Gao Yuan's expression made Yang Minghai feel a little uncomfortable, and he asked Gao Yuan in a low voice, "How is it? Is it true?"

Gao Yuan looked at Xia Qing, who was sitting in front of him, and said to Yang Minghai: "I have never known or cared about her income, so I don't know if this thing is real or fake." ”

Yang Minghai said: "Alas, we can't provide evidence, so we have to let it go." ”

Gao Yuan said disappointedly: "You can do it." ”

Yang Minghai cleared his throat and said, "We can't confirm the authenticity of the plaintiff's income certificate, so please ask the presiding judge to make a clear decision." ”

Li Ming said: "In accordance with Articles 1 and 2 of the Several Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Evidence in Civil Proceedings, since the defendant was unable to provide evidence to prove that the plaintiff's income certificate was inconsistent with the facts, after careful verification by the adjudication party, it is now determined that the income certificate is true and valid, and it is accepted." It is up to the two sides to debate each other. ”

Yang Minghai suddenly interrupted Li Ming's words, "Presiding Judge, before we debate with each other, I have a few questions to ask the plaintiff, Ms. Xia Qing. ”

Li Ming and Gao Yihu discussed in a low voice for a while. Li Ming said: "I agree with the defendant's agent to ask the plaintiff questions. ”

Yang Minghai said to Xia Qing: "Ms. Xia Qing, I have a few questions I want to ask you. First, have you ever thought about why your husband Gao Yuan cheated?"

Xia Qing was stunned, she really couldn't understand why Yang Minghai asked this question, this question didn't seem to play much role in Gao Yuan's recovery. At the same time, Xia Qing didn't know how to answer, worried that she would accidentally say the wrong thing and give someone a handle, so she glanced at Wang Yuhe for help. Wang Yuhe whispered: "Answer truthfully, it's okay." ”

Xia Qing met Yang Minghai's aggressive gaze, "Why don't you ask Gao Yuan this question? He should know better than me." ”

Yang Minghai sneered, thinking that Xia Qing was really smart, and it was not easy to deal with. He said, "I'm asking you now, please don't interrupt." ”

Xia Qing conveyed an inquiring look to the presiding judge, Li Ming, who nodded at her, "Please answer truthfully." ”

Xia Qing said helplessly: "I think it should be due to his personality, or he thinks I'm no longer attractive." ”

Yang Minghai smiled proudly, "You are avoiding the important and light, have you ever done anything to be sorry for him?"

Yang Minghai's sharp question made Xia Qing a little nervous, Xia Qing's gaze quickly swept over Gao Yuan's face, unexpectedly, Gao Yuan looked at Xia Qing very calmly at this time, waiting for her next step. Xia Qing calmly met Yang Minghai's gaze, "I haven't done anything to be sorry for him." ”

Yang Minghai smiled, his smile made Xia Qing creepy, and he didn't know what kind of medicine was in Yang Minghai's gourd. Yang Minghai's words also made Wang Yuhe uneasy, but he was well-informed, and he could think that this might just be a trick played by Yang Minghai, so don't fall for him.

Xia Qing looked at Yang Minghai and nodded slightly. Xia Qing was not fooled, Yang Minghai's wishful thinking failed, and he felt a little disappointed.

Yang Minghai continued to attack Xia Qing, he said: "Ms. Xia Qing, you have not returned to the dormitory for several nights in a row, who did you spend the night with that night?"

Xia Qing looked at Gao Yuan in surprise, he didn't expect that Gao Yuan had never forgotten about it, and he also told Yang Minghai about it, it was Gao Yuan and Liu Xiaolan who were bumped into by her that night, and now they are using it to make a fuss and harm her, it seems that Gao is really despicable enough.

Xia Qing replied cautiously: "It was the day of my birthday, Gao Yuan made an appointment with me to have dinner to celebrate my birthday, but he didn't show up, and I didn't answer his phone, so I went to his company to find him, I didn't expect to meet him downstairs and Liu Xiaolan of his company is his lover who is intimate, I didn't go home in a fit of anger, so I went to a hotel to open a room to live." This matter is very clear. Xia Qing said as she spoke, tears were about to flow out, and Gao Yuan's move made her completely chill.

Everyone present was very surprised, and they all felt that Gao Yuan was a back-and-forth rake, and he was too unkind.

Seeing everyone's disdainful glances at Gao Yuan, Yang Minghai immediately said: "Gao Yuan admits that there is such a thing, but, Ms. Xia Qing, if you open a house and live outside for a few days, must you be innocent?"

Xia Qing was a little angry, she was a little out of control, her volume raised an octave, "The surname is Yang, what do you mean? Do you have a little right and wrong? Do you still have at least some integrity in life? You know that it is Gao Yuan's fault, but you blame me with his mistake, do you have professional ethics?"

After Xia Qing finished speaking, he covered his face and cried, Wang Yuhe couldn't sit still anymore, he stood up and said to the judge and his party: "Judge, I oppose the vexatious behavior of the defendant's lawyer, he has repeatedly used some groundless things in the court to play on the topic, and the case has no substantive effect, which is obviously a waste of our precious time, I request that Yang Minghai's lawyer's qualification be revoked!"

Li Ming and the three exchanged opinions, and Li Ming said, "Lawyer Yang, is there any factual basis for your question about Xia Qing? If not, please ask other questions." ”

Yang Minghai thinks that Xia Qing's insistence on divorce is not as simple as Gao Yuan's cheating, is she also cheating? This may be a breakthrough. Yang Minghai said to Li Ming: "Presiding judge, I hope this issue will continue, because it is related to the question of whether the plaintiff Xia Qing is loyal to my client, which is quite closely related to this case." ”

Wang Yuhe said: "This issue has nothing to do with this case, what we want to discuss is whether the relationship between the plaintiff and the defendant has broken down. ”

Yang Minghai said: "Wrong, this issue is precisely related to this case, and I ask the presiding judge to make a clear decision." ”

Just when everyone was in a stalemate and the presiding judge was also in a dilemma, Xia Qing suddenly stood up and said, "Why don't you ask Gao Yuan why he cheated? ”

Yang Minghai was unrelentingly entangled, Wang Yuhe came out to relieve the siege, he said: "Lawyer Yang, yes, you should ask Mr. Gao Yuan, but how can you guarantee that what your client Gao Yuan said is true?"

Wang Yuhe's words caused an uproar, everyone began to discuss, and they all looked at Gao Yuan, Gao Yuan once again became the focus of attention, and Gao Yuan glared at Wang Yuhe very dissatisfied. Wang Yuhe's words are indeed very lethal. Yang Minghai and Wang Yuhe confronted each other unfriendly, the atmosphere became tense, and there seemed to be a bit of gunpowder in the air.

Just when the tension was tense, Li Ming knocked on the gavel and said, "Time is limited, let's not spend too much time on this issue." The next question is asked for the defendant's representative. ”