Should be a netizen article in the book review area, flip through the old time post - "Also talk about Jin Yong and Gu Long, and another"

A long time ago, I posted a post on the Lianzhong Game Forum, and that section was called "Martial Arts Temple", and Banzhu was a thunderbolt rabbit, and now there is no more martial arts area, sighing ~~~~~~~~

**************************************************************************************

inputdate:2001-6-30 9:38:21 [send to email]

For a long time, he has been in the temple of martial arts, but he has never posted about martial arts, and he is embarrassed, but he also knows that he is not enough, after all, he has not done any professional research and has no right to speak. Pen %Fun %Pavilion www.biquge.info And I watch martial arts, in fact, it is no different from other novels, purely for entertainment, but I have seen too much, and I have my own feelings! Recently (and not only recently), some people have been talking about "ancient" and "gold", which suddenly triggered a little inspiration for me, and I also came to join in the fun:

To sum it up simply, there is just one sentence - Jin Yong's novels are unforgettable after reading, so I only read them once in my life; Gu Long's novels are forgotten after reading them, so he reads them again and again.

Which one is better?

This is necessary to analyze the reasons in detail.

Jin Yong's works are generally long-form masterpieces, with huge plots, intricate character relationships, and a broad and far-reaching historical background, although it is not easy for the author, readers also need to devote themselves to cultivation for a few days before they can enter the plot, or in other words, they can really enter the historical background, make themselves a person in the play, and complete the transformation from a spectator to a participant. It is precisely because of this that there is a unique and rare indifference and detachment.

Gu Long is different, there are few long stories not to say, even if it is a work of two or three volumes, it can also be clear at a glance, easily break through the plot and enter the emotional world, and the mood ups and downs with the development of the story. This is also a characteristic of ancient dragons; It is also one of the things that can attract people about him.

Therefore, for a day or two of free time, or a moment of depression, I would choose the ancient dragon; For big holidays and long holidays, I will choose Jin Yong. After seeing Jin Yong, the whole person will be immersed for a long time, and he can't get rid of it or forget it; After seeing the ancient dragon, at most he looked up to the sky and roared, removing the depression in his heart, and he was relieved.

That's not an excuse. However, it is true that Gu Long has aura, talent, and pride, but after all, he is just a chivalrous man, and he still can't get out of the vast sea of people and the sky is full of dust and fog. He writes about himself, writes about his heart, writes it, and moves himself; Jin Yong, but he is a master outside the world, who is clear about the world and has another world in mind. In that world, he is the master, and with the pen and letter, he can turn life and death upside down and overthrow the country and the people.

Writing about the difference between the two, I can't help but think of another person, Huang Yi.

Why? Because he, like Jin Yong, can "make up stories".

It's disrespectful to say that, but it's true.

Xun Qin, Interstellar, Datang, each work reflects the author's special thinking and precise logic, and at the same time does not lose the magnificent momentum.

The first time I watched "Interstellar", it was unfortunate that it was a pirated book, the kind that rotted to a certain extent. Typos aside, there is no need to wrap lines to divide paragraphs, and even different chapters will be connected to each other on a line of words! Everyone must know that the span of time and space is very large, and the occasions when different characters appear are all very different, and the most common is separated by different chapters and paragraphs. And I'm tired of this switch of time and space!

But I didn't complain at all. Interstellar is really good-looking. At that time, I hadn't read Datang yet, because I was waiting for the whole book to come out. I only watched Xun Qin, and then it was interstellar. But I don't think it's necessary to read Huang Yi's other books, two are enough! It is enough to see how the author is beyond the ordinary.

Moreover, the audience may laugh at me, the reason why I like to read Huang Yi's book is not because of his writing, not because of the social significance contained in it, not because there is a love story that can move people, but because I actually use it as a kind of intellectual training! Because his books always have a very large system in them, so big that I didn't dare to put them down at the beginning, for fear of forgetting! And the many characters, social relationships, and political systems are so real that people can't stop it, and they have a feeling of rebirth, and they can completely get out of this world and reach a new time and space.

Some of Huang Yi's books have historical backgrounds (e.g., Tang Dynasty, Xun Qin, and Overturning), and some do not (e.g., Interstellar). We can see that the author's historical knowledge is very rich and comprehensive, and it can be said that he is not under Jin Yong; However, when he gets rid of the shackles of history and the system that is customary in modern society to create a new world, Huang Yi's talent can be said to be above anyone else. This point can't even be matched by Jin Yong! It's not that there are people who create a new society, but their thinking is so rigorous and the system is so grand, except for Huang Yi, he doesn't think second-hand.

Huang Yi and Wesley (Ni Kuang) seem to be comparable to Jin Yong and Gu Long, of course, it is biased to say this, but to some extent, yes.

Wesley, who writes tirelessly, is constantly innovative and enviable! I also sincerely admire it. But after all, his works are all about putting the same characters in different stories, and it is worth recalling the novel ideas and the social significance expressed in them (which is very rare), rather than the story itself, so many times I can't tell which book I have read and which one I haven't read! (I think I've probably read all of Wei's books a few rounds.) Although there are many series - Wesley, Yuan Zhenxia, Asian Eagle Luo Kai, Magnolia, etc., etc., etc., but between the characters, there is no distinct personality, and there is no essential difference between the things encountered, just the author's artificial change of the character's name!

However, in the final analysis, all the above writers' works are delicacies and pearls to me, and daring to comment is actually self-humiliation. How can I see the furrow in the breast of others? However, don't vomit or be unhappy in your chest~ I'm also a person in the rivers and lakes~ What's more, this rivers and lakes are not so dangerous, but they give me a lot of warmth!

.............................

Some words were often wanted to be written in the reply, but I was afraid that people would scold me when I wrote them, so I deleted them again and again, and in the end I didn't send them out. Maybe it's all jokes and some exaggerations in myself, but it also reflects some reality, and I don't know if anyone feels the same way.

---

※ Source: Lianzhong Online Game World. [from:211.100.87**]

**************************************************************************************

The above is the full original text.

It's been five or six years now...... Seems to have changed my mind a bit......

But it's still roughly the case, book friends can throw bricks in the comment area~