I don't care about the whispered comments of everyone's doubts.

Zhang Ye was calm and calm, and said: "Zhou Yu is a very loyal and heroic figure, when he was twenty-four years old, he was appointed by Sun Ce as the general of Jianwei Zhonglang, and began to make contributions, and it was in this year that Sun Ce, who was the same age as him, married the beauties of the time, Da Qiao and Xiao Qiao, it can be said that Zhou Yu is a young man, proud of the spring breeze, he is beautiful, and things are also done beautifully. At that time, the people in Wuzhong called Sun Ce Sun Lang and Zhou Yu Zhou Lang, which translates to JJ handsome guy,...... and 'Zhou Handsome Guy,. ”

What?

Handsome guy?

Xiao Lu and Xiao Fang popped

Many female viewers couldn't help but be happy

Is this talking about the Three Kingdoms? How can there be a modern language?

"So you want to ......" Zhang Ye looked at everyone and said: "Zhou Yu became a general in Jianwei when he was twenty years old, and married the most beautiful beauty at that time to be his wife, which can be described as a battlefield officialdom and love field, how could he be jealous of others?" Others are jealous of him."

Crushes?

Are the cuties out?

Many people almost fainted, and many people smiled

"In fact, Zhou Yu in history has a lot of energy." Zhang Ye said: "Chen Shou once said that he was temperamental, and his contemporaries also spoke highly of him, Liu Bei's evaluation of him was quite large, and Jiang Yu's evaluation of him was elegant and elegant, so it was wronged to say that Zhou Yu was a villain with a narrow temperament" Ma Hengyuan just said that Zhou Yu was a person with a small belly and chicken intestines in the program that was abolished just now, but Zhang Ye refuted it for him, and there was reason and evidence, citing scriptures, and the true colors of slapping professional households in the face were unobstructed

The audience will be skeptical.

Ma Heng Yuanxin said that you are talking nonsense

The two guests surnamed Xu also did not agree with Zhang Ye's views at all

Zhang Ye smiled: "Some people may disagree, but I can say for sure that romance novels are not history, why is Zhou Yu's image so far away from the image in our impression?" Why are we both familiar and unfamiliar with the history of the Three Kingdoms? There are three reasons for this, because there are three images in the history of the Three Kingdoms, the first is the image recorded in the history books, mainly the image recorded in the official history, which is the image advocated by historians, and this image I call the 'historical image,' and it should be explained here that the historical image is not equal to the historical truth, because the historical record is not necessarily reliable, the second is the image in literary and artistic works, which I call the literary image, and the third chapter is folklore and belief, which I call the folk image. ”

Everyone listened and thought at the same time.

"In this way, in fact, it can explain that Zhou Yu's image is completely different from our impression, because everyone will have their own impression and evaluation of this person in their hearts, once this image is formed, some people can't accept other images, what you say is different from what he thinks, he will say that you are wrong, you are wrong, so we go to watch a historical drama, there will always be viewers who comment below and say, 'Oh, this Zhou Yu is not like him," Zhang Ye looked at Ma Hengyuan and the others with disdain, and said, "Oh, this Zhou Yu doesn't look like it?" That really Zhou Yu...... Have you seen it? ”

The audience laughed again, "Hehehehehe." ”

Hu Fei is also happy, this Xiao Zhang

Ma Hengyuan was so angry that his beard was crooked, but he couldn't refute it

"So history is not a novel, nor is it a literary work that is a character who is born out of righteousness." Zhang Ye said: "Another example is Zhuge Liang, when it comes to Zhuge Liang, everyone will be the first to think of the empty city plan, and when it comes to the empty city plan, it will show Zhuge Liang's military talent, and these are actually portrayed and shaped in the novel, of course, there is a reason in it, not for no reason, in modern times, there is a person named Guo Chong, this Guo Chong, probably a die-hard fan of Zhuge Liang." ”

Die-hard fans?

The audience wants to have fun when they listen to it.

Zhang Ye was extremely serious, "So he wrote a book "The Five Things of Tiao Liang Hidden from the World", announcing five things that Zhuge Liang did not know, the third of which is the empty city plan, so the empty city plan was not made up by Luo Guanzhong, but has this origin, but we all know that the words of hardcore fans are often unreliable, I can clearly tell you that Zhuge Liang in history is an outstanding politician, but his military talent is far inferior, he is not a military genius at all, and the empty city plan" Zhang Ye easily said an astonishing sentence, "It doesn't exist at all"

What the?

The empty city meter does not exist? It's all made up?

Ma Hengyuan was angry at that time, "What nonsense are you talking about"

"How could it not exist? Isn't this nonsense?" Mr. Xu was angry

Hu Fei and Xiaolu were also dumbfounded, and the audience didn't believe it, after all, many things were already ingrained in their consciousness

Zhang Ye said without hesitation: "Many people question this, this is what I said about the status of the folk image in the hearts of the people, but I still say that history, history is not a novel, and the one who refuted it just now was Professor Ma Hengyuan Ma, right?" The camera brother immediately hit Ma Hengyuan, "You are engaged in literary research, research is literary works, the study of "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", I think there are few people in China who can compare to you, but this is not history, this is just a literary work adapted from history, if someone still does not believe it and does not agree with my point of view, then I only want to ask two questions, Guo Chong said that Sima Yi led troops to fight Yangping, Zhuge Liang had no soldiers in his hands at that time, so he used an empty city plan Sima Yi withdrew from the army, right? ”

"yes."

"Isn't it?"

"What's wrong with that?"

The audience all replied with a few words.

Zhang Ye chuckled, "Then my first question comes, according to historical records and research, at that time, Sima Yi was the governor of Jingzhou and stationed in Jiewan City, he was not in the Yangping battlefield at that time, since this person has not been to this place, how could this matter happen?" ”

"Huh?"

"This ......"

"Really?"

The audience is unknown.

Ma Hengyuan and Mr. Xu looked at each other, and they couldn't understand that they were not scholars who studied history after all, so they couldn't refute it

Zhang Ye continued: "The second question, Sima Yi's soldiers pressed the border, Zhuge Liang was in a hurry, opened the city gate, sent some veterans to sweep the floor at the door, and took two boys to sit on the city tower and sing karaoke. ”

"Poof"

"Karaoke?"

"Ha Lu Ha"

Several of the audience members leaned back and forth.

Zhang Ye said: "How did he sing in the play? I was watching the mountain scenery from the city tower, and I heard the chaos outside the city, and then he sang Ma Jian under the useless, and they were handsome and discordant, and you Sima Yi was insatiable and came to beat me again? You can fight, I am ready, I have swept the streets, set up the wine, and are ready to treat your three armies, since you are here, you will come into the city, come, come, come, come to the city, listen to me play the qin. ”

Everyone laughed again, thinking that Zhuge Liang in Zhang Ye's romance was a little too obscene

Zhang Ye blinked and said, "Sima Yi has already come to the city at this time, raised his head and smacked his lips, and said in his heart...... What do you mean by this dude? Invite me upstairs to karaoke with you? Oh, I'm up to Kara, you're OK me? I'm not going to be fooled by this, withdraw."

Everyone laughed even louder

Zhang Ye also hooked the corners of his mouth, "My second question is that this matter is not logical at all, why don't Sima Yi dare to attack?" It's just that I'm afraid that there will be an ambush in the city, how many people can be buried in such a big city? In the era of cold weapons, it is impossible to bury a Scud missile? There can't be any weapons of mass destruction, can I send a reconnaissance company in there to see if it's okay? Why do you want to withdraw your troops? ”

Scud missiles?

Weapons of Destruction?

Once again, the audience burst into laughter

Ma Hengzhi and the others were silent, and they were speechless when asked by Zhang Ye

Zhang Ye looked at Ma Hengyuan and said, "Also, don't you Sima Yi see Zhuge Liang?" Didn't they all hear him playing the harp on the castle tower? You can still hear him singing karaoke, which means that the two sides are very close, even if you are afraid of an ambush and dare not enter the city, then why don't you find an archer to shoot Zhuge Liang down? Why do you want to go? "Paused," Besides, if according to Guo Chong's statement, or according to "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", there is a huge disparity between the forces of the two sides, some say 200,000, and some say 100,000, then can you surround but not fight? Will you put this city under siege for three days and five days, and trap them? So he withdrew his troops

Zhang Ye asked three times, but no one answered

Everyone listened attentively, and some people were even more stunned

Even Ma Hengyuan couldn't speak, and every question of Zhang Ye was too sharp, and several scholars couldn't figure it out

Is there really no empty city plan?

Is this really made up?

Zhang Ye concluded: "So the statement of the empty city plan is not reliable at all, as for the others, such as the burning of Bowang, the burning of Xinye, the borrowing of arrows from grass boats, and the borrowing of the east wind, these are all not recorded in history, but literary works portray him too exaggeratedly, Zhuge Liang has become a clever person, and the other generals have become fools, oh, as soon as the troops are sent to fight, Zhuge Liang will give an order, where will the generals go?" They don't know what to do, they just go over, and then they talk about it when they get to the place, and then they get to the place where nothing else, first open the tips given to them by the military, the tricks are clever, and then they know what the road wants to fight, which is too much to take the war as a child's play."

At this moment, I don't know who applauded

Bang bang, and then a lot of the audience applauded along

Wonderful

It's so exciting

Who said that Zhang Ye, the host, can't talk about the Three Kingdoms and doesn't understand history? What he said was not only humorous and interesting, but also very subversive of everyone's cognition, which made people unconsciously invest in it, and even in terms of historical knowledge, there was no problem, I didn't look at Ma Hengyuan, Mr. Xu and Editor Xu, they were all asked stupid

The most important thing is that he just refuted Ma Hengyuan with Zhou Yu's matter, and talked about Zhuge Liang, when Ma Hengyuan gave a lecture before, he just mentioned how smart and powerful Zhuge Liang was, but Zhang Ye threw out a bomb in a blink of an eye, and the empty city plan did not exist at all, and Zhuge Liang, who was made up by the east wind at all, was not a military genius at all

It's not a slap in the face

Zhang Ye completely denied the views of Ma Hengyuan and the two guests, and criticized them for being incomplete