"We can imagine that in those days, Dumbledore and Grindelwald studied magic and talked about ideals together, each feeling that the other was the one in their destiny, and they even sneaked out to adventure around the world to the magical relics of ancient times. "Earlier, when Sirius and I sent out the secret treasure keys to find the giants and Ravenclaw, Dumbledore told me about the fact that he had been to Sicily with Grindelwald. Under the circumstances, this kind of risk-taking behavior was very reckless for Dumbledore, and given Ariana's physical condition, even if Dumbledore had not been away for a long time, it was very inappropriate. But Dumbledore ignored Ariana because of Grindelwald, and Grindelwald probably thought Ariana was a liability, we all know that Grindelwald was never a good person, he was a complete dark wizard, and when he was a student, he did a lot of research on the dark arts that ordinary people could not imagine. He could have imagined his attitude towards Ariana, who was holding him and Dumbledore back, or perhaps wished she had died sooner. However, Ariana's condition at that time was inseparable from human care, and she could not even be stimulated by any kind, and in this case, her physical condition would definitely get worse and worse. ”

"Didn't Dumbledore know what you said at the time?" asked Harry after a moment's thought.

"I think he didn't know, or knew but ignored, that Dumbledore's mind at the time was all about how to achieve his and Grindelwald's great ideals for the greater good, and neglected his sister, which was the thing he regretted the most in his later life. "Actually, I suspect that Dumbledore didn't know much about Ariana's condition at the time, and he probably didn't know about the Silent Ones, but simply thought that Ariana was magically out of control......"

"If you've read Mr. Newt Scamander's biography, yes, Mr. Scamander, the author of Where the Fantastic Creatures Are Located, he helped Hagrid and us a lot in Buckbeak, and if you read his biography, Harry, you'll find a very interesting description. Evan continued, "As a magical zoologist, young Mr. Scamander once followed the ancient wizarding tradition of a trip around the world focused on studying and rescuing magical beasts, and his first stop was the United States, when Dumbledore returned to Hogwarts and Grindelwald was rapidly rising, and Mr. Scamander met Grindelwald while traveling in the United States. In fact, I think Scamander was able to choose to go to the United States, and Dumbledore played a big part in that. ”

"Where are they going, what?" Harry couldn't keep up with Aven's leaping mind, he was still talking about Ariana just now, and now he was discussing Newt Scamander's adventures in the United States, but he had to admit that Harry was interested in these shocking things.

"Grindelwald was expanding his power, he was already strong, but not enough to conquer the world, at least, he was not completely sure of defeating his old friend Dumbledore, and he did not find all three Deathly Hallows, so Grindelwald began to hope for other powers. "I think he must have seen Ariana's magical riot and even the silent awakening in her body, and was impressed." How could a wizard like Grindelwald ignore such unimaginable power, he had studied it and discovered the secrets of the Silent One. He must have gotten the news that he wanted to find a new Silent One, and Dumbledore was there to stop him. ”

"Of course, with the help of Mr. Scamander, Dumbledore finally succeeded in stopping Grindelwald, they fought all the way back to Europe from the United States, and finally had that amazing duel in Numengard, you can ask Mr. Scamander in person, I think you can also visit him, after all, Grindelwald occupies an extremely important place in Dumbledore's life, and if you want to understand Dumbledore, you can't bypass this dark wizard in any way. "If necessary, we can even go to Newmengard to meet Grindelwald himself, who has been imprisoned there since his defeat in the duel." ”

"The Dark Wizard is still alive?" said Harry, surprised.

"Dumbledore just defeated him, not killed him, the two of them had a good relationship, more than expected, Rita Skeeter was right, but it doesn't mean that if you have a good personal relationship, you won't be enemies, especially for wizards of Grindelwald and Dumbledore's status, ideas may be more important to them. Evan explained, "Alright, Harry, let's turn the conversation back to Ariana, we just said that Grindelwald went to the United States to find the Silent One because he witnessed the power that erupted when Ariana silently awakened in his body, and the reason for Ariana's magical riot was because Dumbledore's younger brother Aberforth found that Dumbledore had not taken care of Ariana when he came home from vacation at Hogwarts, and he and Dumbledore had a heated argument. Well, if there are no accidents, the quarrel that Aunt Muriel's family told us about yesterday is a follow-up to this quarrel. In short, they had a very strong quarrel that time, and Grindelwald was also involved, and finally they should have made a move, and Ariana next to her was stimulated, and the silence in her body awakened, and in that chaos, the magic of Dumbledore, Grindelwald or Aberforth hit Ariana, or because the magic riot was too strong for Ariana's body to bear, in short, she died. ”

Harry didn't speak, didn't ask questions, and for a moment seemed to have a hard time accepting what Evan said.

"Grindelwald thinks he killed Ariana, so he runs away after that argument!, and Dumbledore because he killed Ariana, and since then he has changed a lot, and he no longer has the same thoughts as before, but gradually becomes the professor we know. "Alright, Harry, these are the stories of Ariana, and we can blame Dumbledore for the mistakes he made in the process, but everyone makes mistakes, and Dumbledore is no exception, and the important thing is what we do after we make mistakes." We all know what kind of person Dumbledore was, and the slander of Rita Skeeter and Aunt Muriel has no credibility. ”