In the newspaper, as soon as this article came out, it immediately detonated the attention of countless people.

"In some newspapers, it is reasonable to divide martial arts novels into new and old schools; It's just a martial arts novel, how can it be comparable to words. In martial arts novels, I only saw fighting, killing, and promoting violence, and I didn't see much more. Martial arts novels, propaganda violence, writing fights and killings too much, readers, especially middle school students, high school students, which will teach bad children, school fights have increased! ”

-- The Osaka Daily criticized it.

"Martial arts novels are still better to read less, and it is easy to have a sense of illusion when you read too much, and you can't distinguish between fiction and reality, breeding social instability, and increasing violence!"

-- "Xinmin Daily" wrote.

"In ancient China, there was no such thing as martial arts, some were just rangers, and some were just chivalrous and forbidden. Ranger has always been one of the factors of social instability, and the so-called sect formed by the imperial courts of previous dynasties is actually a group of dark people. Martial arts novels, which glorify these darkness, seem to have some reversals of right and wrong, instilling a wrong worldview in the younger generation! ”

-- "Donghua Daily" commented.

"In martial arts novels, the ones that are promoted are mostly positive, mostly positive, and mostly upward; But in history, those so-called sects, the so-called Ming Sect, the White Lotus Sect, and so on, were extremely dark. The world in martial arts novels does not exist at all, martial arts novels are just the obscenity of literati! ”

-- "Youth Magazine" commented.

"Martial arts novels, the so-called difference between the old and the new, are meaningless at all, just idle books, just to pass the time, just to mix the eyeballs, no practical significance, no educational significance, no depth of thought, just to pass the lonely time. With the advent of the post-industrial era, the more boring the life of the citizens is, the more the work pressure is huge, and various factors have bred the birth of some unhealthy cultural markets. I hope that the cultural supervision department will take action in time, rectify it, and remove the weeds in the culture and those thoughts that can pollute a generation! ”

-- "Tianchen Herald" commented.

But soon, some newspapers refuted it.

"Some people say that martial arts novels promote violence and educate children, which makes a lot of sense. There is also an old saying, if you don't read "Water Margin", you don't read "Three Kingdoms". It is said that the Water Margin can teach bad children and make children talk about righteousness, which leads to an increase in fights. But in fact, most children have watched the "Water Margin" novel, or TV series, or movies, etc.! ”

"There are some thoughts called allergies. For fear that the children's fighting rate will increase, don't watch "Water Margin"; For fear of children's early love, don't watch "The Legend of the West Chamber" and "Golden Vase Plum"; If you are afraid that children will embark on the revolutionary road, do not read Das Kapital; If you are afraid that your children will become a member of God's religion, don't read the Bible............ These thoughts are all allergic to thinking. After watching "Water Margin", there are a few people who dare to kill people and set fires; After reading "Capital", there were a few who dared to rebel against the revolution. Many children have not watched "The Legend of the West Chamber" and "Golden Vase Plum" but are still on the road of early love! ”

-- "Entertainment Knows Early" commented.

"In some newspapers, the accusation of martial arts for promoting violence has exacerbated children's violent tendencies. Actually, it's quite true, it's just that there is no violence in the world. Without violence, there would be no human civilization. Chinese civilization can spread the world, not by etiquette and morality, but by violence, the mouth can't convince you, the fist can persuade you; The reason why the countries of Zhuhua stand all over the world and become famous is only because there are mixed element bombs, and if they throw too much, they can turn the earth into a mixed element. ”

"There are so many species on the earth, why are lions, tigers, elephants, etc., not the lords of the earth, but human beings, just because human beings are more violent! Because humans are more violent, lions, tigers, etc., are imprisoned in zoos and used as playthings; Rare species were slashed and killed, chopped and chopped, cooked, and sent to the table. ”

"Therefore, some people, don't be different, don't say against violence, etc., promote violence, teach bad children, etc., the world is full of violence, and human beings have become the masters of the earth because of violence!"

――――"Dagger Essay Society" commented.

"Many people criticize martial arts novels, mostly pointing out that martial arts novels promote violence, but in fact, it is too much. The spirit of martial arts is the spirit of resistance of the people. is the so-called county order that broke the door, and the prefect who destroyed the family, the majority of the people are actually very pitiful. In ancient times, he was exploited by the emperor and officials, and lived a miserable life; In today's era, public weapons are used for private purposes, and some second-generation officials have one by one, my father is the director, and my mother is the mayor, bullying the people, and many people can only swallow their anger. A certain enterprise is booming, just because it was favored by a certain second generation of officials, so it was acquired at a low price, and the low price was outrageous; The owner of a certain enterprise, just because he offended a certain official, made it difficult everywhere, and was originally doing well, but the business declined, and it shrank step by step, and went out of business! ”

"Someone sarcastically said that the common people are just a dish on the table of profiteers and officials, and people are knives, and I am fish and meat, which can be cut and eaten at will! Of course, it is a bit extreme, but there is some truth to it! ”

"Martial arts novels are indeed propaganda violence, propaganda is violence against power, unbearable, and no longer tolerable. In martial arts novels, most of them have some heroes, and these heroes seem to be born anti-corruption officials, and they seem to be born nemesis of corrupt officials! ”

"Martial arts novels entrust the wishes of the grass people, hoping that a certain hero will appear, and in the middle of the night, he will enter the official office, cut off the head of a certain corrupt official, eliminate harm for the people, and seek justice for the people!"

"In reality, there is no master who flies the eaves and walks the wall, and there is no hero who can hurt people by picking flowers and flying leaves; But if there are ordinary people who dare to expose corrupt officials and dare to die with corrupt officials, then the corrupt officials will inevitably be extremely jealous. If you have scruples in your heart, you won't be too bottomless in doing things. may be greedy for money, but it will be much more restrained; The edible people's fat and people's ointment are still the same, but the appearance is not too ugly! ”

-- In an article in the "Anti-Corruption Daily," he commented.

"Martial arts novels are a special writing theme, looking at one novel after another, most of them are set in ancient times, in a certain dynasty, but if you look closely, it is not a certain dynasty, but it is said that it is the current era, the current world. It's just that the method of allegory, the method of abstraction, and the distortion of the theory are used, and in the absurdity, they talk about the sorrow of the world. Reading martial arts novels, you can always find the prototype in life and find the resonance of life! ”

"In martial arts novels, strength is respected, and the strong are supreme; But in real life, it is money that is respected, and Huaxia coins are supreme. If you read martial arts novels carefully, you will find a lot of interesting things! ”

- writes the Commentary.

;