Chapter 60: Heated Arguments in Court

With a bang, the gavel in the presiding judge's hand slammed on the table, and he read with a cold expression: "The court is open now!" In accordance with Article 1 of Huaxia's Anti-Unfair Competition Law, the Donghai No. 1 People's Court openly tried the unfair competition case of the plaintiff Huaxia Myth Network Co., Ltd. against the defendant Donghai Yunfei Game Co., Ltd., and is now conducting a court investigation. First, ask the plaintiff to state the claim and the relevant factual basis. ”

Yang Lin in the agent ad litem bench nodded politely to the judges and presiding judges, and then said in a low voice: "The plaintiff's claim is like this, first, let the defendant immediately stop slandering the plaintiff and publicly apologize in the media, and second, compensate the plaintiff for the losses caused. ”

After a pause, Yang Lin began to say again: "There are many factual bases for the plaintiff, the first is the so-called chat records and screenshots of the stolen number player, and the second is that the IP address of the stolen number player is from the defendant Donghai Yunfei Game Company, except for some Internet water army, the others are from the defendant Donghai Yunfei Game Company, the number is one hundred and twelve, nearly half of the employees of Yunfei Game Company, so many employees are playing competitors' games in the company at the same time, if Yunfei Game Company does not know, do you believe it?" In addition, we also have reason to suspect that Yunfei Games Company not only slandered the plaintiff this time, but also bought off the hacker's game server attack on the plaintiff in two months, which has achieved an ulterior purpose! Presiding Judge, I'm done. ”

"Presiding Judge, I protest, the Mythical Company is talking nonsense, they are framing it!" At this time, Ma Dongliang, the boss of Yunfei Game Company in the defendant's seat, jumped up like a cat with a tail stepped on, and said excitedly.

The presiding judge knocked on the gavel in displeasure and said, "Silence! There is no room for noise in the courtroom, and the defendant wants to talk later, and then it will be your turn to plead later! ”

Ma Dongliang sat down stupidly, his face was very ugly.

Li Haoyu sat in the plaintiff's seat, looking at Ma Dongliang gracefully, speaking of which, it was the first time he had seen the mastermind behind the repeated attacks on the mythical company, watching his clown-like performance, his heart was full of disdain.

This time the facts of suing him are all there, and he cannot deny it, no matter what kind of small actions he makes, he can't reverse the fate of losing the lawsuit!

What's more, until now, Li Haoyu and Yang Lin have not come up with a trump card, and the three employees of Yunfei Game Company who participated in the whole process of this incident have not yet appeared in court to testify!

"Now the defendant is beginning to state his reasons and evidence." The presiding judge's grim expression was like an iceberg that would never melt.

The defendant's lawyer, a man in his forties, was a little blessed, and he owed a debt and said: "Presiding judge, judges, the defendant has sufficient reasons to explain that the plaintiff is making false accusations. First, the two companies of the defendant and the plaintiff, one of which was far away in Shancheng and the other in Donghai City, were far apart, and the defendant did not know the plaintiff and did not have any conflict of interest with the plaintiff. Second, we have reason to believe that the plaintiff's company fell into business difficulties due to its own reasons, and in order to achieve the effect of grandstanding, it sued the defendant and won sympathy and attention. Presiding Judge, I'm done talking. ”

Li Haoyu was entertained by the lawyer invited by Ma Dongliang in the plaintiff's bench to reverse black and white, and his heart was secretly ruthless, let's make trouble, and when the evidence is really presented, you can't cry!

The presiding judge looked at a judge next to him, who cleared his throat and said, "Now the courtroom debate begins, and the two sides ask each other questions, and the plaintiff asks questions first." ”

Yang Lin stood up and asked Ma Dongliang in the defendant's seat: "Defendant, may I ask if your Donghai Yunfei Game Company is causing a big drop in the traffic of your games because of a game launched by the plaintiff company called Tiandi Fengyun, and the turnover is less than half of what it used to be?" ”

Ma Dongliang scolded in his heart, but he really didn't dare to tell a lie in front of everyone, because anyone who knows a little bit about web games knows this situation, and he can't hide it if he wants to, he thought about it and said: "There is indeed such a thing, but this phenomenon has only temporarily appeared because of the improper marketing methods used by Mythical Network Company, and it will not be long before it will change quickly." I believe that the eyes of the players are bright, and false propaganda can only deceive the players for a while, and cannot deceive the players forever. ”

When Ma Dongliang said these words, he looked righteous and awe-inspiring, as if the Mythical Company was really a heinous black company, and he was exposing the evil situation of the Mythical Company. If people who don't know the inside story of Lu Dao see it, maybe they will really be fooled by his performance.

"Fart, you still have to be shameless with the surname Ma! Obviously, our mythical company's games are more fun than yours, so others only come to play, and you are fools when the hundreds of thousands of players who have registered for our games are fools?! Lin Feng is a person who can't tolerate sand in his eyes, and the mythical company is his brother's hard work, how can he allow others to slander wantonly, when he heard Ma Dongliang reverse black and white, he immediately shouted angrily in the spectator seat.

Ma Dongliang seemed to have entered the scene and turned into an embodiment of justice, he snorted and said: "I can't say what your mythical company has done?" You have to know that this is Donghai City, not just do whatever you want in your mountain city! ”

"Silence!"

The presiding judge knocked the gavel on the table with a cold face, "The people in the spectators must not make noise at will without being summoned, otherwise the bailiff will expel them from the courtroom!" ”

Lin Feng opened his mouth and wanted to say something, Chen Liang and Lin Fei, who were sitting next to him, hurriedly pulled him, otherwise with Lin Feng's fiery temperament, he would not have to make a big fuss in the court!

"Now it's up to the defendant to ask the plaintiff questions." The presiding judge saw that Lin Feng was not making trouble, so he spoke.

The defendant's lawyer stood up and asked Li Haoyu: "Plaintiff, I want to ask you whether the Mythical Network Company has fallen into a situation of poor capital turnover recently, and there are venture capital companies interested in investing in the Mythical Network Company?" ”

"Absolutely nothing!"

Li Haoyu opened his mouth and smiled, seeing that the defendant's lawyer and Ma Dongliang were cautious.

The defendant's lawyer continued to ask unconvinced: "As far as I know, Mythical Network Company started by selling two mobile games for a total of 10.5 million US dollars. At present, the mythical company has more than 100 employees, and the income and expenditure have been completely unbalanced, so I have reason to believe that the mythical company has fallen into a crisis of insufficient funds, in order to resolve this crisis, the mythical company sued my client's Donghai Yunfei Game Company to win sympathy and attention, the most important thing is to attract the attention of venture capital companies at home and abroad! ”

Li Haoyu said coldly: "You are just speculating, what evidence do you have that my company is not well funded?" ”

The defendant's lawyer was overjoyed, feeling that Li Haoyu was already exhausted, and asked step by step: "Defendant, according to what your company has done, anyone with a little business common sense can reason to get this answer." Presiding Judge, the defendant's Mythical Network Company has a motive and reason to make such a false accusation, please ask the Presiding Judge and the judges to be clear! ”

"It's stupid!" Li Haoyu's mouth coldly spit out these words.

The defendant's lawyer felt that he had the upper hand, and what he said to Li Haoyu was also that he was scolding indiscriminately at the end of the road, so he didn't care at all, and said with a smile on his face: "Isn't that the case?" ”

"Presiding judge, the defendant's lawyer just relied on his own speculation to open his mouth, and what he said is a bunch of nonsense!" Li Haoyu didn't look at the defendant's lawyer this time, and turned his head to look at the presiding judge.

"Plaintiff, what evidence do you have to prove that the defendant's lawyer's guess was wrong?" The presiding judge asked.

"It's very simple, because my company doesn't have the problem of shortage of funds at all," Li Haoyu paused for a moment before continuing: "A week ago, I personally injected 100 million US dollars into Mythical Network Company, presiding judge, judges, do you think my company will be short of funds?" ”

Li Haoyu's words made Ma Dongliang and the defendant's lawyer change their faces at the same time, and their idea before the trial was to entangle the mythical company's lack of funds, so that the presiding judge and the judge could focus on this point. If Li Haoyu's words are true, then what Ma Dongliang and the defendant's lawyer said can basically be completely overturned, so they can't help but be shocked.

Li Haoyu then said: "I not only have physical evidence to prove the unfair competition of the defendant Donghai Yunfei Game Company against my mythical company, but I also have three witnesses to prove what the defendant did!" ”

"Do you still have witnesses, where are they, and are you willing to testify in court?" The presiding judge asked.

Ma Xunwei and two other employees of Yunfei Game Company stood up and said, "We are willing to testify." ”

When Ma Dongliang saw Ma Xunwei and the three of them, his face suddenly turned pale, he leaned back in his chair gloomily, and muttered: "It's over, everything is over......

After the testimony of Ma Xunwei and others, and the physical evidence provided by the mythical company was sufficient, the trial ended quickly.

"Just after the court trial, this court heard the confessions, justifications, and most conclusive statements of the defendant and the plaintiff, and the court made a serious review of the case, and the testimony of the witnesses who said in court and the prosecutor presented in court the testimony of witnesses who did not appear in court, and other evidentiary materials, the form and source are legal, the content corroborates each other, and can be used as the basis for the verdict, this court confirms it, and the following verdict is pronounced on this case."

After the presiding judge finished speaking, the clerk next to him shouted, "All stand up!" ”

Everyone, including those in the gallery, stood up to hear the presiding judge's verdict.

"This court believes that the conduct of the defendant Ma Dongliang's Donghai Yunfei Game Company has violated Article 14 of the Unfair Competition Law of Huaxia, and that business operators shall not fabricate or disseminate false facts to damage the business reputation and product reputation of competitors. The facts of defendant Ma Dongliang's crime are clear, the evidence is credible and sufficient, and the charges are confirmed. The defendant Ma Dongliang was sentenced to compensate the plaintiff Li Haoyu in the amount of RMB 3.2 million, and publicly apologized in Donghai Daily and Shancheng Daily! ”

The judge's verdict made Lin Feng, Chen Liang and Lin Fei in the audience breathe a long sigh of relief, as for Lin Zhendong, he didn't care about this matter at all, all he cared about was the safety of Li Haoyu and Lin Feng and others.