Chapter 56: If you don't agree with each other, you will go wild
Don't think that there are only old guns in this world, and there are not many cruel words.
In fact, the really awesome debaters are also ruthless and don't talk much.
Feng Jianxiong's performance in this game can be said to be the first time to interpret this model.
The debate on "whether population control is conducive to economic development" is too big and too fragmented.
The process of closing the contradictions, just let the little minions come out. Feng Jianxiong is responsible for the other party's demarcation of the core defensive position, and then run over it head-on - for example, at this moment, the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences team is regarded as the two arguments that "developed countries do not need to use laws to control the population, and the population will not explode" and "aging will inevitably lead to labor shortages".
Dugu Nine Swords, there is no advance or retreat.
Before the moment when the enemy must be saved, there is no need for Dugu Jiujian to make a move.
After hearing Feng Jianxiong's remarks, "The Marriage Law of Britain, the United States, France, Germany, Japan and other countries does not have a mandatory obligation for children to support their parents, so it can prevent malicious parents-to-be from deliberately giving birth." And this point is not in line with China's legal and national conditions, so it cannot be analogized", the first core stronghold that the Academy of Social Sciences is proud of is easily destroyed and collapsed.
Even Su Qin, the host of this game and the main force of the school team of the Academy of Earth Sciences, couldn't help but sigh that its angle was tricky and unpredictable.
Off the field was a crowd of people who were looking through their phones.
A handful of girls of the same grade whispered with admiration: "Feng Jianxiong is so strong, isn't he a freshman like us? Why do you casually talk about the laws of Britain, the United States, Germany, France, and Japan? This guy has a built-in Baidu in his head, right? Does he have a special ability?"
And some of the more knowledgeable and experienced senior seniors next to them scoffed at this point of view: "What is Baidu in your head, and that's what you have to know?
Feng Jianxiong's information must have been studied before the competition. If you want me to say, the real terrible thing about him is that he has this kind of foresight and vision, and the way to solve problems when he encounters them is simply terrifying! To be able to think of looking for evidence from such a tricky angle is much more awesome than memorizing the law. ”
No matter what differences of opinion there are among the audience, everyone's admiration for Feng Jian's eloquence is obvious to all.
It's a pity that today's mobile phones are not touch screen machines, the Internet is very slow, and the WAP is not convenient for checking information, so everyone can't completely prove Feng Jianxiong's awesomeness at the first time.
However, the few judges in the field who came with laptops immediately used CDMA's USB wireless network card Baidu Google, and it took a lot of effort to cooperate before they verified that the law cited by Feng Jianxiong should be correct - they only dared to say that they should, because now Baidu Encyclopedia and Baidu know that they are still in the beta test period, and they will not be officially launched until the next semester.
The people from the Academy of Social Sciences in the audience were still resisting messily, and a girl from the jury in the audience turned her laptop around three or four meters away, facing Su Qin's direction, and nodded slightly at him.
Su Qin understood that this was a classmate telling him that what Feng Jianxiong said was true.
At this time, Liu Ming, the number one main force of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, barely stabilized a point after retreating, and made the last resistance:
"But...... But how dare you conclude that it is because the law does not stipulate the obligation of children to support their parents, so that the indiscriminate birth of people with low education and low social responsibility is curbed?
Occupy...... As far as I know, there seem to be encouraging subsidies for children in Britain and the United States, and there are also poor parents who can't survive by giving birth to children and receiving relief funds to subsidize their families to support themselves. It can be seen that 'people who try to have children for their own profit' have not been curbed by the ban on maintenance obligations!"
Su Qin just came back to his senses, and when he heard this, he reluctantly nodded slightly. This Liu Ming can have this eagerness, and he is worthy of being the main force who can enter the top four teams.
If it weren't for meeting Feng Jianxiong, this Liu Ming should have been able to make a difference.
It's a pity.
"Because of poverty, they want to have more children and get state subsidies, and of course there are such people in developed countries. However, first of all, such an example is very rare, and in terms of proportion, it is definitely much less than that of the domestic top wind fanaticism, at least dozens of times the difference.
Second, since their country encourages childbearing, they believe that the children born belong to the whole society, not to the individual parents. In the future, these children will not be obligated to support their parents, only to pay Ponzi social security, and then evenly distribute the support of all the older generation of citizens who receive social security - that is, no matter how many children you have, you will receive so much pension insurance yourself.
I don't think there's anything wrong with parents having more children and using some of the money they have subsidized to their own lives – in these countries, parents raising more children are equivalent to working as nannies and working for the country's Ponzi social security fund. The money they embezzled themselves was their salary. But they can only earn this money until the child reaches the age of 18, and they will not get more in return. And the vicious superbirth gap between developed countries and ours is dozens of times that is maintained by this legal guarantee. ”
Feng Jianxiong said this, and Liu Ming was completely speechless about this point and gave up treatment.
From Feng Jianxiong's position, in fact, he does not oppose the country's policy in 05, nor does he oppose the policy that has been relaxed more than ten years later. With so many years of experience, how could he not see this problem clearly?
In later generations, the only problem he was worried about was that after the country was completely liberalized, the ideology did not keep up, allowing people with malicious intentions to take advantage of the loopholes.
After Liu Ming was dumbfounded, Feng Jianxiong made a summary of this point appropriately:
"The reason why Western countries legislate in this way is based on the most fundamental legal principle is the social contract theory - only the contractual behavior negotiated by the two parties can be attached to the rights and obligations of both parties. Any unilateral act should not impose obligations on the other party.
For example, the act of giving is a unilateral act, and the person who gave it says that it has been given, and the act is over. Therefore, the gift must be selfless and cannot be attached, and if it is attached, it becomes a contractual act. Even if it is a "bequest and maintenance agreement", in fact, it cannot be regarded as a real "gift".
When the parents give birth to the child, the child is innocent, and he does not have any right to choose whether he wants to come into this world or not - so the act of giving birth must be accompanied by the obligation of support, and the child must not be expected to return at the legal level. When you make this decision, you have to have in your mind that children are not your private property, and you must be able to bear this responsibility and give birth again. ”
"The law should also be integrated into the essence of the virtues of traditional culture, if ****, without considering Chinese characteristics, then what kind of system will it be!" Liu Ming can still make a final resistance to this summary.
Feng Jianxiong smiled and said: "Really, why don't you go back to the time when the Qing Dynasty was not dead? At that time, the Shen family's "Draft Daqing Criminal Law" also required the prime minister to be hidden, and asked for the punishment to be reduced and the punishment to be increased for the inferior, according to that set of laws, Lao Tzu does not have to pay for his life when he kills his son, and it is possible for his son to pay for his life if he injures Lao Tzu - that must be very in line with the prosperous era of the rule of law that you expect, Liu classmate. ”
Naturally, these words attracted a lot of laughter.
And Feng Jianxiong seemed to be inspired by laughter, and added: "Oh, it seems that it is not enough to go back to the era of the "Daqing Criminal Law Draft". I think the most appropriate for your values would be to go back 3,700 years and return to the plains of Mesopotamia—
Because the Code of Hammurabi stipulates that after a noble man kills a noble woman, he does not have to pay for his life, but should kill one of the unmarried daughters of the noble man.
You see, how good is such a world for you? The daughter is not seen as a human being in the Code of Hammurabi at all, but only as her father's property. Her father killed another woman, but only violated 'the other father's right to own his daughter's property', so he had to kill his own daughter to pay for his life.
Such a worldview of a daughter paying for her father's life must be the most in line with your filial piety. And I can tell you the good news that if you go back in time to the time of Hammurabi and kill not a noble woman, but a commoner woman or even a slave girl, then you don't have to pay for your daughter's life—you only need to pay 20 shekels of silver to the husband or master of the deceased. ”
The lethality of these few sentences is particularly staggering.
The beauties of the normal university are like clouds, and the audience here today, female students account for eighty percent.
Feng Jianxiong easily stirred up the hearts of the girls who hated the same enemy.
"It turns out that Liu Ming's heart is so dark and despicable! No, he can't let him win! The so-called filial piety and patriarchy, the oppression of men is relatively small, and it is the worst for us girls. How can you let this kind of person who turns back the clock on history win!"
"Shameless! despicable! Obscene! On the surface, he talks about filial piety, but in fact, in his bones, he wants men to be inferior to women and play with women!"
"It's still classmate Feng who insists on understanding girls, and he really wants to be his confidante. ”
Countless groups of girls began to lower their voices and insult the team of the Academy of Social Sciences, although everyone knew that they could not speak too loudly, but the voices of hundreds of people in the auditorium were gathered in unison, it was terrifying.
Liu Ming, Chen Xin, and even the other two members of the Academy of Social Sciences were dumbfounded when they saw this.
What about "no judges, no debate"? What about the competition strategy that only cares about the opinions of the professional judges and ignorant crowds?
How can the crowd be stirred up lightly without saying a word!
If it was in private at this moment, Liu Ming would properly yell hoarsely: "Hey, don't you want to be so shameless! Obviously a debater, how can you be willing to degenerate into the Führer and Xiao Huang!"
Feng Jianxiong shrugged helplessly, and he didn't mean to press the crowd back, as if to say: "I didn't mean it, who let my brother understand everything, understand a little." ”
He shrugged his shoulders to show that he "understood a little", and involuntarily had the style of Zhuge Liang played by Jin Chengwu in the blockbuster "Red Cliff".