"Mr. Hu, I noticed that you quoted some historical materials from Zeng's oral history. In my research, I found that a large part of Tsang's oral history was not personally dictated by Tsang Zhongtang at that time, but by the children and grandchildren of Zeng Zhongtang. Therefore, in fact, this historical material, to a greater extent, can only be used as a study of Zeng's family history, is it too child's to use this historical material to demonstrate Gong's situation? Because Zeng Zhongtang doesn't know Gong very well, Gong is more than 30 years older than Zeng Zhongtang, and the two basically don't have much intersection, when Zeng Zhongtang came out, Gong had already passed away, so for many things about Gong, I'm afraid Zeng Zhongtang is just hearsay, and it is also said in Zeng's oral history that these things are not necessarily accurate. ”

What this teacher said was quite euphemistic, and he didn't directly say that Mr. Hu used wild history to argue that history was already very face-saving.

And this teacher Hu also nodded, and then responded: "That's the case, why do we often say that studying modern history is a very difficult thing?" Because modern history is different from the more ancient Qin and Han dynasties, there are fewer historical materials handed down at that time, so many times, we can only take and believe in written historical materials, but there are too many materials in modern history, about one thing, there are many kinds of sayings, it can be said that the public says that the public is reasonable, and the reason why I quote Zeng's oral history is because, at least in these wild histories, Zeng's family style and academic attitude are more credible, and there are several historical materials in which the descriptions coincide with his descriptions. At that time, Zeng Zhongtang was an official to Zhongtang, and Gong's family ancestral hall was under Zeng Zhongtang's rule, and many of Gong's descendants were still under Zeng Zhongtang's direct management at that time, and Zeng Zhongtang may also have a certain degree of persuasion. ”

This answer is relatively perfect, and Ye Xing also nodded.

At this time, another teacher raised his hand.

"Mr. Hu, what you said is very reasonable, but in my research, I have obtained some materials, Gong was sentenced to a serious crime, according to the law at that time, how can he be called revenge? Violating the law and being punished, even if it is a strict law, it can hardly be called hatred. ”

At the same time, the teacher also opened his mouth and said the name of the material he saw.

"I saw in the Ming Wei record that this Li Mingwei was the servant of the Criminal Department at that time, and he was in charge of the Gong family's case, when a son of the Gong family bullied the good and was investigated and punished, on this ground, the emperor at that time ordered the investigation and punishment of the Gong family, but then it was found out that the Gong family had exploited the people with usury in the past few decades, and at the same time took over the lawsuit, and the lives of the people were involved, and several rooms in the family were involved, so how can it be regarded as an action of revenge? Even if he once protected some of the people when he entered the capital, how much damage was caused to the people by the war at that time, and the subsequent reparations made the people miserable, where is there any need for such a person to overturn the case?"

It was already a little unkind for him to say this, and the teacher Hu on the other side frowned slightly, he naturally knew that his research was a bit far-fetched, but now that he is doing research, if he can't do it eye-catching, how can he get more topics.

Although he is a professor and a teacher, he also needs to eat, if he is more famous, it is relatively easier to get the topic, so he did such a research on the category of overturning, such research is not less in the academic world, more often, everyone is silently published, at the same time, there are also some scholars will argue about this research, which is an unwritten unspoken rule in the academic world.

"I have also seen the record of the Ming Wei record, although this Mr. Li Mingwei is a servant of the criminal department, but not long after the investigation of the Gong family, he was also dismissed for corruption, and many records have said that his official reputation and private morality are not good, so the authenticity of the Ming Wei record needs to be verified, in addition, don't you think that this Gong family's crime is more familiar? At that time, it was after the transfer of power, the new emperor was in power for a short time, Gong was a supporter of the old emperor, the new emperor wanted to hold power in his hands, and naturally needed to deal with some of the old magnates, and similar crimes of the same era also happened in many families.

This answer is witty, but it is not too convincing, because Zeng Zhongtang's official reputation and character are good, and the oral history of his descendants can be trusted, while Li Mingwei once had the problem of corruption, his account cannot be trusted? This is not an objective attitude towards scholarship.

Many teachers around frowned, Professor Hu's article, there would not have been so many scholars to refute it, but he should not have come out at this time, to take out this research, this is to let all the scholars present endorse him.

If it is not refuted in this seminar, then he can take this research everywhere to publicize it, and it can be said that his research has been tested by this mathematical seminar.

But you must know that there are several academic leaders present, not to mention anything else, if he goes out and says that this article has been read by Mr. Jin Qizhang, I am afraid that it will become a new truth in the academic world, and his article on reversing the case can be regarded as truly completed.

This is something that many of the veteran scholars present do not want to see.

Mr. Jin Qizhang and Mr. Zhan both frowned, do today's scholars have such an attitude towards learning?

Seeing that the discussion was becoming more and more intense, the teacher in charge of the host immediately came out of the backstage and said: "Teachers, Mr. Hu's time has come, and there are still a few teachers behind us who need to show their academic achievements, so if there is anything else you want to communicate, wait until the afternoon exchange session, and then communicate." ”

Several teachers naturally nodded and didn't say anything anymore, and Mr. Hu also breathed a sigh of relief, and his heart was also slightly happy, if this matter passed like this, he would have a reason to say outside that his research had been verified by this academic seminar.

He could almost imagine that after this incident was over, his status in the academic world would be raised to a new level.

The research of the scholars who made the next remarks was decent, and there were many students whose research, although they were still a little immature, but there were not too many problems.

Until the last student's research appeared.

(End of chapter)