Chapter 40: The Establishment of Judgments Should Not Be Superstitions of Mankind
The moment I found out about this situation, I could remember a lot of things, such as Minister Iizuka's promise at the beginning, such as the confident expression of Kitahara-senpai, such as the way Yui-san jumped up and down when she was trying to help, and even the somewhat hesitant expression when Kogi-senpai gently twisted his hair to indicate that he could replace Yanagihara.
If I want to say whether I care about it or not, for me, the importance of the light music club is far behind the ministry department, so it is not too important for me whether or not the program of the light music club can be performed on the stage of the school festival at this point, as I have said, even if I really regret the affairs of the light music club, it is also a regret for the failure of Minister Iizuka's plan to make a grand farewell in the last year of high school, who had taken care of me a lot before。
The problem, however, is that my principles are reflected in the Light Music Club. Even an insensitive person like Yui-san could notice that the Light Music Club was in crisis, so she approached me with the idea of helping, but I refused, and the reason I refused was because I believed in people's rational decisions.
First of all, we need to make a clear conclusion, that is, for everyone involved in this matter, their unanimous conclusion is that the light music club will be able to participate in the performance of the school festival, which is the best result that our reason desires. Then, different people will definitely have different conclusions about the way to achieve this result, and what leads us to disagreement is the difference in the way to achieve this result.
From the point of view of the principle of absolute neutrality, the arrogance brought about by one's talent can lead to recklessness in dealing with problems, and only by putting oneself in the shoes of a person who is inside the light music club can he grasp the situation of the light music club to the greatest extent and make the final choice according to this situation. And this choice is likely to be contrary to the perception of others. Therefore, as long as it is determined that Takeya Iizuka and Haruki Kitahara are rational people, then we have reason to believe that everything they do is working towards that ultimate goal, so the situation that seems dangerous to others may be a step in the middle of the best way to achieve this goal that they need to achieve under their rational judgment. The unauthorized interference of others is likely to cause the bankruptcy of the atmosphere they have created and the failure of the next plan.
This is also the practical application of the principle of absolute neutrality, because you trust the optimal decision of the other person, so that you do not expect too much from the seemingly rational decisions you make based on limited materials, and watch things go in a neutral way without the other party asking for help – even if you feel that things are not going as well as you want.
If everything goes the way it goes, then the end result will be the best – or at least the closest to the best. However, on the secondary list submitted by the Minister of the city, there is still no shadow of the Light Music Club, and this result cannot be regarded as a state close to the best result.
Then the insistence on absolute neutrality, and all the ideas it upholds, is meaningless.
Yes, the persistence of an existing logical concept is so fragile that when you believe in the correctness of the results of this logic, but then you find a phenomenon that is difficult to explain according to this logic, you have only two methods, either to further improve this logic, or to abandon this logic. But when this logic is a self-consistent pattern, it will collapse on its own as long as it cannot be proven.
On the issue of the Light Music Club,Several assumptions,The people inside the Light Music Club have more information than we do,This premise is certainly not wrong,The final purpose is to let the club participate in the school festival performance is not wrong,For this goal,People will definitely tend to make the optimal decisionThis cannot be confirmed,But it is certain that even if the optimal decision is not made,People will tend to make a better decision-making model。
Therefore, the flaw in this assertion lies in the fact that the human beings themselves, I tend to think that the two subjects in this decision-making process, Takeya Iizuka and Haruki Kitahara, are rational people, or, at least, Kitahara's predecessors, who have the most confidence in this matter, should be rational people. But if they are not, then this logic is broken.
So, a terrible problem can be a stumbling block to the logic of absolute neutrality, and that is that there is an irrational side to human beings.
---------------------------- dividing line---------------------------------
"Uh, Yubihama-senpai?Yubihama-sen?" A somewhat embarrassed voice woke me up from my thoughts, and Minister Kimura's somewhat worried expression appeared in front of me.
"Ah, sorry, I was a little distracted. "In this way, I really should change this state of wandering as soon as I enter my own contemplation mode, which often happened in front of Xiao Mu Shu's predecessors before, and now I also encounter this situation at work, so it is really a little undesirable.
"So, senior, you don't have any problems, right?" President Kimura said with some hesitation, "Your face is very ugly now! So do you have any questions about this list? Well, we have never changed this list since we got it, except for the programs marked on it that we think may be better, we have not taken the initiative to revise it in other aspects!"
Anyway, for this Kimura president who has been working with Koharu before.,But I haven't paid attention to it.,My perception is getting better and better.,As long as it's not for Koharu's things to embarrass me.,It's still a soft girl who understands and understands other people very well!
However, after President Kimura reminded me, I noticed that my current face was really a little unsightly, not only because of my complexion, but in fact, I could clearly feel that the school uniform behind my back had been soaked with my sweat.
Is it just because of this crisis of principles that I have so much nervousness?
"Well, thank you for your concern, I was just a little surprised by some of the situations on this list-"
If you feel that something is not right on our side, then it must be the problem of the aspect you are worried about, not our side. And my words were interrupted by Koharu somewhat mercilessly. After the last conversation, she knew about the light music club, so what she said now was obviously to let me confirm this after noticing this.
However, this guy, now that the negotiations are over, can't you talk to me in a more pleasant way? I can't change the way I make decisions under the snow, but don't learn the unpleasant way of dealing with people under the snow! That will make you friendless, Koharu-chan.
"I see, thank you Secretary Sugiura for your explanation. ”
"Well, then Yubihama-senpai doesn't have any other problems, right?" Koharu added in a somewhat hurried tone.
"Well, it's true that there is no problem, but the way you speak feels very problematic, what do you mean that there are no other problems, right?"
"I routinely raised this question when I knew that my predecessors had no problems, so please don't pay too much attention to the expression of the problem!"
"Even if it's a routine, you can't lose etiquette, if you want to come to Zongwu Gao in the future, you still have to pay attention to this kind of detail. ”
"I'll understand, by-than-hama-senior!" Koharu gritted his teeth and spat out my name, but the feeling made me a little happy, at least I felt a feeling in Sugiura Koharu's body that belonged to her, not a stiff imitation machine under the snow.
"Isn't that right, that's what you look like!" I smiled softly and said, "Look at that girl who is full of snow style just now, do you really think that kind of girl is very attractive?"
"Not necessarily, a lot of boys probably just like that type!"
"Well, I'm not anyway, for a girl with that kind of personality, I just feel very troublesome!"
"Anyway, I didn't make this look for you, so what do you think the trouble has to do with me?"
For the first time in a long time, Koharu and I had this routine conversation, but just as we were both a little immersed in the atmosphere, President Kimura's voice came
"Uh, two-" President Kimura's face was very strange, as if he didn't want to disturb the two of them, but felt that our approach was a little inappropriate. However, even this vague statement is enough to sober up the two of us.
It is true that the feeling of bickering just now is very nostalgic, but the existence that has disappeared can only be the existence that has disappeared, and the recurrence of this situation should not be regarded as a normal phenomenon.
"Well, I really didn't realize that the relationship between the two of you is still so good, sorry. President Kimura said helplessly, "But, if I could, I still think this place is not so suitable for talking about these more personal things!"
Not only Chairman Kimura, but Vice President Sonoda, who had been a "pioneer in protecting Koharu", also showed a look of surprise, and this expression was obviously a puzzled look of "Did my previous practices make my predecessors annoyed?"
"I'm sorry, Minami, it was my problem before. Koharu's voice recovered from the somewhat annoyed state just now, "I shouldn't have been provoked by that person." ”
"Uh, Koharu, you don't have to be so serious, if I had known about this situation-"
"-No, Minami, it's not what you think," Koharu said with a complicated sad look on his face, "At least you understood this correctly at first, and I have nothing to do with him anymore." ”
I don't know what kind of mentality Koharu Sugiura had when she said such things in front of everyone, and even in my presence, I just couldn't understand why she was in a hurry to prove these words, even if she didn't care about my feelings that much, but it wasn't exaggerated to that extent, right?
"Uh, that's it—" Kimura-chan looked at me worriedly, and then at Koharu.
I also believe that only now thanks to the influence of Kazuya Yubihama can I make further changes and become the kind of person I want to become. Koharu interrupted President Kimura's words and said firmly.
Is that what it means to be the person you want to be? Is that what it means to eliminate my influence and become something like that under the snow?
But don't fool yourself, if you think carefully about the opportunity to become the kind of person you are under the snow, then you will realize how powerless your words are now.
But I couldn't say that, because I could see the stubbornness, the stubbornness, in her eyes, exactly the same look of unyielding when I first met her, an expression desperately trying to prove something. With this expression, I knew that although he looked like he had changed a lot, Sugiura Koharu was still the same Sugiura Koharu when I first met.
So, I looked at Chairman Kimura and echoed Koharu's words: "That's right, Chairman Kimura, what Koharu said is not wrong, at least for the two of us, we should let go." Of course, I understand the unfriendliness that you and Vice President Sonoda have expressed to me, but it may be better for us to look forward. ”
"Well, if Hihama-senpai said that—" Kimura-chan nodded blankly, apparently still unsure of the current situation.
However, it didn't matter to me anymore, and I just turned around and walked out the door of the student council room.
Actually, I'm looking forward to it, Koharu Sugiura, if you really think that this is the true idea of your heart, then you can do it and prove it to me!
If absolute neutrality can be bankrupt because of human irrationality, then prove to me the possibility of success because of the choices made by emotion!