ignited a new target fighting spirit.

"Tell me, what do you want me to do. ”

"First of all, our ban on speaking has been lifted. You immediately go and arrange the debate topic of the next issue of "Wonderful Sayings", and follow what I say. The original sin of Apple's 'damage to the free will of mankind' continues to be hyped.

I'll do a good job on my blog, too. In addition, "Fifteen Years of Interconnection", which I have been serializing last time, is also going to be officially published as a physical book, and I will add a paragraph at the end. While this wave of social influence has not faded, let's kill Old Thief Qiao in one breath - I'm talking about real death, let him die directly from anger to the point that his liver bursts. ”